That's assuming anyone besides Twistey is still alive out there. It's been awfully quiet the past week. If you're definitely alive, and you want to play a NSFW game with other people who are also definitely alive, click this link! http://pyx-2.pretendyoure.xyz/zy/game.jsp#game=30
The password is ZOMBIES.
Because I know. I'm on to you.
~Neshomeh, very much undead. [/"Ring Child" reference]
-
Cards Against Headquarters, anyone? by
on 2017-09-25 03:15:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Shoot. And here I spent the last part of my evening... by
on 2017-09-25 12:27:00 UTC
Link to this
... Doing a reading for school, when I could have gone to this!
(In fairness, midterms are next week, and I have three. Can't let myself fall behind!) -
Did anyone show up to play? by
on 2017-09-25 11:32:00 UTC
Link to this
And, more importantly, did they all escape with their brains intact?
hS, probably more of a vampire than a zombie -
They did! by
on 2017-09-25 14:26:00 UTC
Link to this
I think there were eight of us, though not all at the same time. As far as I know, my brain is in the same shape it was when I started the game, but that's not necessarily saying much. {= )
~Neshomeh
-
Monthly reminder that I am still alive. by
on 2017-09-25 23:25:00 UTC
Link to this
For anyone who isn't on the Discord server, I did not die. I simply do not have things that I feel would be worth talking about here.
So, how have you guys been? I went to the Magic prerelease this weekend with a friend. It was nice, if a bit loud. Now I'm trying to mitigate the effects of missing half a night's worth of sleep. -
Welp, hello again. What's Magic about? Sounds cool. (nm) by
on 2017-09-28 01:11:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Re: Monthly reminder that I am still alive. by
on 2017-09-27 04:41:00 UTC
Link to this
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA512
Still alive myself.
Since Discord isn't always friendly toward anonymizing proxies I've been out of the chat too.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
iLUEARMKAB0WIQTfllUBtaeNnRzzfmVK3+74uImA+wUCWcsdwwAKCRBK3+74uImA
+9w5Af4j8HYLoCp4bPq2TsyfSLM/SylwVqjy3AHkXn1Sd0Wh7oGO52kOJ0bDt1Gx
tIhT8SVla1s6xRmsGyWFeT9DKPVTAgCJSVj4wg2wQWvZghA2n9C+dPB5fMGTIFXm
C+jQHOOSDjIynd1/F8xPH9iH/xUG7+vd8rr/Q0Qq5EOlcyA9ni1H
=3dLY
-----END PGP SIGNATURE----- -
Midnight prerelease... by
on 2017-09-26 19:14:00 UTC
Link to this
...it's a hell of a drug. I never touch the stuff myself. I like my sleep too much. I tend toward noon and later events.
How's you end up doing? Pull anything fun?
-Phobos -
It was alright. by
on 2017-09-28 01:12:00 UTC
Link to this
Was playing 2-Headed-Giant (basically 2v2 games) with a friend. Some notable moments:
*Way too many jokes about getting Arcane Adaptation for all of our rares.
*We both ended up pulling Deadeye Tracker for our prerelease cards.
*I opened a Vraska and an Axis of Immortality. My friend didn't pull any mythics.
*We won our first game by dealing 10 points of damage with a tag-team Bishop of the Bloodstained and an Unfriendly Fire.
*We lost our next two games pretty badly. I blame lukewarm draws.
*We got a bye on our last game, so we ended up "playing" against another team that got a bye. We were all sleep-deprived at that point, so you can imagine how that went.
*Trying to figure out how to split the cards we opened. While we were tired. Fun times. -
2HG can be fun. by
on 2017-09-28 03:45:00 UTC
Link to this
Nesh and I did that for Oath of the Gatewatch.
I imagine you play other formats. What's your favorite? I like draft, but I'll play anything and everything. I'm also pretty big into the lore, if that is a thing that interests you.
-Phobos -
Honestly just started getting back into Magic by
on 2017-09-29 12:09:00 UTC
Link to this
Been trying to cobble together a Commander deck for a while, but other than that I'm not sure if I want to get into other formats.
-
I'm pretty good by
on 2017-09-26 11:27:00 UTC
Link to this
Got to Germany a few weeks ago to start on my semester of doing research, and since then I've ... done some research. Most of what I've gotten up to was on the project I had started last semester, which has good results now, but the things I specifically came here for are starting up now that all the relevant people are back from traveling.
On top of that, I'm getting hit with all the stuff that goes along with applying to PhD programs. So I'm busy, but not quite buried under all the work (as the inhabitants of the Discord can attest)
- Tomash -
Oh, y'know, not bad. by
on 2017-09-26 09:50:00 UTC
Link to this
I'm spending far too much time trying to revamp my website in the wake of the loss of Photobucket. I could just patch the problems, but I'd rather do a full rebuild and get something that looks good and is stable.
hS -
Yay for being alive! by
on 2017-09-26 03:03:00 UTC
Link to this
I have some freelance line editing work this coming month, so that's going to keep me busy. Also some proofreading lined up for January. I'm pretty excited about it. I'd just about given up on working in publishing, but I seem to have stumbled upon another path to the goal, if all goes well. ^_^
Phobos wanted to go to prerelease, but unfortunately his usual card shop messed up and didn't get the stuff, and the only other place available was full up. Sadface.
~Neshomeh
-
Two Truths and a Lie—badfic style! by
on 2017-09-27 03:48:00 UTC
Link to this
So, those of you familiar with the basics of Two Truths and a Lie know how it goes: Post two truths and a lie, and responders have to find the lie.
Now, let's do it with badfic excerpts! Post two real excerpts (nothing NSFW), and one you made up yourself. People respond to your post by trying to guess which one is the fake!
For example!
1) "Your daughter will be known for every wizards and witches from now on. She will be remembered as the girl who defeated Lord Voldemort when she was mere child just like Harry. She will be more famous than Harry seeing that she stopped Voldemort first and weakened him. She will be powerful than normal witch with two most important family bloods run in her veins. She will be a powerful veela just like you and your family. And she will always be remembered as the Girl Who Lived."
2) Astrid's eyes were blue, the brightest blue of sapphires in a riverbed, and her hair was silver like the moon. It was a mark of the curse she bore; ever since the night her parents died and left her at the orphanage where she was an outcast. Nobody there wanted to be friends with her, but if they knew she was the princess of the wizarding world and heir to the most important pureblood family in the world, the Bellagios, they would treat her better.
3) It was now my turn to tell him a little bit about myself so I did and said " I'm a 4th year too but I'm kind of a new student ,I love to read and I'm also scared of spiders ." He then smiled and said " That's pretty cool never met a girl who is scared of spiders like I am ." I giggled when I said " Now you do " He couldn't help but smile and laugh then he asked " Do you have any siblings ?" I then replied "Nope I'm just an only child." I explained to him.
Which one did I make up, and which ones are real? Let's see what you come up with. -
Oooh, my turn! by
on 2017-09-30 04:40:00 UTC
Link to this
Because it's been a while since I posted here and this sounded like fun, so why the heck not.
1) "Try Again, Twi. you can do it." said spike
"Phew' This spell's a toughie. But I feel Lucky this time." said Twilight
"You can say that again, Twilight" said Ash as Twilight turns around and sees Ash "Ash you made it" Twilight said as she nuzzle him "I never be late and spike's right try again" said Ash as twilight smiled then went back at the apple "One...Two..." her horn is glowing ready to change the apple until "Hi!" Pinkie pie pounce on her then her magic was misfire bouncing at every side and hits the bird
"Pinkie you should be careful you almost got hit" Ash said
"Ash is right Why'd you do that?" said Twilight
"Sorry 'cause hugs are funeriffic! especially when you throw one around a friend. Whatcha doin'?" said Pinkie
"Trying to turn that apple into an Orange." said Twilight
"But you kind of threw her aim off." said spike as they see a orange with wings flying pass them "Well they don't call them flying oranges for nothing" Ash said in the humor but sees the flying orange ridiculous "Ash I got your side set for you to start practicing your alicorn magic" Twilight shows Ash an strawberry "So I need to turn that strawberry to something?" said Ash
"Yes Ash you need to change it to a kiwi" said spike
"I can do that" said Ash
----------
2) "Your skin... It sprakles!" I gasped.
Violet looked down at her foream, turning her hand over and over. It was indeed true; her skin seemd to glisten like a million diamonds had been embedded into her skin. She stepped away from the ray of sunlight, her expression sullen.
"You cann't be near me, Wilbur, it's too dangerous," she said. "I could kill you. The possibility really is there. You could vanish one night, without a trace, and nobody would eer know hwere you went. The only trace of your fate would be hte blood on my fangs!"
"It's a risk I'm willng to take," I replied, my eyes taking a look of stely determination. "Violet, I... I always wanted to tell you this... You're BEAUTIFUL."
Her eyes widened. "...I am??"
"You've always been beautiful, Vi." A warm smile on my face "And being av ampire doesn't change that at all."
----------
3) Harry finished eating the man that had shot him, he could smell the others that dared come to his island. He quickly got to the odd, white object and growled. He quietly got close to the object and smelled it, yes the intruders were inside of the thing. Harry smashed his right clawed hand into the thing's side, his claws sinking into the 'skin' of the object without any resistance. He then sank his other hand into the other side of the thing and then started pulling, the object making a ripping sound before it fell off, landing with a crash to the forest floor.
His targets were staring at him with fear, yes, he was the alpha predator here! He looked over all of the humans until his eyes came across one with red hair and bright emerald green eyes, he knew her. A memory flashed in his mind, that woman was holding him in her arms and was smiling at him. Roaring in pain as the memory hurt his mind so much, like his skull was being attacked by the vicious claw of the raptors! Harry angrily roared at the woman and lunged forward, attempting to snap at her legs.
He got a man instead, Harry dropped him and as he tried to crawl away, he stepped on his legs before tearing him in half. He ate the man before he used his powers to slash the tree down, making the object roll away, he gave chase. That woman would die, somehow she had hurt him, the greatest predator of the island! The pathetic humans had run out of the safety of the object before returning to it, attempting to hide. Well, he thought, I'll make sure they don't escape.
----------
Which one is the fake? Take your pick! :D
-SS -
Oh this is a tricky one. by
on 2017-09-30 14:32:00 UTC
Link to this
All of these scream like something you'd write, and it's perfectly in the realm of possibility that you did, knowing your past record. Doing some light research, I'm assuming #1 is Pokémon and My Little Pony, #2 is a Mega-Crossover involving Incredibles, Meet The Robinsons, and Twilight, with some crossover ships thrown in the mix... one that's apparently surprisingly common, and the last one is a Harry Potter and Jurrasic Park crossover... one that involves Harry becoming a Dinosaur...
Jesus Christ you're not making this easy, but if I had to choose I'd go with #2 for the simple fact that I can't find anything directly relating to it on The Pit or AO3 -
Sorry, sir, but... by
on 2017-10-01 02:36:00 UTC
Link to this
...your answer was CORRECT! :D
Both #1 and #3 were right on the money, respectively featuring Ash becoming an alicorn (yes, really) and Harry being an animagus who could turn into the Spinosaurus from JP3 (yes, really). Both of them also involved inserting the crossover elements into one of the continua featured in their respective stories, with Alicorn!Ash being shoehorned into the episodes of MLP Season 3, and Spino!Harry actually BEING the JP3 Spino. Yeah, I cringed so much at both and I'm considering adding the one with Spino!Harry to the Unclaimed list if I get the time.
The "excerpt" with vampire!Violet and Wilbur was painful for me to write, but the first two things that came to mind when I thought about what to pull out of my butt were the Willet crossover ship and the fact that the Twilight saga used to be one of the most widely known and polarizing continua back in the day. Violet being a vampire is an AU I've seen on some thankfully rare few occasions while perusing DeviantArt, and my original intent was for her to be frightened by her being a vampire due to a recent transformation but her being a vamp from the get-go sounded weirder for my taste.
Also, how dare you accuse me of actually WANTING to write crossovers as weird and twisted as what I presented, lol. I doubt even I would consider it... especially not after the LAST time I tried it. X'D -
A new challenger approaches. by
on 2017-09-29 14:59:00 UTC
Link to this
Three uncanonical Harry Potter spawns:
1) It took all the Slytherin Prince had not to kick Potter as he looked up at him from the dust of the graveyard. "Not so cocky now are you Potter?" He said sneering.
"Not so cocky indeed." Said Vodemort. He was finally finished regenerating. "You have done well Draco." He walked over to Potter. His black cloak swirled elegantly around him. "You were the chosen one mr Potter." He said. "And now you will die." He pointed his wand at Harry and used the killing curse. "Now Draco my son it is time to begin."
"Yes father." Malfoy said. His silver eyes shone with devotion. Finally after all this time pretending to be a weakling and a coward he would finally take his place at his father's side.
Voldemort took out his wand and pressed it against his Dark Mark. "Come to me my death eaters." And they were there the graveyard. Dolahov and Snape. Malfoy and Greyback. And all the rest. "My friends it is good to see you." He said. "It is time for us to step out from the shadows."
"My lord we will do as you say." They said.
Voldemort put a firm white hand on Malfoy's shoulder. "And my son shall lead you."
The Prince smirked. He was going to make them pay. Granger, Weasley and everyone who had mocked him would all pay.
2) A beautiful baby girl was born to two loving parents within the Snape family: Severus and Jaquiline. Both were of pureblooded origins, making the little girl pureblooded as well.
With curly black hair, deep blue eyes, and pale skin, her parents thought her perfect. Her godparents thought the same, as did her best friend (once he was old enough to understand, that is). Everyone who met her was simply enchanted, though she had no control over this.
Betrothal contracts were begged of Severus Snape, but he refused. If his daughter was to marry, it would be for love- as long as her suitor was pure blooded.
Now, the Snape family (which is one of the oldest when it comes to being pureblood) was also of mythical descent; that is to say, of sirenic descent. The song and beauty of the sirens ran through their veins. Their song was enchanting and caught attention of all. Their voice was a power of theirs, but it was not the most important. What was the most important, you ask? One word.
Love.
3) Harry's jaw dropped at the sight of her. She looked Harry's age and had long flaming red hair, matted with blood and water and hazel eyes filled with tears. Her clothes were wet and torn and covered in dirt from the storm, and her face was stained with water droplets, blood, and dirt. Needless to say, she did look like Lily Potter. Except for her eyes. Her eyes were the exact same color as James Potter. Wait...no...her eyes changed. They went from hazel to green, back to hazel.
Professor McGonagall moved Harry's hand to look at his scar while Professor Snape took the Lily Potter look-alike's wrist. "Bloody hell." Snape muttered. Everyone crowded around to look at her wrist. It was the same lightning shaped scar that Harry had on his forehead.
"What's your name dear?" Professor McGonagall asked.
"Ph-Phoenix." She said softly.
"Your full name, please." Professor Dumbledore stated kindly.
She took a deep breath, "Phoenix Minerva Potter."
Which one's the fake? (Trick question; they all are! {= D )
~Neshomeh -
Hmmm... by
on 2017-09-29 15:32:00 UTC
Link to this
I’m gonna say 3, simply because the scar thing sounds to creative, and because she may have a vague resemblance to Rose Potter, though I could be wrong
-
Nope! by
on 2017-09-30 00:37:00 UTC
Link to this
3 is real. I didn't read far enough to know why she has the scar on her wrist, but I'm sure it's hilarious. I'll post links to the two real badfics when someone has identified the fake. {= )
~Neshomeh -
You picked some really good ones. by
on 2017-09-30 03:55:00 UTC
Link to this
I read through them on my phone at lunch, and I could argue for each one being both a real fanfic, and a fabrication on your part.
I thiiiiiiink number one is the phony badfic. It just feels more like your style of parodic badness to me, in that it's more character-focused rather than changing the social customs of the Wizarding World, like number two does.
—doctorlit, probably wrong this time -
Ya got me! by
on 2017-09-30 15:24:00 UTC
Link to this
1 is the fake. I actually had Phobos come up with it so it wouldn't seem like something I'd think of, but then I tweaked it to add more detail, trying to make it feel more like something someone put all their feelings into, like the other ones, and apparently that was a mistake.
But yeah, two and three are fun. They're from Quotev, and are respectively "Love in the Dark" and "The Second Potter." I haven't read much of "The Second Potter," but "Love in the Dark" features one Mikaela Snape and is pretty dang funny. The fic seems to be mainly a retelling of the books, only with her shoehorned into half the canon events. Meanwhile, she can't make up her mind whether she wants to be a good guy or not. Half the time she's being nice to Harry and friends, the other half she's helping Draco torture Neville and then going out and spending loads of money on fancy rings for her BFF and future love interest. Because eleven-year-old Draco is all about fancy rings and not, say, racing brooms. And also Snape calls her Flower. *snort*
I might claim that one. The fic has a soundtrack I can use to torture Derik. Could be fun.
~Neshomeh -
So I saw It yesterday. by
on 2017-09-29 05:48:00 UTC
Link to this
So guess what fandom I'm doing?
Also, because I'm an especial jerk, below are two real badfic excerpts, one made up by me, and one passage from Stephen King's actual It novel. Make your guess!
-----
1. He stared at you for a moment, smile fading.
“What? I thought we were having fun?”
“You made me fall! My [butt] is wet now! I told you to be gentle if we did this.”
Pennywise frowned then, extending a hand to you which you accepted. He pulled you to your feet. He brushed your wild hair out of your face, cupping your cheeks with one gigantic hand.
-----
2. He felt as if someone had whopped all the breath out of him . . . and then he heard that sound again, that sound that was half pressure on the skin and eardrums, that keen homicidal whispering rush—Swiipppp! He rolled off the bench onto the gravel, thinking So this is what they mean by déja-vu, now you know, you'll never have to ask anybody again—
He hit on his shoulder and rolled, looking up at the Paul Bunyan statue—only it was no longer Paul Bunyan. The clown stood there instead, resplendent and evident, fantastic in plastic, twenty feet of Day-Glo colors, its painted face surmounting a cosmic comic ruff. Orange pompom buttons cast in plastic, each as big as a volleyball, ran down the front of the silvery suit. Instead of an axe it held a huge bunch of plastic balloons. Engraved on each were two legends: IT'S STILL ROCK AND ROLL TO ME and RICHIE TOZIER'S "ALL DEAD" ROCK SHOW.
He scrambled backward, using his heels and his palms. Gravel went down the back of his pants. He heard a seam tear loose in the underarm of his Rodeo Drive sportcoat. He rolled over, gained his feet, staggered, looked back. The clown looked down at him. Its eyes rolled wetly in their sockets.
"Did I give you a scare, m'man?" it rumbled.
-----
3. It had learned, early on, that adults were more difficult to feed on.
Mind, there were no limits on what It could do. Rather than limiting, being in a space with only three dimensions essentially gave It endless room for change: manipulation, transformation, even rewritng the minds and memories of Its prey.
So while It was certainly capapble of transforming into, say, the fear of looming bills or the threat of divorce, there was something so much more visceral about the more overt fears of children.
If nothing else, the forms of childrens' fears made it easier to retain teeth.
-----
4. But The Bat didn't get far as something grabbed him from behind and threw him back into the open spot where he crashed. Batman jumped and threw several batwings at a wide angle but his enemy was nowhere to be seen.
"I/we waited so long for you, Bat-Man...Man-Bat...I/we expected more from you. You used to be such a worthy opponent.", mocked The Joker from the dark.
"Pennywise! Joker! Show yourself!", Batman shouted as he tensed up, ready for the attack.
—doctorlit is his own Loser's Club -
My guess: by
on 2017-09-30 14:25:00 UTC
Link to this
Number four is your own creation. 3 isn't actually inherently badfic that I can tell—which makes me think it's actually legitimate.
-
Except that I'm bad at writing badly . . . by
on 2017-09-30 23:11:00 UTC
Link to this
. . . so #3 is my creation, and #4 is a real story. I didn't think I was being such a tricksy hobbit when I first posted!
—there's a reason doctorlit doesn't typically post in the badfic games -
Okay, so... by
on 2017-09-29 15:10:00 UTC
Link to this
I'm pretty sure #2 is the real excerpt from the book. I haven't read it myself, but I've read enough Stephen King that I think I can recognize his style. Plus it's got a spaced ellipsis, which is a characteristic of real publishing.
As for which one is the fake... I immediately suspect either #1 or #4, and my instinct says it's #1, precisely because it sounds the least like something doc would write. That's a neat trick with throwing in a censored word replacement, too, but I think it IS a trick. So that's my guess. How'd I do?
~Neshomeh -
Got the canon scene correct! by
on 2017-09-29 21:33:00 UTC
Link to this
Unfortunately, #1 is a real badfic, and my censoring was legit. Try again? :)
—doctorlit was pretty shocked at how popular Pennywise/reader is on AO3 -
Congrats, you're the first fooler! by
on 2017-09-30 00:42:00 UTC
Link to this
I was hoping it would be me, but I guessed wrong on yours before Mattman guessed wrong on mine. Oh well. I still fooled someone, too. ^_^
I am also shocked that that's a popular thing. Isn't it sort of like getting it on with a boggart? The whole "embodiment of fear" thing?
I'll let someone else guess between the remaining three. {= )
~Neshomeh -
More like a Cthulhuverse alien godthing with boggart powers. by
on 2017-09-30 03:49:00 UTC
Link to this
There are a few short chapters from Its perspective in It, which I won't quote because my fingers have cheese grease on them. But yeah, It basically looks down on humans like really stupid cattle. If It is capable of love, It certainly wouldn't consider love with a human.
—it's also really hard for doctorlit to hold that brick-shaped book open and type at the same time, so -
Let's go with Percy Jackson! by
on 2017-09-28 23:00:00 UTC
Link to this
1) "Yes, its true." I said looking away in embarrassment. "I am The Lost Olympian."
Annabeth gasped "But that's impossible! Selene disappeared over ten thousand years ago and your only sixteen! And Percy's sister!"
"I was reborn as Percy's sister" I said softly. "I needed to fulfil the Prophecy." I recited:
Daughter of Moon and Daughter of Night
Comes into the world a mortal to fight
With Sea and Wit she sails alone
Until one day she comes back home
"I didn't know about it until now" I said. "Please don't hate me."
Annabeth hugged me. "I could never hate you."
2) "There must be some mistake, my Lady would never have a child, let alone a son" snapped the girl who had been talking to Chiron.
"There is no mistake, Ms Nightshade, the symbol was Artemis claiming her child, I was informed earlier today that Percy was her son" corrected Chiron as he came over just in case she attacked him in some way.
3) My name is Penny Jackson,daughter of Poseidon. And I'm immortal.
Wanna know how? After the defeat of Kronos,the gods offered immortality to Percy,but he refused for Annabeth. Cute right? So they gave the immortality to me. It has upsides,and downsides.
The good thing is I won't die. But turns out,it's actually possible for immortals to die,and since I'm just a junior or whatever,my immortality isn't that strong. So,it's kinda like the Hunters of Artemis thing. If I don't get hurt,I'll be fine. -
I choose by
on 2017-09-29 00:35:00 UTC
Link to this
...hmm. I know #2 is real, because you mentioned that fic already. So that leaves #1 and #3. #1 feels a bit a more Ix-y, but #3 feels a bit more deliberately bad.
I'll go for my instincts: #1. -
Drat, and here I thought 3 was obvious. by
on 2017-09-29 00:49:00 UTC
Link to this
I guess it was a little *too* obvious.
-
(Astrid's hair is NOT silver. It's LIGHT BLONDE! }:@) (nm) by
on 2017-09-28 01:13:00 UTC
Link to this
-
(Whoops, that wasn't a HTTYD fanfic. Oh well. No regrets!) (nm) by
on 2017-09-28 14:43:00 UTC
Link to this
-
This sounds like fun. by
on 2017-09-27 21:48:00 UTC
Link to this
1) I didn't know what to think. Both Draco and Harry wanted me? But I was just an ordinary, plain girl with long, flowing black hair and silver eyes. Why was I so special that the hottest boys in school were about to start hexing each other over me?
2) "Are you going to believe me without Veritaserum?"
"We'll see. Start talking."
"Okay, well first off, I really am Harry Potter…but I'm not four years old. I'm actually seventeen. When I was one year old…"
3) I was so happy with my new job. My father wasn't as pleased as I, probably because he rather see me working at the Ministry of Magic than Hogwarts but I didn't care which one were more important. I only had space in my heart for one place and it was the school of magic. Also, Albus Dumbledore came to my house in London personally to offer the job. Who - in their right mind - would refuse such an invitation? Think I said yes with my mouth fulled of my mother's (delicious!) toasts with smoked salmon when the director asked me during brunch - he didn't seem to mind my behavior and noticed how grateful I was. Since the day he visit 'til the day I had to leave home the anxiety took over me completly. I was eating like a pig with pms, even chocolat started to taste like water after a while - and I couldn't hear that word anymore or I would vomite. When I had everything with me I was ready to go take the train. My father, one grumpy slytherin, kissed my forehead. My mother, a lovely gryffindor, hugged me until there was no more oxigen in my lungs. -
A guess, I guess. by
on 2017-09-28 04:22:00 UTC
Link to this
I think number one is the fake. The Sue description is too on-the-nose, and "hexing" seems too specific a verb for the average write to use.
The other two I can too easily picture as being legit.
—doctorlit, probably wrong though -
Your guess is... by
on 2017-09-28 14:54:00 UTC
Link to this
Correct.
-
Okay, my turn! by
on 2017-09-27 15:16:00 UTC
Link to this
1) Sigyn Faye Anasta stood outside by the park outside of London. She knew it was a matter of time before she was truly hunted for what she was. She was the last of the true immortals. Yes, there was other out there but they were all tainted by the other two immortals, vampires and werewolves. Until there was a way to cure them there was no hope with their blood. The wind blew moving her blonde hair across her face. Her blue eyes locked with the nearly full moon. Her father died when she was in Hogwarts and that was centuries ago. Her mother died in child birth with her during a total solar eclipse. But she looked like she was in her mid-twenties. A scent caught her attention she had many traits of her fellow immortals. A heightened sense of smell and sight were just a few.
2) I grabbed an arrow from my quiver and load it on to my bow, I leaped to the front while at the same time turned my body to face the beast, and simultaneously released the strings of my bow and let the arrow fly towards the giant's head. I did my best attempt of an "action movie style archery" and shoot my arrow right to his head. And guess what folks? I f***ing did it! Well, only the whole "action movie style archery" part that is, it turned out my arrow just bounced off his skin.
3) "How could you, Ruby!?" I screamed, hearing Ruby's hurtful words. The pain in my chest was unbearable, and not only because of the Beowulf's claws. I loved her. She was the only anchor I had in this unfair world. She was everything to me! And now? It was all over.
"I'm one of them now! You know it, Yang knows it, everybody else will know, too! I'm gonna become half-Grimm!" -
Hmmm... by
on 2017-09-27 15:23:00 UTC
Link to this
I'm going to go with the third one. The second one, on first glance, seems like the most likely candidate, but then I wondered... would a PPCer really make a badfic lookalike's OC fail at anything?
Half-Grimm seems more unlikely to me; I get the sense that in a real badfic, the author would go for a full-blown Grimm turning instead. -
You have chosen... by
on 2017-09-27 15:28:00 UTC
Link to this
Wisely.
-
My go! by
on 2017-09-27 14:23:00 UTC
Link to this
1) Once upon a time over 20 year ago professour Lupus was sit in his house he was only teenager now and he had not been made into the wearwolf yet.
2) [...] [Luna] woke rather suddenly with that familiar fire between her perfectly smooth legs. "Oh no, not now! Silly vagina and your feelings, always taking control of me like this!" she spoke to herself softly, a giggle leaving her lips.
3) but professor, hermione whaled, i cant go outside like this! i'm nakid andd ron wont like it! -
Uh... Umm... Okay... by
on 2017-09-27 15:20:00 UTC
Link to this
I know for a fact that it's not the second... Now first one only has minor spelling mistakes which could indicate that it's real, especially since the third one seems forcefully made bad... But since it's scape we're talking about, she might've pulled a twist... and a twist of a twist... and a twist of a twist of a...
Okay, I say you made up number 1. -
Nope! by
on 2017-09-30 13:35:00 UTC
Link to this
That is from the genuine
ly terriblefic Profesor Lupus and the Curse of the Wearwolf.
I made up number 3. Ya done played yourself. =] -
The rules said nothing NSFW. (nm) by
on 2017-09-27 14:57:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Hmm, tough call. by
on 2017-09-27 04:36:00 UTC
Link to this
I think the first one is real because it would be the most difficult style to affect deliberately. Reads like someone whose first language is not English as well as not knowing where to draw the line between narrative and author's note.
The second one could be fake because it's a bunch of Suvian cliches without any obvious writing tics (other than an improper semicolon), easy enough to fake, but that one specific detail about the family name gives me pause. Why Bellagio? Seems like something that could have specific importance to the author—but then again, it could be something randomly pulled out of nowhere. Or both!
The third one could be fake because it reminds me of "The Girl and Her Dragon," and I can totally see Iximaz pulling that off. It's not quite the same tic, though, since there are actual sentences here, even if they are improperly run together in a single paragraph. The weird spacing around the punctuation is another thing I feel like I've seen somewhere before. It could be a deliberate recombination of different problems, or it could just be terrible writing.
Hmmm.
I'm gonna go with the second one being the fake. It just seems like the easiest to make up.
~Neshomeh -
You got me! by
on 2017-09-27 04:38:00 UTC
Link to this
And here I thought the third one would seem like the obvious fake. :P
-
*resurfaces, yawning. Or yarning if you believe autocorrect* by
on 2017-09-27 20:13:00 UTC
Link to this
The third one honestly sounds familiar. What's it from?
~Z -
Just some fic I pulled off the Pit. by
on 2017-09-27 20:28:00 UTC
Link to this
Also, hello again!
-
Hiya. by
on 2017-09-27 20:34:00 UTC
Link to this
Seriously, it looks familiar. Strange.
~Z
-
Oh, also, I graduated by
on 2017-09-28 09:49:00 UTC
Link to this
It happened a bit ago, but what with the faffery and this and that and such. But, yes! I am officially out of school! When I recently joined a gym there was brief consideration of making me pay heaps for it, because I was technically not a student! What! What?!
But, yes, there it is.
Huzzah! -
Congratulations! by
on 2017-10-02 04:10:00 UTC
Link to this
Where did you graduate from, and what are your plans from here?
-
Congraduations! by
on 2017-10-01 23:39:00 UTC
Link to this
I can't believe nobody has made that joke yet. So, let me be the first.
-
Congrats! (nm) by
on 2017-09-29 22:11:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Yeeeee! *throws hat* Congrats! (nm) by
on 2017-09-28 14:49:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Hooray! (nm) by
on 2017-09-28 14:18:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Congratulations! *tosses Spikes* (nm) by
on 2017-09-28 13:49:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Friday Forum: Sexuality and Space edition by
on 2017-09-29 10:22:00 UTC
Link to this
Aaaaand we're back. I've actually paid attention to the news this week, so you get rather an excessive number of items -- yay? (As usual, the images are not important parts of the post - they're just here to add a bit of colour.)
Please remember that, when it comes to the state of the world, not everyone will agree with you. You're free to state, discuss, and defend your viewpoint (provided it does not violate the Constitution), but please don't use that fact to attack others.
Fandom News
(Link)
It's here! For the first time in over a decade, there is a new Star Trek series on TV. Star Trek: Discovery has launched. If you're anywhere other than the US, you can probably get it on Netflix; in the US, you're supposed to buy into CBS All Access, which sounds like a great way to waste money.
Kaitlyn and I watched the first two episodes, and will be watching the third. The first episode feels more Wars than Trek, but the second episode gets a bit more into the groove. It's no spoiler to say that the show taps into the long and honourable school of psychopathic Vulcans - the 'shoot first, never ask questions because logic dictates that it was the right thing to do' style exemplified by Voyager's Tuvok is alive and well here. Also there are Klingons (and long speeches in Klingon, which are unfortunately delivered... like... ShatNER is... speaKING... hey, I never said it was perfect).
The linked article does a good job of covering the controversy that's surrounded the series even before it launched.
Silly News
(Generation Z & Prince Harry)
Recently, BBC TV show Newsbeat had Ipsos Mori carry out a poll about Generation Z. That's the post-Millennial generation, apparently, or anyone born between 1994 and 2001; probably quite a lot of the Board, actually.
You can read the article or look at the survey yourself, but the most interesting fact to me was the question on sexual orientation. Generation Z reported only 66% 'only attracted to the opposite sex', while the older generations (Millennial/Y, X, and Baby Boom) came in at 71%, 85%, and 88%. Most of the difference seems to be down to a breaking of the binary 'straight/gay' definition: 26% of Generation Z reported that they were either equally attracted to both sexes (9%), or 'mostly' (rather than 'only') to the opposite (9%) or same (3%). By contrast, Generation X only has 6% on 'mostly the opposite sex', and only 2% 'equally'.
Given that we don't actually live in a world where people are either made of muscles or breasts, and which one it is determines everything about them, this seems like a good thing to me.
Meanwhile, over in Canada, a toddler decided that Prince Harry's popcorn looked delicious. So she stole it. Repeatedly.
Harry, who is currently fifth in line to the throne of the United Kingdom, took it very well. Because apparently being in the news for dressing up as a Nazi a few years back made him realise that yes, people are watching?
Serious News
(The Moon & Mars)
NASA has announced that they will be partnering with the Russian space agency Roscosmos to build a space station in lunar orbit, to be used as a staging ground for deep space missions. There doesn't seem to be a timeline yet, but hey! That's exciting.
Closer to home, but with a much longer timescale, Dubai/the UAE has announced their plan to build a simulated Mars city, to test out the science behind a completely contained city. This is part of their plan to build a 600,000-person city on Mars itself by 2117, which seems... ambitious. Still, running a full-scale trial in a desert is probably a good place to start.
Not News
(Link)
This week, I found out that Batwoman - Kate Kane - is gay. This will get one of two reactions:
1/ "Who's Batwoman?" To which the answer is, she's an actually pretty awesome character in the current range of Batman/Bat-family comics. I'm not 100% on the state of play in Gotham, but she's definitely playing a major role.
2/ "Well, obviously. That's an integral part of her character." Well, I can't speak to that, but a week ago I was very nearly in answer #1 myself. So hey! Cool stuff.
Interestingly, I seem to recall hearing that Harley Quinn and Poison Ivy have a bit of an on-again/off-again/villainous-again relationship going on, so... is there something about Gotham that attracts lesbians?
hS -
Fandom news: My Immortal author still unknown. by
on 2017-10-06 15:29:00 UTC
Link to this
So you know all the fuss a few weeks/months ago over the supposed author of My Immortal publishing a memoir?
She lied.
The TL;DR of it is that s**t went down, she forged documents, the memoir has been canceled, and her brother wasn't as lost as she claimed. Someone doxxed her; she lied about being Native American, about being put in the foster care system, and her claims of writing a trollfic in order to find her brother when he's been on Facebook all along and contacted her several times are, quite simply, false.
She was just another person who tried to claim the story as hers for attention. -
Noooot convinced by
on 2017-10-08 02:35:00 UTC
Link to this
The "source" is on Kiwifarms- in case you didn't know their reputation, they're a nasty little bunch of harassers and psychopaths. I know people who have been targets of theirs for multiple years- doxxing, swatting, etcetera, are all normal things for them. So- I don't buy it. In fact, I wish they would drop off the face of the earth.
-
If you look at Rose's Twitter feed... by
on 2017-10-08 03:19:00 UTC
Link to this
...You can see starting about ten tweets down her acknowledging the poster as her brother in response to what happened on the thread.
-
My thoughts: by
on 2017-10-07 20:46:00 UTC
Link to this
Yeah, I don't buy the story either. Writing a trollfic to find her brother? How could anyone even possibly believe that would work, seriously? Yeah, no. Even if it were actually coming from the real author of the fic instead of some random fangirl, it's still a terrible excuse. And the whole "Native American and put in foster care" thing, while definitely possible in real life on its own, sounds like the premise of a movie when you compare it to the supposed results. It sounds really contrived, a little bit appropriation-y, and overall just plain suspicious. Much like a bad fanfiction.
I have a feeling that the real author of My Immortal, whoever she is, probably doesn't want to reveal her actual identity. Given how logical and grown-up she seems to have become now from looking at the post she wrote saying that she didn't write Handbook for Mortals, she probably decided that letting the world know isn't worth the huge influx of random crud people would send to her. A very wise choice indeed.
-Twistey -
I'm not convinced by
on 2017-10-06 23:23:00 UTC
Link to this
The person who doxxed her is the same one who claimed to be her brother, but the only proof he offered was stuff you can get from a Google search. The forum he made this claim on is known for attacking women and minorities and Rose Christo basically the perfect target for them. The "fact checking" she failed, according to the EW article on the subject,is apparently that she changed names to preserve anonymity. Also, beyond some jerk's say-so, there is no proof she was lying about anything. Like, why ia no one seemingly willing to question his story th way they har hers?
-
The brother's identity was vetted by Rose herself. by
on 2017-10-06 23:47:00 UTC
Link to this
Take that how you will.
-
Whaaaaat. by
on 2017-10-06 16:31:00 UTC
Link to this
I think the real 'whaaaaaat' here is that a real publisher was actually considering publishing a book about a badfic. I mean, that's... only in the 21st century, folks!
hS -
In hS news: by
on 2017-10-04 09:39:00 UTC
Link to this
-
In hS news: by
on 2017-10-04 09:39:00 UTC
Link to this
-
What is this? by
on 2017-10-04 14:45:00 UTC
Link to this
It doesn't appear for me.
-
Aww, now you've gone and spoiled it. by
on 2017-10-04 14:47:00 UTC
Link to this
I was waiting to see how long it took Scape to realise how banjaxed her HTML was. ^_~
Her post was supposed to be this:
Have some stained glass of Chrysoplax!
Also, small question: did you enjoy the peculiar craft sodas I gave you at the Gathering?
The location of the hidden part of my reply is left as an exercise to the reader. :D
hS -
That looks really cool... by
on 2017-10-04 15:29:00 UTC
Link to this
And that makes me ashamed of using the opportunity to point out a month-old news about Shadows of War (beware of 'spoilers'). They're not even trying anymore.
-
Helm Hammerhand? Isildur? *dies* (nm) by
on 2017-10-04 21:35:00 UTC
Link to this
-
*Picks up the mini-Boarder* by
on 2017-10-04 21:54:00 UTC
Link to this
Hopefully, they won't inflict this indignity to more kings and Nazgul?
I mean, they're all about how they follow an 'alternate timeline' from canon, but there is AU and... badfic. -
It's worse even than that. by
on 2017-10-06 13:24:00 UTC
Link to this
I'm pretty sure Helmwraith directly contradicts the movies, let alone the books. Remember the 'Tomb of the Nazgul' in Desolation of Smaug? They claimed the Nine were buried there after the fall of Angmar, in 1935 - around the time the last king of Gondor died. But Rohan wasn't even founded until 2510, and Helm died in 2759. Helmwraith would have had to be buried eight hundred years before his death.
Or maybe the claim is that the Nazgul keep being killed off and replaced? But that's... dumb. And anyway, Isilgul has an even bigger problem: Sauron was gone at the time when he needed to place a ring on Isildur's finger. That's literally the whole point.
I am annoyed. I am so annoyed that I must express myself...
...
...
... through POETRY!
(Once I've written some.)
hS -
Ode to Canon (by Isildur & Helm, Ringwraiths) by
on 2017-10-06 13:50:00 UTC
Link to this
How do we break thee? Let us count the ways:
We claim the Hammerhand slew friend and foe,
When truth holds him a hero in the snow!
King Helm needed no ring to win our praise!
Nor need Isildur flee the Eye of Flames
When Sauron was disbanded, sent below,
In no fit state to grant a ring of woe...
And these are but a tithe of our dismays!
Should Sauron claim a wraith but leave the One?
Should Nazgul rise three thousand years too late?
Did Saruman not find Isildur's bones,
And Helm not stand eternal at the gate?
No, say we! Let us rest, our battles done
And keep us heroes, as the Words dictate.
(With sincerest apologies to Elizabeth Barrett Browning.)
Yeah: to claim Isilgul, Sauron would have had to go 'oh, what was that shiny thing that fell off your finger into the river? WELP GUESS IT WAS NOTHING, OFF WE TROT.'
hS -
My two cents... by
on 2017-10-06 16:37:00 UTC
Link to this
((Litterally, I doubt they're worth more.))
Shattered canon,
The kings of old are sullied,
The Nine slighted.
In the fair England,
A new source of power,
The tomb of Tolkien. -
May I suggest a haiku or two? :3 (nm) by
on 2017-10-06 13:32:00 UTC
Link to this
-
... you've got to be kidding. by
on 2017-10-04 15:37:00 UTC
Link to this
That's... incomparably stupid.
hS -
I wish so much. by
on 2017-10-04 15:44:00 UTC
Link to this
You know, you can tell it... British are all preparing a cheap energy source for the after Brexit with this game, right?
-
That is quite gorgeous. by
on 2017-10-04 10:23:00 UTC
Link to this
Though I can't escape the feeling it has too many legs... also a flame mustache. ^_^
We did! We spaced them out over about a month, tacking them onto meals that we felt deserved them. :) Thank you very much.
hS -
De nada. =] by
on 2017-10-04 10:48:00 UTC
Link to this
Next time, I will bring sleepy/nervous Canterbury fudge. Next time... =]
-
Awesome News! by
on 2017-10-02 14:56:00 UTC
Link to this
Yesterday, October 1st, Germany's new same-sex marriage legislation came into effect. From now on, a marriage can be entered by "two persons of the same or different sex/gender". Still, there is a lot of cleaning up in other legal texts that still refer to "man" and "woman" necessary, as well as clarification on wether intersex people, who can opt to have the space for sex/gender to be left empty on official documents and IDs, can marry.
Still, it's a big step in the right direction.
~Ak, throwing rainbow confetti -
Re: Friday Forum: Sexuality and Space edition by
on 2017-10-01 16:04:00 UTC
Link to this
Some fandom news.
Sword Art Online: Alicization has recently been annouced. I've been waiting for this ever since Ordinal Scale teased its release.
Some bad news.
Apparently, Hollywood thought it was a good idea to adapt yet another anime into live action. This time, they have chosen to adapt "Kimi o na wa" or "Your Name". They just never learn, do they? Given their track record, I can only hope that it is at least better than Dragonball Evolution and Netflix Death Note. -
Oops by
on 2017-10-01 16:05:00 UTC
Link to this
I forgot to fill in the author part.
-
Nice news, hS. Here's my Not News, somewhat directed to you: by
on 2017-09-30 20:44:00 UTC
Link to this
Did anyone know that Iron Sky has a website? Some of you probably did, but I only recently discovered it, and am very excited to begin exploring once I get over my chicken-ness and start. All I know is it's got a Flash thing on the main page, so it's probably interactive to some degree. Probably also was made to promote the upcoming second movie (which will ironically enough be released in 2018, and if you remember the Friday Forum segment hS did on it, will involve Hitler riding a T-rex. Yep. It's that weird.)
Ironsky.net is the address. Type it in if you dare, because apparently it doesn't turn into a link.
Now, some of you may be asking, why am I suddenly so knowledgeable about this movie that hS told us about one random day? The answer is: I got curious, especially since 2018 (when the space Nazis land in the movie) is the second calendar year in this school year, and I started speculating about what some of my friends would do if some of the spacefaring fascists took a wrong turn and landed near their location. Upon reading the plot of the movie on Wikipedia, I learned exactly how hilariously weird the movie was (and also concluded that were this to happen IRL, I'd probably get some blonde hair dye thrown at my face. And I would absolutely hate it.) I decided I liked it, and then continued researching it further. And then I found the website and bookmarked it. So yeah.
Thank you for reading my weird piece of Not News. You may now continue with life.
-Twistey
(And because this was posted mainly for hS, I shall accompany it with a piece of obligatory googly-eyed Walfas art.
http://www.makemegoogly.com/67XB7
There you go.) -
In additional Not News: by
on 2017-09-30 13:33:00 UTC
Link to this
This post comes to you live from the Touchdown Café in Canterbury Christ Church University, where I have just embarked upon an MA in Creative Writing. It's a fascinating course with a lot of time to hone my craft as a genre author, so it'll be interesting to see how this affects my PPC stuff.
One of the course elements that I'm particularly excited about is a section on learning to write critical essays... so I'll be doing that. I have something in mind for what to write a critical essay concerning, too:
TOS.
Wish me luck. =] -
*Salutes* o7 (nm) by
on 2017-09-30 18:20:00 UTC
Link to this
-
*throws cakefetti* (nm) by
on 2017-09-30 13:57:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Your Brain on Fiction by
on 2017-09-30 01:51:00 UTC
Link to this
This isn't a new story, but a friend of mine showed it to me today, and I bet it will interest most of you folks, too. Neuroscience shows that reading can make you better at peopling. {= )
"Your Brain on Fiction"
~Neshomeh -
My takeaway on this... by
on 2017-09-30 06:22:00 UTC
Link to this
... is that if I read enough, I won't have to talk to people any more.
I am fine with that.
hS, incorrigible introvert
(Obviously talking on the Internet doesn't count; the Board is more like interactive fiction with some seriously awesome characters.) -
From The Neath's Newsdesk... by
on 2017-09-29 15:42:00 UTC
Link to this
Fallen London is a thing, as those who frequent the Discord may be aware. In considerably more exciting news, a new game in the same setting, Sunless Skies, is in public beta, and was showcased at EGX this week.
The fantastic platformer N++ is coming to Xbox One very soon now. If you ever played the original flash game, or N+ on the 360, you know the drill. If you never played the flash game... Well, it's free, so play it before you buy this one if you're considering it, so you know what you're in for.
Another event you may not be aware of that happened... In July? Jeez... Is the annual XYZZY Awards! Where the Interactive Fiction Community picks the best IF of the year, commercial or hobbyist, CYOA and Twine stuff to traditional Parser IF ala Zork or Adventure itself. I haven't looked over this year's winners yet, but in last year's awards (for the works of 2015), Birdland, a CYOA Twine affair, swept the categories. I would absolutely suggest playing it, because it is funny and touching and amazing and you can save the world from birds really what more do you WANT?
[takes breath after run-on]
In other news, I somehow managed to miss the release of The Delirium Brief, the newest Laundry Files Novel. The Laundry Files are, of course, excellent, and I cannot recommend them enough. -
Hah, I know about that game for a really weird reason! by
on 2017-09-30 20:48:00 UTC
Link to this
http://www.seventhsanctum.com/generate.php?Genname=color
This is a generator that generates colors with magical properties like in Fallen London. I was curious about the game and looked it up. As such, I know about Fallen London. Sort of. I also posted this because I kinda wanted to show you the generator itself, as you, someone who has heard of the game, would probably enjoy the generator.
Have fun with the generator.
-Twistey -
erm by
on 2017-09-29 15:44:00 UTC
Link to this
And Birdland's URL is birdland.camp. The Board is messing with the link, sadly...
-
URLs need "http://www." in front of them. by
on 2017-09-29 15:53:00 UTC
Link to this
Otherwise it tries to direct to a sub-directory of the site you're on.
hS -
*facepalms*. I knew that. WHAT WAS I THINKING? (nm) by
on 2017-09-29 16:47:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Regarding Batwoman by
on 2017-09-29 13:50:00 UTC
Link to this
I don't think its anything specific about Gotham in particular, but it is a growing trend in comics at large.
-
I am consumed by curiousity. by
on 2017-09-29 14:10:00 UTC
Link to this
As someone who doesn't read comics that much, I know about Batwoman (... obviously), and Bobby Drake over in Marvel. I also know about Apollo and the Midnighter, but they're old now. And DC's Bombshells series had a lot of this. And the Marvel Star Wars comics have the delightful Doctor Aphra... anyway. My point is that other than Kate and Bobby, those examples are all fairly niche, so probably aren't what you're thinking of. So what are you thinking of?
(Oh, and Wonder Woman. But that's never been explicitly canonised.)
hS -
Actually, Re: Wonder Woman... by
on 2017-10-14 05:40:00 UTC
Link to this
Greg Rucka confirmed in an interview earlier this year that at minimum the version of Wonder Woman that he and Nicola Scott wrote was bisexual. I believe Gaillard Simone said the same thing about her run too. I know she confirmed Catman, of the Secret Six, was, but like half the Secret Six were somewhere on the LGBT+ spectrum.
-
The big one off the top of my head is... by
on 2017-09-29 23:01:00 UTC
Link to this
Northstar. In 2012 Marvel showcased the marriage between Northstar and his husband as the first same-sex marriage ceremony in a comic book.
Bobby Drake was another one.
Other LGBT Comic Characters:
1. Daken (Marvel)
2. Catwoman (DC)
3. Renee Montoya (DC)
4. John Constantine (DC)
5. Mystique (Marvel)
6. Destiny (Marvel)
There are others as well. It really started with both Northstar 2012 and with Batwoman. Both of those has made LGBT characters far more common. -
Wait, Catwoman? by
on 2017-09-30 06:17:00 UTC
Link to this
I'm pretty sure Catwoman is currently in the middle of being proposed to by Batman? Also, I remember Constantine flirting with several women... are they both shown as bi, or is this something else on the spectrum?
Anyway, thanks! Random trivia I've heard:
-Apparently Bobby Drake was always implied to be gay (depending on the writer, at least); it's just that it's only recently they've been allowed to say it. It looks like Northstar had the same issue - it was implied from his first appearance in 1979, but only said in 1992.
-Speaking of weddings... one Batwoman writer was seriously angry when DC declared that they wouldn't be allowed to let Batwoman marry her girlfriend. For... reasons? I'unno.
hS -
Here I am to explain the conundrum! by
on 2017-09-30 15:16:00 UTC
Link to this
Both Catwoman are in on the LGBT ride:
- The Catwoman we mostly know, Selina Kyle, is - as you know - occasional on-an-off fling of Batman (plus she has a child with another man), but she was confirmed bisexual (via smooching a yakuza lady) in Catwoman #39, in 2015
- Second Catowman, Holly Robinson (protegee of Selina), was full-blown lesbian. She was killed off, unfortunately.
As for Constantine, oh yeah - he was confirmed bisexual since 1992.
Adding to what Uber mentioned, I still remember by heart some of other comic LGBT:
- Alysia Yeoh [DC], trans woman
- Wiccan & Hulkling [Marve], both gay
- newest Aqualad (Jackson Hyde; DC) outed himself as gay not so long ago.
- America Chavez [Marvel] -
From the "Various Minor Fandoms" newsdesk by
on 2017-09-29 13:21:00 UTC
Link to this
We now have confirmed airdates for the new series of Robot Wars and Red Dwarf: the 22nd and 12th of October respectively. So that's fun!
Also, in rather substantially less fun news, Northern Irish YouTube content creator and former ChezApocalypse person Jill Bearup (who mentioned us in a long series about the history of fanfiction) was someone I respected considerably. I say was because she went full TERF recently, comparing - and I swear I'm not making this up - wanting to transition to wanting to eat chocolate cake for every meal. Now, when she brought us up in History Of Fanfiction Part 6: I Love You, Mary Sue, she said a lot of what we'd done over the years came off as "mean".
I'm not saying there's a correlation between bad feminism and Mary Sue defenders.
I'm just heavily implying it, because that's what I think. -
For a moment there... by
on 2017-09-29 14:08:00 UTC
Link to this
... I thought you were talking about a combined Robot Wars/Red Dwarf series. But this is almost as good. ;)
Now I'm gonna threadjack my own thread:
Putting 'TERF' into Google takes me to this wiki, which defines it as 'Trans-Exclusionary Radical Feminist'. It clarifies that as meaning 'feminism which excludes trans people'; it doesn't seem to say where the 'radical' part comes in, so I'm just gonna assume it means they have unfilled (but neutral) outer electron shells and leave it at that.
Then it says this:
Their position (which is not shared by this wiki) denies that trans people's self-affirmed genders and sexes are equally valid as cis people's self-affirmed genders and sexes. (Bold added by me.)
So, then. My understanding is that 'sex' is a biological term; it can either indicate the nature of your primary sexual characteristics, or your chromosomes (these often match). It's not strictly a binary affair, but it comes pretty close. Does transitioning sex therefore imply surgery? Or is a change in secondary sexual characteristics (which includes things like body hair, I think) considered a change of sex? (Or is this a 'depends who you talk to' question?)
Then we come to gender, which is... what? A collection of traits traditionally culturally associated with a sex, and restrictions/requirements connected to them? It's obvious that being female-gendered rather than male-gendered (or vice versa) is a big deal for many people (this is what we call 'understatement'), but I'm... not clear why? The way people have talked about it here, they don't seem to be focussed on how they're viewed/treated by others (ie, it doesn't seem to be a result of variations on 'I'm fed up of the anti-female slant of society and would rather escape it by identifying as male'), but then... what?
I guess the question I'm asking in this part is: what is the difference between the genders 'male' and 'female', other than that other people have different prejudices assigned to the two terms?
Where the above includes misunderstandings or misinterpretations, please correct them. :) That's how we learn.
hS -
My (hopefully somewhat informed) understanding by
on 2017-09-30 18:58:00 UTC
Link to this
(aka, I'm attempting to pass on, with some degree of accuracy, things I read on the Internet that appeared to be backed by evidence, but people should feel free to straighten me out)
One thing that seems to exist, from what little we can tell about neurobiology, is a brain-internal map-of-the-self, which gives you a general sense of what your body should consist of. One thing included in that is which sex-linked physical characteristics you expect to have. As I understand it, that mentally-expected layout is your gender identity. This gender identity often both a) matches what is physically present and b) falls into categories we (as a culture) have created called "male" and "female".
Not meeting condition a (gender identity != physical characteristics) makes you transgender (although I believe it's a matter of personal preference and/or fierce debate whether that description persists after transitioning, that is, fixing your physical characteristics so they better match your gender identity, is concluded). Not meeting condition b (gender identity doesn't fall into the male/female buckets) makes you non-binary.
Complicating everything is gender expression, which is how you fit in to the cultural stuff about how a "man" or "woman" should look, act, talk, etc.. That seems to be a related but somewhat separate axis from identity and physical sex stuff. I'll leave that to someone who could say intelligent things about it, except to remark that being regarded as/referred to as/... the gender you identify as is a very big deal, since it's, roughly speaking, a significant component of who you are.
- Tomash -
So if I'm understanding this right... by
on 2017-10-02 09:28:00 UTC
Link to this
... your understanding is that 'transgender' is actually about sex, not gender? Or is that only part of what you're including under 'physical characteristics'?
Meanwhile, your 'condition b' is about fitting in with the culturally-defined male/female binary. That seems to suggest that if someone moved to a different culture with radically different gender roles, they would automatically become non-binary (in that culture), regardless of whether they they elected to fit in by following the roles ('gender expression', as you say). Is that right?
hS -
I appreciate this discussion by
on 2017-10-04 02:29:00 UTC
Link to this
As someone who has difficulty understanding all the stuff about gender and whatnot, I appreciate this whole clarifying, yet non-polarizing, discussion of what transgender, among other things, means.
-
Words are hard by
on 2017-10-02 11:04:00 UTC
Link to this
First off, to clear up my confusion, what are you thinking of when you say "sex" and "gender"? (For the record, I spent that last post staying away from "gender" because I'm not entirely sure what I mean by that word.)
From what I know, if you take a look at humans as a species, you'll notice several sex characteristics, such as chromosomal sex, reproductive-organ sex, hormonal sex, and probably a few other ones. Sex characteristics aren't binary things, but they tend to fall into two groups that tend to be correlated with each other.
One such characteristic is what I could in this context call mental sex[1], which is called "gender identity" (or maybe just "gender", I'm not sure on that).
"Cisgender" is having a gender identity that accurately matches your other sex characteristics[2]. "Transgender" is all the other cases, broadly speaking.
Gender identity, like the rest of these often-correlated things, is not a binary thing. Having a gender identity (what you expect your body to be like) that doesn't fit into the two major categories of physical layout makes you "non-binary". So I think your second paragraph is somewhat off, in that non-binary is defined by what a culture considers a male body and a female body to be, social roles aside.
Now, we as a species have formed cultures that tend to take the two most visible groups of correlated sex characteristics and label them "male" and "female" (recognition of other categories seems to vary by culture). Then, there are generally social roles or expectations associated with being in (or being regarded as being in) each of these categories. Which of these expectations you follow gives you your "gender expression".
[1]: I made this term up while composing this post, and it's possibly misleading or otherwise unsuitable for general use
[2]: More specifically, I think having matching personally-observable sex characteristics is sufficient
- Tomash -
Right. by
on 2017-10-02 11:28:00 UTC
Link to this
I defined/asked how I was using the terms 'sex' and 'gender' here.
It seems like you are saying that everything except 'gender expression' is tied directly to your body-image: external sexual characteristics, primary and secondary, plus(?) things like chromosomes and hormones which can't be perceived externally, but might affect various aspects of your development. Perhaps an example might help?
Alex McZample exhibits masculine body traits, including sex organs, and doesn't feel any issues with this. Alex is therefore cis-male.
Bobbie McZample has female sex organs, but (due to, oh, probably hormones) is flat-chested, flat-hipped, and grows significant body hair. Bobbie is... non-binary?
Charlie McZample has female characteristics, but feels that they should look more like Bobbie and Alex do. Charlie is therefore trans-male, possibly with male gender expression?
Drew McZample is the cat. The McZamples are a fairly odd couple.
El McZample has male body traits and sex organs, and is fine with that, but prefers to wear dresses. El is... cis-male with female gender expression?
Frankie McZample has female body traits and sex organs, but feels like they should have male sex organs (while retaining the same body shape). Frankie is... non-binary?
Georgie McZample is biologically female (and is fine with that), but wears their hair short and plays football. Georgie is... cis-female with male gender expression?
Harper McZample is Georgie's identical twin, and acts just like them, but has moved to a country where that is the expected way for a female to behave. Harper is therefore cis-female with female gender expression.
Id McZample is biologically female, feels like they should have male sex organs and characteristics, but still wants to wear dresses and makeup. Id is... trans-male with female gender expression?
Of the eight McZample children, how many have I got right? And - other people - how much of Tomash's understanding matches yours?
hS -
I'd add one more McZample by
on 2017-10-08 06:52:00 UTC
Link to this
Josie McZample has female body traits. She considers herself fully female, and is attracted to men. She also wears her hair short, wears a mix of male and female clothing. Enjoys some stereotypical masculine things and some stereotypical feminine things. She is hetero cisgender with a neutral gender expression. I think that the expression can be netral without falling into nonbinary?
-
Delta McZample here! by
on 2017-10-02 19:22:00 UTC
Link to this
So! I like your definitions- I would extend gender to also include a lot of self-image and body-shape stuff, though. The world at large believes that women have long hair, hips, a waistline, breasts, etc, therefore that image is part of that gender.
We trans people don't really talk about "transitioning sex" much- even the term "sex reassignment surgery" is falling out of favor for "gender reassignment" or "gender confirmation". The point of my journey has been entirely about my relationship to my gender- both how the world sees me and how I see myself. The most biologically heavy part of it is that testosterone was making me all kinds of depressed, and getting off that stuff gave me huge dividends.
Gender is all about self-chosen identity. It's frequently conveniently in line with how our bodies are shaped, which is the state we call being cisgender. Ultimately, though, it's a choice we make- how are we shaped? How do we want to be shaped? What hormones are we comfortable with? Where aren't we comfortable with our bodies? Basically all the answers to these questions fall into the arena of gender.
The words we use are really just trying to describe the very squishy answers to those questions- they're not hard categories, they're definitely not easy to be specific with, and all of them are mostly used to try to talk about our feelings and experiences. I won't go into the dictionary 101 here, but it's important to note- "trans" is a huge umbrella, and "non-binary" is usually included in it. Non-binary itself is a big umbrella, there are tons of experiences contained in it. As you would figure, given that it's literally "outside these two well-known options."
Some non-binary people find a lot of help in hormone therapies, and other pieces of the stereotypical binary-to-binary transition process. Others don't- it varies by person. I'm even technically non-binary- while my transition looks very stereotypically b-2-b, I'm genderfluid- there are days where I'm a woman and it's important to me to be perceived as such by myself and others, and there are also days where I'm agender- "do I have to engage with social constructs of gender today? Really?"
So! On to the McZamples!
Alex is indeed a cis man.
Bobbie is an interesting case. If she wanted to be flat-chested, flat-hipped, etc, and was taking hormones to deliberately produce that expression, non-binary would make sense as a label. On the other hand, if it's just how she was, I'd be wondering if she was intersex- that's the usual term for when someone's primary and secondary sex characteristics, hormone balances, and chromosomes didn't fit a normal model. Intersex people can identify as trans, and some find a lot of self-understanding in non-binary identities, but some don't.
Charlie is probably a trans man- once again, if they chose to take that identity.
Drew is adorable, and deserves pets.
El is also complicated. There are cis men who enjoy wearing dresses- Eddie Izzard, for example. There are also cis men who perform drag, putting on an entire feminine identity for a while. They also could be non-binary, expressing a feminine side- you specified that they were comfortable with a masculine/testosterone-oriented body, so the only option there that's really off the table is being a trans woman. (I have a friend who's the sweetest guy you'll ever meet, definitely a guy, and looks absolutely smashing in a miniskirt and heels.)
Frankie is probably non-binary- their ideal body shape is compatible with neither binary option.
George is probably a cis woman with tomboy or butch tendencies- I'm assuming that they're fine with she/her pronouns, and generally being "that girl who plays football"?
Harper is a cis woman, also with tomboy or butch tendencies- as you've noted, they're now in the mystical land of butch women. Please send me the address and nearest airport code...
Id could take a few different identities- they could be a very femme trans-man, although mainstream western society doesn't really have a role for that. They could also be non-binary, if they wanted to acknowledge and claim a feminine side to their identity.
-Delta Juliette
(Or, She Who Writes Many Words About Gender With Little Provocation McZample) -
Okay, so. by
on 2017-10-03 14:11:00 UTC
Link to this
I always find the best way to figure out if you've understood someone is to repeat it back to them in your own words. So here we go:
What you seem to be saying is that 'gender' means (to coin a hopefully neutral word) 'bodyshape': the physical makeup of your body, including primary and secondary sexual characteristics, hormonal balance, and things like hair length and such.
You're then saying that people have an innate sense of what their bodyshape/gender should be; you're not putting it quite as strongly as Tomash did, but I think the idea's there. Essentially the Residual Self-Image from the Matrix, but for real life.
You then note that bodyshape (ideal and current/actual) falls broadly into two categories, which are to an extent socially-defined - long hair was a mark of male youth in Renaissance Italy, for instance, but not so much today. Most people are comfortable in one of those two categories, which pegs them as cis/trans-male/female, in some combination.
Anything which falls outside those categories is non-binary. How far does that go? I'm guessing short hair doesn't make a woman non-binary; or does it, if the intent of cutting it short is to be un-feminine (without specifically/necessarily being masculine)?
And then you throw out the term 'agender', which I think means that on some days your innate sense of what your body should look like... what? Gives up and goes home? That seems to be what you're implying (or at least that you don't see it as important on those days), but I'm honestly not sure.
How did I do?
hS
(I really don't think you can call this 'little provocation. ^_~) -
Pretty much! by
on 2017-10-03 18:55:00 UTC
Link to this
There's one other thing to gender that's almost impossible to put into words- there's a sense, somewhere deep inside us, of what group we belong to. I can look at another woman and recognize- I might not look like her, we might have wildly different outfits or body shapes, but we recognize that we are the same group in a way that any guy- even my hypothetical cis-male twin, would not be.
And I think that's the missing part here- everything else probably shapes that underlying sense, and we're comfortable or uncomfortable with bodyshape, presentation, hormones, etc based off of the combination of it and social constructions. It's all approximately as circular as only psychology can be- but there is that deep group-sense that is usually called "gender identity". Everyone has it. Most (cis) people don't question it. But it's still there.
So! with that introduction- you've pretty much got it! Bodyshape is a thing that's very significant (I've even seen it alter my perceptions of myself- looking in a mirror and wait, where did those curves come from? Or where did they go? I could swear I wasn't shaped like this yesterday...), and for most people, falls into two (broad, mostly socially-defined) categories.
I believe that non-binary identities, as with trans identities, are just that- they come from, at root, internally-held gender identities. My sister, who habitually cuts her hair short, identifies as a woman- therefore, when she performs stereotypically un-womanly actions (cutting her hair short, wearing flannel, driving a pickup truck), she is a woman performing stereotypically un-womanly actions.
On the other hand, a non-binary person, whose gender identity is some combination of not-a-woman and not-a-man, is inherently non-binary. Everything that they do, both in life in general and to be comfortable with their body and presentation, is being done as a non-binary person. Cutting their hair short, discarding a normal image of femininity, brings great relief to some NB people who society wants to see as women.
And here it's important to note- while a lot of NB people aim for maximum androgyny- that's their ideal bodyshape, presentation, etc, there are many who do not. The things they do, the way they present and shape themselves, are reflections of their underlying gender identities rather than creating said gender identities.
And finally! Agender is a gender identity that pretty much boils down to, as you so wonderfully said, the sense of self-shape and gender giving up and going home. When I'm agender, I don't want to be seen, or see myself, as an entity that contains gender. We don't agonize over what gender a building is (except maybe in Spanish class), so why should we worry about mine? I just want to be seen as a person- gender identity has left the building, middle fingers upraised.
Obvious disclaimer: agender is definitely not the only non-binary identity, or even the only non-binary identity I visit. There are days where I relish being maximally androgynous, where I want to see people try, and fail, to put me into a binary box. Agender is... not like that. It's "why are we playing this stupid gender game, again?", it's "don't try to ma'am/sir me, just give me my damn coffee." -
Thank you. by
on 2017-10-04 10:39:00 UTC
Link to this
I want to thank both you and Tomash for doing an excellent job of explaining a broad and complex field. And this is the third one >>> Thank you.
I have said it thrice;
What I tell you three times is true.
I'm curious about this concept you call 'gender identity' (in your second paragraph). As someone who has never looked at any group or individual - male, female, social, age, fandom, hobby, whatever - and gone 'yes, I belong in a group with this person', I'm interested to know how common it actually is. I am fully aware that I am odd. ^_~
hS -
Okay, gonna give this a shot. by
on 2017-10-04 13:43:00 UTC
Link to this
I think, in general, it's safe to say most cisgender people don't go "Hmm, what am I, yes I am male" or "yes I am female" because they don't need to question their identity. To them, their gender just is.
I identify as agender (most of the time; it tends to change) and while I was a kid, I never much thought about what I was. Whenever I told people I was a boy that day and was laughed off, I figured it was just me being weird and kind of suppressed that. And then puberty hit, and with it came the dysphoria and a sense that something wasn't quite right. Still, I kept on thinking maybe I was just a weird girl, because I knew I wasn't a boy (except when I was, oh god why is this so confusing what is happening to me is this normal?).
When you already know what you are and where you feel you belong, there's not much reason to put a lot of thought into it.
So that's my $.02, for what it's worth. -
It's true that I didn't always question it. by
on 2017-10-04 15:02:00 UTC
Link to this
Now that I've been exposed to more different kinds of people and learned more about the world, though, I definitely do.
I think about my gender when I have conversations about books with an older friend of mine who is so very female she finds it difficult to relate to male characters in male-authored books, who (she says) don't care about the things she cares about. That experience is totally alien to me, though I suspect it's fairly common, so it does make me question my female identity. I've always related to male characters just fine, my first best friend in preschool was a boy, and though my closest friends in elementary school were girls (one a tomboy and one even more introverted than me), from about middle school on, I've tended to get on with most men better than most women. I also write a ton more male characters than female ones, and even as a kid, I'd happily play male roles. In dreams, sometimes I'm a guy, too. It's not me, I don't think—I'm often not me in dreams—but still.
And yet I'm female, always have been, always will be. I find that pretty dang weird. ^_^; Like, with all that maleness in me, why am I not trans or agender? Because I know I'm not.
I tend to think it's because I was never treated as weird by my family? It was always okay to like who and what I liked, and be who I wanted to be, even if they didn't always entirely approve of my choices (like outfits consisting entirely of pink sweatclothes, yeesh, why was I allowed out the door).
Hence why I would sort of like it if the whole concept of gender would go defenestrate itself, because it's confusing and weird and often seems to hurt more than it helps? Except that it's actually important for lots of people.
~Neshomeh -
And thank you also. :) by
on 2017-10-04 14:22:00 UTC
Link to this
I think I may just be to introverted to grasp, in any non-intellectual sense, the concept of 'belonging' that you're trying to convey. But having multiple perspectives is always helpful; it gives me new angles to see it from. So thanks.
hS
(PS: 'not much reason to put a lot of thought into it'?!?! Iximaz - this is the PPC! Putting too much thought into things is what we do! ^_~) -
I think not quite? by
on 2017-10-03 16:10:00 UTC
Link to this
Scientifically, at least, sex is always used for an organism's biological characteristics—the gonads, chromosomes, and hormones. The stuff that's definitely not a choice or a social construct. Everybody is born with a sex, whether it's male, female, or intersex. (Side note: some people have interesting combinations of sex chromosomes such as XO, XXY, XYY, and more! These combinations tend to cause health and development problems, some obvious, some not.)
Gender, therefore, is all that other stuff we've been talking about: the internal mindstate, the Residual Self-Image, the social expectations, the chosen self-expression relating/contrary to one's biological sex.
So I guess my question is answered by the existence of the brain's map of the body, and transgenderism would still be a thing even in the absence of any social expectations relating to body shape. There would still be people with body dysphoria.
That's my take on all this, anyway.
~Neshomeh -
Aye by
on 2017-10-03 19:05:00 UTC
Link to this
I actually know someone who's mosaic 46-XX/XY: some of their cells are "normal" XX, and others are "normal" XY. They're cool people, and a big activist for intersex issues here at work.
It's also possible for people to be genetically "normal" and still intersex- there are lots of developmental conditions that can produce intersex bodies. And there's things like Complete Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome, in which an apparently normal woman has a Y chromosome.
And we pretty much try to use sex for the scientific reason- although, for trans people whose transitions include chemical or physical changes, "biological sex" becomes an incredibly complicated concept. I'm at risk for breast cancer... and prostate cancer. Whoops?
And, yeah. My dysphoria was entirely rooted in the shape of my body and the unhappiness of a brain trying to run on testosterone. That would exist regardless of the society I did, or didn't, find myself in- even now, post-transition, I'm still just "one of the engineers"- which is basically indistinguishable from "one of the guys". (There's a whole 'nother rant here about the male-centric nature of the technology industry, but I'll spare you all.)
There are people who are otherwise! There are people whose dysphoria includes not being seen as who they are, and that's a very real form of dysphoria too. There are people who feel no physical discomfort, just social discomfort, and that's enough reason for them to change.
-Delta -
Honestly? I'm staying out of it. by
on 2017-10-02 13:11:00 UTC
Link to this
Words are hard, and trying to put words to this is harder.
-
O...kay? by
on 2017-10-02 13:20:00 UTC
Link to this
Is that just because you don't know how to articulate it, or are you saying you're offended/upset that I'm asking?
hS -
I don't know how to put it into words. by
on 2017-10-02 13:36:00 UTC
Link to this
And it feels like whenever I try I just end up making people more confused than before.
-
Well. by
on 2017-10-02 13:46:00 UTC
Link to this
Tomash has successfully articulated an interpretation that I could correctly create eight examples from. Which is great! ... so long as it's right. So (and I'm taking your commenting on this thread as implying an interest in saying something; feel free to ignore me if I'm wrong) are you at least able to say whether you agree with his explanation? Which comes down to 'everyone has a body image, if it disagrees with your actual body then you're some degree of trans'.
(Alternately/also, if you think any of the McZamples are wrong, that could be a good way to try and explain things.)
(Or you can just not, if you prefer.)
(But I'd rather be confused than wrong. ^_^)
hS -
The McZamples seem right by
on 2017-10-02 11:48:00 UTC
Link to this
with the potential caveat that Bobbie could have a gender identity that doesn't match their physical body, and so therefore be rather unhappy about the state of affairs they've found themselves in.
- Tomash -
I wonder about that, too. by
on 2017-09-29 15:33:00 UTC
Link to this
Postulating a future society in which everyone is free to express entirely who they are on the inside regardless of what parts they have on the outside, is transgenderism still a thing? Or is it mostly or entirely a product of society trying to force people into roles they don't fit based on the shape of their bodies?
Recognizing the answer to this may be different for different people, and not wishing to minimize anyone's experience, as a woman who has never especially bought into "being a girl" per society while being completely comfortable having a female body and being referred to as such, I just wonder.
Is it possible to someday do away with gender and just approach everyone as people with a spectrum of anatomies and interests and means of self-expression, or do we need those categories?
~Neshomeh is curious and likes thought experiments.