*blows noisemaker* Let's post some of our New Year's resolutions! Mine are...
1. Eat more fruits and vegetables
2. Earn my first-degree black belt (this is more of a goal than a resolution, but it counts)
3. Defeat the Sinnoh Elite Four on my Pearl ROM, darn it!
4. Complete a riff on/meta-fanfic of Zarrelion's "The Life of the Legendaries". (read it if you ever need to be amused by bickering legendary Pokemon) My riff can be found on my deviantART under the title "Origin Science Theater 649".
5. Be more patient with people
-
Happy 2015, everyone! by
on 2015-01-01 14:33:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Ah, Space Year 2015. Waitin' for my hoverboard. (nm) by
on 2015-01-05 16:04:00 UTC
Link to this
- Here you go by on 2015-01-05 19:51:00 UTC Link to this
-
I want one. by
on 2015-01-07 14:57:00 UTC
Link to this
I WANT IT NOW! Okay, that is flipping amazing. I want. Really badly.
-
Oh my gosh by
on 2015-01-06 15:39:00 UTC
Link to this
IwantitIwantitIwantitIwantitnow.
*Checks the reward prices.*
Er, on second thought I may wait for it. Totally worth the wait, though. This is AWESOME. I really want to see how far this technology goes. -
WHOA. by
on 2015-01-06 12:04:00 UTC
Link to this
THE THING.
THE THING HAPPENED.
Okay, so it's basically just four electromagnets and a computer, and has to run on a smooth sheet of metal, and only rides about a centimeter above the surface.
BUT STILL.
THE THING.
Thanks. ;)
hS -
OMG DID IT REALLY?! *head asplode* (nm) by
on 2015-01-06 21:34:00 UTC
Link to this
-
I KNOW by
on 2015-01-06 13:16:00 UTC
Link to this
Thank you Tumblr for showing me that! Currently the place is half Back to the Future, half Evangelion.
-
Woohoo! by
on 2015-01-02 07:37:00 UTC
Link to this
And to think I just got used to writing 2014. Oh well. As for resolutions, I'll shoot for actually getting my first mission out.
-
The future is here! by
on 2015-01-01 17:16:00 UTC
Link to this
Hoo boy, can I just take a moment to point out how amazing the present is?
We have robots that clean up our living rooms, computer programs that can simulate worlds hundreds of miles wide and an intercontinental web that allows people in California to regularly interact and share ideas with people all the way in the UK. We might not be zooming through chrome cities in our hovercars, but the world right now is kind of amazing. I very much look forward to the coming years.
But as for this year I resolve, for starters, to start writing again (and perhaps to actually put in a Permission Request for the first time in... what, two years?). Also, more personally, I resolve to get my own place, and travel to somewhere I've never been to, perhaps not in that order. -
Nice points. by
on 2015-01-05 16:12:00 UTC
Link to this
It's funny how the present and our past futures have diverged so much. There's almost nothing in retrofuturity which envisioned our style of computer games and programs - Google Earth? Minecraft? Kerbal? Forget it. But on the other hand, there's very little which assumed we'd still be using mice and MSWord, either.
The internet? It's a major part of many people's lives, but retrofuturity barely takes it beyond 'chat'. Think of all the things you do on the 'net that aren't straight communication...
And... yeah, non-humanoid robots. Fiction and prediction alike have assumed that robots need to be fully aware (or at least capable of simulating it), or they're useless. But we have Roombas (my parents call theirs Dobby), and Siri, and self-driving cars, and...
... well, and all the things we don't even notice, the little automatic algorithms that tag your Facebook pictures, or fill in your username for you, or filter out your spam emails. It's all very very clever. But we're still waiting for those hoverboards.
But... I guess it's the same for everything. Why are dinosaurs and mammoths unspeakably cool, when their direct descendents, swans and elephants, are 'coolish' at best? Why is it that the future you don't have is more exciting than the one you're living in - when the one you've got is way more advanced?
hS -
Wait, what?! by
on 2015-01-01 15:27:00 UTC
Link to this
................oh, right, I totally forgot about those resolution thingers. Well, if anything, my only resolution was to get my WoW priest to level 100 today, but that won't exactly be difficult, so... I got nothin'.
Well, I guess missioning Little Miss Mary and Rose Potter might also count.
Also, wow, black belt? That's so cool! In what? -
Re: Wait, what?! by
on 2015-01-01 16:08:00 UTC
Link to this
Karate. Specifically Jeet Kune Do, which is Bruce Lee's mixed martial arts style. I'm currently a brown belt, making my goal slightly more plausible but no less
painfulimportant and good for my health.
Good luck with your resolutions, whatever they end up being! -
Hope you can reach that goal by
on 2015-01-02 03:53:00 UTC
Link to this
As someone who only made it through a year of mixed martial arts training, awesome, you've already done a lot. *Makes mental note about potential fight scene questions*
Anyway, resolutions have never really been a thing in my family, but I want to start exercising regularly again--once a week at least--and study Japanese vocabulary. -
Resolutions? Uh... by
on 2015-01-01 14:49:00 UTC
Link to this
I've kinda never made those.
I guess I want to save money for a gaming PC.
-
Presenting... the PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-01 16:34:00 UTC
Link to this
Happy New Year, everyone, and have a pleasant surprise to kick off 2015! I already broached this idea to two of my betas, but basically, I've decided to set up a new PPC holiday event. The New Year's Gift Exchange is inspired by a similar event I attended at a real-life holiday party a few days ago, and I thought I'd give it a try with a number of PPC agents!
So, without further ado, here are the rules:
ADMISSION AND SETUP:
1. You need to have Permission and at least two agents to enter this event.
2. In a reply to this post, list each of your attending agent teams and one gift for each team member to bring. This may be either a "souvenir" from a mission you've published previously, or just something they happen to have that they want to give away.
3. I will take four or five other Boarders for this year's event, so the first five Boarders to submit applications will be the ones attending it.
4. For future events like this, anyone with Permission can host this event. One of their agents must serve as an in-universe host for this event; any other agents in the host's team are to participate as players.
EVENT RULES:
5. I will set up an introductory post on the Message Board for this event, with a full guest list for all attending. The most important rule: NOBODY MUST KNOW WHAT THE GIFTS ARE UNTIL THEY'VE OPENED THEM. Surprise is the driving factor here! This means that all of the gifts are wrapped and put in a big pile at the start of the game.
6. Once I've tallied the full list, each player will get a random number, with the range depending on how many players there are. The agents must play in that order via replies to the starting post.
7. The agent currently in play can either choose a gift from the pile (I'll provide the full list of gifts on the Posting Board) or, if others before them have already chosen gifts, they can "steal" a gift from the previous owner. A gift can be stolen up to twice; after that, it is locked to the agent it's ended up with, and cannot be stolen again.
8. The game ends once everyone has received a gift. Since the first agent cannot steal, he/she will be given the choice to steal after this. The host cannot steal.
All right, that should be it. Have fun, everyone, and I can't wait to get this thing started! :D -
I come back from working out with my mom to THIS?! XD by
on 2015-01-01 22:26:00 UTC
Link to this
Anyway, lookin' good so far, everyone! Might as well throw in my lot since I started this thing! :D
From RC #227:
Rashida: She'll will be hosting the event, so she won't bring anything. Not that she'd want to, anyway...
Falchion: The coprolite mini-Boulder, shit ruond. He had it wrapped in an airtight package because the smell would be overpowering otherwise!
Sarah: A glitter-stained crowbar. It originally belonged to her mother, but she gave it up once her homefic was killed.
From RC #133,316,666:
Rayner: The severed horn of Not!Sombra, the MLP Character Replacement from his first mission with his new partner.
E.V.L.: From the same mission, a necklace ganked from the fic's Sue, with an alicorn-shaped pendant.
@Iximaz: If you'd be happy to help, I'll gladly take two more slots! Eight Boarders means at least 16 agents... Man, this will be a doozy! (Though to be fair, the gift-exchange event at the party I attended had at least 28 people involved...) -
All righty, then... START THE GAME! by
on 2015-01-02 15:42:00 UTC
Link to this
Since it's technically not New Year's Day anymore, I think I'll close this off. Besides, I've got... *counts on talons*... Twenty-one players total! Hoo boy...
I'll set up the full roster list and the introductory post as soon as I can. Good luck to all participating Boarders, and I will see you on the Message Board! -
Re: All righty, then... START THE GAME! by
on 2015-01-02 16:38:00 UTC
Link to this
The introductory post for this event has been made here, by the way. Have fun! :)
-
RE: Gift exchange by
on 2015-01-01 19:37:00 UTC
Link to this
Awesome, let's do this!
Chris: a photo of Meganium and Mareep being cute
Ami Seeker: four bars of Bleepolate
Trainee Miguel Correa: cyndaquil the mini-Missingno (ghost form). If minis don't count, he'll give one of those neat iPod cases that look like Game Boys instead. -
Heavy weapons crew (and a geth), coming though. by
on 2015-01-01 19:06:00 UTC
Link to this
I'll throw my DIA Special Response team in here and see what happens.
Emiranlanoamar, AKA the Guardsman: An Improved Outer Tactical Vest, ballistic plates included.
Naya'Keegan vas Iktomi: A Lancer VIII rifle with the user manual, spare parts, and maintenance kit.
Terabyte: A CD set of Mozart's operas. -
Hrr, let's see by
on 2015-01-01 18:28:00 UTC
Link to this
The Librarian is too much of a jerk to bring presents, so Agent Des will probably bring a packet of Stygian Tea inside a genuine adamantine box - the box is probably worth more than the tea - for both of them.
-
100% unrelated - sorry by
on 2015-01-08 04:57:00 UTC
Link to this
Heeeeeeeey... Remember that picture I said I'd draw for you way back in June? Yeah. Well. I... I uh. I drew it. Sorry about taking so long... I'm not totally happy with it but I figured it was past high time I got it to you.
*Runs away and hides.* -
Ooh, fun by
on 2015-01-01 17:52:00 UTC
Link to this
I have a bunch of agents and non-missioning folk, but let's go with these guys:
Narav: one pelt of a color-changing lioness CAF
Lana: a zweihander with ice-related magic
Riaa'lzhor: a set of rune-engraved throwing knives. The runes do nothing, but they look neat. -
Eh, let's bring in some other teams as well... by
on 2015-01-01 18:32:00 UTC
Link to this
Ari: Copy of Dumbledore's pocket watch
Tera: Box of Schrodinger's Cookies
Theia: The Unabridged Guide to Poisons, Toxins, and Venom
Cepha: One Grandine/Hailstorm rifle from Madoka Magica Online, which uses magic bullets and looks like this: http://images.puella-magi.net/6/6a/%E3%82%B0%E3%83%A9%E3%83%B3%E3%83%87%E3%82%A3%E3%83%8D.jpg?20121022083446
Amara: One magic (glow-in-the-dark) red scarf
Fiorano: One box set of Hayao Miyazaki movies -
Joining in! But really, only the first five? by
on 2015-01-01 17:45:00 UTC
Link to this
Is it because any more would be too much to handle? Because I'd help coordinate if that's the case. Anyway!
Rina and Randa will be bringing an egg Dogwig laid in a present marked as 'FRAGILE', complete with incubator obtained from the DoSAT.
-
Big Ol' Newbie Here by
on 2015-01-01 23:45:00 UTC
Link to this
Hey there, PPC. A few days ago I googled "casandra claire plagiarism" and stumbled upon the "cassandra claire" article of your wiki. I ended up reading a lot of your wiki, the original series, and the Constitution. I found your mission admirable (I, too, long for the elimination of badfic). Then I decided I'd like to join you. So hi!
A little about myself: I prefer she/her pronouns. I do not exactly "belong" to any fandoms, but I do sort of hang around the outskirts of a few, such as the Thomas Harris Universe (NBC's Hannibal, Silence of the Lambs, etc.), Harry Potter, Doctor Who, and some Broadway plays/musicals. I also like retro gaming, animation, gothic artwork, true crime, drag queens/kings, and independent professional wrestling. I am in university, studying biology, so bad biology in fics drives me especially nuts.
I love to write fiction, but I can't say I've really written fan fiction, except for one or two stories back in middle school *shudder*. It occurred to me that I and a few of my friends have been doing our own sort of "sporking" fan fiction for years now. We enjoy reading/critiquing badfics, and on occasion have even drawn comics of badfics to illustrate how absurd they were. We never posted our stuff on the internet, but when I was reading PPC missions it kind of reminded me of our fanfic critique.
Sorry if I'm too long-winded! I based this post off of the joining section of the FAQ. -
Hi, new newbie! by
on 2015-01-03 03:43:00 UTC
Link to this
I'm not sure if I still count as a newbie or not... I think I've been around a month (or two? hard to remember) or so now.
As for gifts, have a transparent kitten! -
Welcome! by
on 2015-01-02 22:31:00 UTC
Link to this
Hellos, and welcome to the Board!
As a welcoming present, I give you a box slightly used Christmas lights. I'm sure that most of them still work!
What would you say that your favorite Broadway play/musical is? I'm personally a huge fan of Wicked. -
Re: Big Ol' Newbie Here by
on 2015-01-02 21:49:00 UTC
Link to this
I want to thank you all very much! Such a warm welcome, and such a plethora of fantastic presents!
I think I'm going to like it here. -
Hi, newbie! by
on 2015-01-02 18:33:00 UTC
Link to this
Awesome, you've done the required reading. :) Let's see what I can give you...
*rummages through closet*
A-ha! A box of red pens! Hope they all still have ink in them :P -
Welcome by
on 2015-01-02 16:03:00 UTC
Link to this
Welcome to the PPC! Here, have a bola slingshot crossbow handcart with a *slight* calibration issue. Glad i'm not the newest boarder anymore. (no idea why I did not like that fact in the first place though...)
-
Welcome! by
on 2015-01-02 11:35:00 UTC
Link to this
Hi, hello, greetings, et cetera! Have this cup of tea, with the accompanying scones and jam - just don't let the leaves eat you.
-
Howdy! by
on 2015-01-02 07:30:00 UTC
Link to this
No need to apologize for the post, especially since it's based on the FAQ. It's always nice to see newbies show up, so have a juice box and a chainsaw. Because what could go wrong with indiscriminately handing out chainsaws?
-
Welcome! by
on 2015-01-02 03:46:00 UTC
Link to this
Have a bag of holding for all the other gifts--don't worry, it has pockets so you won't lose anything inside. Your fanfic critiques sound fun; any particular fics you've gone after?
-
Re: Welcome! by
on 2015-01-02 21:39:00 UTC
Link to this
Re: Thantosiet: Thanks for the bag; otherwise I might not have been able to carry all these lovely gifts! To answer your question, a couple come to mind...most recently we've tackled some particularly heinous "Ed, Edd, and Eddy" slash fics, featuring extreme OOC, bad biology, plus the author inserted a Mary Sue as the Eds friend who also happens to be a huge yaoi fangirl...ugh! But one that particularly jumps up for me is a Ted BundyxJeffrey Dahmer fan fiction...you know, the REAL LIFE SERIAL KILLERS. Virtually any sane person can see why writing that fic is in ridiculously poor taste.
-
Welcome! by
on 2015-01-02 01:01:00 UTC
Link to this
Have a shovel and a vial of scorpion-woman venom! Don't let this in your bloodstream, you'll be paralyzed for several minutes.
-
Welcome aBoard! by
on 2015-01-02 00:54:00 UTC
Link to this
Have a Golden Snitch, an eight-bit Triforce, and one of my own shed feathers (Careful, it's sharp!)!
-
Newbie! *glomp* *first poke* by
on 2015-01-02 00:52:00 UTC
Link to this
Have a snarling pocket-humpback whale! If the urple bow around its neck becomes too much, feel free to remove it.
So, hi! Welcome to the PPC! Hope you like it here! -
Hey-o. by
on 2015-01-02 00:44:00 UTC
Link to this
please say you're a Brood War veteran pleasepleaseplease
Welcome to the Board, Ô first newbie of 2015! Have some of my hydrophobic water to commemorate the event. Not suitable for adults 18 and over.
Bio student, eh? As a physics major I have to admit that I don't really understand what you guys do in class. Memorize stuff? Write essays? -
Re: Hey-o. by
on 2015-01-02 21:44:00 UTC
Link to this
Oh boy, hydrophobic water!
I'm familiar with the Brood War but I'm not sure I could be considered a veteran.
And on the biology student topic: haha, yes, memorization and essays happen quite a lot in our studies. Also lab work. Funny thing is, we bio majors are just as puzzled as to what physics majors do... -
Thanks for the answer. by
on 2015-01-03 00:57:00 UTC
Link to this
Glad to see that you know classic StarCraft! What's your favourite race? I'm a big Terran fan but I also off-race as Protoss.
Concerning your question: basically, physics majors are shown math formulas, their derivations, their uses, and then solvepractical problemslots and lots of textbook problems. Sometimes the professor starts writing his own homework problems and that's when you start worrying: if he wrote the problem, then he finds it interesting, which means that it's difficult, which means that we have to get really creative in our setup if we need to find a solution to the problem.
Afterwards, we go and laugh at engineers because we think that we're better than them but in reality we have no idea what we're doing. -
First plover! (nm) by
on 2015-01-02 00:35:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Welcome! by
on 2015-01-02 00:27:00 UTC
Link to this
Broadway, huh? Have a copy of the Grimmerie, though there aren't any gurantees on readability. Anyways, I hope you enjoy your time here!
-
The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-02 16:19:00 UTC
Link to this
A/N: Happy [belated] New Year, everyone! I thought I'd start a thing, so here it is!
The post with the rules and all of the listed gifts can be found here, and the spreadsheet I will be using to keep tally, including the order of play, can be found here.
**********
"Do I really have to be the host for this game?" Rashida growled, having swept the last bit of dirt away from the now spotless RC. "I don't even celebrate New Year's..."
"Oh come on, Rose! It'll be fun!" Sarah hedged. "We even invited that DMS team you told us about once! You know, the one with... Rayner, right?"
"You did what?!"
"I actually met Rayner just after my second mission," Falchion reminded them. "He's actually a pretty nice guy, though a bit of a hard-ass at times. You don't have to get so upset about this."
"I completely understand his reasons to doubt me, Falchion," Rashida replied. "But has he learned anything at all?! He sent a Ra-forsaken Author Wraith to the Sunflower's office almost as soon as he was out from Medical, for Mafdet's sake!"
"Funny you should mention that - she's coming too," said Sarah. "I really wanted to meet her after what Falchion told me, so..."
Rashida gave her such a murderous glare that she instantly shut up.
"B-but... E.V.L. got her glitter extracted! She shouldn't be too much of a problem," Falchion insisted. "Besides, we were the ones picked to host the Gift Exchange this year, and you can't just turn someone down in front of everyone! It'll look unfair!"
"I know," the Sphinx agent growled, straightening her whiskers. "But if she tries anything stupid, there will be trouble. Anyway, let's just get this event over with. There should be... eighteen guests. This will take a while."
"Eighteen guests?!" Sarah almost shouted.
"To be fair," her adopted brother pointed out, "this is a fairly big RC..."
**********
"Welcome to all of you!" Rashida announced once all the guests had filed in, exchanged greetings, and took their seats around the huge pile of wrapped presents on the coffee table. "It is my displeasure to host the annual PPC New Year's Gift Exchange. I take it all of you brought gifts?"
Falchion sprang up suddenly. "Guh! J-just a sec, Rosie... I totally forgot!..."
Rashida facepawed while her avian partner grabbed some random tinfoil and rushed off to the closet. A moment later, he'd come back with what looked like a large ball of foil, which he quickly added to the pile.
"I can't believe I'm doing this," the Sphinx fumed silently before continuing. "Anyway, the rules for this Gift Exchange are as follows: You will have all received a random number upon your arrival. That number indicates the order in which you will play. An agent in play can either pick a gift from the pile, or steal one from another agent who's chosen previously. A gift can be stolen up to twice before it is locked to a particular user. You must not know your gifts prior to opening them, you cannot choose your own gift, blah blah blah..."
She raised her feathery tail like a starting flag. "Anyway, worst of luck to all of you. Now, let the games... BEGIN!" -
And with that... by
on 2015-02-19 18:06:00 UTC
Link to this
"Was that the last one?" asked Falchion.
Rashida checked the list. "Yes, actually, I believe it was the last one. So yes, thank you for attending. Now, run along back to your RCs. I'm tired..."
"Wait, wait! Guys, the countdown's about to end!" Sarah cried excitedly.
"We've got thirty seconds to go," said E.V.L. "Just give all of us this one chance?"
Falchion gave his partner a pleading look. "Rashida... This is our first time hosting this event. And we're so close to the finale. At least let us celebrate the stroke of midnight."
Rashida facepawed. "Okay, fine. Just leave me out of it..."
"Actually, I wanted to give you something too. Wait, wait! Ten seconds to go!"
The party goers looked at Rashida's digital sundial, unanimously counting the seconds until the clock showed midnight.
"Nine!"
"Eight!"
"Seven!"
"Six!"
"Five!"
"Four!"
"Three!"
"Two!"
"One!"
"HAPPY NEW YEAR!!!"
Everyone who was in the mood to cheer did so, throwing confetti, cakefetti, and other assorted miscellanies all over the place. Falchion thankfully resisted the urge to throw Spikes as well.
"So... About that gift?" asked Rashida.
Falchion nodded, pulling open a nearby drawer with his beak, and took out several small, black balls, which he offered to her. "I wanted to give you these."
She took them in surprise, turning them over in her hands. "What are they?"
"Dark Balls. A type of Poké Ball from my home continuum - the fourth movie of the anime specifically. I got them from the training mission with Chris and Ami. I told you about a while ago." He nodded to them before continuing. "They were originally used to capture some legendary Pokémon, but I was thinking that they could be modified to quarantine any CAFs we may eventually rescue, so I figured, well..."
She looked at him, her red-pink eyes wide. "You wanted to... give these to me?"
He looked at her with a disappointed expression. "If you don’t want them, well..."
To his complete surprise, she hugged him. In front of everyone.
"I never received a gift from anyone at the PPC. I don't know what to say..."
"You're welcome," replied Falchion. "And Happy New Year to you too."
"Yo, birdie!" Rayner called out to them. "When we're done, can E.V.L. and I stick around for a bit? You may need some extra help to clean up all this confetti!"
If Falchion could have blushed, he would have. "Oh, right... I forgot you didn't like having confetti all over our RC..."
Rashida facepawed again. "This is going to be a long 2015."
[END]
**********
A/N: That took a *lot* longer than I thought it would, but it looks like this RP is officially complete. Thanks for participating, everyone! Hopefully, next year's Gift Exchange won't take two months instead of one. XD -
"Oh, I'm the last one," Ami noted. by
on 2015-02-11 19:17:00 UTC
Link to this
She was far too nice to steal someone else's gift (and most of them looked kind of weird anyway), so she levitated the final package over to her. She untied the bright yellow ribbon and draped it loosely around her hat.
"Ami...?" Miguel began.
"What? It might come in handy someday." She set the box down, then knelt and used her hooves to open it. "Ooo, cookies! I think they're chocolate chip, too! Wait, they're oatmeal raisin...no, chocolate...What the hay is this?" -
Re: "Oh, I'm the last one," Ami noted. by
on 2015-02-16 03:00:00 UTC
Link to this
Tera peered over. "Hm, that's odd. Those are Schrodinger's Cookies - they're either chocolate or not chocolate. But once you take a bite, the waveform collapses... And I don't even know how oatmeal raisin got in there. Perhaps I messed up the recipe somewhere?"
-
The Guardsman huffed. by
on 2015-02-17 01:02:00 UTC
Link to this
"Oh, please," he muttered under his breath. "The entire point of the so-called "Schrödinger's cat" paradox is to prove that the entire concept of a system being in two conflicting states at once is ridiculous. One thing just happens and then you just open the box to find out what it is."
Naya rolled her eyes. "So... are you just going to apply classical mechanics to everything?" she whispered back.
"I'm not saying that! It's just that once these primitives figure out that all of their measurements were missing key variables then they'll get their heads out of the ground and see that quantum mechanics isn't as confusing as they thought it was."
"Oh yeah, and you know all of this like the back of your hand," snorted the quarian.
The Time Lord scowled at his partner. "As a matter of fact, I do." He pointed a thumb at himself. "Time Lord Academy of Gallifrey graduate, specialization in TARDIS micro-multidimensional systems. And yes, that includes complex quantum effects."
"You're full of it."
"Bah, whatever," said the Guardsman and continued to pout in his corner.
- - -
((Seriously, guys. The wave function is only a probability function. Unlike classical mechanics, which allows you to make highly accurate predictions about a system, quantum mechanics only describes the probability of events happening. Your actual measurement interacts with the system under observation, thus changing the result (ex. detecting photons or measuring electron spin). That's why we say the waveform collapsed: we went ahead and poked it with a stick!
/rant)) -
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-02-06 22:06:00 UTC
Link to this
Fiorano stood up and walked over to the pile, where only two presents were left. She closed her eyes and grabbed randomly. She picked up a thin package, and, after tearing it open, held out a bar of Bleepolate. "Uh. OK then."
-
Oooh, shiny! by
on 2015-01-15 00:20:00 UTC
Link to this
Rashida nudged Falchion with her wing. "Your turn, you stupid bird..."
"Huh? Oh, right!"
The Skarmory stood up, strutting towards the pile, and wondering if he should pick anything. Then he noticed a glint of something metallic...
"You know what, I might as well save myself the trouble of trying to open a present," he said with a mischevious smirk. "Rina, Randa, can I have that watch, please? Hopefully, that'll give you ladies the opportunity to nab a certain something..."
Sarah had to struggle to hold in another fit of giggles.
Rashida meanwhile huffed and rolled her eyes at her partner. "Un. Believable." -
"But..." by
on 2015-01-16 18:27:00 UTC
Link to this
Tina watched sadly as Randa reluctantly handed over the watch.
No sooner had Falchion accepted it than Rina stood up. "Stealing back! That makes it locked to us now, right?" -
Dangit... by
on 2015-01-16 18:49:00 UTC
Link to this
Falchion shrugged and gave the watch back to the other agents. "If you really want it THAT badly, well..."
"That item is now locked and cannot be stolen again," said Rashida. "That's the second time this has happened, but no matter. Just pick a new gift already - we haven't got all night!"
The Skarmory rolled his head at her in exasperation, strode up to the pile, and pulled out a box before heading back to his place.
"Here, I'll get that!" said Sarah, helping him open up the box. Inside was some kind of furry animal skin, which seemed to change color every once in a while.
Rashida looked at the pelt with a disturbed expression, her hackles raised. "Keep that away from me," she growled. "I do not want to know where it's from!"
"Who cares?" Sarah replied. "It's so pretty!"
"Yeah, it's not shiny," Falchion warbled in laughter, "but it'll do just fine." -
Re: Dangit... by
on 2015-01-18 02:20:00 UTC
Link to this
Narav twitched his ears in the direction of the Falchion/Skarmory/Rashida group. "Well, it's certainly not contaminated or anything," he noted, turning towards them. "I am quite careful. Only residual glitter remains in that, and certainly nowhere near enough to cause any Sue-related effects."
-
(Isn't it firemagic's turn?) by
on 2015-01-25 18:52:00 UTC
Link to this
Regardless, Rashida gave the pelt a wide berth. "Keep it, Falchion. If you use it as a rug, though, I will be very disappointed."
The Skarmory shrugged. "Don't worry, Rosie. I see it as more like comforter, personally."
"Or a nest lining, maybe," added Sarah.
(It's been a while since we've picked up on this, but we've only got two more contestants to go. I wonder if we can we finish this already before the month is over?) -
(Oh bugger, mini-Agent alert! >_> ) (nm) by
on 2015-01-16 18:28:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-12 23:34:00 UTC
Link to this
"Keelah, what is that thing?" grumbled Naya as she fumbled with the underside of her helmet. "Hang on a second, I just have to..." The quarian pushed a button and twisted a valve under her helmet's chin piece. "There we go. Much better."
The Guardsman, who had pulled a respirator over his face, chuckled at his partner. "Closed off the air intake valve, eh?"
"Yeah. I'll enough air for another hour; I don't feel like scrubbing my suit's olfactory filters today."
"Naya, I believe it is your turn." said Terabyte, raising a finger.
"Oh, is it? Well, then let's see..."
The quarian woman stood up and examined the remaining gifts. There were several small boxes, one oddly-shaped lump, and a long box. She settled on the latter and returned to her seat. She united the strings that held down the box's lid and carefully opened the lid lest another malodorous mini pop out of it. A glint of polished wood caught her eye. She lifted the lid a little further. In the box sat a rifle made of a handsome light blue wood featuring a gold-and-silver hammer, trigger, and sights. Naya carefully lifted the weapon out of the box with both hands.
"My word... now that is what you call a gift," whispered the quarian. She span around in her seat, making sure there was nobody in front of her, and squinted down the rifle's sights while keeping the weapon pointed at the ground. "Iron sights... not bad. Not too heavy, either..." She returned the rifle to her lap and ran a finger along the decoration on the rifle's stock. After a moment, Naya rose her head and addressed the room. "Just a question, though: does the previous owner of this weapon know what this thing fires? It's not muzzle-loading, is it?"
"Who cares?" said the Guardsman. "Look at the thing. It's beautiful!" -
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-13 19:13:00 UTC
Link to this
Cepha smiled brightly as Naya got the rifle. "That rifle is from Madoka Magica Online! It's a cute little browser game, you get a magical girl and can get weapons and clothes and stuff. That's one of the upper-class weapons - on the S tier, I believe. It's called the Hailstorm, or the Grandine - well, they mean the same thing."
She frowned in thought. "I have no idea about the ammo thing. I think it just fires when you pull the trigger - in the game, you just have to have it equipped to a character and it works. The flavor text says it fires magic bullets, by the way. And not Madoka-style magic, where it chews up part of your soul for power every time." -
RE: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-12 13:50:00 UTC
Link to this
Ami, Chris, and Miguel edged away from Ari and the mini-Boulder. "Is there a way to politely tell someone their present's making you nauseous?" Miguel whispered.
"Probably not," Ami whispered back. "We'll just have to deal with it for now." She nudged Chris' arm. "It's your turn, by the way."
Chris picked a large, square present with snowman wrapping paper from the bottom of the pile. "Oof! What is this, a block of iron?" He opened it to reveal a thick book titled "The Unabridged Guide to Poisons." "...Well, that's morbid."
"Useful, though," said Miguel with a shrug. -
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-11 21:38:00 UTC
Link to this
Cepha glared at Des. "Well, how exactly is Amara supposed to know that? There's no label on the box or anything! And anyways -"
Fiorano coughed. "Uh, not to interrupt, but it's your turn."
Cepha made a hmph sound and walked over to the pile, grabbing a thin box out of the (now significantly reduced) pile and tore it open, holding up a unicorn horn. "Uh. Kinda a morbid gift to give, but all right."
Ari stood up. "Oh, it's my turn now, right?" She walked up and picked a sealed box. "Wow, this is shut up tightly," she muttered as she pried it open. "There we go, and - what is that smell Why -" she covered her nose as a mini crawled out. -
Ohhhhh snap... by
on 2015-01-12 17:55:00 UTC
Link to this
Upon seeing the unicorn horn, Rayner broke out into a grin. "That horn came from a replacement of King Sombra. I broke it off him myself!"
His partner nudged him irritably, upon which he added, "Well, my partner helped..."
The mini-Boulder, however, elicited a completely different response. A large number of agents covered their noses too, including Rashida and Sarah. Falchion, meanwhile, had lowered his head to the floor in embarrassment and was carefully backing away.
Rashida grabbed the Skarmory by the neck with her forepaw and pulled him up to her so his beak was inches from her face. "What. Did. You. DO?!"
"I'm so sorry!" he apologized frantically. "It was an accident, I swear! How was I supposed to know that was the stinky one?!"
"How were YOU supposed to know?!" his partner growled. "This, Falchion, is exactly why I don't like coming to your parties!"
"Rosie, please," Sarah added. "You can't just leave everyone hanging! Not after they chose us to host this thing!"
"I said I was sorry!" Falchion pleaded. "I'll try to make it up to you, I promise!"
Rashida looked around at the others, who were no doubt having such a good time. The Sphinx agent sighed bitterly.
"All right, fine. Let's finish this. But if you keep embarrassing me like this, Falchion, we are NEVER hosting anything like this again!"
Falchion obediently sat next to her, regretting his awful choice for a New Year's gift... -
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-08 16:49:00 UTC
Link to this
"I thought the crowbar was from me!" Sarah piped up indignantly. "We'll, my mom, technically, but still!"
E.V.L. ignored her complaint as she stood up and stalked towards the pile. After a few moments' deliberation, she picked up a rather large box. A rather glitchy sound came from the inside.
As soon as she returned to her place next to Rayner, she opened the box - and out popped a pixelated ghost!
Rayner practically jumped out of his skin. "What in Equestria?!..." -
RE: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-09 13:53:00 UTC
Link to this
"That's a mini-Missingno," Chris commented. "Its name is cyndaquil, we 'adopted' it in our first mission, and as far as I know it doesn't eat."
cyndaquil laughed mockingly. "Hello, Glitter-girl, rainbow-boy!" It promptly phased through the thick book hanging from E.V.L.'s left ankle and reappeared on Rayner's back.
"Oh, yeah, and it has a rotten sense of humor," he said. "Have fun!" -
(Isn't it firemagic's turn?) by
on 2015-01-10 16:17:00 UTC
Link to this
Rayner facepalmed. "I should've known," he laughed. "I've run into some of those during some of my previous missions, but I've never actually kept one. I thought they were just too much trouble. Oh, well..."
"This one looks right up my alley, though," E.V.L. smiled, holding up the tip of her tail for the mini to perch on. "I can now say that I have a friend to bother my partner with."
"Yeah," Rayner chuckled. "I guess you... Hey!"
(Cepha's next in order btw. Earth to firemagic, do you copy?) -
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-07 11:56:00 UTC
Link to this
"Is it out turn now?" Rina asked, standing up. "It is? Okay!" She pointed at Tera. "Crowbar, please!"
Randa smacked her lightly on the arm. "Hey now, you can't be wasting our present on yourself," she chided.
Rina pouted. "Oh, fine." She picked up a little box instead. "How about this?" She handed it over to Randa, who tore off the paper in one swift movement. Both girls' eyes went huge.
"Is this what I think it is?" Randa asked, holding up a replica of Dumbledore's pocket watch.
Rina could only squee. -
"I think she skipped me," muttered the Guardsman... by
on 2015-01-07 21:18:00 UTC
Link to this
...as he watched the agents of RC 3-Apple-14 squee over the watch. "Yeah, she skipped me. Did she even memorize the order?"
"Well, just get on with it," whispered back Naya. "And stop complaining about everything to me. Just do something about it for goodness' sake."
The Guardsman stood up and approached the table. One packet-- a long, rectangular box-- stood out of the pile, but another-- a simple envelope-- caught the ex-soldier's attention. The picked it up and returned to his place. Once settled, he slid a finger down the side of the envelope and pulled out a photograph.
"Oh, lovely." The Gallifreyan man showed the photo to his partners. "See this? The Polaroid, capital 'P'. It's an item that, when its carrier is near death, generates an impenetrable shield for seven seconds. This is definitely going to be useful in a pinch."
"From what continuum does the Polaroid originate?" asked Terabyte.
"Eh, The Binding of Isaac, if I remember correctly," replied the Guardsman. "I just got the game recently. Awesome stuff, if a little difficult."
Naya leaned in close, looking at the photo. "I didn't know that there were Pokémon in that video game. Is it a crossover?"
"No, wha..." said the Guardsman, turning the photo over and taking a good look at it. "Oh. Never mind," he said, carefully putting the photo in his coat's pocket. -
((Wait, did I?!)) by
on 2015-01-08 00:44:00 UTC
Link to this
((Shoot, I'm so sorry. >_>))
-
Switcharoo time. by
on 2015-01-06 23:09:00 UTC
Link to this
"You, machine. Hand over the scarf."
Terabyte, who had been alternating between practicing to tie the scarf around its shoulders and feeling the fabric slide between its digits, froze in mid-motion and slowly looked up at the Librarian. Its camera-eyes dimmed and its three-fingered hands tightened around the fabric, then relaxed.
"Acknowledged," said the geth as it slowly undid the knot at its neck.
Upon seeing her partner visibly disappointed with this turn of events, Naya leaned towards the robot and coughed: "Takebacksies."
The geth turned to its quarian partner. "Message not received."
From Terabyte's other side, the Guardsman said: "He stole it from you, so you're now in play. You have the option to pick a gift from the pile or you can... steal someone's gift."
Realization flitted across Terabyte's face-- insomuch as emotion can be read from two luminous camera-eyes and a set of metal plates that might be considered eyebrows-- and the geth carefully folded up the scarf and walked over to the Librarian. The sentient AI gave the Time Lord the scarf, took a step back, then extended its right arm. "You, Gallifreyan. Hand over the scarf."
Terabyte looked back at its partners, then back at the Librarian. "Please," it added. -
((Just wanted to say that I LOL'd)) (nm) by
on 2015-01-07 02:38:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Re: Switcharoo time. by
on 2015-01-06 23:57:00 UTC
Link to this
"The scarf is now locked to Terabyte!" Rashida declared. "It cannot be stolen anymore."
"Alright, Des and Librarian," Sarah said cheekily. "It's your call. Again." -
Re: Switcharoo time. by
on 2015-01-07 11:20:00 UTC
Link to this
“Sorry, guys,” Des told Terabyte and his partners while giving the Librarian the evil eye until the Time Lord threw the scarf in the geth's general direction.
The Librarian returned to his corner, while Des looked around. He settled on picking a small, oblong package from the pile. Taking the silk wrapping off, he found a couple of throwing knives.
“Aren't those beautiful,” he said. -
In which the Librarian is a jerk! by
on 2015-01-06 21:57:00 UTC
Link to this
“Here,” Des said, “catch.” After making sure the safety was on, he nonchalantly threw the rifle to Rayner.
He turned to Cepha. “You really can't appreciate it, can't you? First things first, that box is pure adamentine. Have you any idea how much this thing is worth? Some fantasy world races would kill for a box like that one. Second, these aren't just “dried leaves”, dammit! It's Tippy Golden Flowery Orange Pekoe-quality Stygian Tea, which is, bar none, the best tea in the whole multiverse.” The bearded human pouted. “So show some respect.”
The Librarian, meanwhile, got up. “You, machine,” he told Terabyte. “Hand over the scarf.” -
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-04 06:58:00 UTC
Link to this
Rayner's mild interest in Miguel and his friends discussing their new present was cut short by his partner poking him again with her tail.
"Hey Pony Boy," she muttered in a clearly uninterested tone, "it's your turn."
"Huh? Oh, right!" He stood up and brushed back his multicolored hair, grinning in triumph.
"Y'know what, I might as well throw this gift-giving conga line a curveball and steal from somebody." He turned and pointed at Des and the Librarian. "The rifle, if you please!"
E.V.L. gave him a look that practically screamed, "What in Cocytus are you thinking?!"
"In case I need to off a Sue without making too much of a mess," he explained. The ex-Ficubus, unsurprisingly, did not look relieved at all. -
((So...)) by
on 2015-01-06 18:33:00 UTC
Link to this
((It's Des' turn now, right? I'm 90% sure of this but I just wanted to check.))
-
Re: ((So...)) by
on 2015-01-06 19:09:00 UTC
Link to this
(I sent a reminder to him a half hour ago. He should be getting a response ready soon.)
-
((Oh, okay.)) by
on 2015-01-06 19:59:00 UTC
Link to this
((I was starting to worry I somehow missed that it was my turn or something. ^_^))
-
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-04 03:52:00 UTC
Link to this
((For realsies this time.))
Miguel Correa glanced at the index card labeled "10" in his left hand. "Oh, it's my turn," he noted. "Chris, Ami, do you think I should introduce myself? I don't know anyone here besides Falchion, and..."
"If it makes you feel better, neither do we," Chris replied.
"It's kind of exciting, actually," Ami said, giggling. "Like we're meeting celebrities!"
Miguel laughed, too. "Thanks for the perspective, Ami." He picked a medium-sized box with snowman wrapping paper from the bottom of the pile. "Well, this looks interesting."
He opened it and was met with three very familiar smiling faces--Totoro (and his two nameless buddies), Mei, and Satsuki. "YES! We got some Hayao Miyazaki movies!"
Chris and Ami perked up instantly. "Excellent! How many?"
"Lemme check..." Miguel turned the box around and counted the DVDs. "Whoo, almost twenty. Which one should we watch first?" -
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-04 02:55:00 UTC
Link to this
((Hey, Skarmory. Just a heads-up: I done goofed and accidentally attributed the Grandine rifle to Des in one of my replies. Make sure to change it to the Lancer!))
- - - - -
As Amara puzzled over the tea leaves, Terabyte stood up and wandered over towards the coffee table. The robotic agent stared at the gift pile for a couple of seconds and grabbed a soft-looking package. The geth returned to its seat and, with machine precision, unwrapped the gift without tearing the wrapping paper. The robot lifted a faintly glowing red scarf out of the package and admired it.
"A scarf!" exclaimed the Artificial Intelligence as it ran its mech-digits though the knitted fabric. "It is very... pretty. I like it," said Terabyte as it tied the scarf around its neck.
Behind her opaque visor, Naya arched an eyebrow. "I think that's the first time you said you found something pretty. Keelah, that's so weird."
The Guardsman fake-wiped a tear from his eye. "Lookit, Naya. Our machine intelligence of a partner is learning the meaning of beauty! I'm so proud of him!"
"Don't ruin the moment, you jerk," shot back Naya with a playful swipe at her partner's shoulder. -
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-04 05:18:00 UTC
Link to this
Cepha looked over at the geth. "Ah! Amara made that. She knits a lot of stuff." The Puella Magi pointed at the white scarf she was wearing. "She was working on this when we first met. Though I don't think that her knitting has any magic powers in it." She gave a questioning look to Amara, who shrugged.
"Well, I do not know if it has any particular magical abilities. It is probably inherently magical, if that's quantifiable." -
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-04 01:56:00 UTC
Link to this
Cepha poked Amara in the side. The former Witch glanced up from where she had been knitting (what she had been knitting was indeterminable, given that she was using her hair-hands and regular hands at the same time.) "What is it?"
"It's your turn to go up and pick." Cepha nodded at the pile.
Amara set down her needles and walked over, staring intently at the presents before picking up a box and heading over to where the RC 1.877, 97, and 8888 groups had been sitting. She tore off the paper and held up a metal box. She pulled the lid off and frowned. "A metal box full of dried and shredded plants?" -
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-03 17:12:00 UTC
Link to this
((I'm going to ignore Eatpraylove's post. Seriously: not cool, dude.))
“Why am I even here?” asked the Librarian. He was sitting in a corner, as far away from everybody else as possible, having decided that leaning on the walls wasn't a good idea after having some Sar-plasm stick to his coat.
“Socialisation,” Des reminded him as he browsed the pile of gifts. The Librarian huffed, and Des gave him a doubting look before returning to the pile. He sat down, closed his eyes, and put his hand on a random gift. He picked it up – it was long and not quite light. Tearing the wrapping off, he revealed a vaguely ellipsoid rifle.
“Well, well, like I didn't have enough of those.” -
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-04 02:34:00 UTC
Link to this
Ari got up and walked over to Des and the Librarian's spot. "Hey, you two." She nodded at the package. "So... firearms? Is that a good rifle to have?" she asked with the mild confusion of someone who knew very little about firearm specifications.
-
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-04 03:09:00 UTC
Link to this
From her seat across the table, Naya laughed. "Hey, missy! That right there is probably one of the best rifles in the galaxy," said the quarian, pointing at the Lancer in Des' lap. "It's an automatic, air-cooled turbocharged mass accelerator that makes World One assault rifles look like paintball guns. It collapses into a little box when not in use, it almost never breaks down, it's crammed with stabilizers and recoil reduction systems, and it never runs out of ammunition during battle. It's the perfect rifle."
"Until it overheats," added the Guardsman. "Then the rifle just locks up and refuses to fire until the cooling systems kick in."
Naya sighed. "Yeah. It does overheat, but only after you squeeze out a 50-round burst, which you shouldn't be doing in the first place."
- - - -
((Collapsible firearms! Whee!)) -
((I'm sorry I'm a bad roleplayer. I'll start improving.)) (nm) by
on 2015-01-03 18:35:00 UTC
Link to this
-
(No offense taken. Just wait for your turn next time.) (nm) by
on 2015-01-03 19:14:00 UTC
Link to this
-
The Guardsman turned to look at the Librarian's corner... by
on 2015-01-03 17:44:00 UTC
Link to this
...hoping to catch the fellow Time Lord's eye but froze when he saw Des unwrap the rifle.
"What is that thing?" he whispered to his quarian partner. Naya looked up from the multimeter she had plugged into the maintenance port in Terabyte's robotic body and turned her gaze towards the Floater holding the rifle.
"No idea," she replied. "Hey, TB. Do you know what that rifle is?"
The geth turned in his seat to point his camera-eyes towards Des. "Searching... One possible match: Madoka Magica Online S-tier weapon: Grandine rifle. Special ammunition required for use."
"I don't know what that is, but I want it," said the Guardsman. "So how does present-stealing work again?"
"I think that we all take a gift for the first round, then we move on to a couple of stealing rounds," said Naya. "I guess we'll just sit back and watch for now."
The Guardsman nodded, eyes still fixed on the rifle. -
Re: The Guardsman turned to look at the Librarian's corner... by
on 2015-01-03 19:10:00 UTC
Link to this
"We're actually going to go through one round," Rashida explained. "So that means that if an agent is in play, they can steal from someone immediately. The person whose gift has been stolen from will be in play until another gift is chosen from the pile."
-
Re: The Guardsman turned to look at the Librarian's corner... by
on 2015-01-03 18:11:00 UTC
Link to this
((Also, the Grandine doesn't require any special ammo. It's magic! I suppose you could say that you need to be someone capable of using magic to use it, though the Puella Magi status of anyone in MMO is debatable, to say the least.))
-
Re: The Guardsman turned to look at the Librarian's corner... by
on 2015-01-03 18:02:00 UTC
Link to this
((Man, I'm bad at descriptions. That was supposed to be the Lancer.))
-
((Derp.)) by
on 2015-01-03 18:15:00 UTC
Link to this
((I forgot what the Lancer looked like, actually. Let's forget the Guardsman's little outburst, shall we?))
-
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange by
on 2015-01-03 03:03:00 UTC
Link to this
Miguel cleared his throat nervously. "Hello, everyone, my name's Miguel..."
"Hello, Miguel," half the crowd responded in their best Alcoholics Anonymous voices.
"Very funny. Uh, I'm working with Chris and Ami--" he indicated his partners "--and I hope I get to meet some of you later, once I know what I'm doing." He took a random large gift from the pile and opened it. "...A Guide to Poisons? Wow, that's morbid."
"Useful, though," Chris said with a shrug -
((Psst.)) by
on 2015-01-03 03:15:00 UTC
Link to this
((You seem to have skipped Des, Amara, and Terabyte's picks. Miguel gets the number 10 pick according to the tally sheet.))
-
Sidenote by
on 2015-01-03 16:05:00 UTC
Link to this
((It's also not very much fun to have someone dictate what characters other than their own do. So saying something like 'half the crowd responded' isn't great? Just a thing for future reference.))
-
((Ack! I swear I meant to put in "A short time later"!)) by
on 2015-01-03 03:43:00 UTC
Link to this
((This is what happens when you click "Post Reply" instead of "Edit Message by mistake >_
-
((Yes, but one of the three preceding agents...)) by
on 2015-01-03 03:54:00 UTC
Link to this
((...might've picked that gift. You gotta wait your turn, man.))
-
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-02 23:57:00 UTC
Link to this
Tera looked at the crowbar. " Doubt I'll be able to copy that trick."
Lana grinned. "Ah, that one's mine. Got it off an ATLA fic, if I remember right."
Narav considered the gameboard before moving one of his High Lord figures a few squares forward. "Ah, I believe I'm next?" He loped over to the pile and plucked out a small rectangular package out of the pile before walking back. The Canim, noticing that Theia had made her move, captured one of her Steadholder pieces and opened his gift, holding up a CD set. "Hm."
Lana and Riaa looked at their numbers. "Us now, I guess?" asked the drider. The two walked over and each grabbed a present out of the heap. Riaa tore hers open, holding up an oddly-shaped pendant, while Lana unwrapped a heavy camoflage vest. "Huh. This looks durable," the former Smoke Knight noted. -
"Ooh, the tactical vest. Good choice." by
on 2015-01-03 02:05:00 UTC
Link to this
The Guardsman shifted in his seat, looking at Lana. "As long as you make sure the ceramic plates are intact and that you're wearing the thing properly, this should stop all but the biggest chinks of metal from getting to you. I'm not gonna lie, it's heavy as heck, the deltoid protectors sometimes get in the way, and you sweat bullets with this on your back but the vest can stop most things up to and including seven-point-six-two rounds. Well, I say 'can'. It all depends how close you're standing to the shooter and the angle of penetration of course... but I digress. If ever you need to replace the ceramic plates, you can get some more at the Armoury."
- - -
((Here is a better view of the vest. Note that the shoulder pieces and the groin protector are Kevlar only, but technically speaking those parts of the body aren't as "important" as, say, your heart. Hence the ballistic plates: these things work.)) -
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-03 01:19:00 UTC
Link to this
E.V.L. huffed apathetically at Riaa. "Oh, you got the amulet? That was from my first mission with this rainbow-haired meathead right here," she said, lightly poking Rayner in the cheek with her tail. He scowled and pushed the tail away.
"The Sue of the MLP fic we tackled that time received an amulet from Twilight Sparkle to contain the magic of the four alicorn princesses," he explained. "We restored the magic once we tore her like, oh, twenty new assholes or something. So we figured we'd keep the necklace as a souvenir. Well, at least until now, anyway!"
Falchion and Ami looked at each other, their faces sharing identical expressions of considerable discomfort. -
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-02 20:26:00 UTC
Link to this
[A/N: If any of you recognize the gifts belonging to your agents, feel free to respond to the recipients with their reactions!]
Sarah burst out laughing. "That crowbar belonged to my mother! I wasn't there to see it, but from what I heard, she was able to store it inside her cleavage! Don't ask how that works, seriously..."
A number of other players burst out laughing, the rest of them murmuring amongst each other in a mixture of confusion and amusement.
"All right, my turn!" Sarah cheered, stepping up to the pile. After a few seconds' deliberation, she picked up a rather long package, moved back to her place next to her brother, and opened it up.
"Brrrr, is it cold in here or is it just me?" she asked, picking up the two-handed sword whose blade seemed to exude some kind of frosty vapor.
"Careful!" Rashida snarled before her partner could swing it around. "You could take someone's head off with that!" -
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-02 20:29:00 UTC
Link to this
[Correction: That should be "Sarah started giggling uncontrollably." Don't want any repeated sentences!]
-
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-02 18:56:00 UTC
Link to this
Agent Theia looked at her number. "Guess I'm going first, then?" She asked. She stood up from where she'd been playing ludus with Agent Narav and prodded Tera.
"What?"
"You're number 2, aren't you?" Theia nodded at the slip of paper in Tera's claws. The two agents walked up to the gift heap. "Well, let's see then." She looked at the variously-shaped presents and grabbed a gift wrapped in paper with pictures of cheery zombies on it and went back to her spot, moving her Steadholder piece up to the skyboard.
Tera frowned at the heap. " So I shall take... this one! " She grabbed an oblong present and headed back to where she had been working her way through a small hill of holiday cookies. -
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-02 19:28:00 UTC
Link to this
Sarah looked at the two of them, a little taken aback. "Oookay... I'm number 3, which means I'm going after you two, but... aren't you supposed to open up your gifts and show what you got to everyone before the next round?"
"She's right," added E.V.L. "Maybe we should all know what we got immediately rather than have everyone open up their presents all at once." -
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-02 19:46:00 UTC
Link to this
[[OOC: Huh, ok, I thought we were only supposed to find out what was gotten at the end. I guess I'll just pick randomly out of the list on the GDOC?]]
Theia looked up. "Oh, right, sorry." She carefully unwrapped her gift and held up an egg. "...Uh, what is this an egg from?"
Tera shrugged and tore open her box, pulling out a crowbar. "Huh. Guess this'll be handy for something." -
Re: The PPC New Year's Gift Exchange! by
on 2015-01-02 23:53:00 UTC
Link to this
Rina's eyes grew huge when she saw the crowbar; her fingers were already itching to steal it.
Randa, meanwhile, nodded at the egg in Theia's hands. "That's from our adopted CAF- a Hedwig replacement that barks. You might want to put it back in the incubator."
-
The ROTBTD wiki by
on 2015-01-02 16:20:00 UTC
Link to this
Not sure if I got the acronym right, but"Rise of the Brave Tangled Twisted Dragons"would not fit in the title line. Anyway,I noticed there is a ROTBTD wiki located at http://rise-of-the-brave-tangled-dragons.wikia.com/ and it is currently unmaintained. Recently there has been quite a bit of flaming and everyone posting profanity etc. Should I attempt to maintain this wiki? I an not sure if fanfiction in this continuum is badfic or not but fanfics are not currently posted here, only information. Suggestions anyone? I will need someone to help out with the tangled part of the wiki as I have never seen that movie.
-
Oh my word. by
on 2015-01-05 16:03:00 UTC
Link to this
Just looking at their Recent Activity... how does a page like Jackunzel (the Jack Frost/Rapunzel pairing, it turns out) end up with 500 comments, and 42 attached pictures, and 20 linked fanfics? The wiki itself only has 500 pages - how on earth is there that much activity on just one random page?
No, seriously. Honest question. I understand the PPC Wiki being large - we have a unified fandom which may well be unique, come to think of it - but this is... surely nothing more than a list of popular crossovers? How do people even find it, let alone decide to post endless comments?
hS is a baffled hS -
activity by
on 2015-01-05 20:39:00 UTC
Link to this
I had no idea out was so popular, do you have an opinion on if I should maintain it or not? I still can't find anything on tumblr. :l
-
Opinions? Not really. by
on 2015-01-05 21:06:00 UTC
Link to this
If by 'maintain' you mean go in as a vigilante and start deleting things the fandom in question has put in, I'd advise against it - people like to sort out their own messes (or don't see them as messes). If you mean something else... then I don't know what it is. ;)
hS -
That is not what I meant exactly... by
on 2015-01-05 21:32:00 UTC
Link to this
I was thinking more along the lines of cleaning up all the profanity and vandalism, then blocking all of the sock puppets.
-
Re: That is not what I meant exactly... by
on 2015-01-06 09:25:00 UTC
Link to this
As hS has already pointed out, it's hard to know where to draw the line. On the other hand, maybe the wiki could benefit from having someone neutral who isn't invested in a lot of ships, so I'm not opposed to you trying to clean up. Then again, I could imagine it is a thankless job, so you could maybe consider digging up a neglected wiki for a small fandom that you love and instead contributing there with content?
Anyway, if this is something your heart is really set on, we're not here to stop you. As long as you don't claim to be cleaning up the wiki on behalf of PPC, it's simply something you're doing in your free time.
One piece of advice, however: Start slowly and get to to know some of the other users. No-one likes it when somebody comes out of nowhere and starts editing with a hatchet, no matter how well-intentioned and how much it might be needed. -
How do you choose? by
on 2015-01-06 08:52:00 UTC
Link to this
Profanity I guess, though you could argue that on a shipping wiki, there's certain words that might be accepted by the readers as descriptive. Vandalism? Maybe the obvious stuff, but where do you draw the line? Serious edits could look like vandalism if you don't know what they're about.
And 'sock puppets' -- eesh, I'd just leave that one well alone. Let them edit however they like; the very notion of a sock puppet implies a one-account-only rule, which they may not have or want to enforce.
hS -
autocorrect by
on 2015-01-05 20:40:00 UTC
Link to this
That should say it not out. :l
-
I'm not sure we're the right people to ask. by
on 2015-01-02 17:43:00 UTC
Link to this
Seems to me this is a question for people who are fans of this crossover universe. There might be some here, you never know, but someone else's fanon wiki isn't really the concern of the PPC at large. According to the RotBTD wiki, it's big on Tumblr. Maybe look there for support?
(And by the way, hi! Nice to see you here. ^_^ Sorry I didn't greet you in your intro thread; I was busy when you posted it and I never quite got back around to it.)
~Neshomeh -
Tumblr? by
on 2015-01-03 00:13:00 UTC
Link to this
Yeah, I only posted this here because I thought if there was a lot of badfics in this continuum I could help push it in the right direction. Where did you see anything about tumblr? I looked around and could not find anything.
-
Tumblr. by
on 2015-01-03 04:17:00 UTC
Link to this
It's mentioned here, in the History of the Fandom section.
Like firemagic said, it's not really a continuum in the sense of warranting PPC protection in and of itself, since it's not an officially licensed publication. The individual films involved, sure, but PPCing a crossover with their "Big Four" wouldn't be any different from PPCing any other bad crossover from the PPC's perspective. The popularity of crossing these particular films might warrant mention, but not more than the popularity of crossing everything under the sun with Harry Potter, IMO. *shrug*
~Neshomeh -
The thing is... by
on 2015-01-03 03:22:00 UTC
Link to this
You can't really mission this as a continuum. There is no Word of God on the ROTwhatever verse, just a lot of people's headcanons and fics (frankly I'm not sure why a wiki would even be a useful tool for this in the first place.)
And Nesh very clearly brought up the topic of Tumblr, and did not mention it because of your posts. And she brought it up because that megacrossover seems to have been bred and raised on Tumblr blogs, and therefore, the people who talk a lot about it on Tumblr would likely be the closest thing to authorities on the subject.
-
Agent Exploitation of Suefics? by
on 2015-01-03 09:56:00 UTC
Link to this
There has been a question that has been on my mind for the last... ten minutes. And now I wonder if it's kind of stupid because there may be some kind of critical safeguard against it either in the organization or in the PPC canon that I am overlooking.
Have any Agents ever attempted to exploit a Sue/Stufic for their own (usually questionable) motives? Like, have any power-hungry, envious, and/or insecure Agents ever attempted to go rogue and usurp a Sue/Stu to gain their powers and/or position in life? Or maybe Agents who use questionable means to amass Sue byproducts en masse for whatever reasons?
I have heard of ruthless Agents like Agent X, but she seems more like an anti-Sue extremist than someone with an agenda. -
Could be an interesting story. by
on 2015-01-05 15:56:00 UTC
Link to this
I mean, we write all these violent psychopaths, but they all spend their time focussed on their jobs. We know that there's a Department of Internal Affairs, and we know they've been expanding recently - but we don't have much information as to why. There must be agents being locked up to necessitate the existence of a jail, right?
So what could you do, with access to all the multiverse's Stuff(TM)? Political power in your home universe? If you could get a Sue to serve you and use their reality-warping powers on important people, you could pull it off (think of whichever Thursday Next book it was that happened in). Selling addictive drugs? I'm sure something in a Sue's body must qualify.
And if you go outside the realm of strictly Sue exploitation, you've got Morgan's little breakdown, or even something as simple as mass-producing invisible yarn. So maybe it's best to stay focussed on your original question...
As Cassie said, exploiting the stuff we're here to oppose would get you punished - if you were caught. So the trick is not to get caught...
hS -
I had an idea of that kind. by
on 2015-01-05 19:46:00 UTC
Link to this
Due to my Agents' personalities, they could reach the point where they would choose the safety/happiness of canon characters over ensuring that canon happenings... well, happen. Think about Huinesoron's Ispace, only that we have only three Agents focusing on a single continuum (Puella Magi Madoka Magica. The Rebellion movie left a bitter taste in my mouth for months).
I dropped the idea because, despite the fact that there were some interesting concepts to be applied to it, it would risk ending up as a messy battle royale between Team Turbo, PPC, Akuma Homura, Incubators and whatever way to counter Akuma Homura the hotheaded Ally of Justice! Sayaka can come up with.
I can elaborate on the concept if someone is succumbing to morbid curiosity, though. -
Actually the subject of some WIP stories of mine! (nm) by
on 2015-01-05 17:37:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Yeah, what Cassie said. by
on 2015-01-03 23:46:00 UTC
Link to this
Also, who are you? Just in case you're a newbie, have some extra-buttery popcorn!
-
Re: Yeah, what Cassie said. by
on 2015-01-04 19:05:00 UTC
Link to this
Actually, I lurk around here once in a blue moon. I originally joined like a year ago.
-
Spoiler alert for PPC stuffs. by
on 2015-01-03 12:38:00 UTC
Link to this
At one point the entire PPC was doing that, under the leadership of the Mysterious Somebody. Materials harvested from Suefics were being sold to canon worlds to create revenue for the PPC. Given what else was going on and linked to it (see: The Reorganisation), it shouldn't come as a surprise that all such things were eventually clamped down on with extreme prejudice. Anyone caught doing such things now would likely be severely punished.
-
Paging hS. by
on 2015-01-03 12:39:00 UTC
Link to this
Not sure if you're aware, but Tangled Webs is down, and with it all your PPC stories including The Reorganisation and Lofty Skies.
-
Oh for Bast's sake. by
on 2015-01-03 19:23:00 UTC
Link to this
Fixed. But if they're going to keep doing this, I'll seriously consider moving the entire site over to Google's recently-released HTML-capable Drive addon. I don't want to do that, because of the amount of work involved, but at this point...
Thanks, Cassie, for letting me know.
hS
-
A question of minis by
on 2015-01-04 15:10:00 UTC
Link to this
Is it possible to have minis from a quarantined continuum? I ask because I have mini ideas for A Song of Ice and Fire, and I know that I've misspelled at least Daenerys's name before (and you can hardly blame me, even in-universe that name is a mouthful).
-
Not really. by
on 2015-01-04 16:05:00 UTC
Link to this
The continuum is quarantined because the author has asked that no-one write fanfic about it, and we in the PPC respect that. Writing about a creature from that continuum - even a miniature version - would be writing fanfic of it. So no.
hS -
Dangit, I thought I had a good idea... by
on 2015-01-05 15:07:00 UTC
Link to this
What I had in mind was that the minis would be heraldry, based on the House the misspelled name relates to.
For instance, Stark misspellings would make mini-direwolves, Lannisters mini-lions, Targaryens mini-dragons, Arryns mini-falcons, Baratheons mini-crowned stags, Tullys mini-trout, and Greyjoys mini-krakens.
The ones not related to Westeros would probably get approximated heraldry; Dothraki would be mini-horses, or Slaver's Bay minis mini-harpies.
Of course, I've had "genius ideas" before that turned out to be anything but. I don't know what you guys think of this. -
Well, minis have a process of sorts. by
on 2015-01-05 15:43:00 UTC
Link to this
Even if George R.R. Martin were to open his world to fanfiction - unlikely - it isn't the PPC specifically who decide minis for a 'verse, but the person who writes an OFU for it.
Personally, I don't know what I'd go with for that 'verse. For all there are some nasty creatures out there - most notably for me, the Wights and Walkers, the true evil is always very clearly the characters' lust for power. -
Usually, anyway. by
on 2015-01-05 16:13:00 UTC
Link to this
In the absence of an OFU, whoever first writes a mission to the 'verse and encounters minis gets to decide what the minis are. (It's polite to have a discussion about it first, though.)
I'd be inclined to use mini-White Walkers, personally, since they pretty much threaten everyone equally. Or, since humanoid minis creep some people out (though I dunno if that necessarily applies to clearly monstrous humanoids), maybe mini-winters. They'd be like little mobile blizzards. Maybe with glowing blue eyes set in the clouds. That might be too cartoony, but I kinda like the idea of OFU students retreating through the halls shouting "Mini-winter is coming! Mini-winter is coming!"
Alas, GRRM is unlikely to change his mind about fanfic anytime soon, so this must remain a hypothetical discussion.
~Neshomeh -
Wait, discussion?! by
on 2015-01-05 23:29:00 UTC
Link to this
Uhhh... *raises hand sheepishly* Are mini-Kalkara still okay?
-
Oh... minis need discussion? by
on 2015-01-05 16:39:00 UTC
Link to this
My target fic for if/when I get Permission is a crossover... for two continua that have yet to be represented in the PPC, and both have minis. They're Prototype and Monster Musume, which I'm sure most people on the Board don't know about.
You mentioned discussion, so I figured I should.
Monster Musume: In lieu of actual enemy creatures, I'd go with mini-Suu: http://dailylifewithamonstergirl.wikia.com/wiki/Suu
Well, not in her usual form. Suu can regress to a small, antenna-ed blob if she's dehydrated, which I think is what a mini-Suu would be.
Prototype: I believe mini-Brawlers would serve here: http://prototype.wikia.com/wiki/Brawler_Hunter
Brawlers are the weakest and most common type of Infected in NYZ, after the basic walkers.
-
Is this happening to anyone else? by
on 2015-01-05 02:31:00 UTC
Link to this
So, this evening, I've been trying to edit various pages on the Wiki. Every time I click "Publish", though, it tells me the connection was refused, and when I click the button to go back, the "Publish" button is grayed out. When I refresh the page, it acts like my edits were there all along and doesn't say anything under "Recent Activity".
Please help me understand what's going on here! -
Something similar? by
on 2015-01-05 19:46:00 UTC
Link to this
If I edit anything more significant than, say, removing a category, I go to a blank page with the URL having action=submit added to the page name. The edits are still saved, so I shrugged and kept going.
-
I just tried editing my user page; no trouble. by
on 2015-01-05 03:44:00 UTC
Link to this
It sounds like you're having some kind of connection issue.
While we're on the subject of the wiki, though, could I ask you to please stop editing for matters of simple word choice? One of the first things I learned in my editing internship was never edit unless you can back it up with the rules; you let the author use their own voice as much as possible. For instance, on the Mary Sue page, you recently changed "does not" to "doesn't" and "there's the rub" to "there we have the main problem". The first change doesn't do a thing to aid clarity and actually de-emphasizes a statement I was trying to emphasize, and the second merely replaces an informal turn of phrase with a formal one. Not only are those kinds of changes unnecessary—the first in particular, and the second because PPC Wiki should not be as dry as a textbook—they're also mildly insulting when they're done on pages I wrote. I know I'm not perfect, and I don't mind edits that improve clarity or straighten out backward phrasing, but editing simply because you would have used different words to say the same thing is not cool. Please don't.
~Neshomeh -
Thanks for the advice. *sheepish smile* (nm) by
on 2015-01-05 13:55:00 UTC
Link to this
-
A PPC Comic? by
on 2015-01-07 00:10:00 UTC
Link to this
First off, I want to say that me and my friend have a PPC comic for our agents in the works. Get a special account Tumblr. or DA, the whole nine yards. Of course, since I want to practice my artistry skills,and you want to see your agents in glorious technicolor I propose this thrilling idea. If you guys write a script, be it for a mission you have already done or one you have yet to do, I will draw it. And yes, post the link on this site. If you are going to submit a script, please describe your agents, their RC, and of course leave a link to the fic. You will be fully credited as a writer, and get to nit pick my rough sketches.
Email me at emilybearcub@yahoo.com if you want to hear more or just want to pick my brain. -
This would be different by
on 2015-01-09 15:26:00 UTC
Link to this
Depending on what you chose, you might have to come up with a visual appearance for some really weird concepts--we have punctuation showers and Words already, but what's a line break going to look like? A tidal wave of hyphens?
-
Or an animated glich . (nm) by
on 2015-01-09 15:50:00 UTC
Link to this
-
An actual line breaking, maybe? by
on 2015-01-10 17:47:00 UTC
Link to this
Just a brief animation of a black line on a white background, creaking under the strain before shattering into little bits like a bomb going off.
My four penn'orth, anyway. =] -
Nice Idea. (nm) by
on 2015-01-11 03:11:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Sounds intriguing. by
on 2015-01-07 03:41:00 UTC
Link to this
Of course, I'd need to consult with Randa on letting someone borrow her agent... If there was a mission I'd give you, it would probably be the one with the Sue who turned into a loin. It's short and, best of all, you wouldn't need to worry about pretty background art due to the lack of description the setting got. ;)
Also, lucky you! I already have my RC's floor plan mapped out- all I'd need to do would be scan and upload it. -
BRB, compiling (Un)Intelligence's first episode... by
on 2015-01-07 02:22:00 UTC
Link to this
...in script format. I'll post here with the result some time later this week.
-
I'd be totally on board with this, but... by
on 2015-01-07 01:36:00 UTC
Link to this
...the thing is, my missions are so ridonkeybonkulously (is that even a word?) long that making comics of them could take months, if not years. For example, the first one - and the most likely to be adapted for the sake of character introduction - is 87 pages long, and in comic form it'd practically be a graphic novel!
My collab with eatpraylove may be short enough to qualify, though. If she's okay with it too, that is. -
Of course! by
on 2015-01-07 01:40:00 UTC
Link to this
You can also write new fics and send them to me directly if you want. I understand the length thing, you should see the script for my graphic novel/webcomic thing.
Again, just email me, and we discuss more once you talk to your collaborator. -
Color me intrigued. by
on 2015-01-07 00:38:00 UTC
Link to this
First of all, though, do you and/or your friend have permission to write PPC stories? You'd need that to write a comic about your agents, too, since it would still be a thing set in the PPC universe.
That said, two questions:
1. Do you have samples of your work posted somewhere we could take a look?
2. What exactly do you need in a script that you wouldn't get working straight from the text of an existing mission?
Finally, a word of caution: Others have attempted to make PPC comics in the past, and aside from Generic Surface, which was made with photos of Lego sculptures, none have succeeded that I'm aware of. Writing a mission is a lot of work, and illustrating one would be a lot MORE work. I hope you know what you're getting into!
~Neshomeh -
Yes, Whelp,and Explanation by
on 2015-01-07 01:27:00 UTC
Link to this
Me and my friend have had Permission for some time now, but any missions with claimed fics have been delayed due to OC idiocy. With that now sorted, we can start producing stories.
In the way of easily showing my art, my DA hasn't updated since I've had it, and my Tumblr. is still under serious construction.
That being said, I will be uploading a lot more recent and *E-HERM* better drawn art. ( Seriously. Don't look at my DA. It has art from the sixth grade there.) I can then post a link here and people can decide wheather they like my art or not.
Script wise, things like a highlight of props, settings and weapons design.
And I know exactly what I'm getting into. Thats why I'm telling the world.
-
Theory time? by
on 2015-01-07 15:01:00 UTC
Link to this
So. Who wants to present fan theories on their favorite works of fiction? Doesn't matter how huge or minor the theory is, how crazy, or how obscure the fandom is. Bring 'em in.
And hey, I actually have one from A Song of Ice and Fire that I thought of myself.
Readers of this series: You know the one-eared black tomcat that's hanging around the Red Keep? I think I know his name: Balerion. I believe that the cat that wreaks petty (ha) havoc on Robert's court is Rhaenys' kitten, all grown up and angry at the people that killed his owner. Of course, he's just a cat, so he can't do much more than irritate people. He is a significant nuisance, though, and he does attack ravens... I wonder if that means anything... naaaah, couldn't be! -
Doctor Who theory (Series 8 spoilers). by
on 2015-01-13 10:10:00 UTC
Link to this
The light-creatures from In the Forest of the Night - the Here, according to the subtitles - are Vashta Nerada.
Both species have a strong connection with trees - the Vashta are ubiquitous in arboreal environments, while the Here identify themselves as the lifeforce or spirit of trees. Both are nearly-invisible specks in the air, not pulled down by gravity. Both are capable of rational thought, at least in large numbers, but can't communicate except by convoluted methods (memory chips, psychic crazy girls). And, of course, the episode titles of 'Forest of the Dead' and '(In the) Forest of the Night' are pretty close together.
Yes, the Vashta Nerada were malevolent, while the Here protected the earth - but both acted in response to a threat to their habitat. In the Library, they were living in processed wood, which can't have been very comfortable for them if they're intimately connected to trees. People wandering around reading the books was a threat to them. Back on Earth, the solar flare would have wiped them out; they weren't protecting humanity per se, so much as their own ecosystem.
And of course there's one other related species (in the new series): given another five billion years of evolution, the Vashta Nerada will learn to inhabit and 'awaken' the trees they're linked to. Ultimately, their line will lead to the Forest of Cheem, and to Jabe, who was present when the sun finally overwhelmed the Earth.
hS -
Really interesting! by
on 2015-01-13 10:46:00 UTC
Link to this
Perhaps they spread and spread through time, carried in someone's book back far into the prehistory of the earth... back to when the Ents were "awakened". Just a thought. =]
-
Or indeed the other way round. by
on 2015-01-13 11:07:00 UTC
Link to this
They did claim to have been Here all along, after all.
If they were created with Arda, then when Yavanna awakened the Ents it would've been by force-evolving the Vashta Nerada to the 'make a tree sentient' stage. Huorns are then explained by Ents sharing their VN with normal trees, and taking back non-evolved VN in trade - the trees become more Entish, and the Ents become more treeish, exactly as Tolkien described.
And of course we know that the 'Entish' trees still exist today - there's one on the grounds at Hogwarts, isn't there? (In fact, isn't that a willow? Do... do we know for sure that it's not Old Man Willow? I'm sure we could jig the map to place the Old Forest in Scotland if we tried...)
(...)
(... someone please confirm that there exists Old Man Willow/Whomping Willow slash)
hS -
OH GOD WHY WOULD YOU SAY THAT?! *gouges eyes with spork* by
on 2015-01-13 13:27:00 UTC
Link to this
On the other hand, a DW/HP/LotR crossover based solely on trees? Dude, sign me up!
-
Totally writing that. by
on 2015-01-13 14:26:00 UTC
Link to this
It's more of a perspective piece than an actual story, but what did you expect when the main character is an ephemeral collection of mindless specks who only gain intelligence when in large numbers?
hS -
Only it got more complicated. :(? :)? by
on 2015-01-13 15:48:00 UTC
Link to this
I've found the story hidden in the 'Vashta Nerada mythology'; so I guess I'll be writing that instead? Once I figure out the timelines...
hS -
On it. >=o] (nm) by
on 2015-01-13 12:51:00 UTC
Link to this
-
My own pet theory... (plus some rebranding) by
on 2015-01-09 16:36:00 UTC
Link to this
Coming to you live from the dimmer recesses of my brain and bits of a mostly-forgotten physics education, may I present:
The magic of Harry Potter is actually a quantum field effect with observable results in a macro-scale universe.
Hear me out on this. The Potterverse is a strange, strange place at the best of time, but one of the more consistent bits of weirdness is the idea - patently wrong - that "Muggle technology" doesn't work at Hogwarts. Okay, I get that J.K. probably meant "Muggle science" by that (which doesn't really work either, unless - ah, but that's a discussion for another day), but she used a specific term and I'm running with it.
See, Muggle technology does work in the Wizarding World. We see the great spinning gear setups and locking-bars of the vault doors at Gringotts - mechanisms that work in harmony with magical defences, including whatever the Thief's Downfall is and a dragon (of the non-literal-five-headed variety). Hagrid has a dirty great crossbow firing bolts the size of a small tree, and crossbows (even hand-draw ones) are complicated bits of kit. The Flying Ford Anglia seems perfectly content in the grounds, though I'm not too super-duper sure that that one counts since it's kept going by magic kind of sorta maybe a bit but the headlights work and guh weird.
So, we know that mechanical stuff works. We also see in the films that Luna's knackered Converse (her trackie bottoms tucked in socks, alas, remain unpictured; anyone getting that reference deserves prizes) don't dissolve or anything, so we can safely assume that modern materials like plastics and so forth aren't subject to the effects. However, I'd wager that with the advent of portable electronics - presumably battery-operated torches, Walkmans, boomboxes, digital alarm clocks, and so forth, I mean, it's set from the early-Seventies to mid-Nineties - stuff started going haywire. Why?
Field interference.
See, if we look at magic as an observable phenomenon able to be replicated under laboratory conditions, which it is, assuming there's a wizard in the lab, it becomes obvious. "Magic" is some sort of deeply weird quantum field - and since every field has an associated particle, that's what is interacting with the electronic artifacts brought into Hogwarts by Muggleborn students. If we also assume that magic particles - which I'll call "thaums" for convenience and because I, like everyone else here, am a colossal nerd - act like neutrinos, permeating the world around them and passing through like it ain't no thang. However, they disrupt other fields... like the electromagnetic field, for instance. Like the one you use to read this and parse it into knowledge, also known as brain activity.
Major disruptions would probably cause strokes and so forth, but there's going to be a subset of people who can use it for some biological advantage. But that brings up the old saw of "Why isn't magic evolutionarily selected for?" To which I respond: see previous sentence. Perhaps the rates of strokes and brain damage and so forth were too great in those hypersensitive to this field - something that, even after the advent of effective medical care (which, for all its faults, the Wizarding World got to long before the Muggle one did) - meant that for the longest time, the trait was simply unprofitable from a genetic standpoint. But then someone figures out a healing spell, and everything changes.
BTW, healing spells and stuff that directly affects living matter, like transfiguration? I'd wager that was the first stuff to be discovered... though probably after some kind of proto-Killing Curse. People are warlike. I haven't got that much more to say on that, tbh. It doesn't interest me
Now, though... now there are effective treatments. It's like a genetic defect that people live with, like a tendency towards sickle-cell anaemia or something, it just happens to come with the side effects of flying broomsticks and magical creatures (which I accept this theory does little to explain, though I'd wager they came first). Magic users are, through good old genetic altruism, allowing other magic users to survive and thrive, getting a hold of their powers so that their heads do not a splode. Perhaps that's what Merlin was, the last of the really sensitive wizards. Perhaps magic's slowly coming back, finding a level between Muggle and "Ka-Boom Oopsie There Go My Eyeballs" that's suitable for further recreation.
There's an awful lot of perhapses here, but I think it's okay.
Also, this is wobblestheclown, rebranded and revamped and hopefully less of an angry tosspot this time around.
=] -
Quantum Field Magic by
on 2015-01-10 15:51:00 UTC
Link to this
Well, most people don’t think of wedges and screws as "technology", but where did you get "Muggle technology doesn't work at Hogwarts" anyway? I only remember Hermione saying 'All those substitutes for magic Muggles use – electricity, and computers and radar, and all those things – they all go haywire around Hogwarts, there’s too much magic in the air' (GF 28). Since computers and radar and, by extension, "all those things" use electricity, Hermione apparently doesn’t believe that non-electric Muggle technology doesn’t work at Hogwarts.
I always wondered whether Hermione got this wrong, JKR didn’t think it through, or this is a deliberate setup for a future change in Muggle-wizard-relationships.
If Hermione got it wrong or was misled by Hogwarts: A History, which is not always accurate, the teachers may have set up some anti-electronics charms to prevent "Gaming Boys" and "Walking Men" disturbing their lessons and distracting the students from their homework.
If magic interferes with electricity, then every electric device is a crude magic-detector. Muggles would realize that such things like cell phones don’t work in certain areas of London (around the Ministry of Magic, and probably St. Mungo’s). Muggle scientists wouldn’t think of magic, but they would investigate, and find periodic fluctuations correlated to rush hours (when hundreds of employees apparate to or from the MoM). Since sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic, and sufficiently researched magic is indistinguishable from science, in the end it wouldn’t matter whether the scientists call spell casters "wizards" or "human sources of anti-electronic quantum fields".
Does the MoM monitor scientific publications? Would they be aware of such research and try to stop it? Even if some scientists were obliviated, the accumulated data would still be there and could be found by other scientists. What do wizards know about sensor networks, cloud computing, and the world-wide web? To prevent Muggles learning about magic, the wizards would need to learn much more about Muggles, so either way their relationship would change.
I never considered that using magic might interfere with brain activity in other ways than deliberately casted spells, but now I think that you are on something there.
Dr. rer. nat. Hieronymus Graubart, future Nobel prize candidate for discovering the mathematics of magic. (Not really. "The Mathematics of Magic" already exists, but since it is a novella by L. Sprague de Camp and Fletcher Pratt, it is called "Arithmancy" in the Potterverse.) -
It's a knotty problem, this... by
on 2015-01-10 17:44:00 UTC
Link to this
I was fairly certain it came up across the series that magic and electronics don't mix, but the thing is, wedges and screws are technology. A simple lever is technology. It's something artificial that does something the human body cannot do.
Also, this might just be me, but I've seen plenty of fics where magic just stops any and all technology from working. It's at the to the point where I wonder if the authors have got the wrong Harry.
Personally, though, I was thinking that once Muggles caught up - about now-ish would be a pretty good bet for that to happen, or at least in the next decade or so - to the point where the Statute of Secrecy was pretty pointless, they'd just get rid of it. Part of the reason for it given by a few people (I forget exactly who) is that Muggles would constantly badger them for magical solutions to Muggle problems, which seems plausible until you realise that just makes you a race of fantastic washing-machine repairmen. Magic can do so much more than that, and I reckon that once the Statute DOES come down (I have no idea how well Unplottable landscapes show up on satellite imaging, but it's probably not a risk anyone wants to take) then a lot of Muggleborn wizards and witches will take part in research programs. If nothing else, it's more beer vouchers for uni. =]
As an aside, given that Arthur Weasley is supposed to be a foremost expert on Muggle tech at the Ministry's Misuse of Muggle Artifacts Office, I think we can safely say that they're not exactly getting copies of physics journals in the letterbox. For one thing, they tend to be fairly weighty things, and frankly that'd be animal cruelty. =] -
I agree. by
on 2015-01-10 19:33:00 UTC
Link to this
Wedges and bolts are technology. I wondered whether JKR may have said in an interview that magic and Muggle technology don’t mix, because she said a lot of nonsense when she didn’t have time to think about it, or to look up which subplots only existed in her mind and which had actually made it into the books.
As far as I’m aware, Hermione’s retort to Harry’s suggestion that Rita "The Bug" Skeeter might have "bugged" Hogwarts is the only canonical reference to "magic and electronics don't mix". Fanon may have blown this up to "all technology stops working when magic is involved". I wouldn’t know. I actually don’t read much fan fiction. Rereading the books and filling the plot holes is more satisfying.
"Muggles would constantly badgerthem[us] for magical solutions to Muggle problems." That would be Hagrid (translated from Hagrid-speech) answering Harry’s question in Chapter 5 of Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone. I read this as JKR’s way to avoid mentioning witch hunts in a children’s book. Witch hunts are only brought up in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, meant for a slightly older audience, and even then in a humorous way. I’ve always seen the Statute of Secrecy as an act of humanity. It was the only way to make Muggles forget that magic is real, so that they no longer burned each other based on wrong accusations. And that’s the problem with Muggles catching up – are we really so much more reasonable nowadays?
Unplottable regions and satellite imaging, electronic magic-detectors, Muggles catching up, wizards trying to stay hidden, or wizards abandoning the Statute of Secrecy – so much potential for fan fiction set in the twenty-first century. I suppose it’s mostly unused, and all we get are next generation regurgitations of the original series?
HG -
Perhaps... by
on 2015-01-10 21:39:00 UTC
Link to this
Though part of that may simply J.K. not really wanting to write near-future SF - or not considering herself equipped to do so. Which is fair enough, as far as I'm concerned; she's made her millions, she has a new project in the form of the Cormoran Strike series (underrated, IMO, but I love a good 'orrible muuuuuurdah)... maybe it's best left to us?
There's also potential for a far-future fic, though inevitably you'd get reviews from anime cognoscenti calling you a rip-off of the admittedly excellent To The Stars, which you should definitely read if you have even a passing familiarity with Puella Magi Madoka Magica, and frankly, if you don't, read it anyway. Delicious musings on the presence of AI in society that I won't be able to get anywhere else since Iain M. Banks has died. -
I think what technology works depends on its complexity. by
on 2015-01-11 05:07:00 UTC
Link to this
There are constant (well, maybe not constant, but a few) references to characters checking their watches while at Hogwarts. The most notable example I can think of is how Harry mentions his watch stopped working after doing the Second Task.
I'm pretty sure there's also a mention of Ron looking at his watch in the first book (outside the portrait of the Fat Lady when telling Hermione she'd better not make them late for the duel) and probably other references I'm forgetting.
Also, the magical community has been seen using enchanted clocks (like the Weasleys'), magical watches (like Dumbledore's), enchanted cameras (like Colin's, the one Lockhart's photographer used, the one Rita Skeeter's photographer used...) and the radio (in the form of the Wizarding Wireless). It can also probably be inferred that they use enchanted printing presses to run off copies of the Daily Prophet. I feel like the Omnioculas ought to be mentioned as well, since they're basically ramped-up binoculars. -
Well, yeah, you're right, but... by
on 2015-01-11 09:40:00 UTC
Link to this
We can safely assume that all the watches were using clockwork, which we know works (cf. Gringotts). A digital watch would probably, well, I don't want to think about wearing malfunctioning electrical equipment close to my skin. I'll stick to moisturizer, thanks.
And while we know that technological artifacts can be enchanted - indeed, people doing that is why Arthur Weasley has a job - the Wizarding Wireless Network is a weird one. Normal radios work via a piezoelectric crystal, so perhaps there's a magical equivalent... or perhaps there doesn't need to be and we're all radically overthinking this. =] -
But we're fans! Isn't that our job? To radically overthink? by
on 2015-01-11 15:11:00 UTC
Link to this
Anyway, wouldn't clockwork watches, theoretically, be able to be taken apart, dried, and put back together in working condition? Unless Harry either wasn't able to do that or didn't know how... Maybe he wasn't able to; it's implied in the first book that he repaired his own alarm clock (since I highly doubt the Dursleys would get it fixed for him).
-
Clocks, watches and optical devices. by
on 2015-01-12 10:52:00 UTC
Link to this
If the Dursleys wanted Harry to get up on his own, so they didn’t need to wake him, they better had this clock fixed. If they didn’t want this, why did they buy him an alarm clock in the first place?
The repaired alarm clock rang at six o’clock the next morning in PS/SS 3 is apparently the first time this clock is ever mentioned. When, where, and how was it broken? Maybe the Dursley’s didn’t buy it for Harry; it was an old spare clock they had lying around and it needed to be fixed because it had been out of use too long? Did Harry get it only when he moved into Dudley’s second bedroom? I cannot find this clock’s back story. Has it been edited out because the chapter was too long?
A random fourteen years old boy would probably not have the skills, tools and knowledge to put a wrist watch back together in working order, even if he could take it apart. A horologist could have done it if he got to it before the parts became too rusty, but Hogwarts students cannot go see an horologist every day, even if there is one in Hogsmeade.
Where did Harry get this watch? In PS/SS 2, Harry lay in his dark cupboard much later, wishing he had a watch. Madam Malkin’s robes are not magical; they are just out of style in the Muggle world. There may be a horologist in Diagon Alley who sells old-fashioned Muggle clockwork watches. Clearly magical devices, like one or both of the Weasley’s clocks and probably Dumbledore’s watch may have their own, unique back stories and may not be purchasable at Diagon Alley.
Collin Creevey’s Muggle parents may have bought him a magical camera at Diagon Alley, if the teacher who explained the Hogwarts letter to them realized that Collin is an enthusiastic photographer and thus warned them that his electronic camera wouldn’t work at Hogwarts. But it seems more plausible that Colin brought an old-fashioned photochemical Muggle camera. Since he said ‘if I develop the film in the right potion, the pictures’ll move’ (CS 6), I assume that all the magic is in the potion, and everything would work well, only the persons in the pictures wouldn’t move, if Collin used the usual Muggle developer chemicals.
But now thinking about it, Collin may have needed a magical, non-electronic flash for taking pictures inside the castle. Or there may be more magic in this magical developer potion than just making the persons in the pictures move. Wait, Lockhart’s photographer uses a flash at Flourish and Blotts. Is it magical or a very old-fashioned Muggle flash? I’m not very knowledgeable in this field, but the smoke from burning powdered magnesium should probably not be purple, so the wizards use something else?
Omnioculars and things like the Wizarding Wireless are probably like Alastor Moody’s artificial eye or the autonomous Snitch drone: Powered by Magic, we are not supposed to think about how it works.
HG -
One could reasonably assume... by
on 2015-01-12 18:29:00 UTC
Link to this
That the flash mentioned in Chamber has a magical element to it, which may well be what causes it to move; the whole point of a flash is to illuminate a scene, so it makes sense that wizards would find a way to do it better since they're far more used to working with light thanks to spells and suchlike... and because wizards are an incurious bunch, they settled for refining the powder rather than using something else.
Also, you're forgetting the Occam's Razor solution that Hermione uses on Harry's glasses all the time. A simple Reparo will clear up a clockwork watch no end, and because there's no planned obsolescence in something like that (you literally cannot do that in a society that fixes things by magic), stuff like big fob-watches become status symbols - hence why wizards give watches as coming-of-age presents whereas Muggles get, Iunno, a car or something, my parents don't like me much so I haven't got a frame of reference.
Also also: one L in Colin Creevey. Enjoy your mini! =] -
Occam's Razor by
on 2015-01-13 09:16:00 UTC
Link to this
As far as I remember, we have only ever seen Reparo mending things that were literally broken into pieces. I assume that it is a simple spell and cannot do more. Harry’s watch becoming wet and then becoming rusty is a more complex damage and would require a more complex spell, if there even is any. Oh, and an attempt to magically reassemble the watch after taking it apart would probably result in all moving parts sticking together, because that is what Reparo does.
To clarify the potions comment: I tried to suggest that the magical developer potion would not only make the persons on the pictures move, it would also magically increase the film's photo-sensitivity, so that Colin could get good pictures in a room lit only by candles. But this assumption doesn’t work, because Lockhart’s photographer, who would presumably use the same magical developer potion, apparently had some kind of flash on his camera, and I don’t imagine that Hogwarts corridors are lit brighter than a book shop.
Thank you for catching Collin the mini-Aragog. He probably spun his webs all over the notes on my hard drive. I’m going to cleanup now.
HG -
But HG pointed out... by
on 2015-01-12 19:26:00 UTC
Link to this
that Colin said if he developed the picture in the right potion, the people would move.
"That the flash mentioned in Chamber has a magical element to it, which may well be what causes it to move"
So... yeah.
And if Reparo could have fixed Harry's watch, why would he complain that it was broken? Perhaps he didn't think of it... -
If in doubt, remember that Hermione's the smart one. by
on 2015-01-12 23:47:00 UTC
Link to this
And the adorable one.
And the best one.
And the - oh, you get the point. =]
Anyway, she's the one who does all that because she's the one who remembers all those spells. She's only not leading the entirety of wizardkind in a quest for the secrets of magic because a) world optimization just ain't her style and b) because book-learnin's status-capped in the Potterverse. If it wasn't, the heroes would all be Ravenclaws. =] -
I do believe you are mistaken; Ron's clearly the best. ;) (nm) by
on 2015-01-13 00:52:00 UTC
Link to this
-
I've always thought of him as underrated... by
on 2015-01-13 10:43:00 UTC
Link to this
See, Harry's The Special, and Hermione's my fluffy little nerd Jesus, but Ron's just a normal wizard teenage boy from a normal wizard family, suckered into a quest to help his best friend and crush (Hermione belongs with Tonks btw it is canon in my books no shut up J.K. totally added addenda to that effect in purple felt-tip pen) and not doing because he was destined to or anything like that, but because it's the right thing to do. And he struggles with it, and he isn't always heroic, and that's what I find appealing about him. Ron's a person, a person with flaws and values and weird internal biases, not a heroic archetype. I think this is probably what gets fangirls (particularly Harmony shippers) so utterly furious about him.
That and he's a filthy ginger. =] -
Harry's The Special you say? by
on 2015-01-14 11:34:00 UTC
Link to this
One day, the dark one will choose a foe,
A special one marked with lightning, as you know,
Will find the Horcruxes in their hidden refuges spread around.
And with a noble army at the helm,
This Master Wizard will thwart the Dark Lord and save the realm,
And be the greatest, most interesting, Most important person of all times.
All this is true, because it rhymes. -
For a moment, you had me worried. by
on 2015-01-14 21:21:00 UTC
Link to this
I thought you'd pulled it from a badfic or something. And then I saw the last line. :D I'm a derp.
-
Awesome. ^-~ (nm) by
on 2015-01-14 12:12:00 UTC
Link to this
-
This. Right here. This is why he's my favorite. by
on 2015-01-13 23:25:00 UTC
Link to this
I feel so terrible whenever I find Weasley-bashing fics because Ginny, Ron, and (bizarrely) Mrs. Weasley get the brunt of it.
Why is it so hard for people to realize Ron is Harry's friend because he's a genuinely nice guy, and Dumbledore is most certainly NOT paying them to be his friend, Ron is NOT trying to steal Harry's inheritance, and Ginny is NOT SLIPPING HARRY LOVE POTIONS OF ANY KIND! *pant pant pant*
Yes, Ron can be immature. Yes, he can be insensitive. But the thing is, save for the times when he and Harry (or he and Hermione) fought, his words were never intentionally cruel. His heart has always been in the right place; he just sometimes needs a little help to realize it.
*raises toast to Ron* -
Indeed. by
on 2015-01-14 11:10:00 UTC
Link to this
To Ron.
Of all the wizards I ever read about, to paraphrase Star Trek, he was the most... human. =] -
Right. To Ron. (nm) by
on 2015-01-14 08:22:00 UTC
Link to this
-
WOBBLES! YOU'RE BACK! *flying tacklehug* (nm) by
on 2015-01-09 17:32:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Indeed. by
on 2015-01-09 18:02:00 UTC
Link to this
Long were my journeys through strange lands, like Bunyoro and the Palace of Ewuare. Indeed, I have a slideshow of my travels availa-
*is tackled to the ground, the slide projector falling into a conveniently placed Portable Hole*
Well then.
Also, I'm really happy to be back. As I said, hopefully I can be less of a colossal bell-end this time. =] -
Power Rangers by
on 2015-01-09 15:19:00 UTC
Link to this
The mild one: Mia from Power Rangers Samurai has anosmia/hyposmia--extremely decreased or nonexistent sense of smell. This is why she is so bad at cooking. Her sense of taste is skewed and she doesn't notice when her food is burning because she can't smell the smoke.
The crazy one: Tommy Oliver is a paradox. A few years after he started as a Ranger, the Wizard of Darkness (a minor villain) created a clone of him, which ended up getting sent back to the 1700's. Since it was created through magic, this clone was immortal and unable to age, and was thus the same man who became the legendary White Stranger in 1880.
At some point in the late 20th century he was adopted by the Olivers, and returned to Angel Grove, where he proceeded to get turned into Rita Repulsa's evil Green Ranger. Eventually he was turned good, and the bad guys started trying to get rid of his powers. Eventually they got to the point where using his morpher was dangerous--the power drain started him aging normally. -
I have some about ponies. by
on 2015-01-09 14:38:00 UTC
Link to this
First and foremost, Pinkie Pie is able to warp reality the way she does (being places before Rainbow Dash, pulling stuff from behind her back, et cetera) because the Element of Laughter is a hybrid of harmony and chaos magic.
My reasoning is as follows:
--Pinkie's reality-warping shenanigans tend to happen in hilarious ways and/or where they'd further a joke. Discord, while (mostly) malicious, uses his chaos magic the same way.
--Pinkie and Discord are the only two characters "shown" to have Offscreen Teleportation and awareness of the fourth wall (enough to crack it), two things considered impossible for normal ponies. (Discord's not a pony, but the point stands.)
--Neither character has a real explanation for why they can do all of that beyond "that's just who they are." If anything defies explanation, it's chaos magic.
--Discord was clearly (as seen in the flashbacks in "Twilight's Kingdom") around at the time of Star Swirl (or whenever the Elements were created), who's to say he didn't have a claw in their creation? -
My pet theory: HermioneÂ’s OWLs. by
on 2015-01-08 19:12:00 UTC
Link to this
We know that both Bill and Percy Weasley got twelve OWLs. Probably Barty Crouch Jr. also got twelve OWLs, although Barty Crouch Sr. may have talked about something he wishfully imagined. There may have been more unknown students who got twelve OWLs, and there should also be students who failed some OWLs, but had originally started to study twelve subjects in their third year. Why, then, did Hermione Granger need a Time-Turner in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, if it wasn’t just for conveniently having time travel available when it was needed?
There are seven obligatory subjects: Astronomy, Charms, Configuration, Defence Against the Dark Arts, Herbology, History of Magic, and Potions (not counting Flying, because this is only for the first year). In Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone, Chapter 14, Neville asks about Arithmancy and Ancient Runes, and Percy talks about Divination, Muggle Studies and Care of Magical Creatures, giving us a total of twelve subjects for the third year. Do we really know all optional subjects, or may there be at least one neither Percy nor Neville mentioned?
In Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, Chapter 4, Hermione shows Harry and Ron the books for all optional subjects: Arithmancy, Care of Magical Creatures, Divination, Study of Ancient Runes, Muggle Studies – and there she is conveniently interrupted by Ron. This is such a common trope that it practically shouts “There’s another optional subject not mentioned yet! Prepare for future surprises. “
In Chapter 6 of the same book, Ron tries to discuss how Hermione’s classes for Divination, Muggle Studies and Arithmancy are at the same time on one day. Hermione reacts so annoyed that Ron never dares to discuss what else he might have seen on her timetable for other days. In Chapter 16, we see that Hermione has to sit double exams for Arithmancy and Transfiguration at Monday morning, and for Charms and Ancient Runes at Monday afternoon, but then Harry and Ron just give up and don't look at the other days, because there isn’t any point in asking how she’s going to do this. Is it possible that JKR deliberately avoided showing us full timetables because she knew that there had to be a sixth optional subject somewhere, but she had not yet decided what it would be?
We never see Hermione’s full timetables in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire either. Could JKR still not think of a plausible sixth optional subject, that wouldn’t be covered in other classes? Or did she forget that she had never actually said what it is?
In Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Chapter 31, at the last morning of the OWL examinations, Harry sits in the common room, reading through the notes he had borrowed from Hermione. After the Astronomy examination, Hagrid’s sacking and the aftermath at the previous evening, Ron is sleeping long. But wouldn’t sleeping long like Ron be out of character for Hermione? Shouldn’t she be right there, sharing her notes with Harry to prepare for the examination in History of Magic? Where is Hermione if she isn’t sitting another exam for the still mysterious sixth optional subject?
In Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, Chapter 5, Harry, Ron and Hermione receive their OWL results. Hermione got ten "Outstandings" and one "Exceeds Expectations". Since she gave up Divination and Muggle Studies when she returned the Time-Turner, Hermione had tried to do something that had never been accomplished before: studying thirteen subjects during her third year.
So there is a good reason for giving Hermione a Time-Turner. No, it’s not for letting her try to get thirteen OWLs. It’s for teaching her these important lessons:
Magic cannot do everything.
Your Heart’s Desire may always be out of reach.
Even if you can add some extra hours to your day, it’s still impossible to learn everything that can be learned.
Addendum 1:
Uh, what? A newer edition of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince says that Hermione got only nine "Outstandings"? Did somebody complain that eleven OWLs for Hermione is WRONG and should be edited, because this would require her to have started studying thirteen subjects while there are only twelve subjects available?
Fanon says that time travel isn’t really such a big secret and everybody who studies more than ten subjects at Hogwarts gets a Time-Turner. This theory is very popular because people just love to use time travel in their fan fiction. JKR tried to shoot it down on Pottermore, saying that time travel is really very dangerous and really top secret, and that Hermione was really the only student who ever used a Time-Turner at Hogwarts, but nobody believes her. That’s what you get when you listen to your readers and throw years of planning and deliberately writing around the mysterious subject out of the window because after so many years you don’t remember why the plot of your second book requires Hermione to get eleven OWLs in the sixth book.
Unfortunately the Department of Inaccuracies, even if it existed, can’t do anything about this.
Addendum 2:
Look, Ron, it isn’t too difficult. It took me only ten years, and I didn’t even lurk on Hermione’s timetables. BICIMTG is "Basics of Interspecies Communication: Introduction to Mermish, Troll and Gobbledegook".
It’s sufficiently magic, not covered in other classes, not requiring an additional teacher we have never seen, and Hermione never talked about it because she was just too curious whether Ron would ever figure it out on his own. (Thanks to Julia H. of the Harry Potter Lexicon Forum for suggesting that Professor Dumbledore could teach Mermish and probably also other languages.)
HG -
I think you just made my brain explode. :D (nm) by
on 2015-01-08 22:14:00 UTC
Link to this
-
I assume then that no more harm can be done – by
on 2015-01-10 17:34:00 UTC
Link to this
when I expose you to My Pet Theory, Part 2: The Time-Turner Conspiracy.
Would McGonagall give a very dangerous and top secret Time-Turner to a thirteen year old student just to make her happy and let her have all the OWLs she wants to get? Certainly not!
Would McGonagall give a very dangerous and top secret Time-Turner to a thirteen year old student to teach her a specific lesson? I don’t think so.
But since time travel was so top secret, McGonagall couldn’t even know how this would end when she started it. She only knew that Hermione tried to sign up for every subject available. Then, something like this must have happened (Warning! Scripted badfiction copypasted from a several years old discussion thread):
DUMBLEDORE: You seem concerned, Minerva. Is there a problem?
McGONAGALL (presenting a piece of parchment): I am, Albus. I am and there is.
DUMBLEDORE (reading): So she couldn’t decide and signed up for everything. Is this a surprise?
McGONAGALL: I had hoped – this will never work, Albus! For two years we show our Muggle-born students how much can be done although Muggles deem it impossible. We convey that much more will be possible if they only work hard, but now I have to tell Miss Granger that her Heart’s Desire cannot come true because it’s impossible to fit into the class schedules!
DUMBLEDORE: But this isn’t the first time you have to do this, right?
McGONAGALL: In these other cases, I found something I could refer to. If Miss Granger had ever experienced a situation where magic was available but couldn’t help, we would know. Why should she believe me?
DUMBLEDORE: I’m sure Miss Granger will not assume that you intent to hurt her, or that you are just too lazy to do your work right. So what do you expect?
McGONAGALL: I would be less worried if she were more predictable. For months she is every teachers dream, but suddenly Miss Granger tries to catch a troll on her own. Or she helps Mr. Potter in a prank involving a fake dragon. Last Yule she tried to transfigure herself into a cat! (aside) Why didn’t she ask me first?
DUMBLEDORE: I don’t pretend to understand everything that happens in this school. Miss Granger’s escapades may have better reasons than we know. But I can see your point.
McGONAGALL: Albus, isn’t there a way to show, rather than tell Hermione, that this is really impossible? Otherwise I can’t foresee what this refusal might do to her mental health.
DUMBLEDORE: There is no way as far as I’m aware, but I will think about it and I may ask for advice. If you excuse me now, I have some letters to write.
--- scene break ---
McGONAGALL(reading a letter): Did you know that the Ministry is actually researching time travel?
DUMBLEDORE: How could I know? Everything done at the DOM is top secret.
McGONAGALL: So your friend suggests using a Time-Turner to let Miss Granger take two lessons at the same time. Wouldn’t this be dangerous? Nobody is supposed to change history!
DUMBLEDORE: Since Miss Granger would just do what she already intends to do, she wouldn’t really change anything. There shouldn’t be much danger.
McGONAGALL (reading out loud): Since nobody yet considered that there should be a law prohibiting the use of Time-Turners by under-aged persons or outside of the DOM, this would technically not be illegal. Ha! Your friend is a Slytherin, right? But this should still be kept secret, and for my own safety in case of a breach of security, I need sincere affirmation that your student is an honourable person dedicated to her studies who will strictly limit the use of this Time-Turner to educational purposes only. Didn’t you tell him that this girl’s unpredictability is the main problem?
DUMBLEDORE: So the crucial question is: Do we trust her?
McGONAGALL: I wouldn’t even trust myself. There may always be a situation when you can save a life by doing a minimal adjustment to what just happened – so what would you do?
DUMBLEDORE: I’ll try to get all information about previous experiences with Time-Turners. Miss Granger has to know exactly what can be done and what shouldn’t be attempted. Then I’ll trust her to do nothing unreasonable. And it’s ‘her’, by the way.
McGONAGALL: What? Oh, this signature is as unreadable as you would expect from an ‘unspeakable’. But don’t try to distract me. This is all quite illogical. If we depend on Miss Granger being reasonable anyway, wouldn’t it be better to just tell her that she can’t study more than twelve subjects?
DUMBLEDORE: Not at all, Minerva, not at all! You warned me that this may be a turning point in Miss Granger’s life, and you know quite well that even well-thought decisions may have terrible consequences. Why would you take a risk?
McGONAGALL: Because we have to take a risk anyway! I just want to point out that it may be better to abandon this unnecessary complex project.
DUMBLEDORE: Maybe, but when did we ever miss such an opportunity to experience something new? How long do you reckon will Miss Granger need to learn her special lesson? I’ll bet she’ll hand the Time-Turner in before the spring holidays arrive.
McGONAGALL: Bet? Albus, this isn’t a game!
DUMBLEDORE: Life is too severe to take it always serious.
-------------
Their speech patterns and behaviour may be out of character, but I hope their attitude isn’t.
HG -
More Ice and Fire by
on 2015-01-08 14:23:00 UTC
Link to this
I realized something about the Others and the chidren of the forest. They're not elves; they're fairies.
How do I figure? They're the Courts Unseelie (winter) and Seelie (summer) respectively.
Also, on Howland Reed: I think he represents the old gods, in the same way that Melisandre and Aeron respectively do for the Red and Drowned Gods. Deeply religious, hugely magical, a true connection with his gods (he's a crannogmen, so he knows the secrets of the children), and (more directly related to Melisandre), he has some connection with one of the implied Princes that were Promised (namely Jon Snow). Regardess of whether Jon is Ashara/Brandon's son or Rhaegar/Lyanna's, Howland knows who he really is.
...yeah, I might be anxious to meet this guy in the books. -
Absolutely crazy theory for The Blacklist... by
on 2015-01-08 13:55:00 UTC
Link to this
I think Reddington isn't Liz's father- he's only ONE of her fathers. He and Liz's adopted father were lovers at one point.
Totally nuts, I know. >_>
As for why Lupin never contacted Harry to see how he was doing, I'm fairly sure Dumbledore made Harry's location not only a secret, but protected him from being found by anyone, regardless of their intentions. That would also explain why Harry never seemed to get any fanmail. -
Jareth the Goblin King is Sauron. by
on 2015-01-08 13:11:00 UTC
Link to this
More specifically, he's the tiny fragment of Sauron's power left after the Ring was destroyed, plus whatever he's managed to (slowly and painfully) accumulate in the six thousand years in between.
The proof:
-They both rule over orcs/goblins.
-They both rule kingdoms which are supernaturally attuned to them - Mordor is evil because Sauron lives there, and the Labyrinth is merged with Jareth to the point that his face keeps showing up in the scenery.
-Jareth uses songs as magic (mostly 'As The World Falls Down' and 'Within You', though the latter failed). Sauron comes from a world literally created by magic singing.
-Jareth's all about Words of Power ("Say your right words, the goblins said..."). Sauron, again, comes from a setting where saying the right words is one way to invoke (innate) power ("Naur an edraith ammen! Naur dan i ngaurhoth!").
-They both try to trick people into saying powerful words - Sauron attempts to convince Finrod and Beren to swear "Death to light, to law, to love! Cursed be moon and stars above!" to prove they're really orcs. That would not have been a good idea.
-They both have an unhealthy obsession with specific brunettes - Luthien and Sarah.
-They both have far-viewing crystals.
-They both have the power to change people into goblins - Jareth implies it'll happen to Toby, while Sauron may well have been involved in the original creation of orcs from elves.
-They both have an unhealthy obsession with shiny things - Sauron and the Rings, Jareth and, uh, endless glitter.
-They both transform into flying creatures - a vampire for Sauron, a barn owl for Jareth.
-Just look at them:
Yeah, the Dark Lord is trying the whole 'Hi, I'm pretty and I bring you presents, just call meAnnatarJareth' thing again. And once again, he gets taken down by a girl. ;) Serves him right.
(Does this mean Hoggle needs to go on a quest to throw a bag of glitter into the Bog of Eternal Stench? I think it rather does)
hS, bringing the crazy ^_^ -
Smaug is the hero of his own story. by
on 2015-01-08 09:45:00 UTC
Link to this
I know, I know - you thought he was all about the gold. And yeah, he likes the pretty jewellery as much as anyone. But Smaug is actually a vigilante anti-hero: righter of ancient wrongs, punisher of the guilty for their heinous crimes against dragonkind.
In the First Age, when Melkor still ruled as rightful king over Middle-earth, the dragons had their beginning. The greatest among them were Glaurung the Golden - the Father of Dragons - and Ancalagon the Black, first of the winged variety. Smaug, of course, must be descended from both of them, since he's winged (and a dragon); he also clearly identifies with Glaurung, since he's adopted the same aftername - 'the Golden', or 'Glóren' in Sindarin.
In all the years of the First Age, there were two occasions when dragons were defeated in major battles. First, when Glaurung fought in the Nirnaeth Arnoediad, he was driven back to Angband in disgrace by masked dwarves. Second, when Ancalagon sallied forth in glory in the War of Wrath, he was brought down in ruin by the bearer of a Silmaril.
So imagine how Smaug feels when, after millennia of brooding on these ancient wrongs, he hears that a mountain full of dwarves (Glaurung's bane) have dug up a glowing jewel bearing more than a passing likeness to the Silmarilli (Ancalagon's last sight). At last, there is a chance to exact vengeance for the great dragons of old - and, along the way, to burn down a city of scruffy mortals very similar to the one who (wearing a dwarven helm, mark you) slew Glaurung the Golden himself.
And so Smaug the Avenger flew down from the North in flame, and all burned before his righteous wrath.
hS -
Headcanon! by
on 2015-01-08 04:39:00 UTC
Link to this
I have a whole bunch of headcanons about most of my fandoms! Some are more crazy than others.
One Harry Potter headcanon that I have has to do with the reason why no one reported for the Dursley's for child abuse. If the obvious neglect and abuse had been reported, he would have been removed from the Dursley's home from the British equivalent of CPS. But then that would have broken the protection that he had from being there- in his mother's family's house- and it would be entirely possible that Harry would be at risk from Death Eaters harming him. My headcanon is that the abuse he suffered was noticed and reported. But the British CPS didn't investigate for whatever reason; probably an obliviate or two, and probably cast by Dumbledore- all a way to keep Harry alive until it was the right time for him to die, after all the Horcruxes were destroyed.
My craziest headcanon is for the Marvel universe. I believe that Age of Apocalypse Blink is really Pixie and Nightcrawler's daughter. Pixie isn't seen in AoA; but both Pixie and Kurt are teleporters. A pink teleporter plus a blue teleporter equals a purple teleporter. Plus, Pixie's pink hair is genetic; her mother has the same hair color, so it's plausible that her daughter will have pink hair as well. Blink also has eyes that are one solid color, just like Kurt. It is also implied that Sabretooth is Kurt's father in the AoA universe; if Blink was Kurt's daughter (and thus Sabretooth's granddaughter) it would explain why Sabretooth took her in.
Those are the two big ones that I can think of at the moment. If I think of any more I'll post them later! -
HP Theory by
on 2015-01-08 10:56:00 UTC
Link to this
Dunbledore was certainly not above obliviating some Muggles if he deemed it necessary.
But weren’t the Dursleys always so concerned with what the neighbours would think of them? Wouldn’t they have tried to avoid anything that might have been noticed?
Yes, sometimes Vernon lost his temper and tried to beat Harry, so Harry learned to duck and to stay out of reach. But I’m not so sure that Vernon ever actually hit Harry; he may always have missed.
The original protection Harry got through his mother’s sacrifice worked only against Voldemort. But when Dumbledore worked his magic to give Harry extended protection at the place where his mother’s blood dwelled, why would he limit it to Death Eaters and Dementors, risking that some random mass murderer not associated with Voldemort might slaughter Harry and his family? Why would he set any limits at all?
My headcanon: Dumbledore didn’t need such crude spells like Obliviate to make the world go the way he wanted it to go. Having Harry been monitored by Mrs. Figg was mostly to keep track of what happened to Harry when he left the house. Dumbledore had made sure that no real harm could be done to Harry at Number 4, Privet Drive, and that any abuse Harry might have to suffer would only serve to make him stronger and to form the character we know, but would never go so far to make Child Protection come in and make Harry loose the best protection he could have.
Note: I’m not saying that what happened to Harry was not bad, and certainly he perceived it as really bad, but it could have been worse.
HG -
My own HP theory by
on 2015-01-08 15:55:00 UTC
Link to this
Remember how Lupin says that the Dementor's Kiss turns you into "something like itself"? I wonder just how literal that is.
Yep, I think Dementors are a spreading curse. Kissed for too long, you turn into a Dementor. -
I sort of agree with that... by
on 2015-01-11 00:45:00 UTC
Link to this
However, my own headcanon is slightly different.
See, the Dementor's Kiss sucks out your soul, right? There's no real evidence to prove that they eat them, since they "feed" off happy memories. It could just be a reproductive system, in that the soul sucked out undergoes sufficient torment to become a Dementor over time, incubating beneath the shroud of the adult form until such time as it is free to leave and seek new victims, new things to devour, constantly searching for the happiness and warmth of memories now denied it...
Er, er, here'sakitten! Kittenkittenkitten~ -
Sending Mini-Aragog back to HFA. Farewell Dundeldore. (nm) by
on 2015-01-08 12:39:00 UTC
Link to this
-
You made another one. (Curse you, Toey!) (nm) by
on 2015-01-09 03:49:00 UTC
Link to this
-
What? TOEY! by
on 2015-01-10 16:08:00 UTC
Link to this
Get out of my brain, my fingers, my keyboard, or wherever you are!
HG
-
Off Topic: "Self-Extraction" by
on 2015-01-07 16:53:00 UTC
Link to this
I know this doesn't have anything to to the PPC canon (aside from the obvious theme of Sue hunting), but I've been meaning to bring this up... Has anyone around here read "Self-Extraction"? It's a pretty... interesting take on the idea of Mary Sue slayers, involving a corporation that the canons of affected universes actually contact to get rid of the Sues/Stus in question (usually people who live out their fantasies in the universe of their choice). It's actually a really interesting idea, and it's also one of the very earliest works I ever read pertaining to the topic of Sue slaying. (I must warn you, though: The content presented is not for the faint of heart. There would probably be an M-rating for this thing, and for a damn good reason.)
Anyway, may I ask what any of you folks think about it? The part in the Sonic universe where the Stu blows himself up by mistake was my favorite part, personally.
-
Well... here I am... by
on 2015-01-08 05:19:00 UTC
Link to this
Hello, all!
I'm horrible with introductions, so bear with me :)
I suppose I should introduce myself as EmmaLeUnicorn's partner-in-crime. I am indeed the 'friend' she has been mentioning; I've been rather intimidated by this whole "communicating-with-actual-people" business for a while, so she's held off mentioning me by name.
er... I'm here now, though.
We've got a bit of a long-winded back-story with PPC Missions: A couple years back, while bored in a class whose instruction vaguely resembled that of a science-y nature, Emma pushed a computer loaded with the Original Series at me.
That's... that's about it.
By the end of the month, I'd read through everything, discovered the wikia & TV Tropes pages, and spent many a happy hour whittling away the time I desperately needed for assignments and such immersing myself in lore. It was around this time I discovered my first badfic- one of epic proportions- which I believe is known infamously as 'legolas by laura'.
heh.
Suffice to say, I was hooked.
Nowadays, I run a small-time blog on tumblr, primarily based within the Tolkien and Sherlock fandoms (any media type, I'm not picky), and I have published one Johnlock fanfic.
Other than that...
I honestly can't think of anything else to say here, and I do have an essay to write, so I'll be signing off.
_
M -
Welcome! by
on 2015-01-09 20:55:00 UTC
Link to this
Welcome to the PCC! Here, have a pen with urple ink.
-
Good luck on that essay by
on 2015-01-09 15:13:00 UTC
Link to this
Here is a bag of holding for all your other gifts--it does have pockets so you shouldn't lose anything inside. Do you have any favorite Agents so far?
-
Well, I finished it... by
on 2015-01-09 18:33:00 UTC
Link to this
Thank you, everyone, for your generous gifts and welcomes. It appears my initial terror of contact was entirely irrational, and I needn't have worried :D
Apart from the brilliance of Jay and Acacia, I would say I am most entertained by the antics of agents Eledhwen Elerossiel and Christianne Shieh (I fear I've developed quite a crush on the former). -
Hello there by
on 2015-01-08 20:51:00 UTC
Link to this
-Waves-
-Sets a table with tea, scones and jam-
-Points to various stuff in the Board header-
-Heads off to his freezing office-
-Returns, having forgotten his beret behind-
Hello there. -
First plover! (nm) by
on 2015-01-08 19:50:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Newbie! *glomp* *first poke* by
on 2015-01-08 18:27:00 UTC
Link to this
Have a singing warthog! If the urple bow around its neck becomes too much, feel free to remove it. *serves up SPaGhetti*
-
Welcome aBoard! by
on 2015-01-08 15:17:00 UTC
Link to this
Have one of my own shed feathers and a complimentary kit of Spikes!
-
Hi there! by
on 2015-01-08 13:20:00 UTC
Link to this
Nice to meet a friend of an acquaintance. Have some peanut butter cookies and a knit blue scarf!
-
a LOTR fanfic idea by
on 2015-01-08 06:40:00 UTC
Link to this
I don't have the time (way too many plot bunnies) and I don't think that I could do this idea justice, but perhaps someone here will be willing to take up the challenge:
Summary: A girl from the modern world is inexplicably dumped into Mirkwood. She has only basic wilderness survival skills, doesn't know the language, and she's scared of spiders. This is going to suck.
Longer explanation: A more realistic take on the Girl-Falls-Into-Middle-Earth cliche. The main character ends up in Mirkwood, and while she has some survival skills, it basically amounts to 'anything you could learn as a Girl Scout', and her combat skills cannot be more than 'knows recreational archery' and/or 'has some martial arts training'. She doesn't join the Fellowship, and this should be a mostly OC story (or focus on minor characters in the books). It's mostly a story of a lost, scared girl struggling to survive in an unfamiliar land and adjust to the loss of everyone she knew and loved, not an epic adventure story like Tolkien's masterpiece.
So, how does it sound? -
Well. by
on 2015-01-08 07:17:00 UTC
Link to this
Good Girl-falls-into-Middle-earth fic has been done in that sense, with Don't Panic by Boz4PM and (I think?) Time Will Tell by Bombur Jo.
I've tried doing it for Mirkwood too but that didn't go well, but I'm sure it can be done. Since Mirkwood isn't really on the route of the Fellowship the closest she'd get to the Quest is if she rides to Rivendell with Legolas. I think doing Girl-Falls-Into-Middle-earth for Mirkwood would actually be interesting if someone took the time and effort to research and extrapolate to create an interesting world for the Wood-elves of Mirkwood. There's a lot that isn't covered in the books, so there's a lot to discover. Especially if she isn't turned into an elf or something and there's discussion of turning her over to the Lake-men or the people of Dale. Then you can do even more world-building, since there isn't a whole lot about the era between reclaiming the Lonely Mountain and the War of the Ring. -
That's kinda the point. by
on 2015-01-09 07:15:00 UTC
Link to this
The idea with the story is to not get anywhere near the quest. The point is to use her newbie-ness to explore the parts of Middle Earth that the canon story couldn't touch. She doesn't get to meet Legolas up close and personal (or at least, he's a minor character), but she does get to explore the land of Middle Earth that currently isn't embroiled in a war on which the fate of the world rests. Also, I think that Dale is a pretty cool place.
-
Creative Curses! by
on 2015-01-08 07:05:00 UTC
Link to this
So I just watched Battle of the Five Armies and seriously all I have to say is this:
SCOTTISH DAIN ON A BATTLE PIG!
(or a war pig, if you like referencing Black Sabbath)
I mean seriously what in Arda was that?! First the Battle Moose (rest in peace, my antlered friend, you went out spectacularly) and now this?
And don't get me started on the Battle Rams (they're rams right? or some form of giant curl-horned sheep. I dunno). Where in Arda are they getting these creative steeds? Does Beorn or Radagast or someone just breed giant animals for riding up majestic slopes or into war or whatever?
Please, feel free to respond with other strange things that might work as creative curses. I feel like Battle Rams might be an expletive all by themselves. Thorin on a Battle Ram? -
On curses, creative and otherwise. by
on 2015-01-08 22:41:00 UTC
Link to this
I've always been a bit iffy on creative curses like "Flaming Denethor" or "Jadis in a block of ice." They always felt unwieldy in most situations. I'm pretty sure I've written a post saying as much sometime before now, but my thoughts have evolved a bit. I think writing that workshop on speech helped.
Characterization shapes how someone speaks (and a bit of vice versa). Dialogue and word choice are informed by a character's background and personality. That means by extension, characterization also shapes how someone swears. Hot-headed Laura Dukes and happy-go-lucky Rachel Calendar are not necessarily going to be using the same curse words at the same rate.
The vast majority of curses are quick, forceful expressions. Even the invented fictional ones typically are: shazbot, frak, frell, bosh'tet, and so on. Big elaborate curses like "Radagast on a bunny sled" only work if they seem like something the character would say. I typically associate such profanity with either very large hams, the vaguely eccentric, or certain period piece characters. I could hear Bertie Wooster saying something like that, for example. ("Great Radagast on a bunny sled, Jeeves!")
Such phrases don't feel right coming out of the mouths of most agents, who are typically contemporary young adults. As such, having them say something like "Scottish Dain on a battle pig" feels a bit too much like the author stepping in and inserting something they think is humorous just because they can. It's very forced, in my view. -
I tend to view the long ones as expressions of dismay. by
on 2015-01-08 22:49:00 UTC
Link to this
Sorta like how people say stuff like "Jesus on a pogo stick" or "Great Goddess on a stick" or "In the name of God's green Earth", but adjusted for fandoms. Also agents who originate in certain continua might have curses stylised like those expressions but more befitting their origin canon, or agents who spend a lot of time in those continua pick things up.
So it's not necessarily something quick and forceful like the one-word curses that we all know and love, but more of an expression of long-winded exasperation, when you're completely done and exhausted by the antics of the Sue but you can't kill her yet, so all you can say is "Oh, for the love of Scottish Dain Ironfoot" in an exasperated voice and clutch your forehead. -
People say stuff like that? by
on 2015-01-08 23:08:00 UTC
Link to this
I'm being completely serious. I've never heard someone say "Jesus on a pogo stick" in real life. The most common expressions of exasperation or dismay that I've heard are typically phrases like "Are you serious?" or "For f*ck's sake" or the ever popular quiet murmur of "...oh my God."
You say "more befitting their origin canon, or agents who spend a lot of time in those continua pick things up." If that were the case, why wouldn't they just pick up canonical curse words or phrases? I'm pretty sure no one actually says "For the love of Scottish Dain Ironfoot" in Middle Earth. Agents from that canon would have no reason to use it. Outside agents with a lot of experience working in Middle Earth would more logically adopt Dwarvish oaths, Orcish profanity, or what have you. Fans of the canon working there might use such phrases, but they wouldn't come from the canon itself. -
For myself, by
on 2015-01-09 04:47:00 UTC
Link to this
"Crap on a pancake!"
and
"Oh, monkey f____er." -
This is doctorlit. (nm) by
on 2015-01-09 13:34:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Re: People say stuff like that? by
on 2015-01-09 00:05:00 UTC
Link to this
I've heard "Jesus H. Tapdancing Christ," although that was more astonishment.
(also it was one of the Freeman's Mind spinoffs) -
I've been using some for a long time. by
on 2015-01-08 23:54:00 UTC
Link to this
'Son of a werechihuahua' for several years, along with 'Christ in a sidecar'. I've also heard 'Jesus Christ in a dump truck', which never fails to make me laugh. Also 'Christ on a cracker' and just today my brother used 'flaming Denethor!'.
-
Patterns of speaking might differ? by
on 2015-01-08 23:21:00 UTC
Link to this
I mean, maybe I spend too much time with the Tumblr crowd who love coming up with really creative insults and curses that don't involve gendered slurs, so I'm just more accustomed to hearing/seeing/reading people call others "useless paperclip" and "crinkled plastic bag" and other ridiculous things.
It's all down to people's preferences. In fact, since the Potterverse has creative curses about Merlin's saggy buttcheeks, I'm guessing people (Agents?) who like that kind of cursing would be into things like "Scottish Dain Ironfoot" and "Thranduil on a Moose". Also, people who just aren't comfortable with swearwords, fictional or otherwise, or writers who want to keep their work more family-friendly (once again, the Potterverse cursing style comes to mind, and arguably even some PPC writers; I know in my early days of writing for the PPC I relied more heavily on weird phrases for curses because I was a sweet innocent spring chicken who hadn't become comfortable with dropping F-bombs everywhere yet) might use these.
Look, if it's your personal opinion that these curses are weird, that's your thing. But it's another to dismiss it as stuff people wouldn't say. My Agents (read: Christianne; Eledhwen uses phrases that are more Elvish) might be more comfortable using things like "Radagast on a Bunny Sled" than yours, and maybe that stems from their idea of what consists of verbal humour. -
Like I said before... by
on 2015-01-09 06:06:00 UTC
Link to this
Dialogue and word choice are informed by one's background and personality. That applies to real people as well.
Also, I did say that these curses sound strange coming from "most agents." If your agents are characterized in such a way that it would make sense for them to use things like "Radagast on a bunny sled" -- not liking to swear being a good reason -- then they should be able to do so. Many of the occasions I've seen such phrases used in missions, however, have come across as forced to me because it doesn't fit what I know of their characterization. The voice becomes that of the author rather than remaining the character's. -
Sorry if my comments came off as confrontational. by
on 2015-01-09 06:12:00 UTC
Link to this
And I completely agree that the choice to use long creative curses is dependent on whether or not the agent/person in question knows the context of the curse and would have the personality to use the curse in lieu of other things. It's just that I read your comments as dismissive of the way some people speak, which really doesn't sit right with me.
There are times and contexts in which certain phrases can be used, and the writer in question shouldn't try to force it. But that doesn't mean bringing up new ridiculous things to turn into potential new curses is a bad thing; I'm not saying that everyone needs to use "Thorin on a Goat" or "for the love of Scottish Dain Ironfoot" immediately in all of their missions now. It's just a chance to toss out what I found ridiculous about the last film in a PPC way.
That being said, Thorin on a Goat just brings up such hilarous mental images that I think I might start using it IRL. -
I also apologize for possibly being confrontational. by
on 2015-01-09 06:21:00 UTC
Link to this
As anyone whose work I've edited or reviewed can attest, I can be very... blunt in expressing myself. My intention was to address something related to writing for the PPC. Real life is its own thing altogether.
A peace offering: -
That gif made me giggle uncontrollably. Did you make it? (nm) by
on 2015-01-09 11:41:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Sadly no. by
on 2015-01-09 18:49:00 UTC
Link to this
Credit goes to the Internet Fairy for helping me find that one.
- Wanna learn new ways to swear? by on 2015-01-09 00:18:00 UTC Link to this
-
Well, I suspect that the moose thing... by
on 2015-01-08 20:02:00 UTC
Link to this
...may have been to remind the Abused!Legolas writers that yes, Thranduil does have a good hart.
Seriously, though, Melian did apparently learn a thing or two from Yavanna; the moose were probably domesticated in Doriath. And also, Doriath did have fairly decent relations with Nogrod and Belegost before the unchaining of Melkor, so the battle rams and battle hogs might date back quite a ways. Certainly by the time of the Battle of Unnumbered Tears.
But anyway, I'm trying to find a way to work out the expanded role of Dark Island in the VDT film. "Seven Swords for Dark Island", perhaps? -
That was horrifyingly painful. You villain. by
on 2015-01-09 13:11:00 UTC
Link to this
The idea of Melian being the ultimate source of the giant animals is appealing, though I can't think of any instance of the Doriathrim riding anything. And it doesn't need to conflict with my Dorwinion theory - after all, we know from the Lay of the Children of Hurin that the dwarves of Nogrod and Belegost traded with a wine-producing country of that name, though it appears to have been in a different location.
So, the timeline goes like this:
-Melian sets up shop in Middle-earth.
-To ward off the giant creatures bred by Morgoth before his captivity (eg Wargs), she starts producing large variants of local animals, including the Dorthonion Moose, the hogs of Brethil, and the goats of the Andram.
-Elsewhere in Beleriand, south of Taur-im-Duinath, a group of Nandor reach the coast. They establish the land of Dorwinion, 'the country of new land'.
-The dwarves of Nogrod and Belegost awake. They establish communications with their eastern kin.
-Eol the Dark Elf establishes trade and relations between the dwarves and the Doriathrim.
-For transportation, the dwarves purchase giant boars and goats from Doriath.
-The dwarves establish a trade route with Dorwinion, and make a lucrative profit selling their wine on to Doriath, and selling Doriathrim megabeasts to Dorwinion.
-Morgoth returns. The Girdle of Melian is laid. Trade mostly ceases with the dwarves (there is a war on, you know). Of course, the dwarves still trade cheerfully with Dorwinion, and get blind drunk on a regular basis.
-The dwarves use their megabeasts in battle, and strike an agreement with Dorwinion: the southern elves will breed and train the things, then sell them to the dwarves.
-In time, the War of Wrath comes about. Nogrod and Belegost are destroyed, and their remnants flee to Khazad-Dum. Doriath is lost. Dorwinion is flooded, and their population flees east, following in the footsteps of a certain Oropher and his son Thranduil.
-Dorwinion 2.0 is established on the Sea of Rhun. Since, unlike Oropher (late of Doriath, which does not like dwarves these days), they would be perfectly happy to pass through Khazad-Dum, they establish a new megabeast trade with the Longbeards. They also become friends with the elves of Lorien (long before Galadriel shows up, of course).
-Durin's Folk continue to trade with Dorwinion; when Khazad-Dum falls, the dwarves retreat towards their allies: first setting up shop in Erebor, then moving north to the Grey Mountains, then back to Erebor.
-With the dwarves so close, and using cavalry, Thranduil creates a cavalry of his own. Since horses aren't much use in the forest, he invites experts from Dorwinion up to breed him the giant moose he vaguely remembers from his childhood in Doriath.
-Erebor falls to Smaug. The dwarves are (to Thranduil's mind) a spent force in the Iron Hills. With cavalry now useless, Thranduil downsizes them - keeping just one moose for his own purposes.
Are the people of Dorwinion of the Third Age human or elven? Probably the former, by this point - but with a hint of elven blood like that of Dol Amroth, and several millennia of contact with the dwarves and their megabeasts to keep them looking weird to the rest of the world.
hS -
So, might your theory be undergoing... by
on 2015-01-09 18:04:00 UTC
Link to this
*dons shades*
Dorwinion evolution?
YYYYYYYYEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA-
*is horribly killed*
=] -
*rimshot* (nm) by
on 2015-01-10 15:45:00 UTC
Link to this
-
What about Legolas? (spoilers) by
on 2015-01-08 14:45:00 UTC
Link to this
I have a theory that Peter Jackson has an overwhelming compulsion to make Legolas ride on things.
Think about it. He kept it down during Fellowship by thinking really hard about the boating scene, and by working out the tension during the Moria staircase surf (which I don't think involved Legolas, but I might be wrong). Then in Two Towers he let himself go a bit - Legolas got to ride on a horse, naturally, but also went shield-surfing at the Hornburg. By Return of the King, nothing could satisfy PJ but letting Legolas surf an entire Mumak (after riding on a boat and, oh yeah, an avalanche of skulls). Only a vestigal respect for the plot forced him to keep Legolas off the giant eagles at the end.
But okay, films over. He figured he'd gotten over it. Positive thinking and all that. Then The Hobbit comes up. Okay, fine. Deep breaths, Peter. He's not even in the first one - it'll be fine. You can do this. Good, good, we're past Rivendell, into the Misty Mountains...
... oh gods, this Stone Giant sequence is just like the staircase surf.
And from then on, the compulsion overwhelmed him. Trees, barrels full of dwarves, rooftops, probably boats and orcs as well, Legolas jumped on everything in Desolation. And by the time Five Armies rolled round, he simply couldn't keep himself from throwing Legolas onto falling towers, into the sky for bat-joyrides, up a load of freefalling stonework as if it were a staircase...
(On the other hand, would it be a PJ!M-e film if Legolas didn't engage in increasingly ridiculous stunts? And anyway, he made up for it all with the 'whoops, empty quiver' shot. Orli's face, good grief)
hS -
I've noticed that. by
on 2015-01-08 20:05:00 UTC
Link to this
I think Orli's contract consists mostly of looking around in an attempt to seem mysterious and wise, pulling faces in the background, and doing ridiculous stunts.
Speaking of ridiculous things, though, did anyone else think it was funny how the Elf-army spun around everyone who tried to walk through their ranks? I bet Wood-elf army training involves a lot of synchronised dance classes. -
"And one-and-two-and plié!" (nm) by
on 2015-01-08 23:50:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Suspension of disbelief only takes the audience so far. by
on 2015-01-08 18:33:00 UTC
Link to this
The movie was increasingly finding new ways to disappoint me, but that stone-jumping scene just killed it for me. Do they seriously expect the audience to accept that?
The sad part is that the answer is yes.
Remind me, why other than fan service were Legolas and a new elf thrown into The Hobbit?
As for the Moria falling staircase thing, that was Frodo and Aragorn, if memory serves. -
Oh, and let's not forget the sword-throwing stunt he pulled. (nm by
on 2015-01-08 20:34:00 UTC
Link to this
-
We now have ... by
on 2015-01-08 10:51:00 UTC
Link to this
... a perfect trio of curses. "Thranduil on a moose! (Elk? Megaloceros giganteus?)", "Radagast on a bunny sled!" and now, "Dain Ironfoot on a war pig!"
This makes me very happy. Also I believe someone, possible hS promised some sort of reward for whoever wrote a mission and had their agents use all three. -
Don't forget... by
on 2015-01-09 16:54:00 UTC
Link to this
"Bombur in a bouncing barrel!"
It's not a megafauna, but it's the only curse we've got from the second film, as far as I know. Plus... well, just check out the end of this video. Or all of it. But especially the bit starting at 3:23.
Phobos and I have a theory that Peter Jackson secretly wants to make video games instead of movies.
~Neshomeh -
'tweren't me. by
on 2015-01-08 11:35:00 UTC
Link to this
Though if whoever it was doesn't show up, I can probably try and come up with something. Ehm...
Well, I can offer any one of:
a) A short PPC story.
b) A short crossover meetup story which may or may not be 'shippy (and would rely on me knowing both fandoms in question)
c) A coat of arms for a character of the winner's choice.
hS -
As hS and I were discussing... by
on 2015-01-08 11:01:00 UTC
Link to this
It's not as implausible for Dain to be on a War Pig (or a War Boar) since giant boars were a thing and could have resided near the Iron Hills, which were eastward of the Mountain (and thus where a lot of other giant animals resided).
However, where Thorin got the Battle Goats he, Fili, Kili, and Dwalin rode up the cliffs is still a mystery and an even more unexplainable one at that, so I submit that the curse to complete the triumvirate should be "Thorin on a goat!" Because it just sounds more ridiculous. -
Send in the DMFF to close that plothole! by
on 2015-01-08 13:54:00 UTC
Link to this
It's spitting out rideable animals whenever it's plot-convenient to do so.
Seriously, those goats literally don't appear on screen until the exact moment Thorin starts thinking he needs something to ride. And there are exactly the right number, too.
Also, did anyone else notice Dain is only a live-action figure for about one set of frames, and completely CGI otherwise? What about the dwarf man was so difficult to act that they needed to sub in a computer? -
I feel like at this point... by
on 2015-01-08 20:01:00 UTC
Link to this
...if Mary Sue comes riding in on some giant animal I wouldn't even bat an eye. Damn you, PJ.
-
Possible Connolly wasn't available the whole shoot. (nm) by
on 2015-01-08 16:20:00 UTC
Link to this
-
He was too angry and Scottish. by
on 2015-01-08 14:13:00 UTC
Link to this
It made the camera come out in a rash of tartan and woad.
hS -
I'm not familiar with that expression. >.> (nm) by
on 2015-01-08 15:12:00 UTC
Link to this
-
It... there isn't... it's not an expression? by
on 2015-01-08 15:19:00 UTC
Link to this
Tartan
Woad
Both very Scottish. If you throw too much Scottish at a camera... etc etc.
Things I have learnt in the past three minutes:
-Woad-as-blue-skin-dye is a mistranslation.
-Woad is actually caustic to the skin.
-The 1500s had some weird ideas about war-tattoos. Uh... technically warning for nudity? I think?
hS -
Oh. Blah. Sorry. by
on 2015-01-09 04:38:00 UTC
Link to this
My lack of canon knowledge for my own world strikes again!
Thanks for the info, anyway. -
Oh, it's still hecka implausible. by
on 2015-01-08 11:38:00 UTC
Link to this
The Boar of Everholt was a one-off as far as I know, and Rohan isn't that close to Rhun - not to mention the Anduin's in between. And the Iron Hills are still a fair distance from Rhun themselves, and without the convenient river Esgaroth's got.
But it's possible, at any rate. And... well, there's a Sherlock quote about that. So unless anyone's got any better explanations...? ^~
hS just mistyped that as ^# and created a Borg smiley -
I figured they were goats. (Spoilers, obvs) by
on 2015-01-08 09:30:00 UTC
Link to this
Doesn't Thorin's group do the goatlike 'hop vertically up a mountain' trick?
Giant animals... well, let's see. Historically, both Morgoth and the Valar bred giant animals (Carcharoth and Huan, respectively). There's also the Kine of Araw, which were giant oxen; they lived around Rhun, but were supposedly descended from Orome's cows. I always figured they were aurochs. And there is actually a giant boar in Middle-earth - the Boar of Everholt, which lived in Firienholt in Rohan, and was killed by Folca the king.
All of which suggests a theory, actually. The movie megafauna are:
-Mumakil
-The moose
-The boar
-The goats
-Technically the 'bats', though I'll come back to them.
All of those hail from the eastern areas of the world - the moose is the westernmost, and it's still way east. We know that Dain (in the movies) has contact with the other families of the dwarves, who live out east. We know that Thranduil has trade with Dorwinion (he drinks their wine) by way of Esgaroth - and Dorwinion is on the shores of Rhun.
So to answer your question: there is strong movie evidence that large animals live in the eastern lands - around Rhun, and also to the south of Mordor in the case of the Mumakil. Most of that territory is under Sauron's rule (by way of Khamul the Ringwraith at the time of The Hobbit); those areas which aren't would be struggling for any advantage over the Eastern Shadow. So yeah, breeding giant war steeds might well be a thing they did. And when you've got a breeding program, selling bits of it off is always worth considering.
Though, since I don't recall seeing any sign of Thorin's goats before he suddenly jumped on one - maybe those in particular are actually automata dug up from deep inside the Mountain? They certainly didn't seem to come in with Dain's company...
~
As for the bats - those did not look like bats to me. They looked more like Morgoth's fearsome flying messengers, the vampires - which we know Sauron once had command over (at least in part), and could transform into... hey, he's still using Wargs, why shouldn't he have a vampire breeding program in place too?
~
And, creative curses? "Oh, were-wyrms!"
hS
("We've got were-wyrm sign!" Come on, I can't have been the only one thinking that) -
Re: I figured they were goats. (Spoilers, obvs) by
on 2015-01-13 07:34:00 UTC
Link to this
Dwarves are about 4 ft/122 cm tall, right? Domestic hogs, some of which are very shaggy, can be up to 6 ft/180 cm long and 770 lb/350 kg with tusks up to 9 inches long. That's while breeders are not trying to see how big they can go. The ideal commercial pig of today is slim and low fat, quick gaining, and as docile as possible.
Look at Google images of feral pigs in the US. They are all descended from domestic pigs, but are huge and shaggy. The biggest problem would be that the boars are for the most part viscious omnivores with massive sharp teeth.
How much bigger would one have to be for a dwarf to ride on it?
(Can't speak to the goats. I saw that part and nearly spit my pop corn out. I mean, maybe if they had shown a bunch of dwarves on them at the beginning of the battle, but those were like *hammer space goats!*) -
Also your comment about the Battle Goats... by
on 2015-01-08 10:20:00 UTC
Link to this
...being dug up from the underground pastures of the Mountain suddenly made me think of the Ypurs for some reason.
-
I always imagined ypurs to look like the alot. by
on 2015-01-08 13:44:00 UTC
Link to this
Still, "Thorin on a ypur!" has a kind of nice ring to it...
-
This. Is your fault. by
on 2015-01-08 14:29:00 UTC
Link to this
hS -
>:) (nm) by
on 2015-01-08 22:15:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Now I'm just really fascinated with that idea. by
on 2015-01-08 10:17:00 UTC
Link to this
Just the whole Middle-earth large animal breeding programme. Because why have an ordinary pig when you can have a WAR PIG. Or rather, the War Boar.
(Which, should I actually get around to writing more of the Sherlock/LotR crossover, should make the Hound of the Baskervilles preeeeetty interesting.)
Oh yeah, were those weird giant earthworm thingies also one of the hidden wonders of Middle-earth that I never got around to discovering? Because I don't recall that ever happening in the books. And if giant earthworm thingies existed, how come the Orcs didn't use them during the War of the Ring? -
The name is canon. by
on 2015-01-08 11:32:00 UTC
Link to this
Bilbo says, "I will try it, if I have to walk from here to the East of East and fight the wild Were-worms in the Last Desert". The, uh, precise details may have been contributed by Jackson et al. Also, given that the Hobbits also have tales of giant island-turtles, winged insects called Dumbledors, bone-gathering Mewlips, and heaven knows what else, they probably don't exist. (That said, Hobbits came from the East originally, and they did know about Mumakil, so maybe there's a grain of truth in it...)
The 'why didn't they use that against Gondor' question is an interesting one; it's closely related to the Star Wars question of 'where did Artoo's rocket jets go?'. The answer is really 'filmmaker didn't think of it', though in this case we could argue that the various troll/hyperorc superweapons were driven to near extinction by the B5A, and hadn't recovered for the War of the Ring. We know the Misty Mountains were mostly orc-free by the time the Fellowship set out, at least.
hS -
Here's a thought for you. by
on 2015-01-09 19:08:00 UTC
Link to this
Phobos and I got to talking about discrepancies between The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings last night, such as why the trolls talk in The Hobbit but not LotR, and it occurred to me: what if Bilbo made that up? What if Bilbo embellished a lot of his tale? We know some things had to have happened based on what's reported in LotR, but we also know Bilbo wasn't entirely honest about the Ring, so why not other stuff? What must be true, and what could have been lightened up, left out, or added for the sake of a good yarn to tell his young nieces and nephews?
Regarding the trolls, we know there were trolls because Frodo and friends find them on the way to Rivendell, and they probably did capture and try to eat the dwarves... but I bet they didn't talk. What kept them from getting their meal before dawn, then? Gandalf? Blind luck? Or perhaps the dwarves weren't quite so helpless as Bilbo makes them out to be, and they actually put up a fight? That seems likely to me.
So, what else?
~Neshomeh -
Well it isn't like LOTR's trolls had much to talk about. :P (nm) by
on 2015-01-10 22:46:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Neither did Bilbo's three, but they did anyway. {; P (nm) by
on 2015-01-11 01:02:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Two... no, three responses. by
on 2015-01-10 07:16:00 UTC
Link to this
Some of which may be mutually exclusive. ;)
1/ Why do you think they couldn't talk? We know from all five hobbits that orcs talk, and in an idiom that Tolkien translated as something very close to how the trolls speak. Granted, they probably weren't named 'Bill 'uggins', but that's a translation issue too.
Wait, there's a 1.5 too/ That said, talking trolls are a part of Shire folklore - 'Troll sat alone on his seat of stone' and so forth - so it's entirely the sort of thing Bilbo might have added.
2/ Other things Bilbo might have, uh, misrepresented: how about all that singing? We know he was very fond of songs, so we can accept that he would have sung a lot (though if memory serves, he doesn't). And the hobbits in his circle could well have caught the bug, so they're fine. In fact, all the songs in LotR are justifiable as a racial hobby (hobbits, elves, ents) or a special occasion (the Rohirrim). They also all fit the cultures they're in.
The songs in The Hobbit? Nnnnot so much. Singing orcs, singing dwarves, all of whom sing in Hobbittish ditties? Not a chance. I'd guess Far Over The Misty Mountains Cold is a real song, but the rest of them are just Bilbo's pen running away with him.
3/ And it's not just Bilbo! The Middle-earth stories are semi-unique, in that the writing of the modern book is part of the fiction too. And that means Tolkien can be an unreliable narrator - or rather, a better novelist than he is translator.
For instance, we know that Bilbo's story started life as his diary - the title is still on the front cover. Who writes their diary in third person? I'm guessing that Bilbo's entire work - and that's everything up to Frodo reaching Rivendell, mark you, since we know he caught up with Frodo then and wrote it all down - was written in first person, and (in the case of 'The Hobbit') as and when he had a chance to scribble something in.
So, for instance, everything from being captured by goblins to being rescued by eagles could've been written at Beorn's house. Which means the early parts may have been quite quickly covered, since Bilbo probably forgot about the details. So Tolkien had to embellish.
For specific instance: the riddles. I'll accept that Bilbo wrote 'Got into riddling contest with slimy Thing. It asked me riddle about mountain. [etc] It asked me one that stumped me, and pressed me, so I called out for "Time!", and that of course was the answer.' But I refuse to believe he wrote down the actual riddles - which explains why some of them are Old English riddles.
Of course, the sparseness of Bilbo's account means that all Tolkien had to do was 'fill the gaps'. When he got to Frodo's far more complete work, his changes got a little more... involved.
Things added by JRRT
-Boromir. Boromir exists solely to be a mirror of Aragorn - in fact, to allow Aragorn to sit firmly in the role of 'Anglo-Saxon hero', with none of that icky 'being tempted'. But people don't actually come as mirrors. Clearly in the original, Aragorn tried to take the Ring - and didn't receive any punishment for it, but went on to rule the world.
-Faramir. Faramir consists in equal parts of mirror to Boromir (who never existed), plot device for feeding Frodo ( the real world doesn't have plot devices), and self-insert (need I say more?). We also have an explicit statement by Tolkien that he created him, so there's that. ;)
-Tom Bombadil. He's a children's doll, and Tolkien needed something to fill time. This of course means that Frodo's escape from the Barrow Downs was probably effected in some other manner. My theory is that the great disappearing character, Fatty Bolger, originally went with the other four - and then died in the Barrow. But that's too depressing, right?
-All the history. We know Tolkien was working on his Book of Lost Tales long before he got his hands on the Red Book. That means that everything we know about the First Age is a Tolkien invention - and its mentions in the narrative are either Tolkien additions, or changes to what was really said about history...
hS -
I like the Bilbo-as-unreliable-narrator theory. (nm) by
on 2015-01-09 22:03:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Giant island turtles. by
on 2015-01-08 11:46:00 UTC
Link to this
So...... Discworld?
Oh man, the Dumbledors. I mean, it does mean 'bumblebee', so I'm assuming they're referring to a type of bee, but now I'm imagining a bearded bumblebee flying around meddling in people's affairs like Gandalf does, and... stop me. This is the most unlikely crossing point for a Harry Potter/LotR crossover. (No, there are far more implausible ones but this one is pretty high up there)
On an unrelated note, I'm working on the Silmaril Sue's mission again! I just got to everyone being completely horrified at the Sue's genetically-impossible backstory. -
Nah, bit too much of a mouthful. (nm) by
on 2015-01-08 07:59:00 UTC
Link to this
-
World Hobbit Project by
on 2015-01-08 11:05:00 UTC
Link to this
This might be relevant to our interests.
It's a group of academics, who are researching how the Hobbit trilogy is understood an judged around the world.
And for that purpose they have a questionnaire. http://www.worldhobbitproject.org/
It's not very long, you can do it other languages than just English and it doesn't require an email-adress or any kind of sign up. -
Did it yesterday. by
on 2015-01-09 19:14:00 UTC
Link to this
And was nearly late for a meeting. >.> But on the bright side, I got most of the ranting I wanted to do about these films out of my system, so I can spare you guys and avoid arguments like the Great Radagast Debate of 2012. ^_^
~Neshomeh, not fond of these films at all. (Except Smaug. Smaug was really cool, and I was sad when he died.) -
I grew up on the book by
on 2015-01-10 03:26:00 UTC
Link to this
Or more specifically an audiobook which I adored, so I had the thing borderline memorized. I was . . . less than thrilled with the movies myself, though I did really enjoy the Riddles in the Dark scene and Martin Freeman as Bilbo. Definitely a good way to avoid a lengthy debate.
-
Which audiobook? by
on 2015-01-10 17:05:00 UTC
Link to this
I was raised on the BBC radio plays, myself. More LotR than The Hobbit, but both were a fixture of my bedtime routine for many years. I was super-stoked to learn that Ian Holm would play Bilbo in the LotR movies, since he was the voice of Frodo in the radio play. ^_^
~Neshomeh -
Houghton Mifflin, read by Martin Shaw by
on 2015-01-11 12:41:00 UTC
Link to this
That's a really cool tidbit, though--I remember hearing a radio play version of LotR at one point but I don't think it was the same one. Sam sounded really weird in it.
-
Eh, I thought they were okay. by
on 2015-01-09 22:34:00 UTC
Link to this
But then again, I was there more for Peter Jackson going a bit mad than I was for an actual Hobbit movie. That was what I wanted, and that was, to an extent, what I got. Recall that this chap made Braindead (which Americans may know as Dead/Alive), in which a man barrels through a crowd of zombies with a lawnmower strapped to his chest. Restraint, it am not how he work. =]
-
Huh, I didn't know that. by
on 2015-01-10 16:45:00 UTC
Link to this
I think the only other Peter Jackson film I've seen is King Kong, and I thought that was over-the-top silly, too. So, yeah. As I said in the survey, I now appreciate the LotR films a lot more for their relative restraint. {= )
(Welcome back, BTW!)
~Neshomeh -
Well, that was interesting. (nm) by
on 2015-01-08 19:17:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Done! by
on 2015-01-08 12:04:00 UTC
Link to this
That was longer than I expected! Some quite tricky questions in there, but I did my best to answer them all.
hS
-
Tolkien spins in his grave some more. by
on 2015-01-08 21:25:00 UTC
Link to this
- The Heir of Fëanor > by Aurorien reviews
A runaway-prince-turned-Cassiline-warrior becomes the unlikely bodyguard of the heir of Fëanor, who happens to be one very rebellious elven princess...chaos ensues... LegolasOC, ElladanOC, ElrohirOC
Lord of the Rings - Rated: M - English - Adventure/Romance - Chapters: 3 - Words: 2,196 - Reviews: 8 - Favs: 2 - Follows: 4 - Updated: Jan 20, 2005 - Published: Jan 17, 2005 - Legolas
My comment: Well, Lúthien Maglorien, you can count yourself lucky Agent Dafydd isn't here anymore.
2. Elves behaving badly > by SleepEatRead -- NSFW/B!
Bella Greengrass; Shy, sweet, nerdy, silent, street-wise, smart-mouth, obedient seventeen-year-old, is dragged with the plans of the elves when they show up at her doorstep. She is the exact opposite of any fanfiction heroine. Part of the plan she needs to marry one of the oldest of Fëanor's sons and produce an heir, all part of Maedhros's plans.
Silmarillion - Rated: M - English - Romance - Chapters: 4 - Words: 11,432 - Favs: 2 - Follows: 2 - Published: Dec 10, 2014
My comment: +++ Divide By Cucumber Error. Please Reinstall Universe And Reboot. +++
- The Heir of Fëanor > by Aurorien reviews
-
More badfic by
on 2015-01-14 00:34:00 UTC
Link to this
Death's Daughter by My Harlequin Romance reviews
Even since Chase began to rule the world, with Omi at his side, the underworld has had an overload of souls. Enter Ako, Death's daughter, to sort the whole mess out. Finished
Rated: Fiction T - English - Supernatural/Adventure - Chapters: 13 - Words: 8,473 - Reviews: 36 - Favs: 7 - Follows: 4 - Updated: Nov 3, 2005 - Published: Oct 21, 2005 - Status: Complete
Sue, CAF, makes up Shen Gong Wu, makes up dumb Xiaolin Showdowns, is Death's Daughter, inserts Death into the Xiaolinverse. Augh, my head. - Oh, and FIM isn't the only Pony gen subject to badfic. by on 2015-01-10 14:49:00 UTC Link to this
-
I... Don't quite know what to make of this. by
on 2015-01-13 21:48:00 UTC
Link to this
On the one hand, alicorn OC. That's, like, instant -20 goodfic points. On the other, this author seems serious. After all, they created a website for this series, with art and everything. Clearly, they mean business. Further, the author's note on the first chapter says that they know it is not the best, and is actively trying to fix it.
Seems to me like this fic should be left alone, at least for now. Even if the fic is just as bad later on, do we want the fight that this will likely bring? I dunno. Still pretty bad though. -
And at least, the art is pretty good. (nm) by
on 2015-01-15 19:31:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Oh, isn't he? >:D by
on 2015-01-09 09:22:00 UTC
Link to this
You say Dafydd isn't here any more, and you'd be right - but that story dates from 2005.
So I think Lúthien Maglorien will be receiving a backdated visit from her purported father. Now to decide who to partner him with for it...
hS -
Also: bwahaha, blast from the past. by
on 2015-01-09 09:29:00 UTC
Link to this
In the reviews for The Heir of Feanor, I see a message from a certain red wolf, directing the author to someplace called the PPC Board? Yes, it seems we already talked about this fic - ten years ago - and that our most infamous troll took it upon herself to tell the writer about our discussion.
Alas, the Board archives don't quite cover the date in question, so we can't see what we were saying about it. But still - pretty cool!
Dafydd's still going to murder it.
hS -
Looking forward to seeing this! (nm) by
on 2015-01-10 14:29:00 UTC
Link to this
-
You think that's bad? by
on 2015-01-08 23:55:00 UTC
Link to this
I found a Suefic on FFNet. The Suethor has read the Silmarillion, knows that a male elf is called an "ellon," and knows details of the War of Wrath.
So why, oh, why, did she write a Suefic where a modern-Earth human dies and reincarnates as Ancalagon's adopted daughter, and plans on romancing Smaug?
https://www.fanfiction.net/s/10508024/1/Draconic-Supremacy
Uurrrgghhh. This is all kinds of wrong... oh, and the Sue's dragon form has lavender scales. Yeah. *actually shudders IRL* -
I read the first couple of chapters. by
on 2015-01-09 16:58:00 UTC
Link to this
It... doesn't really resemble Morgoth's Beleriand at all.
I mean, yes, all the names are there - but the characters feel more like, I don't even know what. It feels like Morgoth's running a company, with Sauron and Ancalagon as his employees, and... no elves around at all. Beleriand doesn't feel like it's in ruins - it feels like a city park that Ancalagon wanders around.
Actually, yeah: the whole thing feels like a high school AU where the author forgot to change the species around. It's weird.
hS
(Lavender... tell me she doesn't eat ice cream at any point) -
Re: I read the first couple of chapters. by
on 2015-01-09 17:21:00 UTC
Link to this
Blessedly, there's no ice cream. Thank goodness for small favors.
-
Oh dear. by
on 2015-01-09 16:05:00 UTC
Link to this
I'll have to keep that one in mind for Derik and Gall. I'm not going to outright claim it, since I don't know when I'll be able to get around to it, so if anyone else is really pumped to tackle it, please do. Otherwise, let it be known that I've got my eye on it.
~Neshomeh -
And now I've read all eight chapters. by
on 2015-01-10 19:57:00 UTC
Link to this
... Ugh. Just UGH. Aside from the bad grammar and general uncanon (dragons gain the ability to take another form at age 100? Ancalagon forms an alliance with Gil-Galad? Bwuh?), there's a really graphic description of dragon-rape in chapter eight. Given to someone that should be considered a baby by the one doing the describing. Totally unnecessary, doesn't fit with the tone of the rest of the fic, let alone Tolkien, and just WHY? D X}
I'm gonna go throw up now.
~Neshomeh -
That makes no sense at all. by
on 2015-01-10 21:47:00 UTC
Link to this
I mean, for starters, if Smaug could do that, the entire plot of The Hobbit would be different. He disguises himself as a gold coin or whatever, waits for the Dwarves and everyone else to come in, then barbecues the lot. GG three of the Five Armies, and the fourth Good-aligned one won't bother to turn up.
Also, wasn't Ancalagon dead by that point? I mean, my knowledge of that era of Middle-Earth history's a little sketchy (translation: I can't be bothered to do research for the benefit of this tripe), but I was fairly certain he died fairly early on. -
Oh, but-- by
on 2015-01-11 01:01:00 UTC
Link to this
They can only take one form, and whatever they choose, they're stuck with it forever. And if the prologue is to be believed, Smaug chooses an Elvish form.
Which would still totally change things.
But, the fic so far is set before the War of Wrath, when Eärendil kills Ancalagon, and Smaug is a baby at twenty-something. The timeline seems to check out. The amount of research the author appears to have done makes everything else all the more baffling. O.o
~Neshomeh -
Hm. by
on 2015-01-11 01:59:00 UTC
Link to this
If that's the case, then... well, I smell troll. Or a very, very well-intentioned badfic. Casual Suethors don't put in that level of research. They just... don't. At least, that's what I've garnered from the stuff I've read.
(and written please don't talk about the l words i don't like to be reminded of how turdtastic i was when younger) -
Aren't... most badfics well-intentioned? by
on 2015-01-12 10:14:00 UTC
Link to this
I mean, most people try to write something which is good. It's just that people's knowledge/understanding of what 'good' is varies dramatically. Some people think getting name+sex+vague description right means you're doing it properly; some think that only writing about actual events explicitly mentioned in the canon is viable; most of us are somewhere in between.
hS -
Yeah, but there's different kinds. by
on 2015-01-12 10:27:00 UTC
Link to this
In the event that this is legit, I think the author of the fic in question isn't just trying to tell a good story; they're trying to tell an interesting story about a bit of Middle-Earth history that wasn't covered at all in the primary material fangirls are familiar with. That's sort of what fanfiction is supposed to do. And they've obviously done at least a little bit of research into the period, even if it is only to get the names right, so... yeah, if it's legit, then the author doesn't know they're terrible.
However, it being a trollfic makes more sense to me; the things that are wrong with it on the surface - quite the list - are cliched to the point of ridiculous. Endbringer's bones, if we ever figure out a way to burn speshul we're quids in with this one. And that's what says troll to me - it's badfic bad, but with actual research and effort... unless the author was already familiar with that bit of Arda's long and storied history, and just decided to dick around with it for a cheap laugh. =]
(Also, for Nesh's benefit: The L Words was a Friendship Is Magic darkfic I wrote a while back, which I now realise is terrible... and I am on record as defending it to the hilt. I was a badfic author. Maybe that's why I disappeared for a year under something of a cloud.) -
(Oh, BTW, hS...) by
on 2015-01-12 10:35:00 UTC
Link to this
I'm still working on that fic concerning early blackpowder weapons in the Third Age and similar fun stuff. I've got a rough plan for the first act, if you want to look it over and rip it to shreds. =]
-
Oh, speaking of BTW... by
on 2015-01-12 17:02:00 UTC
Link to this
... welcome back, was gonna say that earlier, but, um... didn't? Didn't.
While you were gone, I temporarily turned your Time Lord into a multiversal supervillain's sidekick, but that whole timeline got wiped out so it's fine. And Wobbles' TV show got syndicated by NutMint TV, though apparently she's not very helpful when it comes to actually passing on information (or maybe they just suck at asking).
And... goodness, yeah, I'd forgotten about that. I'm always up for shredding duty; do you have my email? It forgets, preciousssss.
hS -
Thanks! =] by
on 2015-01-12 17:31:00 UTC
Link to this
I'd read the Council stuff (heh, if we find a Doctor Who/XCOM badfic, we HAVE to call it Council Mission), but I hadn't seen the stuff about NutMint. I like the thought of the Tengwablocks and would watch the herbacious border out of Canon Primer. Edutainment at its most edutaining is always a joy, and I think it's the closest the Nursery bods'll ever get to watching Come Outside.
Of course, I'm not sure certain Flowers would really want to encourage the idea of an "outside", but whatcha gonna do?
Also, I'm afraid I don't have your email to hand.
I'm sorry, Uncle.
I'm afraid I lost it. =] -
Email. by
on 2015-01-13 11:08:00 UTC
Link to this
Should be visible above. If not, I, uh... won't be all that surprised, it's always been a bit of a long shot.
hS -
Bugger. It does not appear to be. by
on 2015-01-13 14:44:00 UTC
Link to this
However!
You may contact me via Harry Heath 99 at that email service where the mail is hot. =] -
Assuming it's right... by
on 2015-01-13 12:49:00 UTC
Link to this
Then I've supplied you with a link to the googly dockerment. =]
-
It feels legit to me. by
on 2015-01-11 18:01:00 UTC
Link to this
I believe the author is well-intentioned, but very, very clueless. One of the first author's notes says something about how the fic is definitely very experimental, or something like that. She also says the main character isn't a self-insert at one point.
On the other hand, there's an author's note where she's agreeing with a reviewer that proper grammar is important, and it's so hard to read fics where people just ignore it, so yeah. I think it's a case of knowing, but not understanding. She's trying to write like Tolkien without knowing what makes Tolkien sound like Tolkien, so she uses overly complicated phrasing and throws in fancy words where they're not warranted.
Like "albeit." Albeit is not a synonym for "but" or "yet," and yet she uses it like that throughout. So annoying. >.
(I don't know what the l words are, sorry if I mentioned any. o.o )
~Neshomeh -
Re: Oh dear. by
on 2015-01-09 17:07:00 UTC
Link to this
I'd be willing to come along for the ride. I've wanted to feed a Sue to Ancalagon anyway, though my original idea for a leadup to it wouldn't work in this fic, since it depends on one of the agents not knowing who Ancalagon is. It goes something like this
Agent 1: "I want to feed this Sue to a really big monster... and I know just the one."
Agent 2: "Smaug?"
Agent 1: "Bigger."
Agent 2: "Cthulhu?"
Agent 1: "Bigger."
(scene change, as they walk through the mountains)
Agent 2: "Balerion?"
Agent 1: That continuum's quarantined. Also, bigger."
Agent 2: "Ego, the Living Planet?"
Agent 1: "... okay, smaller." -
A Dragon!Sue on ARDA!? Oh, Glaurung! by
on 2015-01-09 15:49:00 UTC
Link to this
WHAT color scales? And Ancalagon as an OVERPROTECTIVE dad!?
Ëarendil, you have a phone call on Line One. Ëarendil, Line One. Thank you! -
*cringes* Ouch. by
on 2015-01-09 03:44:00 UTC
Link to this
Interesting idea, but...ouch.
Also, as long as we're talking about badfic, I would like to announce my next claim! Behold:
A Deeper Wound than Love, taking place in "Free!", an anime about high school boys who start a swim club. This one has kind of a cookie-cutter plot, as per usual, but I think I can come up with enough fanservice jokes to get me through a mission. (Seriously, there is a lot of fanservice in this show. Probably why the Internet loves it.) -
Ugh. Just.. ugh. by
on 2015-01-09 01:31:00 UTC
Link to this
I couldn't get past the first chapter. Why oh why are there no good dragonfics?! (At least I haven't found any yet...)
-
Waiiit a minute... by
on 2015-01-08 23:24:00 UTC
Link to this
Didn't Isaiah/the PPC at large already deal with a Sue who romanced (one of) the Twins and Legolas? The reviews compliment the first author on her use of the Silmarillion (and even offer concrit!), so you'd think she'd have acknowledged the whole elves-marry-once-and-only-once thing. (Assuming the same OC is shipped with all three of them, of course.)
The second one sounds like the summary for a parody Suefi...il she mentions Fëanor's descendants. Speaking as someone who hasn't read the Silmarillion (yet)...seriously? Seriously? -
Gah, that should be "fi...il". Stupid censors. (nm) by
on 2015-01-08 23:25:00 UTC
Link to this
-
The first word should be Suefic and the second until, yes? (nm) by
on 2015-01-09 12:36:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Yup. (nm) by
on 2015-01-09 13:24:00 UTC
Link to this
-
New Mission! by
on 2015-01-08 21:45:00 UTC
Link to this
Here it is, my old badfic ripped apart for all to see.
-
Good work. by
on 2015-01-10 19:53:00 UTC
Link to this
And we see yet another Boarder overcome the shackles of an old shame. Good work, Rina!
However, there are a few things amiss with the mission:
1) In this segment, it takes a while to figure out who said what in the middle paragraph:
"Ooh, I wanna be in Hufflepuff!" Randa said. Rina looked at her.
"...said nobody in the history of forever," she said slowly. Randa kicked at her. "Ow! Randa, you know I didn't mean that!" Rina rubbed her shin. "I like Hufflepuffs too, come on!"
"Hufflepuff," Randa said firmly.
I eventually figured out that all of the quotes in the middle paragraph are Rina's lines, but the paragraphing threw me off. (You have Rina react at the end of the first paragraph, then start a new paragraph with a quote, so I expected a change in speaker back to Randa. The "she" in the paragraph muddied the water even more. Only the context of the rest of the paragraph cleared everything up.) Please allow me suggest a fix:
"Ooh, I wanna be in Hufflepuff!" Randa said.
Rina looked at her. "...said nobody in the history of forever," she said slowly.
Randa kicked at her.
"Ow! Randa, you know I didn't mean that!" Rina rubbed her shin. "I like Hufflepuffs too, come on!"
"Hufflepuff," Randa said firmly.
This way, it's a lot clearer who said what.
2)
A horrible smell hit them just then; Rina peered out into the corridor. "Here comes Peter," she said, one hand pressed over her nose, "and he's covered in Stinksap." ...
Randa couldn't keep the grin off her face. "So, what have we learned here about proof reading?"
Rina stuck her tongue out.
Unless the Stinksap is something that a Harry Potter fan should know about, I'm guessing that it's the result of a spelling error in the Words. Please tell me what the context is.
Either way, not too shabby a mission. -
Duly noted about the formatting. by
on 2015-01-10 20:13:00 UTC
Link to this
I'll clear that up when I get home.
And Stinksap is a Potterverse thing. It was sprayed by Neville's Mimbulus Mimbletonia when he jabbed it with a quill. I'm sure there are other instances, but I'm drawing a blank right now. *hangs head in shame* -
If memory serves (and it may not...) by
on 2015-01-10 21:43:00 UTC
Link to this
I think the twins use the stuff as an ingredient in one of their souped-up Dungbomb replacements at Weasley's Wizard Wheezes.
(NB: I really, REALLY hate it when people get the name wrong. I mean, it's a pun, gang, but it's a pun that Americans almost uniformly don't get so they just assume it was something different. IDK, maybe it's changed in the American editions or something, but it crops up everywhere in the Pit and it makes me want to stab stuff.) -
Huh? by
on 2015-01-10 22:44:00 UTC
Link to this
When do people get the name wrong? Or rather, how? What name?
Sorry if I sound really derby right now, but I have no clue what you're talking about... :( -
Explanation time! by
on 2015-01-10 23:09:00 UTC
Link to this
It has often been my experience that American authors call the Weasley twins' business "Weasley's Wizarding Wheezes". This is not what it's called, and the reason for that is that the phrase "wizard wheeze" is a slightly archaic term (I think it was used in the Just William books, but don't quote me on that) for a really good practical joke or prank of some description. Wizard Wheezes is the perfect name for the business, not least because it's something people have half a chance of getting in Diagon Alley and so forth. Changing it to Wizarding Wheezes, well... that irks.
Just a spot.
=] - People seriously call it that? by on 2015-01-10 23:32:00 UTC Link to this
-
Nice work! by
on 2015-01-10 02:28:00 UTC
Link to this
Rina and Randa are right, by the way; that foreshadowing is kind of unsubtle. (Also, I was confused when Rina used the DORKS to restore her disguise. When did the disguise drop?)
And...oh my Din, you're doing My Inner Life? Can I help in any possible capacity? I want to help Hyrule too! -
Re: Nice work! by
on 2015-01-10 03:32:00 UTC
Link to this
Rina changed back to normal after the boat ride. And kind of unsubtle? It was about as subtle as a baseball bat to the face. >_>
As for My Inner Life *shudders*, Randa's got LoZ knowledge out the wazoo... but would you like to beta? I'd be honored. :3
Since I'm planning on tackling Little Miss Mary and Rose Potter further down the line, I figured a non-Legendary Badfic (how is it not, now that I think of it? I stumbled across it years ago) of epic proportions would be a nice starting point. -
Congrats on the mission! =] by
on 2015-01-09 16:43:00 UTC
Link to this
It's pretty awesome, and it shows a good deal of courage to go through an old shame and have to read it critically, usually with a stiff drink and a therapist nearby.
One thing that struck me was that the D.O.R.K.S unit disguised itself as a copy of Magical Me, which seemed odd considering this is set in the Marauder era and the book wasn't published until the autumn of 1992. But then I realised; that's exactly the kind of totally minor deviation from canon that wouldn't upset the Words at all but a PPC agent would definitely notice. Good job. =] -
I wish I had a drink for this one. by
on 2015-01-09 17:24:00 UTC
Link to this
But it's probably better to save it for the next mission- wait, crap, I'm too young to drink! D:
I just figured the D.O.R.K.S. was being stupid on purpose... ^_^' But we'll pretend your interpretation is what I planned. Yep. *grins sheepishly* -
In similar vein... by
on 2015-01-09 18:00:00 UTC
Link to this
Regardless of the illegality, there's been no word on how well Bleeprin and related products work in regards to blood-alcohol content. It goes kaboomsky enough on the outside; its effects on one's arteries doesn't really bear thinking about.
But I am anyway.
I r smurt. -
Bleeprun is for people who can tolerate it. :P (nm) by
on 2015-01-09 19:25:00 UTC
Link to this
-
...well, poop. It looks like I created a Bleeprin with legs. (nm by
on 2015-01-09 19:26:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Hey, you could always use that! :P by
on 2015-01-10 21:47:00 UTC
Link to this
Bleeprun! The Bleepproduct that comes to you! Of course, it's more likely to be the Bleepproduct you have to chase down. ;)
-
NOOO! I DON'T WANNA BE EATEN! *scampers off to hide* (nm) by
on 2015-01-10 22:42:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Oooh, mobile Bleeproduce dispensers! by
on 2015-01-10 21:53:00 UTC
Link to this
Nick a replicator or something similar from a sci-fi badfic, bolt some legs on it, have it run around to the RCs in question!
And have them look like this. =] -
I was imagining them as looking closer to mini-Luggages. by
on 2015-01-10 21:58:00 UTC
Link to this
Probably with the same bad temper. I mean, would *you* be happy if you constantly had to give away your Bleeprin?
-
Quite literally, considering the typo in question. =] (nm) by
on 2015-01-09 22:31:00 UTC
Link to this
-
Cathartic cringe by
on 2015-01-09 15:49:00 UTC
Link to this
Rina's pain is so palpable I can't stop cringing. It makes for a unique mission, though, particularly the acknowledgments of when you did learn from your mistakes (and when you tried without understanding what actually made a Sue). Plus the resulting back-and-forth with the Agents is a lot of fun.
-
It's pretty obvious I had no idea what I was doing. by
on 2015-01-09 17:21:00 UTC
Link to this
There were some things that I knew I had to avoid, like urple prose and tragic backstories, but that alone wasn't enough... >_>
Glad you enjoyed it! -
Good job! by
on 2015-01-09 04:21:00 UTC
Link to this
The mission was very fun to read, though as a lover of terrible puns I didn't mind the Sirius/serious thing too much. I definitely relate to Rina's pain, though, and it's times like this I am happy none of my fics ever got past first chapters (and were all deleted years ago.)
-
Thank you :D (nm) by
on 2015-01-09 11:43:00 UTC
Link to this
-
I've got a better Sirius pun. by
on 2015-01-09 03:19:00 UTC
Link to this
"Are you serious?"
"Yes, I am. Oh, sorry, I thought you meant my name."
Not sure if it's funny, but it's probaby an improvement over what you had.
Why yes, I am a pun enthusiast. Puns are supposedy the lowest form of wit... but wit is the highest form of humor. -
They're simply punderbar! *is shot* by
on 2015-01-09 03:36:00 UTC
Link to this
Bad jokes aside, it's nigh impossible to find a Marauders-era fic that doesn't use the Sirius/serious thing at least once. You'd be hard-pressed to come up with a variation that doesn't make most people just roll their eyes. If I ever rewrite that story, I'll most likely just cut them and save everyone the headache.
-
You should sometime. I'd like to see how you'd save it! by
on 2015-01-09 03:46:00 UTC
Link to this
I would've done the same thing with "Rise of the Galeforces" myself, but sadly, I have never had the time to write any fanfic since my graduate degrees and it was doomed from the beginning anyway. At least in your case you stuck to a single continuum.
But anyway, I think it would be an interesting idea to try writing about a fifth marauder in a more realistic way, and possibly explore what happened to her and why they don't mention her in canon. It'll be hard, of course, but maybe it'll be a worthwhile investment. Maybe... -
Well... (Also, mini alert!) by
on 2015-01-09 04:48:00 UTC
Link to this
(*ushers marauder to the HFA*)
The plan I had from the beginning involved time travel and alternate timelines, but it required a Time-Turner. This wouldn't have been a problem, but JKR recently said on Pottermore that Time-Turners can go back only a few hours.
Not to mention I kind of stole an idea from A:TLA and the Sue also needed those stupid prophetic dreams in order to motivate her... I don't know. It would take a lot of finnageling. Which is sad, because I had ideas on how another Marauder would have an impact on Harry's story. -
Niiiiice~! by
on 2015-01-09 02:59:00 UTC
Link to this
I was actually reminded of my very first PPC mission while reading this - though to be fair, I sporked that 35-chapter horror story specifically to clear my name as a writer and to give Falchion a jump-start on character development. Yours comes off as more of a "Why not tackle an old shames for spits and giggles?" kind of deal, which isn't a bad thing.
And dear Arceus, "My Inner Life"? Oh wow, you have my sympathies. *virtual hugs* Godspeed, you two, and may you have Farore's blessing (and a firm grip on your sanity!)! -
*accepts hug* by
on 2015-01-09 03:31:00 UTC
Link to this
I'd been looking forward to sporking my old shame, and the deed is at last complete!
But yeah, My Inner Life... *shudders* The badly-written sex scenes, atrocious grammar, and utter Suishness were horrible enough on their own, but poor (RL) Randa has it way worse... she's a major LoZ fan, so this one hits her harder than it does me.