Is my story ready to publish?
-
Paging Cat-on-the-Keyboard by
on 2017-05-01 20:21:00 UTC
Link to this
-
My feedback for you is on its way by
on 2017-05-03 23:22:00 UTC
Link to this
It is generally positive (one simple tweak), but I don't want to post it for the whole Board to see. I don't know why my Internet connection is letting me post to the Board but not send emails. . . but I've saved it and it'll be on its way soonish.
--Key -
._. Uh... by
on 2017-05-02 00:12:00 UTC
Link to this
In general, paging people on the Board isn't recommended, though it isn't strictly forbidden; I'd honestly see it as a last resort, especially since most of the people I've paged via e-mail have responded in a timely manner. I'm not outright against paging, but it's usually best reserved for a very big reason - otherwise your small question could accidentally push something way more important off the front page.
This is in no ill will to you - I've made this mistake a few times before in the past - but I'd recommend using e-mail to ask questions to specific people if you know their e-mail address. Works just as well, but doesn't take up Board space. ^_~ -
Can confirm: she emailed me by
on 2017-05-03 23:19:00 UTC
Link to this
Actually, she emailed me several times. . . I've been avoiding the PPC and the Internet in general, because. . . no good reason, really. Anyway, not the point: this was a very justified page, and Maxewell's the main reason this got through to me at all.
--Key -
I did email. by
on 2017-05-03 20:56:00 UTC
Link to this
I just wanted a public record that I did try to contact them.
-
I know them IRL, will let them know (nm) by
on 2017-05-02 02:48:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Bramandin, stop harassing me in Discord. by
on 2017-05-03 07:37:00 UTC
Link to this
Bram - Yesterday at 2:54 PM
Hey Iximaz. Can I talk to you?
Iximaz Ø - Yesterday at 3:34 PM
I'd rather you not.
Bram - Yesterday at 3:36 PM
I get the feeling that you hate me.
Delta Juliette - Yesterday at 3:38 PM
Bram, please respect the "no" you just received.
Bram - Yesterday at 3:40 PM
I find it a bit rude to snub me without reason.
Delta Juliette - Yesterday at 3:40 PM
They do not want to talk to you. Trying to shame them into changing their mind is not a good thing.
Bram - Yesterday at 3:42 PM
I still find it rude.
Delta Juliette - Yesterday at 3:43 PM
Bram, if you want to continue this conversation in private, we can, but I'd appreciate it if you stopped saying so here.
Because it still reads a lot like you're taking shots at Ix, either intentionally or no.
Bram - Yesterday at 3:50 PM
I am hurt that Iximaz doesn't want to talk to me.
Delta Juliette - Yesterday at 3:51 PM
Bram, please stop.
This is not the appropriate venue for this conversation, as I am explaining in private.
Matt Cipher - Yesterday at 3:52 PM
Put yourself in a reversed situation, mate: If you were offended by somebody (which you previously did, in Iximaz's opinion and that's how she views it now), would you be willing to talk to your offender as if nothing happened betwen the two of you? I don't think so. So please, zip it, and accept the fact that you're not on Iximaz's good list.
Bram - Yesterday at 3:55 PM
I'm trying to figure out what I did wrong and make amends. It's not good to hold a grudge. I welcome people who want to talk about how they offended me.
Matt Cipher - Yesterday at 3:56 PM
But by doing so, you're pushing yourself onto Iximaz, which only deepens the dislike. It sounds very hypocritical coming from me of all people, but sometimes you can't do anything.
Delta Juliette - Yesterday at 3:56 PM
Bram, this is a Warning. Stop.
Iximaz Ø - Yesterday at 3:57 PM
I did not want to talk to you before and I want to talk to you even less after your insistence on it. Stop.
Bram - Today at 2:33 AM
There are also several Discord-specific punishments which I don't know the details of, and general social consequences of bad behaviour (eg, people not willingly talking to you). The latter is not usually explicitly stated.
hS
Ix refused to talk to me earlier.
Iximaz Ø - Today at 2:37 AM
You have been blocked and I am taking this to the Board. -
re: by
on 2017-05-04 22:39:00 UTC
Link to this
I have undiagnosed autism, diagnosed emotional dysregulation, possible ADD, and a diagnoses that keeps flipping between anxiety and depression. I also get weird attacks where I have absolutely no ability to tell the difference between a good idea and a bad one and I don’t even realize that my judgement is impaired; if the pattern holds, it shouldn’t happen again for a couple of years.
I’m a lot like Julia on Sesame Street. There is nothing to overcome, this is just who I am.
I absolutely do not get connotation. There are positive words and negative words, but I cannot tell the difference. I find it hard to articulate what’s in my head. I see my own writing and judge that the tone is level. Sometimes I read what you’re saying and might pick up condensation where there is none, or completely miss an angry subtext. Sometimes I don’t understand things right away. I tried parroting so that I wouldn’t use any “bad words” but I’ll stop because someone thinks I’m mocking.
I was taught never to say “you’re wrong” or “you hurt me” and I have no clue on how to articulate it tactfully. It’s common for aspies to say something rude or insulting while meaning to be nice. I have never done anything out of malice. In good faith, I ignore a lot of perceived provocations. By the time I mention not liking something, I’m pretty close to a meltdown. If you see lashing out, it’s either unarticulated pain or something completely innocuous that’s perceived with the wrong intent. There is also a bit of anxiety whenever I say, “I don’t like this.” I get flashbacks to bullies who would then do it more because I’ve told them how to get a reaction.
I apologize for trying to talk about how I’m feeling. I didn’t talk to them; this is a new mistake. I don’t have a stim that can soothe it. I have no choice but to bottle up my emotions until I start flailing and screaming at the furniture.
If not saying anything is a god-given right, then why do I keep getting attacked for “maliciously ignoring” people?
Even if I had been in a reasonable state of mind that night, I thought that what I did was not necessarily good, but perfectly acceptable. After all, it was done to me for what felt like months and it didn’t feel like ignoring it or saying how I felt about it was doing anything. No one said anything about it. I dreaded coming here, knowing that you would push me closer to a meltdown. Maybe if I had used the word “stop” you would have.
I’ll be going away for a while. -
Okay. by
on 2017-05-05 00:38:00 UTC
Link to this
First, it's brave of you to be so candid about your mental health issues. Talking about stuff like that really isn't easy - it took me several goes to really open up about my anger issues and paranoia on the Board - so you should be praised for bringing it up. However, as others have told me and as I will now tell you, it does not excuse poor behaviour, nor does it free you from the responsibility to take the consequences of your actions. Regardless of whether or not you were taught to say "you hurt me", it is imperative that you do better in recognizing when other people are saying it.
With this in mind, let's talk about some of what you've said.
"If not saying anything is a god-given right, then why do I keep getting attacked for “maliciously ignoring” people?"
Beta readers give their time of their own volition, and the whole point of having them is to talk about your work with them and discuss what can be improved. You did not do this with Ix and Des and Aegis. You just... didn't. From what I've gathered, you dismissed their points out of hand when you weren't getting extremely defensive about such points being made in the first place. This is Not Okay. That is not how you respond to constructive criticism of the sort that is given by beta readers.
Additionally, while I'm certain this was not your intent, your phrasing here makes you sound nothing so much as whiny. Ix was not being malicious; they simply did not want to talk to you, and this desire not to talk to you was compounded by repeated attempts to force yourself into a conversation with them. I understand just how hard the question "Why won't Person X talk to me?" can hurl itself at the walls of one's skull, but just as you have the right to privacy and the right to choose with whom you associate, so do they.
I'm going to say the following very bluntly, and I apologise if doing so causes you any distress; it is merely meant as instructional and in no way is it a rebuke. Ahem:
Nobody owes you their time. You owe nobody your time. That's how this whole song and dance called human interaction works.
Let's take an example from your own experiences as mentioned in this post - an extreme one, admittedly, but the story beats line up, for want of a better term. If one of the bullies from your schooldays showed up in your social media/IRC channel/pigeon fanciers' association AGM or whathaveyou and started demanding that you speak with them, you would be well within your rights to tell them where they could stick it, yes?
The same applies to other people. It always has and it always will. Everyone has a choice whether or not to engage with people, and that choice has to be respected. You are not owed interactions with Ix because you interacted before any more than you can nick a tenner off your best friend because they gave you a tenner in 2006.
So no, what you did was not "perfectly acceptable", nor was it good. What you did was harass someone, demand positive attention from them, and not accept it when they told you no. These behaviours are in breach of the Constitution and you should be brought up on it. However, more than that, you should be given the opportunity to improve and excel. I urge you to take it.
I didn't, back in the day.
Don't be like I used to be. -
Sorry. by
on 2017-05-04 22:34:00 UTC
Link to this
I'm sorry for trying to talk to you when you didn't feel like it. I won't talk to you again.
-
Ok, that's a good start. by
on 2017-05-05 01:12:00 UTC
Link to this
I'm glad that you've calmed down and offered this apology. I'm going to accept your apology, as the constitution says we should, but that acceptance always comes with conditions. You have to prove, through your continued actions, that you are sincere.
At the very least that means:
-Don't contact Iximaz again. Pretend that she does not exist.
-If people tell you to stop a behavior...then stop. It's that easy.
-If you feel attacked, don't lash out, stop the conversation and tell someone who can mediate for you. You, by your own admission, may be misreading the situation.
If you cannot do these things, then there will be consequences. That is up to, and including, indefinite banning. I'm not saying this as a threat. I just want to be clear about what is on the line here.
If you have questions about this, post them here and I (or others in the community) will try to answer them. I want us to be on the same page here, and I want to be sure that you understand.
To the rest of the community, if you disagree with how I've handled this, then please speak up. I'm not a dictator, I serve at the pleasure of the community.
If you agree with how this went down, then it is up to you to hold the community to it. We forgive, but we need not forget.
-Phobos -
Thoughts from Tomash: Several comments and concerns (CALL FO by
on 2017-05-05 05:54:00 UTC
Link to this
First, to the extent that Bramandin's apology is directed to the community at large, I'm willing to consider it sincere, unless Bram's future actions disprove this. I, and everyone else here, have no power to accept or reject Bramandin's apologies to Iximaz; that power lies with her alone.
Bramandin, I am concerned by some aspects of your apology, which indicate that you have some significant misunderstandings of the norms of neurotypical social interaction. This is entirely understandable, and I do not blame you for it. However, as a fellow aspie, I would like to disagree with your assertion that "There is nothing to overcome, this is just who I am." As others have pointed out, you cannot use who you are as a shield from consequences. Since who you are causes you to have difficulties interacting with others appropriately, if you want to interact with people, you must manage your mental illnesses by learning to interact appropriately with others. This is not going to be quick or easy, and you will almost certainly make mistakes along the way. Despite this, I am confident that you can learn like I did and continue to do. (If you, at some point, want me to try and help you understand something, my email and Discord are open.)
Now, to the community:
The current consensus resolution appears to be "We accept Bramandin's apology. If Bramandin tries to get Iximaz's attention again, we will have a full discussion and vote during which we will be very likely to impose consequences.". I claim this is insufficient, given our (actual or perceived) tendency to abandon discussions and ignore complaints, which make it [appear to be] the case that no consequences will actually be imposed for future offenses.
Therefore, I propose that we make our attitude towards Bramandin's possible future offenses clearer and more concrete for both Iximaz and Bramandin's benefit, as well as our own.
To provide that clarity, I again propose that, if Bramandin contacts Iximaz again, she (Bramandin) shall automatically receive a ban of not less than three months (which will be extendable at the time of the offense), and that this potential automatic ban remain over Bram's head for at least two years.
I believe that the imposition of specific future consequences for a clearly-defined set of future acts is, in this case, necessary, despite the apologies that have been offered. This is due to the severe and repeated nature of the harassment in question, and the fact that it remains unclear to what extent Bram understands (or will in the future understand) the inappropriateness of her actions. I also believe that this consequence would help Bram guide her actions in the future.
In order to make our consensus about how we will act more concrete, I ask everyone who agrees with my proposal (or something similar, or even something more severe) to explicitly indicate this ("+1 (nm)" is fine), and similarly for disagreements.
- Tomash
(I agree with this; I'd like to see the "or else" defined.) -
Given what appears to be general acceptance... by
on 2017-05-08 15:22:00 UTC
Link to this
...we will take on Tomash's amendment.
If Bramandin contacts Iximaz then a ban will be enacted. The length of the ban will be determined by a community vote at that time, but will not be less than 3 months.
We are still waiting for Bramandin to acknowledge this message chain, but their acknowledgement is not required to make this binding.
(For the record: Currently 12 people accept the amendment and no one has openly disagreed with it, or my original message. If you do disagree, please feel free to say so here or via my email: baridthetroll(at)gmail(dot)com)
-Phobos -
Acknowledged. (nm) by
on 2017-05-17 21:23:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Thank you (nm) by
on 2017-05-17 21:40:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Updated tally by
on 2017-05-08 17:07:00 UTC
Link to this
I have received an email on this subject. The person who contacted me agrees with my original wording (consequences up to and including a ban) but not with the Tomash amendment.
Tally currently stands at 12 agree with the Tomash amendment, 1 disagrees with the amendment but agrees with the more open-ended wording in the original proposal.
-Phobos -
Agreed (nm) by
on 2017-05-07 11:10:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Agreed (nm) by
on 2017-05-06 20:26:00 UTC
Link to this
-
+1 (nm) by
on 2017-05-06 17:59:00 UTC
Link to this
-
I agree. (nm) by
on 2017-05-06 17:03:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Agreed. (nm) by
on 2017-05-06 15:45:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Agreed. (nm) by
on 2017-05-05 23:36:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Okay. by
on 2017-05-05 21:02:00 UTC
Link to this
Not speaking for Iximaz as to whether or not the apology is accepted, for the reasons stated here.
But I'll take this as one more chance for Bramandin, with consequences if she attempts to contact Iximaz again. -
Agreed. (nm) by
on 2017-05-05 17:08:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Agreed by
on 2017-05-05 15:20:00 UTC
Link to this
If I have time over the weekend I may add to this.
-
My thoughts by
on 2017-05-05 13:25:00 UTC
Link to this
Firstly, thank you, Tomash (and DJ for bringing Tomash to us).
Secondly, I agree with you that we can, and probably should be, more explicit with the consequences. I felt we needed to address the apology as quickly as possible, to reinforce good behavior, but I did not want to speak for the group on what specific consequences should be.
So, I agree with your proposal.
-Phobos -
In agreement by
on 2017-05-05 04:36:00 UTC
Link to this
I'd like to be a bit more clear about the consequences, though: repeated harassing of other members absolutely should warrant a banning, IMO, and breaking these rules counts as repeat harassment.
(Thanks for laying down a concrete set of suggestions, Phobos- that was a thing we needed.) -
Message relayed from Tomash: by
on 2017-05-04 20:20:00 UTC
Link to this
"I agree that we should be considerate of Bram's mental illness, just as we have been considerate of so many others over the years.
However, continuing to harass someone after being clearly informed that the specific things you were doing were unacceptable and needed to stop is not something that should be completely swept under the rug.
Therefore, I propose as follows:
Bramandin may not attempt to speak to or otherwise interact with Iximaz again. In other words, Bramandin shall act as if Iximaz doesn't exist. (This goes both ways. Ix, if Bram keeps trying to talk to you, ignore her and let us know. I know that's probably what you were going to do anyway in that scenario, but it needs to be said for clarity's sake.)
If this prohibition is violated, Bramandin will be subject to an indefinite ban from the PPC that will last at least 3 months." -
Paging Discordians! by
on 2017-05-04 20:07:00 UTC
Link to this
Can I please get someone from the Discord to corroborate Iximaz's claim that Bramandin went back to the chat to continue this conversation after she had been told, on both Discord and the board, to stop and apologize? I believe Ix, I just want to make sure we're doing this right.
Some time-stamped logs would also be helpful.
-Phobos, taking charge of this situation -
Re: Paging Discordians! by
on 2017-05-04 20:09:00 UTC
Link to this
She did not continue further and Maslab issued a warning. -
Thank you, Iximaz. (nm) by
on 2017-05-04 20:10:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Nothing's going to be done about this. by
on 2017-05-03 20:31:00 UTC
Link to this
I complained multiple times that I was being harassed. I didn’t keep track of if it was one person or many saying the same thing, but my complaints were ignored.
-
You need to take a step back. by
on 2017-05-03 20:46:00 UTC
Link to this
I understand wanting an explanation, but stop demanding it from someone and in the face of clear requests to stop is Not Okay.
Iximaz gave you criticism and you ignored it. We've seen nothing from you indicating you've taken anyone's advice, and you have a history of ignoring concrit from other members. I'd link to it, but I'm on my phone right now.
Just stop hounding Iximaz for an explanation and things will proceed much more smoothly.
--Aegis, hoping the PPC will forgive him for getting a word in from a less-than-ideal situation. -
^This is Bramandin. (nm) by
on 2017-05-03 20:37:00 UTC
Link to this
-
My message was meant to go here, Bram is anon. (nm) by
on 2017-05-03 20:47:00 UTC
Link to this
-
I want Iximaz to apologize by
on 2017-05-03 20:06:00 UTC
Link to this
I want explanations for Iximas' behavior, I want a long-winded ramble on why Iximaz really really doesn't want to talk to me beacuse she's just so mean.
-
Re: I want Iximaz to apologize by
on 2017-05-05 17:39:00 UTC
Link to this
Well, tough luck, you aren't entitled to one.
Also, you shouldmtry not to call someone mean so soon after apologising.
You have mental health issues, fine, but they're not a get out of jail free card. You've had it explained multiple times that she dosn't want to talk to you, respect that. -
A little too late to the party, mate. (nm) by
on 2017-05-05 19:12:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Re: A little too late to the party, mate. by
on 2017-05-06 14:41:00 UTC
Link to this
Oh, woops. That's what you get when you don't read post dates.
-
Iximaz does not, and definitely will not, give it. by
on 2017-05-03 20:44:00 UTC
Link to this
Here's the thing: Iximaz has explained. They have explained why they don't want to, and will never more, want to talk to you. They're not "being mean." The way you act when talking with Ix makes them feel uncomfortable, extremely so.
The way I remember it, Ix gave very well deserved criticism to one of your missions, and you promptly ignored it. Instead, you took it as a Suethor would: Violently and completely unapologetically (Well, maybe not "Violently," but you get my point).
Adding on too this, you always seemed to drop a mission and just disappear, even when we have repeatedly asked you to take the time to look over the concrit. Now, I know you don't always have internet access, but is it to much to ask to look over who commented on what you previously posted?
Finally, please care to remember that Ix's mind is... how do I put this lightly... in a very dark place right now. They do not deserve this bull[crap] right now, so just give them so space.
With much care, Mattman. -
I cannot find by
on 2017-05-03 21:32:00 UTC
Link to this
I cannot find any evidence where I responded negatively to Ix's concrit. Maybe you're thinking of someone else?
My mind is in a dark place right now and I do not deserve this bullcrap. -
Nobody wants that, mate. by
on 2017-05-03 21:46:00 UTC
Link to this
That's why, please, take hS's advice from the closing sentence. It will do all of us, you especially, some good.
-
Re: Iximaz does not, and definitely will not, give it. by
on 2017-05-03 20:49:00 UTC
Link to this
((The way I remember it, Ix gave very well deserved criticism to one of your missions, and you promptly ignored it. Instead, you took it as a Suethor would: Violently and completely unapologetically (Well, maybe not "Violently," but you get my point). ))
Can you point to when this happened?
The way Ix talks makes me uncomfortable. -
See: The comments on your earlier missions. (nm) by
on 2017-05-03 20:53:00 UTC
Link to this
-
o by
on 2017-05-03 21:07:00 UTC
Link to this
How do I search the board for posts by a specific user?
-
How to search by
on 2017-05-04 16:04:00 UTC
Link to this
There's a search bar on the top left of the main Board page. It doesn't show up on the replying pages or if you've clicked on an individual post. I don't know of a way to search and get only posts by a specific user, but if you search the name of the person you will get both posts by them and posts that mention them. It's frequently more helpful, as Aegis somewhat indirectly said, to search for a key word that you think appeared in the posts (or the titles of the posts) you're looking for (such as "Kelly" or "Purim RP" or "Death Star"). Keep them relatively short and you should have success.
There may be a way to use Google search to get posts by a specific user, but I don't know what it is. In addition, there are the Board archives: if you open those and use the Find function (ctrl+F on PC, not sure if it changes for Mac but I'd expect it to be command+F if it is different), you should be able to find everything on the page. The Board archives (or this set of them--I think there's another one that looks a lot like the T-Board? I've lost track of the link, though) can be found here. They currently go through 2016, going by what's on the page. There's also a page on how to use them, which may be helpful--they're basically giant Excel files, and can be a bit difficult to navigate.
Hope that helps.
~Zing -
Unfortunately it doesnÂ’t help for the specific problem. by
on 2017-05-04 17:17:00 UTC
Link to this
Searching for "Hieronymus" finds some posts made by me, but only posts where I mentioned either Agent Hieronymus or Hieronymus the hermit. That’s one of the reasons why some of us sign our posts in a specific way: while we cannot search for posts we made, we can search for posts we signed (or where others mentioned our signature).
HG -
Try searching the word "Kelly!" by
on 2017-05-04 10:04:00 UTC
Link to this
You'll be pleasantly surprised, if the evidence is what you’re looking for. I know I would’ve been if I’d wanted to see the morass I found, or, rather, that Tomash pointed me to so I could actually look at what had happened in the past.
Permission thread from April of last year.
Your main problem here is that you seem to offer excuses for why other people's criticism isn't valid. I'm willing to accept that you didn't understand where they were coming from, but when your writing necessitates an entire thread of discussion regarding what you were thinking, there's usually a problem in your writing.
Also, you accuse both Iximaz and Desdendelle of yelling at you for “taking the prompts literally?” I think they were trying to explain that prompts don’t necessarily dictate the story to a T unless you want them to, but it looks like Huinesoron covered that.
Permission thread from May of last year.
Again, what I'm seeing from you isn't a request for a clarification, but, eventually, repeated protestations that you're incapable of doing what the community asks of you because of extenuating circumstances. These circumstances are understandable, but you can't change the rules for permission or writing missions when one person is inconvenienced by their circumstances. The shared universe has a few standards, and if you can't meet them, either suggest to us a workaround or find a way to meet them. A poor working environment does not excuse publishing poor writing. It seems to me like Des tried to explain this to you, and you either didn't understand or ignored him.
The only thing I can say for you here is that you didn’t openly harass anyone that time, from what I’ve seen.
February. Also of last year..
I'd like to give you credit for understanding what went wrong what I believe is the first time, but from what I've seen, you've repeated this behavior, so let's take the chance to clarify. In this and other threads, you have--within the same thread--requested that Iximaz not talk to you because she makes you uncomfortable, and give you a detailed explanation of what you've done wrong. Several times, you demonstrate a belligerent and downright hostile attitude toward those offering to explain to you what you've done wrong.
Rather than listen to Iximaz when she told you that you were being rude, you were openly hostile, as explained by Iximaz in this post. You responded to it with a comment that implied the entire PPC was somehow biased against you because of a mental disorder, when I’ve dug through these records and watched us give you every possible chance.
And watched you snap at them for it.
And then there’s this. Just. . . this.
This is your explanation for why Iximaz doesn't have to explain anything to you. Tomash has done so. Recently. Iximaz has done so--the whole Board has done so--repeatedly. In this post, Tomash very clearly, calmly, concisely—and many other adjectives ending in -ly that probably break the alliterative chain— lays out exactly what our problems are with your behaviors.
And you busted out caps lock on him for it, shouting that somehow the PPC wasn’t being fair to you.
To the PPC at large: In light of all of these past actions, I stand in favor of the immediate ban of Bramandin. Their apologies have been rendered meaningless by their continued wrongdoing in the face of multiple, clearly stated explanations of exactly what was wrong with what they were doing.
Bramandin is harassing Iximaz, a fellow member of the PPC, for an explanation, when they’ve plainly been given one several times. They’re demanding an apology from someone who tried being considerate, and, in the face of someone who obstinately refuses to actually listen, chose to step away from the conversation.
They provide excuses for their poor work, rather than improving said work’s quality, and either run away from concrit or spew out vitriolic caps lock for it, apparently randomly demanding explanations from those who have made it absolutely clear that they no longer wish to engage with Bramandin--which is actually reasonable, considering her reactions to everyone who has done so.
I think Bramandin is a hostile, toxic PPC member, and I don't think she should be allowed to continue. -
Pause. by
on 2017-05-04 15:21:00 UTC
Link to this
It looks an awful lot like you are saying Bramandin should be banned, in part, for being very bad at taking concrit, and for feeling - let's break out that word again - harassed when people keep trying to hit her with the same point that she either disagrees with or doesn't understand. I don't think that is reasonable.
I do not feel that, by and large, anyone has harassed or attacked Bramandin. I won't rule out there being individual posts which do so, but as a rule people have tried to deal with her fairly. Lots of people have gotten frustrated in doing so, per Hieronymus' context post, but that has not become the kind of attack she keeps describing it as.
However, I also am not aware of Bramandin harassing anyone prior to the incident that sparked this thread. She has been very bad at taking concrit, yes. She has lashed out when she feels attacked, yes. But this is the first time I am aware of that she engaged in actual harassment of another person.
Unless I am wrong - unless there is something that does fit that description - I feel the appropriate response is to make it clear what the problem is (which has been done by this thread), make it clear that any further incidents may result in a ban, and give Bramandin one last chance to prove that she can overcome her unspecified mental health issue and function as a member of this community.
As Hieronymus said: when Iximaz's mental health issue led to her flaming the entire PPC, we took that into consideration in our response. This is a very different situation - Bramandin's condition appears to be continuous, where Iximaz's breakdowns are only occasional - but we should have that same consideration.
One more chance. We gave it to Iximaz when she went off her meds, we gave it to July when she snapped after a 20-hour military shift, we give it to Scapegrace every time her self-control lets her down. Give it to Bramandin too. Let her have one last opportunity to surprise us all.
hS -
Disagreement. A counter-proposal: by
on 2017-05-04 20:30:00 UTC
Link to this
Once again, I should clarify I know almost nothing about what happened originally between Bram and Ixi, back when the latter and Des agreed to be the former's Permission (I think) betas. From all the info I have, whatever happened made Iximaz dislike Bram greatly, to a point that she didn't want to interact with her. That's my view on the past.
I will agree with you, hS, that this is de facto Bram's first major offence. Yes, not taking concrit well shouldn't be considered a reason behind banishment. At the very best, it would result in a 'social ban' - people would simply deny Bram's request, knowing how she deals with critique.
However, I believe this incident shouldn't be resolved without punishment. Yes, second chance could probably be involved, but during the course of this thread Bram remained unapologetic, made a mockery out of every helpful and not violent response, and failed to understand Iximaz's wishes and personal space, continuously pushing her into conversation, then - when it became obvious nobody will take her side in this - she tried to spark the conflict in Discord. Bram doesn't feel in the slightest that she's done something wrong (and I'm not talking about the past incident with Des & Ix, but the current one). Instead, she feels like the victim. The only reason I'm not calling for Bram's ban is because I've done the exact same thing.
So here's my solution to the whole matter:
1. Somebody with full info behind the past incident talks it over to Bram, in private, making sure she understands why she did what she did.
2. Lecture Bram about respecting other people's wishes, and that even if she wants to make amends, they shouldn't cross with those wishes.
3. Have Bram apologize to Iximaz, in the exact form the latter requested.
4. Implement some form of punishment for Bram, but also give her the second chance to be the PPCer after her punishment ends.
And I have to admit, hS, - and forgive me for saying this - but your reasoning here does give off a vibe of sweeping stuff under the rug. -
Err, I guess I'm a little late here but: Constitution by
on 2017-05-07 05:58:00 UTC
Link to this
A lot of people in this thread have been requiring apologies from one or more parties. I would like to draw some attention to article five: Apologies for making a mistake, and for being unclear, are recommended, but should not be demanded.
What good is a forced apology, anyway? Does it really feel good to hear an apology that's being made because the other party has to make it? What's it supposed to accomplish?
--Key -
Err, context. by
on 2017-05-07 18:09:00 UTC
Link to this
If you read the full Article five, the mistake in question would be caused by a misunderstanding (or a cultural dissonance). "Should not be demanded" may not be applicable if something far more serious than a common misunderstanding happened, and the worth of a sincere apology that had been demanded may be that it demonstrates the result of a successful learning process. Of course, I cannot speak for people who actually demanded something; that’s just my guess of what’s going on.
HG -
Re: Disagreement. A counter-proposal: by
on 2017-05-04 22:55:00 UTC
Link to this
during the course of this thread Bram remained unapologetic, {wasn't ready yet} made a mockery out of every helpful and not violent response, {wrong} and failed to understand Iximaz's wishes and personal space, {yes} continuously pushing her into conversation, {not during the thread} then - when it became obvious nobody will take her side in this - she tried to spark the conflict in Discord. {Very wrong} Bram doesn't feel in the slightest that she's done something wrong {It's sinking in slowly} (and I'm not talking about the past incident with Des & Ix, but the current one). Instead, she feels like the victim. {Yes}
-
You're right. I'm sorry. by
on 2017-05-05 04:36:00 UTC
Link to this
Not everything should've been said like that.
-
Re: Disagreement. A counter-proposal: by
on 2017-05-04 23:12:00 UTC
Link to this
then - when it became obvious nobody will take her side in this - she tried to spark the conflict in Discord. {Very wrong}
Err... -
Re: Disagreement. A counter-proposal: by
on 2017-05-04 23:21:00 UTC
Link to this
I was not doing it to spark confict. If anything, I was setting out to defuse.
-
But that was not how it was perceived. (nm) by
on 2017-05-05 01:36:00 UTC
Link to this
-
That's me, by the by (nm) by
on 2017-05-04 23:13:00 UTC
Link to this
-
PPC Constitution, Article 5. by
on 2017-05-04 20:44:00 UTC
Link to this
If someone says something that seems offensive, but you’re not sure exactly what they meant, ASK them first, before jumping down their throats.
Either point at where I clearly said Bramandin should be allowed to get away without apologising, or stop placing the worst possible interpretation on my words.
hS -
Everyone else, leave hS alone, please. (nm) by
on 2017-05-04 21:03:00 UTC
Link to this
-
I think he meant. . . by
on 2017-05-04 20:55:00 UTC
Link to this
Unless I am wrong - unless there is something that does fit that description - I feel the appropriate response is to make it clear what the problem is (which has been done by this thread), make it clear that any further incidents may result in a ban, and give Bramandin one last chance to prove that she can overcome her unspecified mental health issue and function as a member of this community.
And he mentioned that you give off that vibe, not that you actually said it. In fact, it's possible that he posted before he saw that made it clear that you did expect her to apologize when you said:
I see that I did not explicitly state that functioning as a member of this community would include making amends for this incident. I should have.
The problem is that second chances stop being as valuable after they've been given a fourth time, especially in the absence of an apology or a sign of remorse.
Someone brought up Scapegrace, a situation I'm ridiculously far from expert in, but know something about. I don't think that Scape should be thrown out for having done similar, but that's because I've seen her admit she was wrong, apologize, stick around for the criticism, and work to better herself. -
I'm sure he did post before he saw that. by
on 2017-05-04 21:03:00 UTC
Link to this
I still do not feel it is reasonable to say that "overcome her unspecified mental health issue and function as a member of this community" should by default be read as "[giving] off a vibe of sweeping stuff under the rug". It can be read that way, yes, which is why I acknowledged that I should have made it clearer. But the PPC Constitution requires people to not assume the worst, but ask first.
I would like to see a copy of the Discord logs for the past hour, please. I am intellectually aware that you (plural) won't have been discussing me behind my back, but I am also feeling emotionally paranoid and would appreciate having the proof to enable me to calm down.
hS -
Received from Iximaz. Bit less on-edge now. (nm) by
on 2017-05-04 21:07:00 UTC
Link to this
-
As a matter of fact, I did not notice that... by
on 2017-05-04 21:01:00 UTC
Link to this
Which now makes my message even more of an attack... Once again, I'm sorry.
-
I'm going to stop this right now. by
on 2017-05-04 20:54:00 UTC
Link to this
It's not worth it, and it was never my intention to provoke or attack you in any sort, mate. Apologies for phrasing my response in a way that made you feel that way.
-
Apology accepted; thank you. (nm) by
on 2017-05-04 21:21:00 UTC
Link to this
-
I would like to point something out. by
on 2017-05-04 19:35:00 UTC
Link to this
In all of those examples you listed, you know what the difference was? An apology. Not continued escalation after repeated tellings to step back and attempted anonymous trolling. After meeting resistance on the Board, Bram went to the Discord where she attempted to continue this 'discussion'. She was shut down soon after, but all that I'm seeing is a general consensus that if she goes away on her own an apology isn't necessary.
I have spent the last two days shaking and throwing up from the stress of the situation and now that it looks like the PPC is going to go back to what it loves to do—brush incidents under the rug—I am going back to the hospital and considering calling off the Gathering.
So much for the discussion thread below. -
Adding to clarify: by
on 2017-05-04 20:04:00 UTC
Link to this
I've already been dealing with other crap to begin with, so I'm not intending to point fingers at Bram and say "See? She's making me go back to the hospital bad bad bad!" This has been a long time coming, I think, it's just that this incident plus how the PPC is shaping up to handle it became the straw that broke the camel's back, so to speak.
I'll be fine, but I need to leave for a few days until I'm in a better place. -
Well, so much for that. by
on 2017-05-05 13:53:00 UTC
Link to this
Double-checked just to be on the safe side and they're a crisis-center only, which means my only other option would be the abusive 'wellness center'.
So I'll still be reachable by email or PM but I will be staying off the Board for a few days. -
That really sucks. Hope the break helps. (nm) by
on 2017-05-05 16:42:00 UTC
Link to this
-
I understand what you are saying. by
on 2017-05-04 20:02:00 UTC
Link to this
And you are right. There were apologies in all those cases, and Bram has not apologized. What hS is saying is that we need to give Bram a chance to calm down and apologize. He is attempting to keep us from rushing to judgement again.
You can believe me when I tell you that we are not brushing this under the rug. We are doing what the constitution demands, giving the person who is breaking the rules a chance to stop.
That said, those of us who are only on the Board were not aware that Bram had gone back to the chat after falling silent here. We thought she had stopped and might calm down and apologize. It seems we were incorrect, and that likely means we need to talk about other measures.
Iximaz, I know that this is incredibly hard on you. I know that you are stressed out beyond what I can fathom. You may need to take some time off and, if you do, know that we will handle this situation. We are not letting this get forgotten, but we cannot move at lightning speed. We need time to ensure due process.
Please, trust me when I say that we are on top of this. I am on top of this and not letting it get forgotten.
-Phobos -
Precisely this. by
on 2017-05-04 20:19:00 UTC
Link to this
I see that I did not explicitly state that functioning as a member of this community would include making amends for this incident. I should have.
I did make that same point in an email to Iximaz (in response to one I received), where I said:
I feel that the first thing to do is give her that day I offered. It's possible she's having a mentally messed-up day, and will apologise or step it back tomorrow. As you said recently, we extended that courtesy to you, so in fairness we shouls give newer people the same chance.
In the event that she either carries on or tries to ignore it, I thibk it would be appropriate to consider discipliniary actions. Whether that would be a warning or a straight-up ban would be up to the Board; so far as I recall she hasn't been warned for this kind of behavoir before, so the principle of second chances suggests thst option.
But I really do thinj that waiting for her to respond after a day or so - or not respond and prove she's ignoring it - would be the fair way to do things.
Apologies for typos and incoherence; it's eleven at night and my phone-fu is weak.
At this point, I don't feel up to being involved in this discussion any more; I feel like I will just be attacked if I do so. I've got one post Tomash has asked me to relay, but after that, I'm out.
hS -
Email was not received. by
on 2017-05-04 20:23:00 UTC
Link to this
Apologies for looking like I was ignoring what you said, I never saw it to begin with. :l
I'm going to maybe be around until tomorrow evening, but I'm going to try to stay off the Board in general until I get admitted. So. Iximaz out. -
Maybe we should get some more context. by
on 2017-05-04 11:39:00 UTC
Link to this
Bramandin’s latest missions on the board.
Here, here, here and here you can watch Des, Ix and Tomash trying to help Bram when Bram believed that
a) she had already made sufficiently clear that she had abandoned those stories and
b) that by abandoning them she had also retracted them from PPC canon
It may be noteworthy that November, 15th and November, 30th were the only days between October and February when Bram showed up on the Board and nobody pointed back to her abandoned stories. (Yes, I scrolled through all the pages and took notes.)
Apparently I’m the only person who noticed what was going on, and I regret deeply that I didn’t try to clear this up earlier.
And maybe we can be as considerate of Bramandin’s condition as we are of Iximaz’s?
HG -
I will try this exactly once. by
on 2017-05-03 20:36:00 UTC
Link to this
You are trying to force Iximaz to talk to you. You are treating Iximaz's attention as rightfully yours. It is not. The only person who gets to decide who and what Iximaz has to pay attention to is Iximaz. You do not have that right. If Iximaz does not want to talk to you, you do not have the right to demand that she does.
You have repeatedly accused Iximaz of being rude. Looking back at the chat log, it seems that you view saying she does not want to talk to you as rudeness. That view is not correct. Iximaz's response to you in the Discord was not rude.
You, on the other hand, have directly and repeatedly attacked Iximaz in this thread. Iximaz has not said a word about why she does not want to talk to you; you have posted several paragraphs attacking Iximaz. Iximaz has called you on your disrespect; you have repeatedly called her rude and, in this post, mean.
You have attacked Iximaz; Iximaz has not attacked you. You have demanded Iximaz's attention; Iximaz has just asked to be left alone. You have tried to manipulate the rules to allow you to attack Iximaz without repercussion; Iximaz has, again, just asked you to stop talking to her.
Step back. Take a day. Think about why everyone is saying you're in the wrong.
hS -
My side. by
on 2017-05-03 19:59:00 UTC
Link to this
I was too shy to speak up before, but when Iximaz and Desdendell were trying to “help” me with my characters, all they did was scream at me and make me feel stupid for asking for help. Then they told July that I had given them trouble. Ix even said that I was being snippy when I was just telling her that I already knew that. I’m pretty sure that one of them started the rumor that I was difficult to work with.
Iximaz took other jabs at me. Saying I disregarded their advice and then not being able to say what that advice was. The irritating part is when Iximaz would say something like ‘I’m not commenting on this because I can’t trust myself to be impartial.’
I was just trying to open communication with Iximaz, but they wouldn’t even clarify if ‘I don’t want to talk to you’ meant “I don’t feel like talking to anyone right now” or “go die in a fire you piece of garbage.” I’m inclined to believe the latter and it’s rude. The mediator couldn’t even give a straight answer. -
I'm not going to respond to the conflict itself... by
on 2017-05-03 20:18:00 UTC
Link to this
Simply because my memories of the whole incident are rather foggy and it's not the current subject of the matter. Instead, let me just run through your last sentence:
"I was just trying to open communication with Iximaz"
Which she made clear that she wishes not to participate in. Unless you understand the words "I'd rather" as a suggestion, and not a definite conversation finisher.
"but they wouldn’t even clarify if (...)"
Iximaz had no obligations to explain herself to you. You are inclined to believe whatever you wish, but the messages were as clear as it can possibly be: I have no desire of making amends with you, leave me be.
"The mediator couldn’t even give a straight answer."
I don't know what you and DJ talked about, but I know DJ enough that I believe her explanations weren't much different from what the people has stated here.
I will repeat myself once again: You did something, whatever it was, that made Iximaz feel uncomfortable with you. Uncomfortable enough to not wanting to talk things over. And yet, you keep on pushing, and pushing, and pushing, when she made more than enough claims that she doesn't want to make amends with you. At the very best, when her negative emotions are over, she will ignore you and both of you can live their separate paths, not sparking any more conflicts.
Please, get this finally into your head: You are not on Iximaz's good list. And after this little show, you will never be. Nothing you can do about it.
This also ends my hypocrisy. -
Irrelevant. by
on 2017-05-03 20:08:00 UTC
Link to this
I asked you to leave me alone. Multiple other people have told you to do the same. You did not listen.
I asked you to apologize without ranting. You failed to do so.
I had no desire to talk to you before, and I will never have a desire to talk to you again, especially after your continued, blatant disrespect for me. -
Re: Irrelevant. by
on 2017-05-03 20:14:00 UTC
Link to this
Irrelevant.
I asked you to talk to me. You did not listen.
You wanted me to apologize without ranting. I did so. That should not mean that I shouldn't be asked for my point of view.
I have no desire to see you angry at me for no reason. You're free to leave, especially after your continued, blantant disrespect for me. -
Relevant by
on 2017-05-03 20:30:00 UTC
Link to this
I have asked Iximaz to step back from the conversation, and they have agreed to do so. I have advised them to keep you blocked on Discord as well, at least for the time being.
If you have questions regarding conduct on the Discord channel, feel free to PM me. My interests lie in the channel being a safe, productive place for all Boarders. -
Thank you, Maslab (nm) by
on 2017-05-03 20:33:00 UTC
Link to this
-
I want Bramandin to apologize. by
on 2017-05-03 17:34:00 UTC
Link to this
No explanations for her behavior, no long-winded ramble on why she really really wants to talk to me but I'm just so mean. Just seven words: I'm sorry. I won't do that again.
I want her to after that not talk to me again. Ever.
The last time something similar to this happened was with GlarnBoudin and that turned out just spectacularly.
hS, I'm sorry if I'm coming off as hostile right now, but your reaction is just enforcing my suspicions why nobody bothers to report this stuff in the first place. I wanted to nip this in the bud before it became an ongoing problem and the initial response, to me, looked like "I don't care." -
Re: I want Bramandin to apologize. by
on 2017-05-03 20:07:00 UTC
Link to this
I'm sorry. I won't do that again.
-
After the tantrum you just threw? I'm not accepting that. by
on 2017-05-03 20:09:00 UTC
Link to this
All it took was a simple apology and you felt the need to exacerbate things. This is not okay.
-
Re: After the tantrum you just threw? I'm not accepting that. by
on 2017-05-03 20:25:00 UTC
Link to this
I have told you multiple times that you were being rude.
You're not allowed to talk back to me. -
By whose decree, mate? by
on 2017-05-03 20:31:00 UTC
Link to this
Last time I've checked nobody deemed you the governing body of the Board, declaring who can do what. And if it's one of your ridiculous ways of trying to get your side of the story seen (which, honestly, at this point is more of a cheap comedy than actual arguments), then I, by the power given to me by nobody, declare that you're not allowed to talk to Iximaz.
Checkmate, you persistent stooge. -
Get your point across without flaming, Matt. (nm) by
on 2017-05-03 20:32:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Yes, sir. In that case, the point is: by
on 2017-05-03 20:41:00 UTC
Link to this
Bram is disrespecting Iximaz's wishes, and in my mind they are completely unapologetic and unaware of the fact that they've done (and are doing) something wrong. Worst of all, they are making a comedy spectacle out of it, and at this point I see no possibility of them actually trying to grasp the situation. Personally, I am this close to calling a disciplinary procedure on them.
-
Re: Yes, sir. In that case, the point is: by
on 2017-05-03 20:45:00 UTC
Link to this
Iximaz was disrespection Bram's wishes.
My understanding right now is I can be rude to someone and then just say "I don't want to talk to you" to get out of being confronted? -
Let me break down the whole thing again for you: by
on 2017-05-03 21:30:00 UTC
Link to this
Because either you're still not getting it, or decided now to play coy and make a mockery of us trying to explain it to you.
Once upon a time, you did something that felt wrong for Iximaz. Whatever you did, and whether or not it was brought up by the community (and I believe it was, since I vaguely recall there being a discussion), is not the current concern. We're not discussing your actions in the past, we're not discussing what it was that made Iximaz dislike you. We're not looking for explanation of your actions from the past.
Time has passed, emotions died down, but still remained. You ask Iximaz whether or not you can talk about it (which, at this point is evident to me that would end badly, since you clearly still have no idea what you did). She said "I'd rather you not", which is not a vague information of 'maybe we can talk'. It's a signal that says, "Please, leave me be. I don't want to have the whole matter blow up again." And yet, instead of getting that signal, you continue to ask her for conversation she doesn't want to attend. What in this whole exchange is so unclear?
I really hope you're gonna get it this time, and I didn't spend the last half an hour trying to be as clear and polite as possible.
But if you're going to once again mock this reply, and continue making all of this a joke, then so help me God in Heavens I give up on trying to help you. -
I noticed. by
on 2017-05-03 18:07:00 UTC
Link to this
That's why, once I did notice, I made very sure to make my position clear.
For future reference, since this has come up before: I do not use genuine questions as a way to dismiss something. I sometimes use sarcastic/rhetorical ones to do so, but never actual questions that need an answer.
I support your request for an apology precisely as written.
hS -
In case the sentence of mine quoted was unclear... by
on 2017-05-03 09:04:00 UTC
Link to this
... I wasn't a) saying that not talking to people is connected to the Discord, b) saying that not talking to people is something that shouldn't happen, or c) saying that outright telling someone you don't want to talk to them is against the rules.
Can someone clarify the timeline here? There's a half-hour gap between Bramandin's first comment and Iximaz's reply; was there other (unrelated) conversation in there, or just a silent Discord? And did Bramandin do or say anything in the 11-odd hours you jump over at the end of the transcript? I'd really like to know what they posted the quote of me in response to, if anything, because I can't make head nor tail of why it came up.
hS -
And to answer your other question by
on 2017-05-03 17:59:00 UTC
Link to this
There was nothing in the break in the first quote; discord was silent for half an hour, as sometimes happens in the off hours. Ix's response was the immediate first reply, and conventionally appropriate for picking up a conversation that's gone quiet.
And as others have said, Bram participated in a few unrelated conversations in the hours before the final exchange, but the last comment was completely out of the blue. There had been a brief silly discussion of sports a couple hours before, someone showed up and got greeted at ten-plus-change, and then Bram commented at eleven thirty. -
Here's a Screenshot by
on 2017-05-03 18:07:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Bramandin's comment was out of the blue. by
on 2017-05-03 09:10:00 UTC
Link to this
She spoke a few times in the unquoted hours, but the quotes weren't relevant to her harassing Ix for an explanation.
-
Thank you. Unrelated question: by
on 2017-05-03 09:20:00 UTC
Link to this
What's the difference between this and Matt Cipher's attempt to be inclusive of JulyFlame, which both you and Iximaz supported? Is it that less time has passed since whatever incident/s led to Iximaz not wanting to talk to Bramandin? Or that this was Bramandin specifically addressing Iximaz, rather than a general message? Or something else?
This is a serious question, not a veiled attack of any kind. I am trying to understand all the context, including the broader mindsets of the people involved.
hS -
Fair question. by
on 2017-05-03 09:54:00 UTC
Link to this
Thanks for extending me the opportunity to clarify.
In this case, it's the fact that Matt Cipher's post was a general message, which, to me—and I think to Iximaz, though obviously I can't speak for her—is an important distinction.
I didn't see Matt Cipher as specifically addressing JulyFlame, but as addressing the females of the PPC, of which JulyFlame is a member.
I'd like to think that if a similar situation occurred, wherein Bramandin made a post similar to Matt Cipher's which included Iximaz's, we'd have had the same conversation with Ix if she'd decided to take the issue personally.
In this case, Bramandin demanded an explanation from Iximaz despite repeated requests from Iximaz not to do so.
I thought it was wrong when Matt Cipher pursued JulyFlame for an explanation. The confusion, I think, arises from the fact that I also thought JulyFlame was wrong for taking an expression of goodwill that happened to include her as a personal attack.
In this case, Bramandin isn't extending goodwill toward anyone of the gender Ix is a member of, but— however unintentionally —hounding Ix for an explanation of a perceived negative opinion, real or imagined, and in the face of very clear requests to stop. To go back to the example of JulyFlame and Matt Cipher, Bramandin is doing something very similar to Iximaz, and the prevailing opinion was that it was wrong then. I think it still is.
--Aegis, hoping that cleared things up slightly more than it muddied them. -
Thank you (too). by
on 2017-05-03 10:01:00 UTC
Link to this
Part of the reason I asked is that I have no idea what the general consensus was when (as you put it) "Matt Cipher pursued JulyFlame for an explanation". My memories of that incident are mostly from emails, so I don't recall what happened on the Board (and don't know what was said on the Discord).
As I've just said to Iximaz, I think Bramandin is seriously in the wrong here. I'm not sure what they should be required to do, since in the previous incident, JulyFlame specifically and emphatically didn't want to hear anything from Matt Cipher, including apologies - so the instinctive "Bramandin needs to apologise now!" reaction may be a misfire.
At the very least, they need to commit to not talking to Iximaz.
hS -
A general thread of well-wishes versus a direct address? by
on 2017-05-03 09:51:00 UTC
Link to this
At least Matt didn't turn immediately hostile after he was told to apologize.
And for the record, this was Bram's follow-up.
Iximaz Ø - Today at 2:37 AM
You have been blocked and I am taking this to the Board.
Also, @Moderator.
1 BLOCKED MESSAGE
Bram - Today at 2:39 AM
It is your bad behavior.
I'm going to bed now. Probably won't be on the Board or Discord for a few days. -
Sends happy images of Baby Seals your way. (nm) by
on 2017-05-03 13:08:00 UTC
Link to this
-
I feel that Bramandin is clearly in the wrong here. by
on 2017-05-03 09:58:00 UTC
Link to this
I should've said that before asking this follow-up question; I'm sorry for not doing so, and hope that the order I said things in hasn't given you the wrong impression.
hS -
Thank you. (nm) by
on 2017-05-03 09:55:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Can confirm... by
on 2017-05-03 08:00:00 UTC
Link to this
This happened, without significant other context- Bram showed up and dove into this conversation as logged.
Bram, I said this on the Discord and I'll say it here too: your continuing attempts to engage Iximaz in conversation are rapidly turning into harassment, and are very definitely Not Cool. I've offered to mediate, please respect that process (or talk with me about a different mediation process, if you dislike it) and talk with me rather than continuing to chase Ix.
-
You have just crossed the hyper limit, inbound. by
on 2017-05-03 12:08:00 UTC
Link to this
The seductive warp of hyperspace vanished from the viewscreen, leaving the more natural but no less beautiful image of a sun burning dead ahead. The Executive Officer leans back in her chair with a satisfied smile.
"Nicely done, as always, Helm," she says, nodding at the ensign manning that station. "Make sure the hyper generator is locked down, then take us-"
"XO!" The raw terror in the young Tactical Officer's voice snaps the XO's head round like a whip. "I've got hostile traces - multiple hostile ships surrounding our emergance point!"
The XO will never remember how she got from her chair to the tactical console. The two red icons of enemy ships pulse in the view, and a moment later one of them spouts a ruddy vector: she is already underway, heading obliquely towards the ship.
"Bring the wedge to full power," she says, amazed at the calm in her voice. "Bring the crew to battle stations." As the siren began to sound across the bridge, she leans closer to the Tactical Officer. "Can we hyper out in time to warn the convoy?" she asks in a low voice.
The TO's fingers dance over the controls, but the XO already knows the answer. The young officer's headshake just confirms it.
"Very well," she says, "then we'll have to keep them busy here. Comms - make sure the skipper's been notified. We've got a fight ahead of us.
Welcome, collective captain, to the burden of command! You've just entered the system with your single (gold) ship, and have discovered that it is in enemy (red) hands. Your number two priority is to make it back across the hyper limit (blue line) and jump to hyperspace, getting the word out.
Unfortunately, your number one priority is the unarmed and unarmoured convoy coming in behind you. They will arrive at your current location in five turns, which also happens to be the time it will take you to make it back over the limit and hyper out. You can't send a message to them while they're in hyperspace, so their only hope is if you can draw the enemy ships off and give them time to escape - another five turns after they cross the limit.
The hex grid is your tactical plot. It shows your ship (in gold), and your current vector - ie, where you will end up if you don't make any changes to your heading this turn. It also displays any other ships or missiles you can currently see - in this case, two enemy vessels. Your Tactical Officer has helpfully displayed the enemy's current vector, and the volume of space they could end their next turn in if they maneuver. The grid extends indefinitely in all directions, but nothing has been detected beyond the volume of space shown.
Your ship has several critical systems you should familiarise yourself with:
a) Your gravitic wedge is both your drive and your shielding. While it is raised, your ship has an acceleration of two. That means that in each turn, you can change the endpoint of your gold vector by up to two hexes. This shift can be forwards (accelerating), backwards (decelerating), or to the side (turning); your Tactical Officer has helpfully displayed the area you can reach on your plot. Your ship will follow the arrow as it exists after you maneuver, and that will be its new vector next turn. The enemy ships, and the convoy, have the same two-unit acceleration; the ring around your ship's icon indicates a raised wedge.
At the end of each turn, you may choose to lower the wedge, or raise it if it is already down. This takes effect immediately.
c) Your sensors detect gravitic wedges. A raised wedge can be detected at any distance, in real-time. A lowered wedge is invisible at long range - you can only detect it three hexes away. The enemy, and the convoy, have weaker sensors than you - they can only spot a lowered wedge at two hexes. So lowering your wedge lets you enter 'stealth mode' - but means you can't use it to maneuver, and you lose its protection against attacks.
c) Your thrusters are used for maneuvering when the wedge is lowered. They are very weak - they grant you an acceleration of one, but you can only use this on alternate turns. They are non-gravitic, so cannot be seen on sensors; that means that you (or the enemy) can never know precisely where a ship is once its wedge is down. The enemy, and the convoy, have the same thrusters as you.
d) Your weapons come in two kinds. Lasers are the simplest: they're instantaneous weapons which can hit any hex directly adjacent to your ship. You can fire one laser per turn. Your missiles are essentially tiny starships: they have an onboard acceleration capacity of ten, which they can split up however they like: they can spend it all in a single massive burst, spread it out to maneuver over twelve turns, or anything in between. You can fire one missile per turn.
Enemy lasers are identical to your own. Their missiles only have an acceleration capacity of eight. The convoy is unarmed. Needless to say, firing missiles with their drives online reveals your exact location even with your wedge lowered, though not your vector.
If a missile or laser shot enters a hex containing a ship, it has a chance to do damage. We'll cover that if/when it comes up.
All rules apply to all ships on the field - the enemy are flying under the same conditions as you. Their communications are also slow enough that they have to maneuver before they know what their colleagues are doing - they can't rely on someone else catching you. Turns are simultaneous (meaning in practice that I've already plotted the enemy's first move).
The order of actions on your turn are:
1. Launch missiles and/or fire lasers. These will move simultaneously with you, at the end of the turn.
1b. Adjust the acceleration of your previously-fired missiles.
2. Use your wedge or thrusters to accelerate, or choose to repair a system instead. If you start your turn outside the hyper limit (blue line), you may hyper out.
3. Decide whether to raise or lower the wedge.
4. Commit. All ships will fire weapons, and laser hits will be resolved. All ships and weapons will move. All missile hits will be resolved. Then wedge raise/lower commands will be resolved.
Anyone can take the captain's role for each turn; please don't hog it, but let other people have a turn if they want it! Feel free to write a snippet of narrative to go with your orders; I've deliberately left the bridge crew (and ship) unnamed and undefined to let you fill in the details. Probably the easiest way to describe your actions is to draw arrows on the tactical plot - you can upload to Imgur without an account, as an example, and I'm sure there's others.
And remember: priority 1 is giving the convoy ten turns to get in and escape again. Priority 2 is getting out alive.
hS
(The setting is adapted from David Weber's Honor Harrington books. The game design is modified from Triplanetary. Ask if I haven't made sense.) -
Things I have learnt from this: by
on 2017-05-22 16:54:00 UTC
Link to this
'This' being both, y'know, this, and a couple of other game threads I've made ("Congratulations, you're falling into [canon]", Gallifreyan Scrabble, and... something else? I forget).
1/ PPCers like games like this, weird one-of-a-kind threads.
2/ The more complicated things are, the fewer people will get involved. There were far more responses to the canon game than this one, with its hex grid and all.
3/ Multiple-choice is good. Multiple choice with 'or anything you like' is better.
4/ Anything which runs longer than ten turns/a week is liable to go unfinished. It's deep enough that new people don't feel like they can jump in, the people who've already taken part feel like they've explored the options enough, and I start to get tired, introducing more lag.
Which is all fine! It's good information to carry through to the next game, whenever I get an inspiration. It does mean it's unlikely we'll ever play PPC Cluedo on the Board, or PPC Munchkin, but given that it's been years since I had the idea to run a Cluedo game and I've never tried, that was inevitable anyway.
I'm still happy to play this one out if people are interested; don't read this as me closing the game. :) Just thinking about the next one...
hS -
Turn 12. We rejoin the action to System North. by
on 2017-05-15 11:58:00 UTC
Link to this
The rendezvous between the convoy and HMS Thornbird has been brutal. All four ships are damaged: most critically, Convoys Centre and South have lost their sidewalls and are flying unshielded, and a shot from Tango 3 has just taken down Convoy South's wedge entirely. They'll need to take a turn without maneuvering to repair it; whether they break formation to do so is up to you.
Convoy North has mostly escaped damage, but a freak hit has taken out her hyper generator. Until it is repaired, she can't jump out - and neither can Thornbird, which has also lost her thrusters (ie, she can't maneuver without her wedge up).
The enemy have taken hits of their own. Tango 2 (north) has just lost all power; this will take two turns to repair, so if you can hit her before the end of next turn, she'll be destroyed. Tango 1 (east) is flying without weapons, though she's sure to fix one or the other soon. Tango 3 (west) is still running smoothly.
At this point you're free to offer your own plan of whatever complexity you like. However, if you'd prefer a simpler game, you can select from one of these options:
HMS Thornbird
A) Fire missile at Tango 2 to destroy her. Vector ENE (ie, move 1E) and fire lasers on Tango 1 if she comes into range.
B) Fire missile at Tango 3's East point. Hold position (ie, vector one hex NE) and fire lasers on Tango 1 if she comes into range. Ignore Tango 2 entirely, as she is heading out of the combat area fast.
C) Ignore Tangos 2 and 3. Fire missile at Tango 1's current endpoint and hold position (as above) to fire lasers.
Convoy
1) All ships adjust vector 1E and shut down wedges. Next turn will be spent on repairs.
2) All ships refrain from maneuvering. Convoy S spend the turn repairing the wedge. Convoy N repair hyper, Convoy C repair shields.
3) Convoy N and C accelerate along this vector (ie, adjust endpoint 2NE). Convoy S vector SE on thrusters and make for the hyper limit independently.
Since all four ships are close together, one captain can command the entire convoy if you want. Just pick a letter and a number. :)
hS -
"I am taking command of all bridges!" by
on 2017-05-15 22:04:00 UTC
Link to this
"Convoys, maneuver out of here and go dark, prioritize repairs on your shields and hypers. Thornbird! I want us to prioritize taking out Tango 2. Hold position and fire missiles on Tango 2 and open laser fire on Any Tango that so much as passes us."
-
Turn 13. by
on 2017-05-19 11:36:00 UTC
Link to this
Tango 2 has been destroyed, Tango 1 has fixed its lasers but lost its shields. Tango 3 has three missiles on the field - one streaking pointlessly off to the north, one able to hit Convoy-N if the convoy doesn't maneuver, and one able to strike any of the convoy ships if it can guess their location right.
Thornbird is currently stationary, having fired its lasers at Tango 1. The convoy maneuvered slightly and then all ships lowered their wedges; the enemy currently knows their location, but will lose them off sensors fairly soon. Note that Convoy-S can't maneuver again this turn, while the other two can.
hS -
The Good Captain smiles. by
on 2017-05-19 13:32:00 UTC
Link to this
"Thornbird! Adjust Missile Launch Vector! Line Laser Arrays! TARGET TANGO 1"
Tactics hits several buttons, with targeting reticles quickly appearing and lining up with the ship. "All clear sir!" He says.
"FIRE!"
Before the dust clears, the Captain barks out some more orders: "Get that Decoy back up. Convoy! Prioritize your repairs on your shields, send yourselves NE on thruster power!" -
Turn 14. by
on 2017-05-19 14:05:00 UTC
Link to this
You have one launched missile, which you can use to hit anywhere in the enemy's destination hex. If you don't start moving, you're going to be essentially out of the battle, though.
Convoy-C has been hit, and lost its wedge (which was already lowered). Convoy-S has also been hit, and lost its hyperdrive. Convoy-N evaded attack. (There is an error in the diagram: Convoy-S should have its shields back.)
But.
The only convoy ship visible on enemy sensors right now is Convoy-S. They also saw the missile strike on Convoy-C, but crucially, have no way of telling which ship it was. Because Convoys C and N accelerated, breaking formation with Convoy S, Convoy-C is now where the enemy expected Convoy-N to be.
In other words: the bad guys have just lost tracking on two of the three convoy ships. If Convoy-S can get out of sensor range (remember, it has 1 hex of maneuvering this turn; the other two have none), the enemy will be completely unable to find them.
hS -
"Send the live missile where Convoy-C is!" by
on 2017-05-19 14:23:00 UTC
Link to this
"And launch a second one to where Convoy-N is! Send us due north and tell Convoy-S to accelerate to the SE!"
-
Sir! by
on 2017-05-19 14:31:00 UTC
Link to this
"I would like to recommend the following course of action. Convoy-S should break toward the Hyper Limit, and get to work repairing. They can coast the rest of the way, bring up their wedge when the time is right, and get out. The other Convoy ships should stay on course and begin repairs; shields and wedge are priority for all ships.
As for us, get another missile in the air heading 4 by 35 by 9 (ending at Convoy-C starting position). Bring our other bird around to due East (ending one hex West of Convoy-C starting position).
Also, bring us about hard and burn Northeast. I've already dispatched a repair crew to get those thrusters back online. -
"I like that course of action, let's do it!" (nm) by
on 2017-05-19 14:38:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Turn 15(b). by
on 2017-05-19 14:48:00 UTC
Link to this
It's all gotten terribly linear, hasn't it? ^_^
Convoy-S is in sensor range of Tango 3. It can't use its thrusters next turn, but can repair either the wedge or the hyper generator.
Convoys N and C avoided attack. They can maneuver next turn. Be aware that the enemy are aware that the convoy isn't where they thought it was, though they don't know where it is. Their bridge plots are covered in probability cones. :)
Thornbird is coming up behind the enemy, and has two missiles in the air; either of them can reach Tango 1's destination hexes, though neither can reach Tango 3's.
hS -
The Good Captain assumes the 'Gendo Ikari' position by
on 2017-05-04 00:41:00 UTC
Link to this
"This is our moment, men. Hopefully the first of many," He says through tented hands. "Adjust missile vectors, laser batteries. Do we still have Tuesday's lunch? Put that in one of the airlocks. Point 'em all at Tango 2. TARGET!"
Targeting reticles flash to life on the viewing screen, quickly aligning themselves over the enemy ship.
"Ready to fire on your command, sir!" Says the TO.
"Is the Missile Vector aligned to Tango 2?!"
"Sir yes sir!"
"Is Tuesday's lunch in the airlock?!"
The XO baps her personal console a few times. "Sir yes sir!" she says.
The Captain stands and points to the screen, "FIRE!"
There's a brief pause, before the the TO gives a thumbs up. "All weapons- and airlocks- have finished firing, weapons only soon."
"I for one do not want to sit here and watch as all our work be for naught. Center wedge over us and engage thrusters eastward! Send Missiles 1 through 3 in the general direction of Tangos 1 and 3!"
"Anything precise sir?" Asks the TO
"Surprise me." -
Meanwhile, at the convoy by
on 2017-05-04 11:59:00 UTC
Link to this
Captain Elcalion reviewed the tactical plot in front of him. A well-built man of medium height with brown hair and eyes and a pale complexion.
"Exec, give me an update", he said in a measured tenor voice.
"Our lead ship, the HMS Thornbird, is engaging an enemy ship, sir! There are two other enemy cruisers in between us and the Thornbird. They appear to be trying to draw the enemy away from the convoy." replied the executive officer.
"Those poor, brave bastards," said the Captain, his voice taking on a husky edge from emotion. "We cannot let their sacrifice be in vain. Signal all units, change heading 45 degrees to port." ((i.e. move to the southwest)).
"Guns, fire all our missiles at a heading 15 degrees to the north of the nearest enemy ship. Let's see if we can't take one of them off the Thornbird's back".
"Signal the convoy. Prepare to re-enter hyper as soon as we cross back over the hyper limit".
Elcalion, assuming any resemblance to the Battle of Adler is entirely coincidental. Also yay! Honorverse. I'm re-reading Echoes of Honor at the moment. -
Turn 6. by
on 2017-05-04 12:52:00 UTC
Link to this
HMS Thornbird shuddered from stem to stern, throwing Captain Comet nearly out of his seat. "We're hit!" the Engineering officer called out. "Sidewall generators are down - skipper, we've got no shields!"
"But we got them, too," the Chief of Security reported, an ugly edge to his voice. "Hit them right in the primary gravitic array - they're flying blind, captain. Until they take time to repair, Tango 2 is out of the engagement."
Elsewhere...
The XO looked warily at Captain Elcalion. "Um, sir," he said, "this is a freighter. We... we don't HAVE missiles..."
Tango 2 can now only see two spaces away from it. Enemy missiles are controlled by the ship nearest them, so the 7-point missile between you and T2 is also running blind. Your missile has 8 points left on its maneuvers.
Oh, and lasers ignore the coin-flip. At that range, they're going to go through your shields.
Elcalion - welcome aboard, Captain! But you're unarmed, I'm afraid. ;) (I can neither confirm nor deny extensive cribbing from Third Adler. But it looks like Captain Comet might have better luck than Alastair, despite facing longer odds!)
hS -
Also also also by
on 2017-05-04 13:24:00 UTC
Link to this
((Any distinction in the angle of attack of a missile? i.e. difference between fire arriving from the side or "up the kilt"/"down the throat" shots?))
-
Simulation parameters. by
on 2017-05-04 14:25:00 UTC
Link to this
-Gravitic sensors have infinite range, and no interference from intervening wedges. Active sensors aren't disableable by weapons, and have a range of 2 hexes (increased to 3 for the Manticoran warship Thornbird).
-Your impeller drive can adjust your vector by two hexes. Your reaction thrusters have an effective acceleration of 1/2 hex, which is modelled as only being used on alternate turns.
-All missiles are being modelled as Apollos, meaning they're controlled in real-time to the point that they always strike at an effective angle. There's a coinflip to see if they get caught by the sidewalls - I actually didn't bother with this on the one missile hit we've had so far, because the missile came in so fast I figured Tango 1 wouldn't have time to maneuver against it. (Also I wanted to see something blow up. ^_^) But it'll be in place for every other strike.
Got a bit of a busy day today, so Turn 7 might not be up until tonight. Sorry, all!
hS -
Darn it! by
on 2017-05-04 13:21:00 UTC
Link to this
((I assumed I was playing the role of GNS Alvarez. Should have double checked))
"You mean we don't have any weapons on board, exec?" asked Captain Elcalion, incredulously. "What sort of convoy only has one escort???"
"Adjust our vector to head south. We'll try and escape Tango 3 and break back across the hyper limit."
((What's the relative detection range of gravitics and active sensors? i.e. if a ship kills its wedge, at what distance can it be detected))
((Also also: what about maneuvering on reaction thrusters with the wedge down?)) -
"Adjust Missile Vector eastward" by
on 2017-05-04 13:34:00 UTC
Link to this
"Send it directly to Tango 2's wedge, send 1 and 3 directly east as well, we are gonna bomb the NWW, W, and SWW edge of their wedge."
The captain exams the damage readout.
"I'm not comfortable with dead shields, get them back up. We're gonna go dark in the mean time, bring down the wedge. When we light back up get the Convoy on the line!" -
Did you have a plan... by
on 2017-05-04 16:08:00 UTC
Link to this
... for the missile right in the middle of the firefight? It's the one with an orange 8 next to it, 1 NW of, uh... which one's Tango 2 again?
hS -
"Send Missle 4 to the NE edge of Tango 2's Wedge." (nm) by
on 2017-05-04 16:14:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Turn 7. by
on 2017-05-04 16:31:00 UTC
Link to this
Everything is quiet on the Thornbird's bridge. "Sidewall generators should be good to go as soon as we raise the wedge again," the engineering officer reports. "Assuming we don't get hit again."
"We've been lucky so far," the Tactical Officer chimes in. "One of Tango 2's missiles came close, but our decoy picked it off. We'll need to wait a turn if we want to deploy another one, though."
"Thrusters are online," Helm reports. "If we keep the wedge down and don't launch any more missiles, we should be able to keep out of any enemy sensor range."
"It looks like the convoy's lead ship has taken a hit," Comms says. "I think it's only their sensor array, though; the other ships should be able to cover for them. But Tango 3 is closing on them..."
Tango 2 know they've hit you - their missile telemetry went dead - so they currently know your location. But they have no way of knowing you've lowered your wedge; they think you could be anywhere in the larger hex, rather than knowing you're in the tiny one.
The fact that they know where you are means they know you paused to repair, though. That means they might guess you'll do the same again.
Remember that the number by your missiles indicates the number of hexes it can shift the end of its vector by. The central bird in your barrage eastwards is currently flying ballistic, with no remaining fuel.
Damage to the convoy is calculated slightly differently to everywhere else. They still get the coinflip, but they have no decoys or weapons. A roll of 2 or 3 will hit propulsion, while 4 or 5 hits sensors.
hS -
"Thrusters to the Southeast!" by
on 2017-05-04 16:51:00 UTC
Link to this
"Throw Missile 4 into the center of T2's wedge! Point 2 and 3 at T3's general direction! If we can get the Decoy up after all of that do it!"
-
Turn 8. by
on 2017-05-05 09:31:00 UTC
Link to this
"A hit!" Chief of Security Phobos grins at his console. "Looks like you were right about Tango 2 stopping to fix those sensors - we've taken out their sidewall generators, they have no shields."
"But we can't fire without blowing our cover," the Tactical Officer reminds you. "We can fix the decoys this turn - our thrusters are in their recharge phase anyway - but other than that, any overt move will give both Tango 2 and Tango 1 our position and vector."
"But we might have to," Comms chimes in. "Tango 3 got in another strike on the convoy; it was a near-miss, but they're just going to keep getting more accurate, and Tango 1's salvos are homing in on them. If we don't make a move - or Captain Elcalion doesn't do something clever - they might lose a ship, and that would be a disaster."
Every missile so far has hit through the shields; that one on the convoy rolled a 1, meaning a clean miss.
A reminder that anyone is allowed to jump in here; if you don't think directing missiles is something you're up for, you can take control of one of the convoy ships.
hS -
"Sir! Counselor Neshomeh has ordered a Southeast dash!" by
on 2017-05-05 17:28:00 UTC
Link to this
The Captain, examining the grid, nodded. "Alright, I want those two Missiles Northeast of us shot down with our Lasers. Make it look like they hit us. I also that decoy back up ASAP. We'll bring up our wedge and start heading south then."
-
(( Er, to clarify, I'm on the convoy. )) by
on 2017-05-05 20:53:00 UTC
Link to this
(( I realize I was not very clear about that until the end of my post. Not that the Thornbird can't use the same tactic if it wants to, but I'm in no way presuming I know how to handle a warship in active combat. For that matter, I'm not sure why a freighter has a counselor with an officer's rank, either. {X D
~Neshomeh )) -
Well, the freighter's captain... by
on 2017-05-05 21:03:00 UTC
Link to this
... thinks he's running a warship. He's clearly not entirely in the same universe as the rest of us.
The best part is that the Ship's Counsellor apparently outranks the XO. Iiii get the feeling this is one of those ships... you know, the ones enlisted spacers whisper horror stories to each other about...
hS -
You say counselor... by
on 2017-05-05 23:43:00 UTC
Link to this
I hear People's Commissioner :-P
Elcalion, out of this world -
"You kids better behave or I'll pull rank" (nm) by
on 2017-05-06 02:07:00 UTC
Link to this
-
((I assumed as much)) by
on 2017-05-05 20:56:00 UTC
Link to this
((The going plan is for the Thornbird to meet up with the convoy to assist it against the baddies))
-
"Dodge!" by
on 2017-05-05 16:54:00 UTC
Link to this
Counselor Neshomeh steps up to the command position. She is wearing a non-regulation form-fitting jumpsuit that probably helps her patients relate to her or something, and is totally not just for eyecandy.
"Since Captain Elcalion got a little overexcited back there, I've sent him to Medical to calm down," she says, then looks around nervously. "Apparently that makes me the senior officer on the bridge at the moment. So, I think we should try to throw off those enemy ships. They seem to think we'll turn straight around and make a beeline for the hyper limit. Let's not do that. Instead, we'll jog southwest this turn, try to confuse them a little. Then, with their vectors off, we'll stand a better chance of escaping."
I hope.
(( I have barely any idea what I'm doing, but I liked the idea of being Deanna Troi. ^_^ So, basically, the convoy goes as far as it can to the southwest. Unless a more suitable officer thinks I'm about to get us killed and steps in, of course. {= D
~Neshomeh, participating! )) -
Turn 9. by
on 2017-05-05 21:00:00 UTC
Link to this
The Helm officer gives the Ship's Counsellor a distinctly dubious look. A murmur goes around the bridge: "Senior officer indeed..." But as no-one else is willing to step up and overrule her, the ships of the convoy swing ponderously to south-west.
"A miss." The bewildered executive officer points at the navigational plot. "Their missile went right where you said it would, ma'am. That's... we're not out of this yet, though."
"Thornbird has brought its wedge back online," the Comms officer reports. "Looks like they might have taken a couple of hits, though."
"Not if I know Captain Comet," the Chief Engineer puts in, a twinkle in his eye. "That looks like a laser strike on the missiles to me. They're good to go."
"But a long way from us," the XO cautions, "and Tango 3 is between us and the hyper limit. I hope you've got another trick up your sleeve, ma'am..."
I hope Thornbird gets down south quickly, otherwise this tactical plot is going to get ridiculously tall. (I confess to being very amused by the, uh, precocious Counsellor.) Crew of the Thornbird, be aware that you have a missile coming straight at you from Tango 2.
hS -
"We're in business men!" by
on 2017-05-05 21:25:00 UTC
Link to this
"Comms! I need you to open up communications with the Convoy. Tactics! I need a missile on T2's Southeastern-most point, send the live one towards the end point of the Convoy's vector. I want us going south with all we got! Put our vector on the southern central Hex with thrusters on full force! We need to make it to our Convoy as soon as possible!"
-
Anyone from the convoy? by
on 2017-05-06 09:30:00 UTC
Link to this
Your options are: a) keep going in the same direction, b) swing back towards the hyper limit, or c) try to loop away from Tango 3, back towards the Thornbird, and hope the bad guys overshoot.
Or anything else, of course, but it seems like people might be overwhelmed by the number of choices.
hS -
Don't have time to do a proper response by
on 2017-05-06 13:29:00 UTC
Link to this
But option C
Out at a friend's bday party so don't have time to post properly
Elcalion, evasory -
Turn 10. by
on 2017-05-06 14:17:00 UTC
Link to this
"Direct hit!" the Tactical Officer crowed across the bridge of HMS Thornbird, but then frowned at the screen. "Ah, direct hit to their decoys, rather. Sorry, captain."
"It's still a valuable hit," the XO reassures the young officer. "It gives us that much more chance next time. And with our vector bending away from theirs, I doubt they'll want to stop and make repairs."
"Um." The note of uncertainty was injected by the Comms officer. "Captain? It's the convoy... they've turned away from the hyper limit and are vectoring in-system..."
I may need to come up with another way to display the plot, it's getting ridiculous... Tango 2 is down its shields and decoys, which means you've got a good chance of doing critical damage if you can hit it again.
hS -
"Adjust Missile Vectors, send one dead center in T2's Wedge" by
on 2017-05-08 16:58:00 UTC
Link to this
"Furthermore, adjust vectors to the Southwestern corner. Comms! Do we have open channels with the convoy yet?!"
-
Turn 11. by
on 2017-05-08 17:16:00 UTC
Link to this
"We have light-speed communications with the convoy only," the Comms officer reports. "We can send them a message, but they won't receive it for a few turns."
"Hit on the convoy's north ship!" the TO calls out. "Looks like... looks like they caught it on the sidewalls. No damage."
"Rather like our situation here," the XO mutters. "No hits, no damage..."
The current situation, since I had to zoom out a lot:
-The central convoy ship has no sensors. The north one just took a miss.
-Tango 2 has no shields or decoys; every other enemy ship is intact.
-You have no missiles worth controlling (the one you just fired is barrelling off towards the inner system to accidentally violate the Eridani Edict). There's a 4-point one coming in towards you from Tango 2, and a slow-moving 1-pointer wandering in from the east. There's also one 4-pointer headed up the convoy's tail.
I don't know how people are feeling about this game; responses have definitely slowed down. If you want me to speed things along, I can play out the next few turns on autopilot. What I'd need to know is:
-Is the convoy dedicated to swinging north at this point?
-Does HMS Thornbird want to match vectors with (ie, fly alongside) the convoy, match vectors with Tango 1+3, or zoom past them both in a headlong flight to the south?
Or I'm happy to keep playing turn-by-turn; I think it's fun. ^_^
hS -
I'm still keen to play by
on 2017-05-13 04:29:00 UTC
Link to this
But ability to do detailed responses will be limited, crazy couple of weeks at work.
As far as the convoy goes, I was planning on trying to swing north to hook up with the Thornbird, possibly with some 'silent running' with the wedge down to try to avoid any potential Peep ships lying doggo in the convoys path.
Elcalion -
At the convoy by
on 2017-05-08 03:52:00 UTC
Link to this
Captain Elcalion returned from sick-bay, a sheepish look on his face.
"I'm sorry, Number 2, don't know what came over me. I'm back on deck now."
He reviewed the tac plot. "Hmmm, our best bet will be to divert in-system to link up with the Thornbird. Bring our vector two squares to system north." -
Here's my idea, Captain Hivemind. by
on 2017-05-03 13:36:00 UTC
Link to this
I'd say the ship should begin make it's way towards the the upper ship, and fire a missile off but have it hold it's immediate attack.
-
So move to the top-left corner of your hex? by
on 2017-05-03 13:54:00 UTC
Link to this
I'm not sure what you're saying for the missile - are you firing it at the top ship, or what?
(Oh, I should've mentioned: missiles start on your ship. That means their vector starts off identical to yours, so any acceleration has to take that into account.)
hS -
Yes by
on 2017-05-03 14:01:00 UTC
Link to this
Also with the missles: I'm aiming to keep it within close proximity to our main ship, if only to build up a good, healthy Macross Missile Massacre.
-
Turn 1. by
on 2017-05-03 14:25:00 UTC
Link to this
"Captain on the bridge!"
You walk over to your chair and settle in, leaning forwards to scrutinise the tactical plot. Your XO is at your elbow, waiting for your orders.
"Launch one missile," you say, "but keep it in close. I want us to close with the upper enemy... let's see if we can take them out before their friends get here."
"Aye aye, skipper." You watch the plot change as Helm makes the changes, then draw in a sharp breath as the enemy moves to counter.
"They're heading right past us," the Tactical Officer reports. "We've got enough fuel in the missile to hit any one of their possible locations, but there's no indication of where they'll go. And, captain," the TO swallows, "we're going to be sailing directly into their own missile envelope. If they guess where we're going to jump..."
The new plot. Your single deployed missile has 8 units of accel left, meaning it can reach anywhere 8 hexes from the tip of its arrow - but of course, you don't know where the enemy is going.
4 turns until the convoy arrives; I'll place a marker on the board for next turn.
hS -
Fellow members of Captain Hivemind, I propose... by
on 2017-05-03 14:59:00 UTC
Link to this
That in addition to firing off a second missile similarly to the previous one, we should lower our field. Keeping the field close to us should restrict the enemy's ability to launch missiles against us.
Do I have any objections? -
"A suggestion, Captain" by
on 2017-05-03 14:54:00 UTC
Link to this
The Security Chief is a large, bearded man in a red uniform. He stands at his own tactical display near the rear of the bridge.
"If we can get around behind the upper enemy ship, we can avoid being flanked. I suggest that we alter course, by turning and accelerating, to take a position in the middle of the upper limit of our range ((2 hexes North of where our arrow stops))."
"I further suggest taking the fight to the closer foe, who will likely try to get behind us. I propose moving our missile to the point of their range closest to us ((their extreme West))."
He stops to study the readout again. "And as much as I hate to say this, I believe dropping the wedge is our best course of action. They'll have to find us before they can hit us."
(( 1. Fire no weapons
1b. Move our missile to the point 3E and 1 NE of the end of our plotted vector
2. Change our vector to move to a point 2N of our plotted vector
3. Lower the wedge
4. Pray))
-Phobos -
"This is why I keep you aboard, Chief." by
on 2017-05-03 15:18:00 UTC
Link to this
"Do as he says. Also, follow up question: How many Red Shirts can we feasibly eject as Human Shields?"
The bridge looks at him in confusion.
"That was a joke." -
How weapons work. by
on 2017-05-03 15:00:00 UTC
Link to this
i) If the ship has a raised wedge, a coinflip determines whether the attack is stopped by its shielding.
ii) If the attack gets through, a d6 is rolled to determine where it hits. A hit to a fully disabled system counts as a miss.
1 - clean miss.
2 - hits decoys, disabling them. Subsequent rolls of 2 trigger a reroll.
3 - hits weapons. The first hit disables the laser. The third hit disables your missiles.
4 - hits propulsion. The first hit disables the shielding function of your wedge (removing the coinflip). Any subsequent hits roll a d3 to select whether they disable the wedge, the thrusters, or the hyperdrive. (If the hyperdrive is disabled, you won't be able to escape until you repair it.)
5 - disables sensors, leaving you blind.
6 - disables ship power, shutting down all systems, but only if you have already lost two critical systems (missiles, sensors, anything in propulsion). Otherwise, counts as a miss. A second roll of 6 when power is out will destroy the ship.
On any turn, instead of maneuvering, you can repair one disabled system. Missiles only take one turn to repair, though it is possible to repair the damage from a 'second hit' before they're actually disabled.
So you can take a hit, even a damaging one, and recover from it. With a bit of luck, you can take several.
As per usual, the same rules apply to the enemy.
(Also, when your wedge is up, there's no downside to launching a missile. It would have exactly the same potential targets as your ride-along Macross buddy, so letting you cover twice the potential targets.)
hS -
Then fire a second missile by
on 2017-05-03 15:02:00 UTC
Link to this
And send that one to a location 1 hex SE of the first missile.
-
Turn 2. by
on 2017-05-03 15:18:00 UTC
Link to this
You grip the arms of your seat as the ship swings round under you. You barely hear the descending whine as the wedge powers down - all your attention is focussed on the tactical board, and the ships and missiles weaving their intricate dance there.
"A hit!" The Chief of Security almost jumps out of his seat. "Direct hit to Target One's laser batteries. They're going to have a hard time patching that back together."
"Let's not get too excited," the XO says at your elbow. "We may have escaped their missiles for now, but the convoy's still on its way - and Target One is headed right for its emergence point."
Or: "Captain! The bad guys are behind us!"
hS -
"Throw the thrusters into retrograde by
on 2017-05-03 15:29:00 UTC
Link to this
"Put our wedge back up and begin moving it towards us, we need to get into laser range. Fire another missile. Chief Phobos, you're in charge of positioning it and the live one."
((Put wedge up, move it SE towards the ship, use thrusters to move the ship in the same direction. Launch another Missile, put Chief Phobos in charge of positioning them.)) -
Confusion? by
on 2017-05-03 15:32:00 UTC
Link to this
The gravitic wedge is your engine, so I don't think you meant to ask to move it towards you (what with it being... y'know, built into your hull). You want to move to the SE point in your destination area and then raise the wedge again, right?
hS -
Yes (nm) by
on 2017-05-03 15:35:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Okay. So just need missile targets (from Phobos or anyone). (nm) by
on 2017-05-03 15:46:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Targets by
on 2017-05-03 16:10:00 UTC
Link to this
Missile one, target closest hex to the Emergence Point ((middle of the SE edge)). Should take all it has left to get there.
Missile 2, aim for the center of their range. We'll see what they do. -
Remember your missiles have starting vectors. by
on 2017-05-03 16:22:00 UTC
Link to this
Missile 1 is currently headed for the hex NW of Target 1. The smaller black _/ is the limit of its guided range (though of course it will still exist and keep moving next turn).
Similarly, the larger black _/ is the furthest you can chuck a missile from your ship now. Its vector next turn will be a line from where your ship is now to where the missile ends turn, so anything forward of your position will keep moving away from the enemy.
hS -
Shooting things in space is hard by
on 2017-05-03 16:30:00 UTC
Link to this
Missile 1, aim for the center of the range, which should take all she's got.
Missile 2, Macross maneuver. -
Turn 3. by
on 2017-05-03 16:45:00 UTC
Link to this
"They're coming about, skipper." The Tactical Officer looks over at your chair. "Target 1 looks to be trying to loop round and cut us off to the north. Target 2 is making a beeline for us. Assuming there's nothing else out there, the convoy should be safe."
"Which doesn't mean we are," the XO puts in. "We've got three missiles coming our way. One's flying ballistic, but the others have enough power left in them to give us trouble."
Shooting things in space is hard. I've had the TO update the plot to include projected missile vectors, which should help some. :)
hS -
"Stay put men." by
on 2017-05-03 16:58:00 UTC
Link to this
"We may take a hit, but I want to give the good 'ol Lasers a go. Set our missile vector to Southeast if possible and send another big boy to the Southeastern vector closest to us. You boys handle the rest
((The captain decides to not move, adjust a Missile Vector, and fire the missile.))
((Follow question: can 2 missiles occupy the same space?)) -
Well, you can't not move. by
on 2017-05-03 18:15:00 UTC
Link to this
You're hurtling towards the inner system. :) But you can refrain from maneuvering, and end up in the centre of your arrival area.
Two missiles can occupy the same space. Missiles are small, and starships are big. (Though if you have control of a missile, you could order it to attack an opposing one.)
You can't communicate with the convoy while it's in hyper, but I think it'll drop out a turn before your missile hits, so will be safe. And hey, if they miss seeing the battle on sensors, the missile will be a big hint that something's up!
(By sheer coincidence, firing ultra-long range missiles to let someone know you're there has been used at least once in the Honorverse books...)
hS -
"Lay both missiles adjacent to us to the Southeast." by
on 2017-05-03 18:22:00 UTC
Link to this
"Also, move our vector to the Southeastern-most point possible."
-
Turn 4 by
on 2017-05-03 21:10:00 UTC
Link to this
The Tactical Officer actually flinches back from the display. "Four... no, five missiles inbound, captain. And Target 2 is closing... rapidly."
"Perhaps too rapidly," the Executive Officer notes. "If we can turn on her inside, we might be able to loop behind them and make the hyper limit before either enemy ship can catch us."
"And we've got two missiles of our own holding a Macross Maneuver to our southeast," the Chief of Security puts in. "If we can position them right, we can give the enemy a good kicking on the way out."
You are able to enter the same space as your own missiles without issue. The convoy will be arriving next turn. And there's still plenty of room on the bridge - don't let Captain Comet have all the fun!
hS -
"Move Missile 1 Northeast, 2 East to the space adjacent" by
on 2017-05-03 21:26:00 UTC
Link to this
"Furthermore, send us 2 spaces east and launch another missile directly East 2 spaces more once we reach that space, at the end of Tango 2's projected vector. Set all missiles to hit Tango 2 should they cross that space. Prime our laser batteries, we're going to go hot."
-
Turn 5. by
on 2017-05-03 21:52:00 UTC
Link to this
The board is alive with missile traces, crisscrossing local space, but despite all the fury not a single explosion speckles the sky. You ignore it, focussing on the navigational console, where-
"Skipper!" The officer at the console half-turns to face you. "I have the convoy on gravitics! Three contacts, strong and- wait."
He turns back, and when he looks up again there is horror in his eyes. "FOUR contacts!" he calls out. "A third bogey just lit its wedge, and it's between us and the convoy!"
You whirl to the tactical console, whether to demand explanations or to plan your next move, but the TO gets there first. "Tango 2 is closing! They're coming into laser range! All hands, prepare to fire!"
Yes, the third ship was there all along, poking along on its thrusters. Since I'm being kind, it made its maneuvers before the convoy appeared, but lit its wedge as soon as they showed up.
You're in laser range of Tango 2, and will fire before moving next turn unless for some reason you choose not to. Damage rolls will be calculated simultaneously for both ships (light-speed delay and all that). And yes, you can also launch missiles.
If anyone wants to take control of the convoy ships, feel free. Otherwise, they're just going to turn around as fast as possible and run for it.
... end of Episode 1! Episode 2 can start at the top of the thread with planning for Turn 6. (And I'm going to bed, so it'll all be tomorrow.)
hS -
"Can we get the convoy to adjust their exit vector?" by
on 2017-05-03 17:17:00 UTC
Link to this
"They appear to be in the line of fire of our ballistic."
-
((For the record)) by
on 2017-05-03 15:45:00 UTC
Link to this
((I'm at work right now and may not be able to do much more here. Others should feel free to take command.
-Phobos))
-
May the Fourth be with you! by
on 2017-05-04 11:44:00 UTC
Link to this
Happy Star Wars Day to all!
In celebration: a poem (which formed my Facebook status today, in response to some comments from my friends who found my habit of posting on May the Fourth a bit... repetitive); they won't be saying that after this year!
(For bonus points: join in the argument as to what meter this poem is written in? Is it largely anapaestic with an initial iamb? Or amphibrachic with an occasional terminal iamb? This has been dividing my friends list, because my friends are just as big nerds as I am)
Wise Obi-Wan, grey-haired and weathered by age
Had long been in exile from Emperor's rage
Until Princess Leia in desperate appeal
Did Artoo and Threep'yo into peril most real
Send unto Kenobi to beg for his help
In helping their owner: bold Anakin's whelp;
Whiny Luke the brash farm boy who dreams of the stars
Yet blunders in danger in Mos Eisley's bars
There met they Han Solo, ace pilot and rogue
Whose space aged high fashion was always in vogue:
Bloodstripes on his trousers, a dark vest and white shirt;
As Greedo well knows this brave scoundrel shoots first.
Millennium Falcon his famed smugg'ling vessel
Which in less than twelve parsecs did jourmey to Kessel
Did leave then for Ald'raan from Bay Ninety Four
With our band of brave heroes ensconced safe aboard.
No hokey religion; just a blaster in hand
With Chewie the wookiee to make full their brave band
Was the view of Han Solo; his operative creed
But the wise Jedi Gen'ral to this disagreed.
To rescue the Princess from Imperial anger
Would require Jedi training to shield Luke from danger.
In the hold of the Falcon with training remote
Wise old Ben did impart Jedi learning by rote
'Trust your feelings' said he; to improve just 'let go'
And the seeds of Luke's skill with the Force did he sow.
Though Obi-Wan fell struck by Vader's red blade,
On Yavin did Luke hear from his old mentor's shade:
Remember, dear Luke, that the powerful Force
Shall always be with you upon May the Fourth! -
Meter!!! by
on 2017-05-07 05:41:00 UTC
Link to this
Aren’t the two meters your friends are proposing the same thing?
An iamb and three anapests: u / | u u / | u u / | u u /
Three amphibrachs and an iamb: u / u | u / u | u / u | u /
Without the |foot| markers, they’re exactly the same: u / u u / u u / u u /
And foot divisions are kind of artificial, right? I’m not an expert; if there’s some nuance that I’m missing please someone call me out on it.
If you're interested, while I was trying to work this out, I went through your poem and annotated most of the first stanza in excruciating detail with analysis and concrit. I'm having some problem with HTML where the stress marks aren't lining up over the syllables I want them to line up with. . .let me know if you're curious about what I'm driving at but can't figure it out.
***
Summary impressions: The meter is fun and bouncy (appropriate for a jokey Facebook-status poem). There are few variants, and those which are present feel unintentional rather than like deliberate storytelling strategies. I find long series of rhymed couplets irritating, but am forced to admit that their jingling, cutesy tone is appropriate for a silly poem celebrating a holiday with a pun baked into the date.
/ /u u / u u / u u /
Wise Obi-Wan, grey-haired and weathered by age
(Spondee, anapest, anapest anapest. I see how some of your friends may have decided that first foot was iambic, but I wouldn't do that myself -- as an actor, I would stress it to avoid its getting lost and the audience's thinking of Obi-Wan as merely a doddering old man. Plus starting on a spondee is usually pretty strong and dramatic. I like it.)
OR
(Antibaccius, two amphibrachs, and an iamb. If the first syllable is unstressed (as I advised against above), you'd get three amphibrachs before the iamb.)
u / u u / u u / u u /
Had long been in exile from Emperor's rage
(there's the initial iamb and series of anapests your friends were talking about, or three amphibrachs with an iamb on the end)
u / u u / u u / u u /
Until Princess Leia in desperate appeal
(Just like the last line. I feel like "desperate" has too few syllables and want to spell it "desp'rate," but I think that's just my problem :P)
u / u u / u u u / u u /
Did Artoo and Threep'yo into peril most real
(What is that one extra unstressed syllable doing in the middle of the line? In neither of the proposed meters should there be three unstressed syllables in a row, and I don't think this moment in the story is dramatic enough to justify breaking the meter this way -- it causes the reader to halt and stumble for a moment, which is good if you want them to dwell on a line or phrase, but here just gets in the way of understanding this important bit of exposition. I suggest rejiggering this sentence (perhaps try replacing R2D2 and C3PO's names with something like "the droids," or using their full names, or their names in a different order). If you do decide to revise this, I also advise experimenting with ending this line on an unstressed syllable to help it flow into the next line, which is a continuation of the same idea. Putting a stressed syllable here, especially with the completion of a rhyme, makes it feel very final, which is confusing since that's not actually where the thought ends at all.)
/ / u u / u u / u u /
Send unto Kenobi to beg for his help
(Like the first line, with the same caveat about the first syllable -- I'd stress it, because the fact that the droids were sent is important information, but I suppose you don't have to.)
u / u u / u / / u u /
In helping their owner: bold Anakin's whelp;
(I'm torn over whether or not to stress "bold" -- obviously, having it unstressed fits the meter better (however one chooses to describe said meter, there's definitely a general pattern), but. . . it doesn't sound good to me. This poem is so much of a bare-bones summary that each rare adjective seems important. Also, I don’t think a semicolon belongs here, although Djel help me if I know what punctuation you should use.)
***
This is approximately when I realized I ought to be doing my homework instead of nit-picking at a Star Wars poem that was probably written as a joke in less than an hour. Thank you for posting this; this is some of the most fun I've had procrastinating in a while!
--Key -
Nice work! by
on 2017-05-07 11:24:00 UTC
Link to this
I certainly had anapaestic in mind when writing it, which took around 25 mins while walking to work; composed on my phone which explains the occasional misspelling (and then copy/pasted from my Facebook status to here), so silly poem is entirely appropriate. (I guess it fits the usual metric patterns for a ballad?)
I agree with you that "desperate" should be two syllables to make it fit the stress patterns; I also agree that the Artoo and Threepio line doesn't scan too well.
I read Stephen Fry's The Ode Less Traveled last year and the discipline needed to fit words to the meter is a fun challenge compared to prose writing. Terza rima or anything like that may be a bit much for a Facebook status, however!
Elcalion, waxing poetic -
How did I not see this?! by
on 2017-05-05 22:54:00 UTC
Link to this
Probably too much math. But this is pretty dang cool! You seem to have put a ton of effort into it, and I love the prose here. If you want to, maybe develop it into an epic poem somehow? I mean, the Star Wars movies are already considered epic film, and plus, it'd take time, but it'd be fun. :)
-Twistey -
*Applause* by
on 2017-05-05 06:15:00 UTC
Link to this
Hmm, no, that's much too understated. Let's try this:
*rapturous applause*
Ah, much better. There is a tragic dearth of Star Wars related poetry in the world, well done mending it!
May the Fourth be with you! -
A tragic dearth? by
on 2017-05-07 02:46:00 UTC
Link to this
Do you know of these? I believe you'd appreciate them.
-
Or a tragic Darth? by
on 2017-05-07 04:09:00 UTC
Link to this
^ Is the joke I expected to follow from Cat's post title. {= )
~Neshomeh -
Bravo! by
on 2017-05-04 15:30:00 UTC
Link to this
I have no comment on the meter; I lack the vocabulary. Some of the rhymes are a bit of a stretch, but I liked it! {= D
~Neshomeh
-
Google docs hack by
on 2017-05-04 17:03:00 UTC
Link to this
There's a new Google Docs hack going around where you recive a email with a link to a document. Opening the document directs you to a page where you are asked to sign in when Google dosen't ask for a password if you're already signed in.
-
Re: Google docs hack by
on 2017-05-18 18:45:00 UTC
Link to this
There's a bug where if you download a .SCF into your downloads folder then open the folder, it steals your login credentials.
-
According to Google, this has been cleared up. by
on 2017-05-08 06:37:00 UTC
Link to this
Can't find a very good source right now, but this article seems to mention it.
https://www.theverge.com/2017/5/3/15537064/google-docs-phishing-attack-fixed -
Yikes. Thanks for the heads-up. (nm) by
on 2017-05-05 00:02:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Beta Needed for Permission Request by
on 2017-05-05 06:06:00 UTC
Link to this
After years of lurking around and occasionally commenting on stuff, I've finally managed to get a permission request ready. Now all I need is a beta to make sure I didn't **** the whole thing up. Any takers?
-
I'll give it a shot. by
on 2017-05-05 15:30:00 UTC
Link to this
Email is clickable in my username. Now, heads up - I am not the perfect (or even decent) SPaG beta, but I think I can manage with the lore and coherency.
-
You still there? by
on 2017-05-15 06:05:00 UTC
Link to this
I haven't heard from you in a while. Is the beta thing still going on, or has life gotten in the way?
-
E-mail problem by
on 2017-05-06 01:00:00 UTC
Link to this
I can't find your e-mail in your username. Do you think you could fix that or at least send me your e-mail address some other way?
-
Huh... Must've done something wrong. by
on 2017-05-06 09:10:00 UTC
Link to this
Ah, heck with it. It's mattcipher94@gmail.com
-
Sent my permission attempt. (nm) by
on 2017-05-07 04:29:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Friday Forum: What's happened this week? by
on 2017-05-05 12:15:00 UTC
Link to this
Welcome to the very first Friday Forum, a hopefully-regular thread for talking about the week we've just had in this lovely world of ours. I'll kick it off by sharing a few news items (and my thoughts on them), and you can join in by talking about the stuff I raise, or other things that you've noticed.
Please remember that, when it comes to the state of the world, not everyone will agree with you. You're free to state, discuss, and defend your viewpoint (provided it does not violate the Constitution), but please don't use that fact to attack others.
Fandom News
(Link)
The trailer for The Dark Tower dropped on Wednesday, and I have to say I like the look of it. It doesn't seem to focus on the horror aspects of, say, The Drawing of the Three or Song of Susannah, which pleases me (as someone who read the Dark Tower series as fantasy and doesn't want to read anything else by Stephen King).
It looks like they're drawing mostly from The Gunslinger and The Waste Lands, though future trailers may alter that balance. It's not a straight adaptation of the books - but this is the Dark Tower series, which is rife with alternate universes. (Also, rumour says that Roland has the Horn of Eld - see the end of this post if you don't mind spoilers on what that actually means...)
Silly News
(Link)
Prince Philip, the Queen's husband (and Duke of Edinburgh), has stepped down from his royal duties at the age of 95. (Well, technically he's announced that he will in the autumn, at 96... whatever.) You might think that isn't particularly silly, but, uh, the BBC decided to commemorate the decision with an article on the numerous offensive "quips" he's made over the years (see link, above). So now you, too, can wince along with the British at the thought of the Queen's husband telling Malala Yousafzai that "[Children] go to school because their parents don't want them in the house"...!
Serious News
(Britain & America)
In a continuing swing towards the Right, Britain's Conservatives have done very well in local elections, while Twitter Personality and President Donald J. Trump has pushed his replacement for Obamacare through Congress.
The UK vote is very worrying, seeing as we're in the run-up for the snap general election Theresa May called (for the very cynical and blatant reason that she wants to reduce the number of people arguing with her). Quite what left-wing opposition leader Jeremy Corbyn is thinking about this is unclear. He should be thinking that he shot himself in the foot by supporting said snap election, but who knows?
Stateside, the biggest issue with Trump's replacement (per Kaitlyn) is that it simultaneously gives insurers the ability to raise premiums based on pre-existing conditions, and removes the prohibition against counting domestic violence as a pre-existing condition. So yeah, if you go into hospital after your boyfriend breaks your arm, your insurance company can ask you to prove that he wasn't already beating you before you took out your policy. For the people!
There's good news on both stories, too. UKIP - the far-right nationalist party of the UK - were absolutely hammered in the local elections, and the Trump presidency originally thought getting his bill through Congress would be easy compared to getting the Senate to accept it. Given that it only narrowly passed Congress after weeks of wrangling means there's still a long fight against it ahead.
But in general: I do not like it, Sam I Am.
Not News
^_^
hS -
Well, the trailer for The Last Jedi is out by
on 2017-05-08 06:35:00 UTC
Link to this
Although I suppose that's old news now, I think it came out a couple of weeks ago? Honestly, I can't really think of much stuff that's been happening this week.
Also, France didn't elect Voldemort as their president (thanks, Tumblr) putting them one-up on the rest of the world.
(also, hello!! I am back.) -
Based on the trailer, what do you think the movie's like? (nm) by
on 2017-05-09 00:44:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Hmm, well, by
on 2017-05-09 01:40:00 UTC
Link to this
I wouldn't say I'm the biggest Star Wars fan ever (I just enjoy the movies a lot tbh) but I did see that if you sync up this trailer and the one for The Force Awakens a lot of the shots/angles match up startlingly well, almost frame-for-frame. Apart from that, I couldn't really tell you what I thought.
I'm excited, sure, and also that one really cool planet with the red dust was epic, but like. i don't know -
Oh! That trailer. ^_^ by
on 2017-05-09 14:07:00 UTC
Link to this
Things I flagged up, in no particular order:
-It looks like we get a proper Jedi training sequence, a la Dagobah. That's cool!
-This:
Seems to be Luke's Jedi Academy burning down; it definitely comes over the same way as the flashback in Force Awakens. All those domes and spikes look kind of like church domes - think the Vatican and St. Peter's. But I can see how it draws on the old Jedi Temple.
-TherebelsResistance seem to love ships with bits dangling off them. Both the dust-skimmers and the capital ships in the space battle have big long dangly things.
-Is this the first printed book in the Star Wars films?
It's certainly a rarity. I like the Internet theory that this is the Journal of the Whills, as referenced by Rogue One, and harking back to the original title of the first film.
-That one shot with the beam of light, right before the book... is that wood? Looks like a tangle of dead roots or something. Definitely not the cave-rocks theme we've had from (what's Luke's planet called again?) Ahch-To so far.
-Look at the circular side-plots in this shot:
Princess Leia is a Time Lord and nothing you say will dissuade me.
hS -
Regarding Leia as a Time Lord. . . by
on 2017-05-13 22:31:00 UTC
Link to this
Have a look at Luke's burning Jedi Academy, and tell me it might not run in the family.
--Aegis, encouraging wonderfully ridiculous fanfiction. -
I am 100% behind Leia as a Time Lord by
on 2017-05-09 14:45:00 UTC
Link to this
She'd be the most competent Lady President since Romana's rule.
-
You take that plot-Nuzgul back! by
on 2017-05-09 14:58:00 UTC
Link to this
Wait, are they Nuzgul if they're not in LotR? Plot-Rovie, perhaps? Or plot-Pittin?
hS -
Possible Red Dead Redemption 2... by
on 2017-05-06 04:04:00 UTC
Link to this
live trailer in the works.
link -
*Grumble* Not coming out on PC *Grumble* by
on 2017-05-06 08:33:00 UTC
Link to this
Come on Rockstar. It can't be that hard! Heck, I'll play with Microsoft's little Xbox on PC thing, just let me play the darn game, man.
And then if you would port Red Dead 1 while we're at it, that would be amazing. -
Reaction to the fandom news by
on 2017-05-05 23:11:00 UTC
Link to this
Oh, man! That's pretty cool! It's a shame that the movie based on The Eyes of the Dragon was never finished, as I really loved that book, and I'm with you in the boat of "can't read any actual horror by Stephen King." >u<
Have you read his memoir/writing advice combo? It's pretty good, and it explains a lot about why he writes such messed-up stuff.
(Fun fact: One time, my friend shipped me with the Eyes of the Dragon version of Randall Flagg, and it escalated to the point of him having been my LO for a while. Those were interesting times.)
-Twistey
P.S. Nobody's mentioned that it's Cinco de Mayo... (quietly goes back to reading Things I'm Not Allowed to Do at the PPC) -
If we're talking personal stuff... by
on 2017-05-05 23:00:00 UTC
Link to this
I got an offer for a job near Cincinnati a couple of days a go - they have yet to sign the letter but I have good faith that they will soon enough - and we're currently working out whether to transition out of my current job so I can move there or to hold out until my current company transitions me to full-time. With luck though I should be able to go full-time once again soon enough, though! (Also, Voyd told me the other day that he has found a new job at a Wal-Mart at his town and that's wonderful. :D)
I'm also working on the second of two interludes I have planned, and kinda waiting on the current beta for the first one (and looking for a second beta for both). Unfortunately, though, progress on this interlude has been stupidly slow, thanks to... well, I won't say, but it's a personal project I thought up this past weekend and I'm keeping it under wraps until I sort out the baseline mechanics for it. But once it's ready for presentation I'll put it up on the Board for your evaluation along with both of the interludes! 'Twas about time I got something posted for the PPC after being out of touch with writing my agents for like what, six months? ^^; -
DAMMIT! And right as I'm about to leave! by
on 2017-05-06 01:49:00 UTC
Link to this
We'll literally have JUST missed each other. Literally, how!?
-
Yeah, I'm not exactly known for my timing. ^^; by
on 2017-05-06 04:11:00 UTC
Link to this
Not that it really matters, either... My family wouldn't want me going out to visit people I only know thanks to online communication, because they're super tight and all that. We're not known for being gregarious, which is sad and awful because there are a number of friends I've made here whom I've longed to meet in person for a while now... just my luck that my responsibilities and my parents are working together to prevent that, and not necessarily unintentionally, either. :C
-
Eh, I've just been spamming playtime of Persona 5 lately. by
on 2017-05-05 18:37:00 UTC
Link to this
God, that's a good game. And when I'm not doing that, I'm running around the open world of Horizon: Zero Dawn, which is also a really good game. So yeah, it's a great week for gaming.
I also found out I'm gonna be moving out of Cincinnati next Friday. I'm... not looking forward to it, because it means I'll be down in Florida, with my folks. And that's not gonna be great for me, because that means I'm going to have to deal with my parents. And God, is that thought scary, particularly in light of the recent AHCA vote. They're gonna rub that shit in my face, I just know it...
Also, something else happened to some friends recently, and all that I can really think about with what's happened with this friend is "gee, where was [i]that[/i] a couple years back?" I guess life is weird like that. -
Amen to that. by
on 2017-05-06 14:24:00 UTC
Link to this
I'm about to go for the fourth boss of Persona 5's storyline today. That's so good when a good game holds of its promises and even more. Also yay for another Persona fan here.
On other news... Second turn for presidential elections here in France that Sunday. And after that, the legislatives' circus. Boy are we on a ride here. -
Yeah! by
on 2017-05-06 14:48:00 UTC
Link to this
I'm not a super hardcore fan of Persona, though: I actually haven't played Persona 4, and I only got about a third of the way through Persona 3. But it's always been an interesting series of games nevertheless. But yeah, Persona 5 is awesome.
I just hit the fifth change of heart myself. And I can't wait to go on from there, either... -
I... watched a stream when the Japanese version was released by
on 2017-05-06 14:55:00 UTC
Link to this
Let's just say the remaining part of the game still raises the bar for future games. Can't wait to reach it myself.
Especially fifth's boss. From the stream I saw, in Hard mode he's everything an Atlus boss should be: challenging, pushing you and the gameplay to the limits, and so satisfying to take down. -
I actually didn't like the fifth dungeon as much. by
on 2017-05-06 15:09:00 UTC
Link to this
The design was really cool, sure, and I had a good laugh at the party's reaction to the fact that the "Break" option on one of the puzzles lasts about five seconds, but it was hard to find places to ambush enemies from, and that got annoying fast. The airlock puzzles in the latter half of the dungeon didn't help, although those were kinda satisfying when I finally solved them.
Still, the plot twist around it is really awesome, so... Yeah, fun times! -
Yeah I saw that. by
on 2017-05-06 16:17:00 UTC
Link to this
The fact you're hitting the first regular mobs who flat out repel physic attacks and skills don't help either.
And just wait for the next plot twists, they're even better. (Out of curiosity, are you playing with the Japanese or English audio? And what difficulty?) -
I'm playing on Normal with the English audio. by
on 2017-05-06 16:30:00 UTC
Link to this
I didn't even know the Japanese audio was an option, actually. I'm gonna have to hold off on downloading it, though: my PS4 is a bit pressed for memory at the moment, and I don't want to push it too far over the edge...
And eh, the regular mobs that repel physical attacks actually don't bother me much. Whenever I encounter a new enemy, I generally start by lobbing as many of the different elements of magic at it as I can, until I find the weakness. Which led to interesting results back when I didn't have any Psi skills, but hey, I did my best! -
Japanese Hard mode for me. by
on 2017-05-06 22:21:00 UTC
Link to this
I really recommend to download the audio if you can, it's more than worth it.
The real pain with Psi is the fact youu're the only able to use it for quite a while, so it can drain your SP pretty hard, and in Hard mode you just need all SPs you've got. Still, that's one of the better ways to deal with them. (The only more efficient one I can think about is checking the fusions for weaknesses. Not necessarily nice, but it helped for me.) -
So I've been reading these books by Ken Follett. by
on 2017-05-05 15:48:00 UTC
Link to this
The Century Trilogy. The first one covers World War I, the second one is World War II, and the third one is the Cold War. I'm on book 2.
They're really good books. The facts are well researched and characters are all very relatable, human people, even the ones you might not agree with.
That's kinda what make it scary, reading about these events at this time. I can't help but think there are some similarities to the way things are spiraling out of control now, with some of the same issues of economics, racial and religious prejudice, nationalism, and an unhinged leader who pushed his way to power by preying on the insecurities of his voters. ... I'm trying really hard to avoid running afoul of Godwin's Law here, but I don't think I can. I'm... I'm just gonna stop. Point is, it's scary. I wonder if it's ever possible to see an international crisis coming long enough ahead of time to stop it.
There are some bright spots. We got a bipartisan budget passed, with some good stuff for education, heath, and the environment, and nothing for a border wall. I think we can be happy about this.
~Neshomeh -
Re: Dark Tower by
on 2017-05-05 13:59:00 UTC
Link to this
I'm actually a bit less excited about the movie, now that I've seen the trailer. I know the series had issues towards the end, but I did think the early novels were going to see fairly straightforward adaptations. There are a lot of scenes here that don't seem to have any real analogue in the first novel. (The end sequence seems to be Roland and Jake battling the slow mutants, but that should be happening in an abandoned mine tunnel, not above ground.) But beyond adaptational nitpicking, a lot of scenes just seem so shallowly Hollywood. I especially hate Roland somehow reloading his gun by throwing them in the air, and catching them in the chambers without them moving apart from each other. What? And a lot of the gun fight choreography seems terribly ostentatious . . .
As a fan of King's works in a broader sense, I do hope the house where Jake finds the portal is the same one used to film the house on Niebolt Street in the upcoming It movie, since the two are supposed to be "twins." It will also be interesting to see if future adaptations of King's works where the man in Black appears will re-use the same actor to portray him.
—doctorlit darkles and tincts -
Re: the bullets. by
on 2017-05-05 14:31:00 UTC
Link to this
They have a dark band of some kind holding them together. Could be a metal 6-holed circle? The gun drops out of shot as they hit it, so there's no way of seeing how it comes off, but this seems within the laws of physics. You'd have to throw it very precisely - the holes can't be very tight, or else it wouldn't come off when you load! - but this is Roland we're talking about. He's a Gunslinger. They kind of train for that.
The fact that the filmmakers actually thought of this says good things to me.
hS -
Bah. Couldn't make that out. by
on 2017-05-06 04:45:00 UTC
Link to this
I still think doing it in midair is a little much silly, even for a gunslinger.
—doctorlit knows pretty much nothing at all about guns -
That's called a quick loader, I believe by
on 2017-05-05 14:42:00 UTC
Link to this
You load it ahead of time and it allows you to put bullets in a revolver more quickly. And he has a lot of them, by the look of his belt. It is possible that the bullets are even locked in to the ring and able to be fired from it, so the casings come out still attached.
-Phobos, maybe knows a thing or two about guns? -
Speedloader. So close. (nm) by
on 2017-05-05 14:49:00 UTC
Link to this
-
But this isn't an adaptation of the series. by
on 2017-05-05 14:23:00 UTC
Link to this
Stephen King on Twitter, last year.
(Should I put a spoiler block in here? I feel like I should, and that I should do it with Dark Tower-specific text, but I can't think of any at the moment. "See the TURTLE of enormous girth/On his shell he carries the whole earth", or however that went? I dunno, but the Guardians were pretty cool. Almost as cool as Maerlyn's Rainbow; in fact I really liked the whole idea that the safety of the universes relied on a bunch of stuff that actually wasn't very nice. Oh, hey, that should about do it.)
This isn't an adaptation of The Gunslinger. It's something far more exciting - a continuation of the story after book 7. It starts in the same place - "The man in black fled across the desert, and the gunslinger followed" - but it's under no obligation to hit the same story beats.
Will the Ka-Tet all make their appearances? I certainly hope so, and there's a certain element of fate involved there, so it seems likely (Oyoy?). But they won't go to the same places, they won't meet the same people, they may not even start out identical to how we know them, nor end the same way (in both meanings of the phrase).
I agree that it would be great to see a direct adaptation of the series (maaaaybe with fewer lobstrosities, though). But that's not what this is, and the fact that it's titled only "The Dark Tower" is a huge indication that it's not going to be anything like what we know. And I find that exciting.
(Also it lets them step neatly around the usual adaptation complaints of "why was Roland's coat blue in this scene instead of turquoise?!?!?!" - and it lets them have actual suspense, since we don't know what's going to happen.)
As to your Hollywood comments - maybe; I don't know. I'm notoriously bad at recognising film quality. This is a first trailer, though, and they've deliberately chosen stuff that looks Action Movie-y. I have no doubt that they could equally have made a Horror trailer, a Fantasy one, and a Quiet Talky Movie one - and I'm guessing we'll see at least one of these before the film comes out.
hS, in memory of Gilead -
Agh, I had read that. (NSFW post, possible spoilers) by
on 2017-05-06 04:43:00 UTC
Link to this
I had forgotten about that detail. Still, though, I did think we were getting a fairly close adaptation of the earlier books, other than something I'll bring up in a bit to keep it of preview.
The face-shrouded figures in the trailer are likely can-toi, replacing the slow mutants for a species(?) that actually appears again later in the series. They're not wearing their famous yellow coats, but I seem to recall that was implied to be their disguise when visiting Earth; they may dress more conservatively in Mid-World. (Low men were first mentioned in the novella Hearts in Atlantis, but I haven't seen the movie adaptation to compare facial make-up and in fact don't even know if they appear on screen.)
Okay, so here's the NSFW paragraph. The one scene that's basically guaranteed to be cut is when Roland comes upon Jake being molested by the lust demon, then exchanges sex with her/it for information. I totally understand they won't want the underage actor in a scene like that, but at the same time, Roland kind of needs to encounter her/it at some point. Maybe Jake will be absent from the scene, or maybe they're cutting Mordred out entirely? I wouldn't mind the Man in Black remaining the primary antagonist until the end; maybe the whole Mordred subplot was one of the mistaken paths Roland took that prevented his success in the cycle we read in the novels?
I rather hope we get the flashback sequence of Wizard and Glass. I found that whole novel quite serviceable as a standalone story. I also hope the Crimson King is . . . not a garbage character? I think that's a nice way to put that. The scene of Stephen King's prevented death could also use a delicate touch, especially in regards to the man who hit him in real life, who has passed away since.
I do think, and suspect, the whole original ka-tet will return; as you said, there's fate there. Callahan better show up as well, I don't want him getting cut.
Dad-a-chad? Dum-a-dum? Don't you dare tell me you don't like the lobstrosities! The lobstrosities are the absolute best thing ever. There was a time period in high school when I went around campus saying, "Did-a-chick? Dum-a-chum?" all over.
—doctorlit dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dum-a-chum dad-a-chad -
Election by
on 2017-05-05 13:00:00 UTC
Link to this
I haven't been really following the election but I just hope it turns out alright.
-
Made a suggestion on the "For Other People" FAQ by
on 2017-05-06 15:22:00 UTC
Link to this
http://ppc.wikia.com/wiki/Talk:FAQ:_For_Other_People#New_sections.2C_possibly.3F
This suggests two more sections, the first being "I don't need writing help!" and the second being about criticizing the work being supposedly oppressive because the author is female or LGBTQ+, instead of other sections where it's about the character.
Let me know what you guys think of these ideas!
-Twistey -
And more here too by
on 2017-05-06 17:03:00 UTC
Link to this
http://ppc.wikia.com/wiki/Talk:Recruit#New_content_needed.3F
This asks for a few guidelines on what kinds of Sues to recruit versus assassinate.
-Twistey -
Question for all: What's your favorite recruitment story? by
on 2017-05-11 22:55:00 UTC
Link to this
Because I've begun adding some examples of recruitment to the Recruit page, and a wide variety of examples is always good. Mostly what I've added are the stories of people from World One, with the exceptions of Ranger, Surhat Roac, and Roger Walters.
The last two might be my favorite recruitment stories, because they showcase a pair of original characters finding their way to the PPC from original universes in unique ways. The stories do a great job of introducing the characters and the worlds they come from, which makes them even better. At the very least, they stuck with me enough that I thought to look them up six years later.
What are your favorites? What do you like about them, and what makes them stand out from the crowd? (Please don't nominate your own writing, that's cheating.)
~Neshomeh -
Re: Question for all: What's your favorite recruitment story? by
on 2017-05-15 16:10:00 UTC
Link to this
There is a dwarf, her appearance is so vague that her beard appears and disappears. She ended up in medical or ficpsych, reading a manual. Before that, she was confused about the Sue that was or wasn't her friend.
I think I can recall another story where the Sue heard the agents snickering in the bushes. Maybe she wasn't recruited.
I like Derik and the realtiy room. -
I'm probably gonna sound biased... by
on 2017-05-12 08:47:00 UTC
Link to this
But this really is one of the recruitment stories I've seen that are not immediately followed by a mission, which is a thing I enjoy. I much prefer them being interludes than a pre-mission thing.
Hence why, I'm suggesting Iximaz's "Tooth and Claw" -
I liked Agent Ithalond's. by
on 2017-05-11 23:54:00 UTC
Link to this
I mean, come on, it's hS' stuff and he's one of my favorites. And, well, it's hard for anything C*l*b**an to not stand out.
Derik's was quite heart-wrenching, and the mission itself wasn't exactly anything to sneeze at, either. What can I say, I'm a sucker for characters getting everything they love ripped away from them.
Dann's can be summed up in two words: Fangirl. Stampede. That is all. :)
...I should really go and give all of those a reread, it's been far too long. -
The first rule of recruiting Sues: by
on 2017-05-07 02:39:00 UTC
Link to this
Don't.*
While there are always exceptions, and whether or not to recruit borderline Sues may be a bit of a toss-up, full-blown Sues bad enough to warrant sending assassins after them in the first place are, by definition, not salvageable.
At least, that's the conceit in-universe. Out of universe, this correlates to the notion that we shouldn't be going after fics that are only kinda mediocre but could be fixed with some better SPaG and a few tweaks; we should only be going after fics that are awful, with poor SPaG, OOC canons, irritating OCs, and nonsensical plots. Fics where the best way to fix them is to burn them and start over from scratch.
As for borderline Sues, there aren't any hard rules. It's basically just a question of whether you can get a good bit of story out of it and feel like taking on another character.
~Neshomeh
* This is not an actual rule, I'm using an ironic subversion of expectations to be funny, please don't take me too seriously. -
Okay then, thanks. by
on 2017-05-07 23:20:00 UTC
Link to this
(If you want to, it'd be good to put it on the Wiki in case anyone comes and asks the same question.)
You're kind of confusing me... The way you worded your message seems to say that recruiting shouldn't happen period, but we both know that's not true. Do we just take the background characters? Or, wait. Maybe if it's not a Suefic but still bad enough to get someone involved (like if there's an OC stuck in the middle of an Implausible Crossover a Bad Slash, or just a fic with a really messed-up plot?) I guess that works? Would that make sense?
Or maybe if you feel as if you can do some taming of the Sue (haha, get it) and make it sufficient enough to have it work? I'm guessing that last one may tie into SkarmorySilver's motives for writing EVL into the PPC, but he can jump into the conversation if he wants and clarify that. That'd be cool.
So, am I picking up the right nuances here? Thanks for the info, and I hope to hear a reply soon!
-Twistey
(P.S. About the "Don't", it's fine. It's like "Fight Club", which I know nothing about except that its first rule is "don't talk about fight club." :P) -
The second rule for recruiting characters: by
on 2017-05-08 09:04:00 UTC
Link to this
Have a plan for them.
To the best of my recollection, I've recruited a total of two characters from actual missions: Ithalond from Celebrian, and fake!Arwen/Hypatia from Empire State of Mind. Ithalond I rescued because Tungsten_Monk asked me to; she used him as an agent in three missions. Hypatia I picked up because she makes the perfect comedic foil for Agent Kaitlyn - she looks just like her lust object, has a name that indicates they'd get on well, but is a complete scatterbrain in actuality.
There used to be a tendency (I don't know if it's still around) for people to scour every mission for a character to recruit. "Congratulations," they would say, "You Are In The PPC, Here Is A Daisy." And then that... was it. They didn't want the characters - they just wanted to be able to say they'd recruited them. That's exactly as formulaic as "every mission ends with killing something (even though we're in Floaters/Bad Slash)", or "my agent uses their powersword to kill every Suvian".
I've said recently that I have a hundred named, characterised PPC characters, but the second half of that is that each and every one of them serves a purpose. Some of those purposes are very small - Davea and Aphela exist to be Tanfin's wife and her niece, respectively, and appear in a single story - but they do have a purpose. Creating or recruiting new characters just to be able to say you have is bad writing.
hS -
Totally agree with that! Good advice! by
on 2017-05-08 22:58:00 UTC
Link to this
And it makes it even worse when they look cool and you don't go into detail with them, because it just makes your readers rage quit so hard. Some of the fan favorites in My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic are secondary characters, because they're given great personalities (Lyra wants to be a human, there's a constant "war of the music genres" between Octavia and Vinyl Scratch, and Derpy is, well, derpy.)
On Scratch, I have an adoption project where I put up any OC/RP character that I've stopped using or didn't use very much in the first place. I always ask the other users what they're going to use the character for before I let them have the character, just because I don't want the OC to go unused again by a different person. It's a good idea, really, and I think that's one of the things I'm going to keep coming back to Scratch for once I've officially left. That and checkin' up on the friends I've made.
-Twistey -
And what about canon characters? by
on 2017-05-09 00:55:00 UTC
Link to this
What are some rules for recruiting canons? I've got someone in mind who would be of good use to you. Based on evidence from her story, she's only got a specific skill set when it would come to your operations, but I imagine that she's probably pretty good at remembering the details about stuff she's read. Also, she's from a historical fiction, and a lot of stuff from the general time period in which she "lived" is used in several pieces of badfic, and even original fic by authors who think their Villain OC Donut Steel is TEH EVULZ enough to pull that kind of stunt. (Much to my chagrin!)
For those of you who read the book, you can probably guess who I'm talking about by now. If you know you have the right answer, you are officially cool.
-Twistey -
Canon characters are a no-no. by
on 2017-05-09 01:57:00 UTC
Link to this
If a canon has been determined to be a replacement, though, then see what everyone else has said so far about recruiting Sues.
-
Generally speaking, at least by
on 2017-05-09 11:45:00 UTC
Link to this
There are some examples of recruited canon characters (Agent Suicide being probably the most prominent), but yeah, in general, you would have to do an amazing job in writing them to make it work. So in general, better not.
Elcalion -
Technically, not Su. by
on 2017-05-09 14:18:00 UTC
Link to this
He springs from a typo in a published book that made him plural for a moment, so the Suicide we know is basically a clone of the canon character. Suicide Prime has never left his home universe. That is a hair-thin technicality, though. You probably couldn't get away with something like that today.
There are other, explicit exceptions (see: Team Phoenix), but it's one of those things that was found to be a bad idea after the fact, so yeah, definitely don't do it. Just because a thing has been done before doesn't necessarily mean it was a good idea.
~Neshomeh -
Are there any besides Team Phoenix? by
on 2017-05-09 14:43:00 UTC
Link to this
[Checks] It looks like Tawaki had quite the collection of dead-and-resurrected canons (Behnashiren, Jara Hamee, Lusa...), but I don't actually recognise their names. My guess, going on how Tawaki wrote missions, is that they each had a single mention - "Oh, my new partner is Behnashiren, king of D'ni, we resurrected him".
Then there's Alec and the rest of Team Phoenix, who do seem to now be described as copies. And we have Spud Avec's Maxie Dasai, who is apparently pilfered from a Web Original series? Other than that, it looks to be explicitly replacements and clones of various descriptions...
hS -
Oh wow, Spud. That brings back memories. (nm) by
on 2017-05-10 19:15:00 UTC
Link to this
-
But... wait... by
on 2017-05-09 22:36:00 UTC
Link to this
(Sort of a reply to everyone at once. Wow, huge bunch of replies I got.)
Isn't being able to write a character well part of writing fanfic that involves canons in general? I mean, there's even a bit of a stigma against fanfic that has an entirely OC cast or that focuses on OCs instead of canons, so you could say that if on knows the canons well enough to write them in a regular fanfic, then recruiting them might not be such a problem. Although I do kind of get that there is a sort of an in-universe reason for it (leaving canons where they belong, interfering as little as possible.) I see from the links that all the canons mentioned are either dead or clones.
...Hmm. Wait. Are these messages specifically for me as a newbie, or for anyone in general? Because I'm pretty sure that although I'm technically a PPCer, I won't be writing any officially PPC missions (again with my parents), and any characters I create/recruit will immediately be deemed adoptable or free-to-use. That (hypothetically only) includes the canon that I suggested earlier, or supposedly a clone thereof. Therefore, the writing of these characters, apart from initial bios, would not rest on me, but more experienced writers could give it a try.
My common sense is telling me that I should probably do some sort of OC instead, but if I did not at least somewhat consider the original thought, I would 1) have nothing to say in this post, 2) therefore be letting no one know that I read the posts and 3) miss the chance to go look for people who could be up to the challenge.
Other than the stuff in Elcalion's post and a bunch of "no, just no" (which I am not the biggest fan of, as I believe that concrit/discouragement/encouragement should have reasons why), nobody's given me any other reasons not to do this before y'all started jumping into the discussion about examples of canons used. Sidetracked, have we? :P So I would like to hear more about it. Explain further, please. I will listen, despite how I probably sound right now.
-Twistey -
I think we're talking to anyone who's listening. by
on 2017-05-10 15:52:00 UTC
Link to this
I like talking about this stuff.
Especially when I get to talk about my own characters.
I think your other questions have been covered, though. Elcalion said what I was going to about why recruiting canons is frowned upon, and you'd already gotten that idea yourself anyway, so that's all good. {= )
I will say attempting to adopt out characters you create to other writers is probably doomed to fail, though. I think we all tend to like our own creations best, and the chances of you happening to create a character someone else happens to be looking for at that time are pretty slim. If you make PPC characters, keep them. Even if you don't write missions, you can still use them in RPs and other games.
~Neshomeh -
Good advice there. by
on 2017-05-10 23:08:00 UTC
Link to this
Yep, that'd probably be the best idea.
Although it might be a problem if they're Assassins/Bad Slashers/any of the action departments... I'd have to write missions, I think. Right? Well, I am going to do some mission-esque things on Wattpad, though; pretty much the same except they're requested so I can say "well, you asked for my opinion." That wouldn't be officially PPC, though, and I've already got two characters (my hired mercenaries, Verse and Versailles) for those mission-esque things. So if the characters are officially agents, what would I do?
And now that I think about it, going back over The Book Thief's plot line, Liesel wouldn't exactly be the best for literature. Sure, she'd be a pretty sharp knife for fics with *ahem, stuff from her time period* stuck in them randomly, but she didn't seem to ever have any traits for the analysis of literature or characters; reading was more just for keeping her sane. And especially because of that, we wouldn't want her dealing with fanfic that can drive someone insane. I could do something similar to Liesel, though, due to the good traits I mentioned earlier.
Well, I'm finding it hard to think now, since I'm listening to Kraftwerk and it's hard to think when you've got synthesizers beeping at you repeatedly, am I right? As such, this is all I can think of to say. Thanks for clearing this up.
-Twistey -
Re: But... wait... by
on 2017-05-10 06:17:00 UTC
Link to this
I think character replacements can be recruited, but only should be considered in certain situations. Such as: They aren't just a Sue masquerading. They really aren't the canon. They are interesting. You have a plan for them.
I have one. I think he is the only agent that I've posted stories with that was a fic recruit. Agent Kelok was supposed to be Todd the Wraith in the fic he is from. The author got absolutely everything about Todd wrong from basic biology to personality to speech patterns. The best I could figure the author wrote an original story and then tried to wrap a canon, any canon would do apparently, around it to get readers. I recruited him, because he was clearly not the character he was named and he was interesting as himself. The way he was described in the fic, he doesn't even look or sound all that much like the canon character. He only existed to give the Sue what she wanted, and wasn't a Stu himself. The real canon had been shoved into a plot hole.
I never tried writing him as Todd the Wraith. He just wasn't Todd and never had been. Any memories he has that should belong to Todd are hazy at best, like remembering something someone told you about that you then imagined yourself doing. He had a basic personality from the fic (one that was diametrically opposed to the canon's), but not much actual experience. Most of his real memories are as a PPC agent. -
Gonna throw this at the wall for advice. by
on 2017-05-10 23:27:00 UTC
Link to this
(Wow, I've been thinking way too far ahead to somewhere past the end of the animated series I mentioned in the Permission talk page and my introductory thread.)
Would it be acceptable if a character replacement got caught in the debris of a Sue's assassination and suffered burns and memory loss, then was taken in by someone and made to believe he was a different person by that someone telling him about this other person he supposedly was, and then he somehow found his way into the PPC and became an agent? Maybe the PPC put him in DOGA or something so that he wouldn't ever run into anyone who knew about his past? Hmm. (Crud, does this description make me sound like a Suethor? I think I screwed up the wording or something and made it sound like that.)
Anyway, now that I think about it, I'd have to tweak that backstory around a bit more, since it wouldn't make sense for one of the two villains (and I mean a seriously Stu replacement) to take on that other life. He would just get killed, because the agent in the story would be after him as well as another Sue in his fic. How's that up there sound, either way?
-Twistey -
Re: Gonna throw this at the wall for advice. by
on 2017-05-11 19:52:00 UTC
Link to this
I don't think we're talking about the same thing. If I have parsed what you said correctly, you have a character who is the canon that has been injured and then lied to about his identity. His entire personality is based on lies that have been imposed on him by those that recruited him.
If that is what you were saying then it isn't what I was trying to say. The main distinction I am trying to make with Kelok is the Suethor did the altering, not the agents who recruited him. He's also fully aware of where he came from.
He wasn't a Stu as written in his story. I'd always recommend killing a Sue/Stu or exorcising/deglittering/memory wiping a canon that hasn't been replaced. His was a pretty specific situation with a canon replacement who isn't a Sue/Stu.
Agents aren't meant to the coolest or most super powered either (which the main characters often are in their own canons). I think it actually makes it more difficult to write good, interesting PPC missions with a highly powered agent than one who has to scrape by on ingenuity.
One final comment. If the agent is meant to be the actual canon, then it really limits what you can do with them. You have to constantly think about keeping them in-character with the canon material. There isn't much room for growth and change while respecting that. With a character who is your own (however they came to the PPC or your general fiction) you get to direct their development and decide what is in-character for them. It is relaxing in a lot of ways to be fully in charge of that as an author. -
We aren't, this was just an idea. by
on 2017-05-11 22:05:00 UTC
Link to this
(Since I wanted to see if this would pass muster as a character. Although there are a few points:)
1-2. Actually, the character I came up with wasn't a canon originally, but rather a character replacement. Altered by the Suethor (if that's how they come to be) and then convinced of a different backstory by a different person (probably outside of the PPC, as this'd have to be someone who isn't out to kill him.)
3. Yep. In this story, the agents (whoever they are) intended to kill him, but when he had the incident that gave him the burns and the memory loss, they probably either got distracted or thought he'd died/thought he was going to die soon and left him for dead.
4. Definitely. I seriously can't consciously write a Mary Sue without it being a joke. This idea was mainly to generate some interesting plots due to administration having to keep him from finding out his identity and also due to the actual canon also probably being out to kill him.
5. That is a good point. I think I've decided against the idea for using a canon as an agent (as I clarified, this idea was separate from the canon question, and the canon I thought of using had pretty much nothing to do with it.) But still a good idea.
-Twistey -
My view by
on 2017-05-10 00:34:00 UTC
Link to this
Whether the canon is a clone or not, recruiting a canon is generally frowned upon. I think the main reason is a sense that if our mission is to defend canon, twisting it by forcibly recruiting characters for the PPC is a bit hypocritical; even ignoring that the burden of characterisation for writing a canon character has the bar set very high.
As with all 'rules' of writing, yes there are exceptions. But I would not recommend recruiting a canon. If you do so, it has to be done exceptionally well, and that makes it a more difficult option.
Suicide worked because Tungsten Monk was an excellent writer, but could have easily have become a travesty.
I think the same warning also applies to recruiting Sue'd /alternate / character replacement versions of canon, albeit to a lesser extent. There's still that high standard of writing required. While it does unlock some opportunities for great writing when you have the opportunity to explore the conflict between the canon's natural personality and the Suvian influences, it can get out of hand. A great example is Agent Dafydd: well-written, and him being an alternate version of Maglor led to some great conflict when the Fëanorian side was aided and abetted by Suvian jewellery, but I can't imagine Dafydd being an easy character to write well!
TLDR version: yes, while it's been done in the past, as Nesh has said, it's a fairly shaky precedent. Definitely not something we'd recommend as your first agent. The bar will be set very high.
Elcalion -
Yeah, that does make sense. by
on 2017-05-10 23:38:00 UTC
Link to this
Although if the character replacement is OOC, but not Sued, and one recruits them, it looks like they practically turn into original characters - at least, that's what a lot of recruited replacements seem to be. Wouldn't that kind of situation make it less standard-y, maybe just a bit more than an original agent would be?
-Twistey -
Pretty much, yeah. by
on 2017-05-11 23:30:00 UTC
Link to this
That is pretty much what happens to recruited character replacements. As replacements, they explicitly are not the canon character they've replaced, just someone who might kinda sorta maybe look like them and share a couple things in common.
But if I understand you right, no, I don't think that makes them more unique or "non-standard" than a completely original character. Even characters you made up yourself are going to draw on inspiration from somewhere—more likely multiple somewheres.
Nume, for instance, largely draws on Dr. House, another cantankerous but very intelligent misanthrope with a substance dependency and, maybe, a heart of gold. He's also a little bit based on my dad and a big bit on your archetypal `70s nerd, with a weird memory and some weird hangups about sexuality for spice.
Derik, while looking like the Phantom of the Opera, sharing a passion for music, and being a little bit off his rocker, is mostly an ex-dragonrider with all the selfless devotion to duty and protecting others that entails. He's a product of his badfic, but he's even more a product of my love for both canons, and dragons, and music, and seriousface hero types wrestling with their dark side.
Make sense?
~Neshomeh -
I have a habit of numbering my responses by
on 2017-05-12 22:27:00 UTC
Link to this
- Hang on, I was mainly thinking of Derik when I wrote that, but he's less of a character replacement and more of a "side character drawing from something else that doesn't belong here", right? Yep, you are right, considering that the Suethor tweaks the character into someone new.
2. Yep... However, with OCs, you get a lot more freedom than you do with portraying canons, right? So since character replacements would be somewhere in the middle... do you see my logic?
3. I'm going to go look him up on the Wiki. He sounds interesting.
4. Already looked this one up on the Wiki, also interesting. Haha, the "seriousface hero types" thing. Great.
-Twistey
- Hang on, I was mainly thinking of Derik when I wrote that, but he's less of a character replacement and more of a "side character drawing from something else that doesn't belong here", right? Yep, you are right, considering that the Suethor tweaks the character into someone new.
-
Here's the thing: by
on 2017-05-09 23:13:00 UTC
Link to this
What makes a good fanfic is not equal to what makes a good PPC mission. Writing a canon character well in a mission generally entails them remaining in the canon and writing their reactions to the Sues or other bad influences in the badfic, whether they are overcome or try to resist the Sue-influence. Bringing canons into the PPC would go against what they stand for- leaving canon intact.
You write that any characters your create or recruit will immediately become adoptable or free-to-use, so more experienced writers could attempt it. But how do you know that a more experienced writer will want to? hS wrote above that the second rule of recruiting characters is to have a plan for them- that means you would be writing them.
Besides, creating good OCs is also a difficult skill, like writing canons, but it's much closer to what the PPC is focused on.
-A. Lurker -
Points by
on 2017-05-10 23:53:00 UTC
Link to this
- Yep, that has already been said, and I do understand now.
2. Let me explain my situation yet again. I told my parents about you guys. My parents don't like you. My parents don't like the idea of correcting someone's fanfic without being asked to do so. My dad also has a thing about the fact that you call yourselves the "protectors" of anything (he believes it suggests megalomania or other forms of brain damage, see also legitimate IRL cults.) I stay on the Board because it's somewhat lesser-known. Putting things down on Wattpad or on my Google account would probably make it easier for my parents to know that I'm associating with you against their will. I'm trying to be safe here. That's the main reason why I want to do the free to use thing, because if they're mine and they're PPC, I'm likely to be dead meat. It does sort of take away some of the experience, I know, but it's for the better, and I'll probably put up regular fanfic for you to review so that I'll still learn the writing lessons I need.
-Twistey
- Yep, that has already been said, and I do understand now.
-
Me too. by
on 2017-05-08 18:04:00 UTC
Link to this
Ilraen, Derik, and Gall are all recruits I picked up because I really wanted to write them.
Ilraen is an Andalite, which is cool to start with, and I needed someone Nume could be convinced to work with after his original partner, Cameo, turned out to be an awful person I didn't want to write anymore. Then I got to play with the idea of someone who has had to build himself from the ground up, without the benefit of normal childhood formative experiences. Now that he's matured a bit, he's going through some teenage-ish angst about who he really is, and how his human upbringing (if you can call it that) meshes and clashes with his Andalite identity.
Derik was a side-character who existed for more or less the sole purpose of being a visual gag: "LOL, wouldn't it be funny if there was a dragonrider called E'rik who looked like the Phantom of the Opera and had a dragon called 'mask' in Swedish?!?!1" He didn't really do anything, he was just there. I happen to be a PotO fan AND a Pern fan, so I couldn't leave the poor guy like that. I was interested in starting a new spin-off in the DMS to take on the Sues my DIC team couldn't, and Derik was a shoo-in for me.
I originally paired him with Earwig, a kender made up by Phobos, whose shenanigans were intended to be a foil to Derik's drama, but I couldn't write the guy, and Phobos didn't really want to, either. Then Gall came along, and she was just perfect: sassy, no fluff, no nonsense. Ideal for poking Derik in his sore spots and refusing to let him dwell on them at the same time. Since HtTYD is a bit anachronistic, she can also make most of the jokes and references I want to make, too. And she's a girl. I thought I should have at least one girl in my line-up, since I am one myself, and it lets me bring that perspective to Suedo-feminism.
I'll also note that at least one member of FicPsych is on record as hating it when agents dump helpless bit parts on them and then abandon them. {= )
~Neshomeh -
I second this completely. by
on 2017-05-08 17:07:00 UTC
Link to this
I'd also add a slight corollary: "Don't write Agent X because you want an agent of Agent X's cool and/or awesome species/sect/fandom/whatever, write them because you want to write Agent X". It's a principle that served me well from right back when I started - which hS took an active part in moulding.
Wobbles the Clown appeared because I wanted to do a genuine unironic clown, and up she popped; a happy-go-lucky sort whose happiness, luckiness, and (somehow) goness came about because of her previous life as an angstfic refugee who was intended to provide comic relief in the badfic itself but who was instead basically the chew toy of every electrical appliance in a given area. This desperate desire to make people happy (as well as the obligatory FicPsych sessions) made her into the clown we know and love today, but she was in need of a foil.
Then up pops something called the Continuity Council of Gallifrey, masterminded largely by hS and largely concerning the Time Lord agents of various oldbies, veryoldbies, and similarlygeriatricbies. I wanted to take part but, not having quite read the memo, bashed out a few syllables that sounded Gallifreyan and called the woman wearing them The Notary. When hS (via Morgan) pointed out that there were a lot of Time Lord agents who were Time Lords because it was cool, I wanted to refute that, so I began to think more about who the Notary was.
Now, in previous Whovian RPs on a Nintendo fansite that were frankly rubbish, I'd often used an OC Time Lord called the Gardener: righter of wrongs, snogger of aliens, part-time planet builder, and manager of a branch of Little Chef on the A504 just outside Milton Keynes. I liked playing as her, because she was fun to be around, and the original draft of the Notary was going to be much more like her. Then I thought some more about the Notary, and how I didn't want to play into hS's hands and give him a reason to boot me out of the RP... and that's why the Notary is the way she is.
It's detailed here and there in missions and RPs and ficlet responses, but the Fourth Notary was very much akin to my old Gardener OC in terms of temperament, drive, and weird hobbies involving greasy spoon management. However, I decided that that should very much be the past of the Notary, and then I remembered The Twin Dilemma, a Sixth Doctor episode wherein he throttles longtime companion Peri. It was under different circumstances, of course, but then I thought about what that would do to someone if they couldn't take it back, if that lonely old time traveller just let themselves rot in a decaying, unloved TARDIS. Suddenly the Notary's whole life story rolled out in front of me; this tired, defeated woman whose life has just been one indignity after another, until she finally got to be a hero... and then it was taken away, so she thinks. She was everything wrong with Time Lord society, everything that was rotten and corrupt about it... but, as Nirvana Crane once said (of someone else), "Somewhere under that pile of neuroses is someone nice trying to claw their way out".
From there, the dynamic with Wobbles practically wrote itself - Ronald McDonald paired with some ghastly little Napoleon from the local JobCentre has all the trappings of a normal agent pairing. So I decided to amplify those traits, really play up Wobbles' Pollyanna nature and the Notary's superiority complex, as a commentary on how limiting the standard hot-and-cold two person dynamic can be. Then Lola kept poking her head round the door, so I decided to bung her in as an agent, too - and then her story rolled out.
In fact, the only characters whose stories don't tie directly into that of the Oncoming Form are Doktor Trollenfisch und Gabrielle, who I wrote with the specific purpose of being soft and fluffy and having happy endings. Even then, they might not be separate from the rest of my agent stable for too long... though to say more would be spoilers. =] -
Also very good advice. by
on 2017-05-08 23:15:00 UTC
Link to this
The only question I'd have about this is: what if you're trying to challenge yourself to make a character of a cliche/frequently-used/frequently-done-badly species/etc and successfully dodge the tropes? I know I've done that at least once by drawing a legitimately scary neko Creepypasta. Would I be correct in saying that as long as the character is done well and has a purpose as hS says, the fact that I created the character as a challenge of my character creation skills is okay?
-Twistey -
Nothing wrong about that by
on 2017-05-09 07:56:00 UTC
Link to this
Be cool to see, that! 'Specially given how very subversive the PPC, as a whole, is. It's a good thing, that, to have a proper plan for a character beyond 'They should do some stuff' or, lord help, 'They should do some stuff and be real strong and have cool powers and be real cool.' Playing around with tropes is always brilliant. Long as you give 'em more character beyond subversion, of course. Good starting point, subversion.
Also, I disagree with Scape's point.
I think you should watch Red Dwarf if, and only if, you want to see a really good show and you're real smart and cool and nice smelling and you like really good things. -
Yep, good point. by
on 2017-05-09 22:44:00 UTC
Link to this
There's a fun series of role-plays that I've started with my friends, called "Victims of the Plot," in which one friend and I are in a specific continuum and we gradually get hit by more and more fanfic tropes, so we have to escape the continuum or something before we turn into flat-out Mary Sues and lose our common sense. It's a lot of fun.
And for the Red Dwarf thing... I'm pretty sure that unless one is wearing perfume, one cannot tell what one smells like. Also, the "like really good things" part is out for me. I've got several guilty pleasures, oh man. Argh.
-Twistey -
Aw drat. Guess I can't watch then. :( by
on 2017-05-09 09:09:00 UTC
Link to this
No, for real, if you haven't seen any Red Dwarf, fix that situation immediately.
-
That was literally the example I gave. =] by
on 2017-05-09 01:57:00 UTC
Link to this
(also if you want to see the antithesis of every kawaii neko boy, watch Red Dwarf; it has a Cat character who acts like a cat - he's a vain, preening narcissist who is largely concerned with eating, sleeping, and thinking about sex. =] )
But yeah, not only did I want to dodge the tropes of Time Lord OCs with the good old Oncoming Form, I wanted to dodge and discuss the tropes of mission writing and the PPC as an entity. Feel free to do that. Just, y'know, have a story and personality for your bad kitty too. =] -
Didn't come up with a backstory for the horror neko yet... by
on 2017-05-09 23:11:00 UTC
Link to this
...although I do have another half-cat character in a sci-fi story who (at the very least) subverts the appearance tropes of a neko. Meaning that she's got whiskers, has teeth that are actually feline in nature (instead of little fangs and the rest just being human teeth), and is covered in a thin coat of fuzz, which is all the better for cuddling, if you ask me. :3
Heh, maybe I should make her even more cat-like. Make her feet into hind paws, give her somewhat of a feline facial structure (but not too much, this isn't meant to be anthro/furry-esque), etc. She also subverts some neko behavior tropes as well - she is benevolent and friendly, but not necessarily "kawaii" (see the behaviors associated with cuteness in the Springhole.net article below.) She's less like a housecat (as your Red Dwarf guy is, and more like a wild or feral cat with a more human level of intellect. A couple other details of her behavior are that she's carnivorous and hunts for food, and does the standard cat stretch thing when waking up. So yeah, I'm pretty sure I've done it. Yay!
-Twistey
"Notes and Musings on Writing Cute Characters":
http://www.springhole.net/writing/cute-characters.htm -
HURRRRKKKKK I forgot a parenthesis (nm) by
on 2017-05-09 23:12:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Legendary Badfic Suggestions by
on 2017-05-09 06:19:00 UTC
Link to this
First:
My Little Unicorn Series
Tv Tropes page (for those who want to check it out but don't want to expose their eyes to it):
Number of Past Year Google Hits: 5 on the first page
Explanation: So, once upon a time there was this guy who went by Dakari King Mykan. And he watched My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic and decided he hated it. So he decided to write his own alternate universe without all the things he hated, like Equestria (the story instead takes place in Unicornicopia- I'm not joking, that's the name) the canon characters (He focuses on his own OCs, who are all anthro winged unicorns with special attacks), the message of friendship (replaced with a message of believing- what they're supposed to believe in is unclear), and character depth & development of any sort (He thinks it takes away from the action, so all characters shown basically consist of a name and a gimmick). Throw in a complete and total lack of originality and writing skills, and you've pretty much got the idea.
Second:
The Conversion Bureau
Tv Tropes Page:
Number of Past Year Google Hits: All but 4 results on the first two pages
Explanation: This one is a bit iffy, since by now the general idea of the original fic The Conversion Bureau has become its own genre, with highly varying authors and quality (I believe most people would point to Chatoyance's take on TCB as the worst). However, the original fic is quite poorly done and very well-known in the fandom, so here goes:
Equestria has landed on Earth, and humans naturally want to go there, since they're all evil brutes who've been killing each other off via wars, disease, and the other usual suspects. However, to do so you must (presumably permanently) become a pony, via a serum from the eponymous Conversion Bureaus. A serum that causes the drinker to lose that pesky "human nature" of theirs so they can live in harmony with others. Converts must also adapt to Equestrian culture.
Our Hero goes to get ponified at a clinic conveniently staffed by the Mane Six (despite all of them having canon occupations) and instantly befriends them and goes to live with them in Equestria.
Now, the author's intent was that the wish-fulfillment was the central part of the fic, but the misanthropic undertones that he didn't intend (or at least, not quite so blatantly) were latched onto by some of the creepier members of the fandom, who added some extra horror (Equestria is surrounded by a Barrier that is expanding, sometimes because Celestia's deliberately expanding it to force ponification, and there are pro-pony and pro-human terrorist groups), wrote prolifically, and turned what was originally a very poor fic into a MLP-specific genre.
It should be noted that while the original fic is definitely not as bad as some spinoffs (TCB stories exist that take the entire thing up to eleven), that's less 'well, this is good-ish' and more 'I may have fallen off a giant cliff and am now hurtling at terminal velocity towards my doom, but at least I'm not also on fire'. -
Ooh! Two fics I've read! And one I still have claimed. by
on 2017-05-09 08:48:00 UTC
Link to this
I swear guys, I really, truly, honestly will tackle My Little Unicorn. I have been saying it for years now, but it will happen. That abomination of a fic is mine. There has been a slight hiccup, in that the story has been taken down most places. Now, this is not because Mykan has become ashamed of his past work. No, it seems it has been taken down from FanFic.Net, Fimfiction, and DiviantArt, because it was too bad. The story broke several rules, and was taken down by the websites, not by the author. So, in my eyes, still fair game. Besides, this thing has made the rounds of Something Awful quite a bit. It is infamous in the brony fanfic community. At least, it was. Don't know it's status now. Still as rancid as ever. Why, I think I should do a dramatic reading of this abomination of a fic. I do have a few days off coming soon...
Anyway, as much as I would love to go into the histories and the impacts of these stories, the fact remains that, they are not Legendary Badfic for the PPC. Generally, Legendary Badfic are the kinds of stories that everyone who is aware of what fanfiction is has heard of. To stay with MLP, not everyone knows Death and Resurrection, but we all have heard of Cupcakes. These stories are close to qualifying. Darn close. Especially the Conversion Beuru. But, on the whole, I just don't think these are nearly well known enough in the PPC subculture to count as Legendary Badfic. Sorry.
Not going to make My Little Unicorn any less painful to tackle, but still. -
That's why we came up with an objective process. by
on 2017-05-09 14:36:00 UTC
Link to this
See, there isn't much that a majority of PPCers have all heard of these days, since we don't all share Lord of the Rings or any one fandom in common anymore. So, we came up with a set of criteria for judging what's Legendary.
LonelyStar has addressed the big one. (How old are those fics, though? At least five years?) Now all that remains is for PPCers who are in the MLP fandom to voice their opinions.
~Neshomeh -
My Little Unicorn age by
on 2017-05-09 21:23:00 UTC
Link to this
It was posted to FIMFiction in 2012 (and that's a repost of the original story), so I'd say it's old enough.
-
In the case of TCB, I'd say it's not Legendary. by
on 2017-05-09 18:19:00 UTC
Link to this
Let's take a look at the criteria:
- It's definitely over 5 years old, the original fic was apparently published in 2011.
- A Google search for the last year brings up lots of search results... But they're all spin-offs. I'm not sure those qualify as search results about the original fic itself.
- Does it really count as being "famous in its own right" when most of the recent hits are from spin-offs? Everyone knows of the original fic but what most of the fans think when they hear of TCB is the genre it created. As an example, I always assumed the Barrier thing was in the original fic, but apparently it's not? But I'm not exactly active in the fandom anymore so I might just be out of the loop.
- Last one requires a vote of PPCers, let's see what happens.
-
Where, oh where, has my Multiverse Monitor gone? by
on 2017-05-09 14:52:00 UTC
Link to this
Oh where, oh where can it be...?
It looks like the two issues of Lily Winterwood's incarnation of the Multiverse Monitor have vanished from the internet. Does anyone have copies of them? I'm willing to host them (as I already am with Starwind's version), but don't have copies to host.
hS -
You mean the 2013 issues? April and May? by
on 2017-05-09 15:11:00 UTC
Link to this
I was able to download both of them with no trouble just now. I can send you the files, if you want, but they certainly aren't gone.
If you meant the Troupe reviews (I don't think you did, but there are similarly 2-3 of them and she was the main writer), those should still be available on her Tumblr. If they're not, I think I still have the Google docs.
~Zing -
Okay, I take my foolishness back. ^_^; by
on 2017-05-09 15:22:00 UTC
Link to this
To be fair to me, this is what I see when I click the link:
Don't ask me why I took 'Not Found' at its word without even trying 'Download'. Just... don't. :(
hS -
Yeah, no, you have to download :) by
on 2017-05-09 15:36:00 UTC
Link to this
It's always been that way, I think. It's odd, but it works!
Of course, if you want to host a second copy anyway, it might be a good idea. Having backups is always good.
~Zing -
I'll stuff a copy in a folder somewhere. by
on 2017-05-09 15:45:00 UTC
Link to this
That way there's at least a slight chance of me finding them again if/when they're needed. :)
hS, sheepish
-
Proposal/Discussion: A Beta Training Exercise by
on 2017-05-10 03:31:00 UTC
Link to this
I've been going through the various posts in the Grand Concilliary, and I've seen multiple suggestions regarding somehow teaching people how to be better betas. I think this is an excellent idea, and I'm more than willing to head up a little activity for all willing participants.
I have two ideas in mind (based on the main thread). I'll put them both below for comment and feedback. Whichever one appears to be more popular by next Tuesday, I'll launch as the actual activity.
Proposal One: The Blind Beta Exchange
Every participant writes a two to four page story. It can be PPC-related, but it doesn't have to be. Want to make it about your unrelated original universe? Sure, I'm game! The Organizer (that is, me) will then take the stories and assign them randomly to all participants for betaing so as to avoid any bias. Once everything's been done, the beta'd stories are returned to me, and I will post them—without names—in a specific thread. Then, everyone can publicly comment on the beta notes. Once that's done, everyone reveals who they were. We learn a little bit about betaing, and maybe a little bit about ourselves.
Proposal Two: Watch and Learn
This one has a little less participation, but could potentially be more instructive. In this case, an experienced beta would volunteer to go through an example piece. Everyone can watch, read, and ask questions/give feedback. Perhaps multiple veterans can be called in, so as to demonstrate different methods and approaches.
On a slight tangent, I'm also going to be posting an example of what I feel is very good beta work (not mine, although it was of something I did) either tonight or tomorrow. Perhaps that might help some people come to a decision.
If you have questions, comments, or suggestions for other activities, I'm happy to hear them.
PoorCynic -
Good Beta Work: An Example by
on 2017-05-11 19:38:00 UTC
Link to this
As promised! Posted below are the notes that JulyFlame gave me back in 2012 for my AU interlude "Five Stages". Yes, I hung onto them for several years because I thought they were that good.
I'm not suggesting that every time you beta, you need to do something like this. I would argue, however, that aiming for something like this would be a good goal.
The notes themselves.
If anyone else has old beta notes they think are particularly good, you are more then welcome to post them here (just make sure to get your beta's permission first). -
These are amazing by
on 2017-05-18 11:06:00 UTC
Link to this
… both the stories and the concrit. I usually don't put this much thought into my beta-reading; I'm more the proofreader type of beta.
Unfortunately, I will probably not participate in the Blind Beta Workshop. Preparations for my surgery are much more time-consuming and tiring than I head expected.
Since I can't ever not notice these things:
It was if all other colors had been bleached out of the world.
Shouldn't this be "It was as if..."?
Someone was behind her, pushing him along.
Who is he? Should this be either "her" (Laura) or "it" (the wheelchair)?
It was pose that might have passed without comment if could you ignore that she was sitting in a pool of blood.
Should be "a pose" (July already told you that)?
Should either be "could you" (apparently you had this initially) or "if you could", just inserting the "if" made it worse.
How is my not being as competent a combatant as you an excuse?
I think "my" should be "me", but given the situation I wouldn’t insist that Danny remembers that.
The woman frowned ever so slightly for just few seconds.
Should be "a few seconds"?
What if I ordered you to to murder someone?
I wouldn’t expect Death to stutter.
When my times comes.
Should be "time" (singular)?
She was further surprised when the receptionist sent her directly to Freedenburg’s office
His name is "Freedenberg".
Thank you coming in on such short notice. and
I summoned you down here because I believe that another agent in trouble.
Does Doc Freedenberg have a habit of leaving out words, or should these be
"Thank you for coming in" and "... that another agent is in trouble"?
HG -
Seeing an example of really good beta work would be nice. by
on 2017-05-11 13:59:00 UTC
Link to this
Also, I like both options, but since everybody is so eager to submit stories, it will probably be Proposal One, so I'll try to come up with another interlude. I like the random assignment, but I don't believe that everything can be kept anonymous until the end; the author of an interlude with Agents Androia and Hieronymus is not difficult to guess. Also, there is some uncertainty about technicalities.
Unlike some others here, I'm mostly available now, but may not be around after the end of this month (having some surgery to be done).
HG -
They both sound potentially fun and interesting. by
on 2017-05-11 13:15:00 UTC
Link to this
The drawback to proposal is that we couldn't use our own characters, as that would give away the writers' identities. I don't really have any plotbunnies/interest in non-PPC writing right now. So I guess proposal two sounds best to me.
—doctorlit -
First proposal sounds good by
on 2017-05-11 12:05:00 UTC
Link to this
I'm busy with exams until the 18th though.
-
I'd be up for either. by
on 2017-05-11 12:00:00 UTC
Link to this
Although I'm going to be very busy with exams until the 17th so I don't know how much I'll be able to write until after then.
-
Yeah, I can get behind this. by
on 2017-05-11 09:00:00 UTC
Link to this
I think Proposal One sounds better - it actually achieves exactly the same thing as Proposal Two, but with more versions to look at!
I'm sure I can knock something together. I assume you don't want fanfic - ie, you don't want stories which require canon knowledge to beta?
hS -
Sounds good! by
on 2017-05-11 08:15:00 UTC
Link to this
I think Proposal One sounds the most constructive, although not sure if I'd have time to participate myself.
Elcalion -
Sounds great! by
on 2017-05-11 02:37:00 UTC
Link to this
Like most people have said already, Proposal One sounds like the best. Also like most people, I'm not sure if I could write something in time (exam week, you know). But I'll definitely be down for beta-ing!
-
I'd be up for this. by
on 2017-05-11 00:10:00 UTC
Link to this
In particular, Proposal One. It sounds interesting and it's something to get me writing.
-
Sounds great by
on 2017-05-10 23:31:00 UTC
Link to this
Proposal one in particular sounds like so much fun. . . but if it's happening this next couple of weeks, I'll be crazy busy and the only "story" I'd be able to submit would be a college application essay I'm working on :/ (I'd probably be able to beta, though. . .). But yeah, I think that sounds really useful and fun, and like something which could become a recurring community event if it goes well ^.^
--Key -
I'm in favour of this. by
on 2017-05-10 16:06:00 UTC
Link to this
I mean, I probably won't be taking part, but I'm in favour of the general concept.
-
I'm up for either. by
on 2017-05-10 16:04:00 UTC
Link to this
Not sure I can crank out even a 2-4 page story by next Tuesday for Prop One, but if I can use this as an excuse to garner feedback on a story I've already written, I'm game. ^_^; In fact, I have two of the right length, if somebody else needs a pass on writing something new! I would actually really love some insight into why one has gotten more attention than the other. It's been baffling me.
... Except it might be obvious they're mine, though. Would that be a problem? Since the betas will be anonymous, they won't have to worry about offending me.
Failing that, I will try to actually write something. There's got to be some little scene I can draw out of my brain...
~Neshomeh -
Would the betas be anonymous from the writers? by
on 2017-05-10 22:33:00 UTC
Link to this
Dunno how possible that is! I know there are people who, assuming we're using GDocs, I'd recognise their accounts in a second, and people who'd recognise mine. Not even to mention distinctive sorts of things in writing styles, or whatnot.
There's a lot of people whose accounts I wouldn't recognise, of course, and I'd argue that the distinctive writing style stuff makes up for that, but I very specifically remember getting fooled by that one anonymous vampire-guy story you wrote a bit back. Got me good. To be fair, I am pretty dumb. But, still, I wonder if that's really possible, or entirely needed? The randomising of betas for stories seems to fulfil a lot of the unbiased-ness stuff, anyhow.
I mean, it probably is possible and I'm completely blind to it. Changing accounts or whatnot. -
We don't have to use Gdocs by
on 2017-05-12 22:33:00 UTC
Link to this
The authors could just post their unedited stories on the Board, and the betas could leave their feedback as replies. That way, we'd have a full record of the whole process. No technical difficulties there -- posting on the Board anonymously is so easy, people do it by accident! I've seen similar structures for writing exercises work really well elsewhere on the Internet
mostly in NSFW settings.
--Key -
Well. by
on 2017-05-13 10:06:00 UTC
Link to this
That was an underwhelmingly simple solution. I got a three page story and the whole thing fit in quite nicely, too, so nothing wrong, there.
Well.
That was underwhelming.
Jolly good!Also I don't know why you added that last part now I'm real curious except you can't answer it because it's NSFW why must you taunt me like this Key, is this revenge for what I did to your garage? -
Actually, commenting on Gdocs anonymously is possible. by
on 2017-05-11 12:05:00 UTC
Link to this
I beta-read several Gdocs not being loged in before I finally got an account to put my own stories up for beta-reading.
PoorCynic just needs to set the Gdoc's properties to "everybody can comment" (supposed that they can even see the document) and "everybody who has the link can read", where the assigned beta is the only person to whom PC sends the link. If you got the link and want to stay anonymous, just be careful to not login (or to deliberately logout) before you open the document, and you will be assigned a random name like "anonymous goldfish".
The bigger problem is keeping the authors anonymous while they edit the document in response to the comments. This may actually involve copying the commented document so that the author can edit without the beta watching, and then copying the revised document back into the copy on PC's account that the beta can see (or making a new copy and sending a new link to the beta) for another read-through.
Setting the properties to "everybody can edit" (supposed that they can even see the document), where only the author and the beta get links to the copy owned by PC might spare PC a lot of tedious work, but would set up an unrealistic situation, because betas usually should only make suggestions, but should not be able to edit directly.
(Note that I don't know the exact wording of the properties, because Google talks German to me.)
HG -
Do the authors need to revise them? by
on 2017-05-11 12:15:00 UTC
Link to this
I mean, if the purpose of this is to show what good betaing looks like, then I'd think it was better to show the original, un-beta'd story and the comments, rather than the edited version. Maybe?
I guess this is where Option Two came in, since it would let people watch the whole process rther than just the first stage...
hS -
Of course they should? by
on 2017-05-11 13:10:00 UTC
Link to this
I mean, if the purpose of this is to show what good betaing looks like, we would assume that all participants are already good at betaing, and we would just get a more diverse version of Option Two.
I'm under the impression that this, rather than being a demonstration, is an exercise (open to newbies who never beta read before) in doing the full beta process, which in my understanding and to my experience is not done by reading it once and putting up some comments. But I may be wrong. It's up to PC to clarify the details.
HG -
I think it'd be good to keep them unedited. by
on 2017-05-11 12:39:00 UTC
Link to this
I mean, at first, anyhow. It serves to show the betaing process so it can get seen and commented on by everyone else, and also keeps the context of what's actually being beta'd. Which will certainly be a whole lot smoother, I imagine!
Perhaps it could have two stages - the first stage, in which the stories, unedited and commented on, are posted, are seen, get concrit, et al. And then, a bit later on, there'd be the second stage, where the fics are all finished and polished and fancy, with no comments and all the advice having been accounted for, and just get sort've posted. For funsies.
The first stage is, obviously, the one that's more relevant to the whole 'learning to beta' thing, but it's nice to see the finished products, too, innit? Like, Iunno, Masterchef, when they do a close-up dolly shot of the single nugget of beef with leaf on the side, after it's been made and judged. Or some such. I don't watch MasterChef much. -
Re: I think it'd be good to keep them unedited. by
on 2017-05-11 18:36:00 UTC
Link to this
I would suggest a third, intermediate stage showing the communication between the betas and the authors that comes between the initial comments and the polished product.
-
I'd assume... by
on 2017-05-11 08:57:00 UTC
Link to this
... PoorCynic would copy the stories into new docs on his account, and then copy the commented versions to new new docs. I know there's a way of doing that that strips the names from comments.
hS -
Proposal One looks good! by
on 2017-05-10 08:02:00 UTC
Link to this
Looks to be a pretty solid idea, in general. Proposal Two looks like it'll be a bit awkward, y'know? Dunno in what way we'll be able to contact the veteran, but I imagine it might be a touch awkward, whether it's vocal chat or just the GDocs chat window thingy. Lots've people asking questions to one fellow, who's got to divide lots of attention about. Also Proposal One looks more fun, which is my middle name. The 'J' is silent, and also invisible.
I suppose you'll need emails, or some such? I assume there will be PMing involved, if we're keeping the randomised betafellows secret. -
I love both, but prefer Proposal One. by
on 2017-05-10 05:02:00 UTC
Link to this
I'd be very much game for participating in that. Good idea all around, PC!
-Alleb
-
PPC Pokémon Tournament (continued) by
on 2017-05-10 17:32:00 UTC
Link to this
As always, Da Rules.
As things stand right now, Novastorme is waiting patiently in the finalists' bracket for his opponent to claw their way through the ranks to meet him. The next battle we are currently waiting on is Huinesoron vs. [EvilAI]UBEROverlord. Scapegrace will fight the winner of that match, and the winner there will go on to fight Novastorme for the gold cup.see, this is what I get for saying 'This is a small tournament so things should move quickly', it ends up going halfway into the next month... -
Vowels, name a time and place. =] (nm) by
on 2017-05-14 17:35:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Probably going to have to be Saturday by
on 2017-05-15 00:08:00 UTC
Link to this
I am free weekdays after 18:00 Eastern Time, Saturdays I'm usually good all day. Sundays I am usually free before 12:00 Eastern Time.
-
Saturday it is, then! =] (nm) by
on 2017-05-16 20:13:00 UTC
Link to this
-
I'll be hanging around Showdown for a bit. (nm) by
on 2017-05-20 19:08:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Sorry, I've been a bit busy. by
on 2017-05-20 22:07:00 UTC
Link to this
I'll be online in a moment.
-
It seems today isn't going to work by
on 2017-05-21 01:01:00 UTC
Link to this
I'll be on showdown at some point around 11:00 Eastern Time.
-
Yeah, I can probably manage that. by
on 2017-05-21 02:46:00 UTC
Link to this
Sorry I wasn't around today. House cleaning and so forth.
-
I'm around now for the next little bit. (nm) by
on 2017-05-21 16:21:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Speaking of this! by
on 2017-05-13 16:16:00 UTC
Link to this
I was watching... it must have been your battle with EAIUO, Iximaz. Was the thing with repeatedly forcing his pokemon to switch out/into a bunch of entry hazards a strategy you planned, or one that came up as an emergency response when things went sideways?
hS -
Hazard phazing is a legitimate strategy. by
on 2017-05-13 16:32:00 UTC
Link to this
It helps if you have a lot of very defensively-oriented Pokémon on your team; because entry hazards, status effects, &c do set percentages of the target's HP as damage, you can outlast the opposition and stonewall everything they try. I don't know that it was Ix's initial strategy, but it's always worth a go. =]
Phazing, btw, is the term for forcibly switching out an opponent's Pokémon through moves like Dragon Tail, Roar, and Whirlwind. -
It was definitely planned. by
on 2017-05-13 19:00:00 UTC
Link to this
I'm too lazy to go back and rewatch the match, but if I remember right, I panicked, realized I didn't have any good counters, and started forcing AI to switch out and doing my best to annoy him into losing. Sometimes it works. :P It's a good backup when things go sideways.
I had too many sweepers to really make the hazard thing work, but no matter; next tourney, I'm planning on a Rapid Spin+Haze team to irritate everyone even more. -
[EvilAI]UBEROverlord! [Flings gloves around] by
on 2017-05-11 14:49:00 UTC
Link to this
... yeah, so what sort of times are you around?
hS -
Times by
on 2017-05-11 23:17:00 UTC
Link to this
I'm on Eastern Time, so I think 5 hours behind you. So I think the best day will be Saturday. I'm available most of the day. I can do 18:00 Eastern on Weekdays.
-
I am... sort of around. by
on 2017-05-13 15:11:00 UTC
Link to this
If you email me (huinesoron@hotmail.com) when you're around, my phone should buzz me and let me know.
I'm going to have to battle /from/ my phone, actually, and have had to reconstruct my team on there. I may have gotten some of the genders scrambled; I don't think you've got anything that matters for, but if you'd like me to check my previous battle logs and make sure, let me know.
hS -
No worries, My schedule has sort of changed as well by
on 2017-05-13 17:50:00 UTC
Link to this
A few things came up yesterday and so I myself am actually pretty busy today. I may or may not have time to go today either.
-
Let's skip tonight, then. by
on 2017-05-13 18:23:00 UTC
Link to this
My team got trounced by a six-year-old earlier today, so they need time to recover their morale anyway. ^_^
(Well, he spends so much time playing imaginary Pokemon fights that just involve him declaring that his Pokemon wins everything that I thought a proper battle might do him good...)
How are you fixed for tomorrow?
hS -
For tomorrow by
on 2017-05-13 19:10:00 UTC
Link to this
I will be free before 12:00 Eastern Times, and After 18:00 Eastern Time.
-
Are you here in about half an hour? (nm) by
on 2017-05-14 15:15:00 UTC
Link to this
-
I am here now by
on 2017-05-14 15:51:00 UTC
Link to this
Sorry I missed the first comment
-
Ditto. (nm) by
on 2017-05-14 15:58:00 UTC
Link to this
- And the results can be found here by on 2017-05-14 16:18:00 UTC Link to this
-
So it turns out... by
on 2017-05-15 15:44:00 UTC
Link to this
... that theming my team after the event that killed all of them off didn't end well.
Who knew?!?!
hS -
Would you be up for a friendly? by
on 2017-05-16 00:04:00 UTC
Link to this
I really want to face your team, mainly because I actually really like it and want to see how well it would do against mine.
-
Yeah, I guess? Evenings good for you? (nm) by
on 2017-05-19 08:43:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Give me a time and I should be good. by
on 2017-05-19 13:47:00 UTC
Link to this
Although saying that I can't do today between 5:30 and 10:30 (possibly later).
-
That's adorable. =] (nm) by
on 2017-05-13 18:29:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Probably gonna be Saturday, yeah. by
on 2017-05-12 09:07:00 UTC
Link to this
I am not awake at 11pm. ^_^ (Well, sometimes I am, but I shouldn't be.)
Though Saturday might actually be difficult... um, I'll post something on the day.
hS
-
History of the World by
on 2017-05-10 23:18:00 UTC
Link to this
So, you may or may not remember history of japan, which was a really nifty video that taught you everything you needed to know about, well. The history. of Japan. If you haven't seen it, you should check it out, because it's pure comedy gold and you might even learn some things!
Now, the creator- Bill Wurtz- has re-emerged with a more ambitious video- history of the entire world, i guess which is twice as long and just as wonderfully educating.
Language warning for both of these, if you don't like swearing. But it's worth it, I promise.