Sep 2013 Archive, part a

  • A littler bit of genre theory... by AdmiralSakai on 2013-09-01 01:38:00 UTC Link to this

    I got into a discussion recently with a friend about the differences between magic and technology, in the context of why I researched Galactic Age so thoroughly. Together, we made a couple of very interesting points, which I will summarize here.

    I was the first to point out that in a lot of the more well-thought-out fantasy universes (including my own aborted Thinking About Fantasy series), arcane magic is really just that universe's form of technology: mages study the natural laws of their universe, which are logically consistent despite being radically different from our own, learn how they operate through experimentation and hypothesis (science), and then figure out how to exploit those predicable behaviors to bring the "forces of nature" under human control (engineering). So while the result is something that looks radically different from the real world's technology, it is fundamentally the same process.

    Sam agreed, and mentioned that in a lot of "less-well-researched" science-fiction settings, technology operates more like magic: put a bunch of wires and glowy bits together, push some random buttons, and presto- it's a laser gun! Or maybe a microwave? We don't know, and don't bother trying to understand how it works, you're either a scientist who can make anything out of anything with the proper application of technobabble, or you're just hopelessly out of luck.

    This was a major idea. But it doesn't tell the whole story. Yes, there's levels of logical consistency/intensity that span multiple genres, but those genres themselves are also qualitatively distinct things- "magic" and "technology" are more than just levels of nitpicking. That's why I've created a two-dimensional classification system: logical sense and nonsense are referred to as "hardness" or "softness", respectively, and are separate from what we will be discussing as our main point today: features of the "magical" as opposed to the "technological."


    • Basis: Probably the aspect of magic/technology tied the closest to hardness and softness is that of which physical laws the setting obeys. In hard technological settings, the physical laws of the fictional world are the same as ours, and soft technological settings at least put on an attempt to seem that way as well. In hard magical settings, however, the laws are often very, very different from ones that we are familiar with (no chemical elements or subatomic particles, maybe even no Newtonian motion), and in soft magical settings they likely do not exist at all. Seeing a hard setting, with radically different physical laws, that still looks technological, is very rare. However, this isn't a reliable metric because it can break down entirely in soft settings.

    • Objects Vs. People: It's surprisingly consistent: technology relies on objects to function, whereas magic needs human intervention. In a technological setting, even though a person is often involved in the process of doing Cool Things, what they do is operate and control a device that actually manipulates the powers involved. In a magical setting, generally you actually need a mage to be there, casting the spells, and the "equipment" that said mage uses is generally minimal. Occasionally in magic you will encounter constructs such as golems and enchanted objects that do Cool Things with little to no human intervention, but I guarantee you that said constructs will have been created by people, without the help of other devices.

    • Corporeality: Magic generally involves a great amount of incorporeal "glowy stuff": instant runes, summoning circles, beams of light, apparitions and puffs of smoke, that sort of thing. Even when physical objects are used, they tend to generate at least one of the above when active. Technology, on the other hand, tends to rely much more on matter, or physical structure. There's glowy stuff there as well, but it's almost always emitted by, contained within, or attached to a sizable chunk of hardware.

    • Accessibility: Tying into the corporeality and object/person dichotomies, technology can often be mass-produced to make it accessible to the everyday person. With magic, that is often not the case. Depending on the setting, magic may be vanishingly rare and disbelieved entirely by most people, but the most accessible it seems to get is to have some enchanted weapons, potions, etc. purchasable the general population, as well as occasional mages who are about as accessible as chip designers or other highly-educated professionals in a technological society. Any more than that, and the setting starts to seem like a hybrid of magical and technological rather than just more sophisticated magic.

    • Structure: In conjunction with the above, technology seems to generate new materials (especially metals) that fall into active use in the next generation of technology. Magical neomaterials are rare, and not often used for building.

    • Shape: One of the easiest ways to make something look magical or technological is the way it's shaped: technology tends to have either smooth lines or right angles with lots of geometric shapes, while magic is generally more squiggly. Except for circles. Magic likes circles for some reason.

    • Character Sets: This one is actually kind of strange, but oddly persistent. Technology tends to be numerical- everything encountered has measurements associated with it ("Warp core power at 53% and rising!"), science is done with math and equations, and of course computers spout nonsensical strings of binary if you so much as look at them funny. Magic on the other hand, is much more literary-based. There are of course a bunch of spells and spellbooks involved, but the instant runes are also, well, runes, the magibabble is much more object-oriented, and the standard image of magical research involves the wizard browsing through hundreds of old tomes in some arcane library (as opposed to the chalkboard-of-equations setup in science).



    • I like your analysis (+ another distinction) by Huinesoron on 2013-09-01 13:30:00 UTC Link to this

      I've played around with the level of 'hardness' in magic myself; my own preferred magic system has a limited number of spells, each of which is accessed by tactile sensation. In simple terms, if you (ie, anybody) feels the right pattern of ridges, you cast the spell.

      That's a science, even if no-one knows how it works. For plot reasons, though, I've had to shift it into something entirely magical: there are a limited number of spells, each of which is cast in an entirely random way, and only by people who are capable of casting magic. Of course, since the beings working with the magic still verge toward the science end of the spectrum, they find it incredibly frustrating that there's no pattern to how it works.

      And another distinction... you mention 'Objects Vs. People', but there's also the matter of belief. A fair number of magic systems (not all, but lots) require the caster to believe the spell will work, or at least to put some indefined form of willpower into it. Technology, on the other hand, will work whether you think it will or not.

      hS

      • Re: I like your analysis (+ another distinction) by AdmiralSakai on 2013-09-01 15:36:00 UTC Link to this

        I don't mean to be a pedant (although I very much am), but technically what you've done is make the magic "softer", not more magical. This particular dissertation mentions hardness and softness, but doesn't really go into detail. A lot of people do confuse hard/soft with magic/tech, which is partially why I wrote it. Of course, I'm demonstrating quite a bit of hubris by taking it onto myself to define what is magic and what is technology, but then all mathematics starts with arbitrarily defining something useful and then improving it over time.

        Also, great point about the "belief" issue. It, and the idea of certain people having an inborn gift to use magic while other people are Muggles, do indeed seem to show up a lot more often in magical settings, probably because of the person-focused nature, and while it tends to show up in softer settings as opposed to harder ones, it is EXTREMELY rare in technology.

        • I sit corrected. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-02 09:42:00 UTC Link to this

          I guess the point you're making is that you can treat either magic or technology as a science - it can still be 'magic' if you follow a precise formula to achieve the same results every time, according to a known pattern, just as it can still be technology if you use a wishy-washy, 'you have to get a feel for it!' approach. Individually, your descriptors can be hit with counterexamples, but as a collection, they provide a pretty compelling structure.

          hS

          • Re: I sit corrected. by AdmiralSakai on 2013-09-02 14:44:00 UTC Link to this

            That's pretty much it. I knew you'd disambiguate it properly yourself pretty quickly. PPC has some SMART people.

            (Oh yes, and I should be getting rid of this crappy keyboard soon, so no more extraneous 'r's in the post titles!

    • Good analysis. by Sergio Turbo on 2013-09-01 09:55:00 UTC Link to this

      Also, just to better bring your point home, I'll make an example of a continuum where magic and technology are deeply intertwined: Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha.

      Here, magic is cast with the help of portable advanced computers (called Devices) and is no more and no less than a science, to the point that spells are cast through mathematic calculations and magical constructs are referred as "programs". Mana is basically just a form of energy as any else.

      • But what about the opposite? by Huinesoron on 2013-09-01 16:51:00 UTC Link to this

        As you and KittyEden have pointed out, there's a load of examples of people mucking about with magic, often making it more technological. But what about the opposite? Can we take technology and make it act more like magic?

        Well, actually, I guess the PPC has already done that. There is a faint technological basis to the portal generators (they take written plotholes and inject them into the Words), but they... well, actually, let's go through AdmiralSakai's list and see where PPC technology falls on the 'tech-magic' scale.

        -Basis: While the basic laws of physics are the same as ours, PPC tech is very much influenced by the Laws of Narrative Comedy. In the real world, excess punctuation does not fall as rain, and portals cannot be created by bad writing. Magic

        -Objects Vs. People: While a lot of the weird stuff that happens to PPCers just happens, all the 'technology' - the things that give them special abilities - is object based. This even applies to things that originally weren't: the 'canon shields us from view' has given way to an electronic SEP field. Tech

        -Corporeality: No contest here. Portals, CADs, all the good stuff - it's all either a hunk of metal, or (in the case of portals) emitted by one. Tech

        -Accessibility: I'm not sure on this one. PPC technology is mass-produced - but it seems to be mass-produced by one person, or at least a small group (DoSAT). What distinction do you draw between freely-available magic swords, and freely-available personal computers? Sure, one's magic, one's technological, but they're both equally accessible.

        -Structure: The PPC has a fair number of neomaterials - Generic Surface, Concrit - but they're not produced technologically. They come out of the altered laws of physics, I suppose.

        -Shape: Yeah, all right, PPC tech is very angular. Tech

        -Character Set: Can I just say, this is one of the more interesting things you've highlighted. I think again PPC tech is, well, technological - CADs give nice percentage readouts, for instance, and you have to punch in coordinates to get somewhere. Tech

        So apparently I'm wrong: PPC technology is not very magical. It's straight technology - just in a world with different rules.

        hS

        • Re: But what about the opposite? by AdmiralSakai on 2013-09-01 17:07:00 UTC Link to this

          I'd call it straight technology, but very soft.

          • I'm not so sure. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-01 19:15:00 UTC Link to this

            We have a fair history of people using their willpower to manipulate the story while on the job. I guess if you limit your analysis to the technology itself - portal generators, CADs - then it's all technology... but that's a self-selecting criterion. I reckon if you pull in things like Agent Lou talking to her author, the DTE suffering from (and occasionally weaponising) punctuation rain, spontaneously-appearing minis, various ex-Sue agents who use their Sue abilities to warp the story, the Laws of Narrative Comedy, manipulating the Laws of Narrative Comedy, etc etc etc... then I think the setting swings more towards magic.

            hS

            • Re: I'm not so sure. by AdmiralSakai on 2013-09-01 19:28:00 UTC Link to this

              You've got a point. Given that we work in both technological and magical canons and generally deal with reality abuse in every form, technology, magic, and everything else get mashed up with considerable frequency.

      • Another series like that... by KittyEden on 2013-09-01 12:45:00 UTC Link to this

        ...would be the Artemis Fowl series. The faries that live underground use highly advanced technology alongside their normal magic.

        • Re: Another series like that... by AdmiralSakai on 2013-09-01 15:53:00 UTC Link to this

          Oooh, I love the Artemis Fowl series!


          Both of these examples, by the way, introduce a somewhat "fuzzy" concept to my neat two-dimensional grid, namely the mixing of magic and technology. This is more or less independent of hardness/softness, so I'll just ignore that element and note that there are two different ways to "mix" magic and technology, both of which can exist in the same setting.

          The first is through magitech, where a single "thing" contains both magical and technological elements from the dichotomy categories above. A good example of this would be alchemy, which combines weird runes and archaic materials with laboratory glassware. While I'm not familiar with the series, the Nyona example above seems like magitech. However, you can also have things that are clearly magical and things that are clearly technological coexisting in the same setting, as in Artemis Fowl (although if I recall, some Fairy technology can make use of magic).

          Then you get into things like Clarke's third law and "bamboo technology", and it becomes hard to tell what's magical and what's technological (although I prefer to think of both methods as ways to get magical-looking stuff into a technological setting without actually introducing magic itself or violating hardness with things that SEEM to break our laws of physics).

    • That's a very, very interesting analysis. Good points. (nm) by Ailavyn Siniyash on 2013-09-01 05:35:00 UTC Link to this
  • Where We Were by Huinesoron on 2013-09-01 11:48:00 UTC Link to this

    Using the same spreadsheet technology as my occasional PPC Statistics posts, I thought it might be interesting to take a peek at what the PPC Board was doing on (approximately) this day in each year of its existence. It seems like it'd be fun to revisit past insanity, and who knows? Maybe in amongst this kaleidoscope of unfamiliar (and familiar?) names, we'll learn something, too.

    For each year, I'm going to give a few figures, summarise the topics under discussion on the Front Page, and list everyone who posted on that page. I will bold anyone who is still active - which in practice, translates as 'who posted in July 2013'. I may underline particularly significant names - but I'll avoid just underlining everyone I recognise. ;) (Oh, and I won't highlight anyone for this month - that would be silly)

    Oh, and for maximum coverage reasons, the 'today' I'll be using is August 12th.

    2013

    Length of Front Page: 25 threads.
    Total Posts on Front Page: 312

    Time Between First and Last Thread: Aug 3 4:24pm to Aug 12 11:07pm, so 9 days 7 hours
    Average Threads per Day [threads per page/time-length of page]: 2.7
    Average Posts per Hour [posts per page/time-length of page]: 1.4

    Topics:
    -5 newbies, 3 PPC questions
    -2 plugs, 3 badfic threads, 1 Permission request, 1 beta request
    -The Random Title Generator, The PPC facebook page, OFU discussion, 'Writer's Alzheimer's', Tumblr, Dead links, Mary-Sue Article, Pacific Rim, the game 'Exalted', the Twelfth Doctor

    Posters (54): AelinTheAmazing, Ailavyn Siniyash, AquaMarine, a-rubra, Autumn68, Ayane458, Bausiren, Bryn, Cassie, Crimson Flight, Cronist, Cyba Zero, darklordaakmal, DawnFire, DemonFiren, Desdendelle, doctorlit, EileenAlphabet, Elcalion, Ellipsis Flood, Endless Sea, Falcon7974, firemagic, hermione of vulcan, Herr Wozzeck, Hieronymus Graubart, Huinesoron, IntelligentAirhead, Ivan the Not-so-Terrible, Kittythekatty, Legacy, Lenore Snow, Lily Winterwood, Lynne Lloyd, Miah, Neshomeh, Outhra, Phobos, platypus, Ponystar17, Pretzel, Rin, SeaTurtle, Sergio Turbo, sonofheaven176, SpecstacularSC, Storme Hawk, Techno-Dann, the Irish Samurai, The Mind Tool, Time Engineer, Tomash, VixenMage, Voyd

    2012

    Length of Front Page: 25 threads.
    Total Posts on Front Page: 548

    Time Between First and Last Thread: Jul 25 10:48am to Aug 11 1:45pm, so 17 days 3 hours
    Average Threads per Day: 1.5
    Average Posts per Hour: 1.3

    Topics:
    -4 newbies, 1 PPC question
    -3 plugs, 1 badfic thread, 1 Permission request
    -PPC fanart, 'Curiosity' landing on Mars, expanding the Canon Protection Initiative, Things I Am Not Allowed to Do at the PPC, Percy Jackson Sues, Writing what you don't know, How to stop yourself doing stupid things, Camp NaNoWriMo, Sharks vs Bears, a funfair, Voldemort at the Olympics, Amending the Constitution, DeviantArt, what we can spork, fandom pet peeves

    Posters (69): Aeidhryn, AnnaBee, Antigone68104, Araeph, Artell, Aster Corbett, Astral Void, Calista, Cassie, Cyba Zero, darklordaakmal, Data Junkie, desdendelle, doctorlit, Dragormir, dramaticsoprano, Dropship8, EileenAlphabet, Elcalion, Ellipsis Flood, firemagic, Gandalf the Beige, HimochiIsAwesome, Huinesoron, Ivan the Not-so-Terrible, Jacer, JulyFlame, Kaitlyn, Laburnum, Lilac Lielac, Lily Winterwood, Litany, LunarHuntress, Maslab, MAXinsanity (409), Miah, MrThorSir, Neshomeh, OpinionedAngel, Ozzielot, Past Llamas, Phobos, PitViperOfDoom, Ponystar17, PoorCynic, Puck, Rosie Azrael, saintdane05, SeaTurtle, Sergio Turbo, Sevenswans, ShatteredSanity, Shellfur, SingingTheThunder, StarShadow, Tawaki, Techno-Dann, ThatOne, the Irish Samurai, The Rabbit from Hourai, TheMadHatteress, theusualsuspectshines, Tira, Tomash, Tungsten
    Monk, VixenMage, voidoid-, Wikimaster, Wodan

    2011

    Length of Front Page: 25 threads.
    Total Posts on Front Page: 250

    Time Between First and Last Thread: Aug 2 3:01pm to Aug 12 7:43pm, so 10 days 5 hours
    Average Threads per Day: 2.4
    Average Posts per Hour: 1.0

    Topics:
    -3 newbies, 1 returnbie, 1 PPC questions
    -9 plugs, 2 badfic threads, 1 Permission request, beta request
    -Spam in ff.net's Redwall section, Seattle Gathering, OFUs, Things I Am Not Allowed to Do at the PPC, Neshomeh and Phobos' wedding, RPF, wacky crossovers, 'Assisting Skaianet'

    Posters (65): Aeidhryn, Albatross, Antigone68104, Artell, Aster Corbett, Astral Void, Bluesunnyday, caddy-shack, Calista, Cassie Cameron-Young, Charlie dodo, doctorlit, dramaticsoprano, EileenAlphabet, Elcalion, Elemarth, Ellipsis Flood, Firebird766, Fish Custard, Flyndragon, gaijinguy, galenfea, Gandalf the Beige, Guvnor of Space, HerrWozzeck, IndeMaat, insanepersonishappy, Jacer, Kaist, Khroma, Kitty's Muse, KsandraMallan, Laburnum, Lily Winterwood, Luigifan, Makari, Maudlin Hart, Miah, Mister Shoebox, Myrtle Tamlane, Neshomeh, Nin68, OpinionedAngel, Phobos, Pieguy, PoorCynic, Pretzel, Ray Chell, ReginaTheNinja, Rosie Azrael, Sara, Sedri ,Sergio Turbo ,ShatteredSanity, Sonne, Stan, Tawaki, Techno-Dann, Tomash, Tranum, TungstenMonk, Vixenmage, Will-o-wisp, Worthington, Xanthia B.

    2010

    Length of Front Page: 25 threads.
    Total Posts on Front Page: 311

    Time Between First and Last Thread: Aug 4 7:04pm to Aug 12 9:47am, so 7 days 15 hours
    Average Threads per Day: 3.3
    Average Posts per Hour: 1.7

    Topics:
    -2 newbies, 1 returnbie, 1 PPC question
    -5 plugs, 4 badfic threads, 1 beta request
    -PPC movie, Things I Am Not Allowed to Do at the PPC, The Great Typo Hunt, PPC Cookbook, Sue videos, minis, food fight, Coney-Grelvish, Klingon-language fanfic, The Batimaeus Trilogy, Lovecraft-verse,

    Posters (51): Aeidhryn, Araeph, Aster Corbett, Barid [aka Phobos], BattleHamster, Callista, Cassie Cameron-Young, Charlie DoDo, Chliever, Chrystallix, Data Junkie, DigitalSocrates, doctorlit, Eclectus, Edward Wilder, Elcalion, Elemarth, Farseer Lolotea, Firebird766, galenfea, Gandalf the Beige, Honu
    Wahine, Huinesoron, IndeMaat, Italian for Grandma, jakraziel, JulyFlame, Keily, Khajidu, Kyoki, Laburnum, Lleu, Makari, Maudlin Hart, Miah, Michi, Neshomeh, OpinionedAngel, orangedream13, PitViperOfDoom, PoorCynic, Pretzel, Rosie Azrael, Sedri, Sergio Turbo, Silikat, Simon, Tawaki, TungstenMonk, Wide Eyed Idealist, WikiMaster

    2009

    Length of Front Page: 25 threads.
    Total Posts on Front Page: 387

    Time Between First and Last Thread: Aug 1 7:56pm to Aug 12 11:36pm, so 11 days 4 hours
    Average Threads per Day: 2.2
    Average Posts per Hour: 1.4

    Topics:
    -4 returnbies
    -3 plugs, 4 badfic threads, 2 beta requests
    -Art commissions, What Leto saw on vacation, Things I Am Not Allowed to Do at the PPC, least favourite webcomics, checking for Sues, Leeds Gathering, Fair Trade chocolate, birthday, het v slash, casting call, 'G-Force', politics

    Posters (49): (name here), An Raidre Dubh, Anity, Ansela, Araeph, Bailey Matutine, Buta, Cassie Cameron-Young, Chliever, Cinnia Aine, Crystal, Faith, Fiveclawed, Hellga, Huinesoron, IndeMaat, JulyFlame, Kd7sov, kgarrett [aka Ekyl], khajidu, kitsune106, Laburnum, Leto Haven, Lily Winterwood, Luana Starlight, Makari, Maudlin Hart, Neshomeh, Oozaru Angel, Orange Hotaru, Pads, Paladin, Pipistrellus, PitViperOfDoom, Rosie Azrael, Sara, Sedri, Seranis, tabbycat, Tawaki, Techno-Dann, The Trojanhorse, thejadefalcon, Tiroth, Tomato, Ulalume, Vixenmage, WarriorJoe, WikiMaster

    2008

    Length of Front Page: 25 threads.
    Total Posts on Front Page: 365

    Time Between First and Last Thread: Aug 7 9:17pm to Aug 12 10:04pm, so 5 days 1 hour
    Average Threads per Day: 5.0
    Average Posts per Hour: 3.0

    Topics:
    -1 newbie, 2 returnbie, 2 PPC questions
    -3 plugs, 5 badfic threads, 2 beta requests
    -Elves, new Departments, Things I Am Not Allowed to Do at the PPC, Board showing IP addresses, the DCPS, seeking for interviews, Wikilots shutting down, OFUs, PPC Orchestra, spambot

    Posters (45): Adagio, Anity, Ansela, Araeph, Artic Blade, Cassie Cameron-Young, cga, Crystal, Elcalion, Enelya, Eni, Fichunter, Fynn, Gandalf the Beige, Huinesoron ,immortal
    jedi, IndeMaat, insanegrrl, JulyFlame, JusttheDoctor, Korora, Laburnum, Leto Haven, Lily Winterwood, lynxihez, Makari, Neshomeh, Oozaru Angel, Paddlebrains, pigeonarmy, Platinumyo, Rilwen Shadowflame, Sara, Sedri, Skid, Tawaki, Techno-Dann, The Trojanhorse, thejadefalcon, Tomato, TZA, Vixenmage, Wandering Critic, WikiMaster, wingnut

    Prior to this point, the date I can select depends on what the Wayback Machine has archived.

    2007

    Length of Front Page: 25 threads.
    Total Posts on Front Page: 225

    Time Between First and Last Thread: Jul 30 11:48AM to Aug 16 10:21AM, so 16 days 23 hours
    Average Threads per Day: 1.5
    Average Posts per Hour: 0.6

    Topics:
    -1 plugs, 9 badfic threads, 1 beta requests, 1 Permission request
    -Rose Potter, List of the Slain, chatroom and betachain, minis, Harry Potter Book Seven Challenge, That Series, PPC baby, something off-topic, Torchwood, Watership Down minis, nm&nms, a mass mission, Feet of Clay

    Posters (48): A Random Boo, Adagio, Agent Overdrive, Air Of Mystery, Angel Barchild, Ansela, Araeph, Araine, BattleHamster, CedarCopse, Crystal, Dorcas, Err..., Gandalf the Beige, Gen, Gillespy, Huinesoron, IndeMaat, insanegrrl, Jabraille, Karma, Kd7sov, Kerowyn, kitsune106, Laburnum, Leto Haven, Mackenzie, mari
    braveheart, Neshomeh, nscangal, Oozaru Angel, Rath, Rez, Sara, Starwind Rohana, Tawaki, Techno-Dann, thejadefalcon , Tindomiel, Tomato, TZA, Vasi, Vered, Virtual Aardvark, Vixenmage, Yattara, Yubi Shines, Zoe

    2006

    Length of Front Page: 20 threads.
    Total Posts on Front Page: 230

    Time Between First and Last Thread: Sep 15 6:57PM to Sep 19 6:41PM, so 4 days
    Average Threads per Day: 5.0
    Average Posts per Hour: 2.4

    Topics:
    -1 returnbie, 1 PPC questions
    -4 plugs, 1 badfic thread, 1 Permission request, 1 beta request
    -'Two way nerdy queries', Talk Like A Pirate Day, publication of 'The Children of Hurin', Silmarillion vampires, dystopias, birthday, Doctor Who easter eggs, "Since they aren' (nm)", 'Baby's Named a Bad, Bad Thing', James Bond, Tolkien languages

    Posters (43): Air of Mystery, Alania, Angel Barchild, BeautyID, Blayze, Coffeecup, Cygna-hime, Elcalion, Ella Darcy, Eni, eris86, Err..., Fynn, Gandalf the Beige, gundamkiwi, Huinesoron, Karma, Keily ,Kerowyn, kitsune106, Laburnum, MatthiasWaverunner, Nathonea , Neshomeh, Nin Brandt, nscangal, Rez, roseleeks, Salix, Sera Erykah, Sil, Sophia, Starwind Rohana, Tawaki, Techno-Dann, TungstenMonk, Twiggy, TZA, Versus, Visp, VixenMage, Yattara, Zoe

    2005

    Length of Front Page: 20 threads.
    Total Posts on Front Page: 333

    Time Between First and Last Thread: Jul 25 11:55pm to Jul 28 10:49am, so 2 days 11 hours
    Average Threads per Day: 8.1
    Average Posts per Hour: 5.6

    Topics:
    -2 newbies, 1 PPC questions
    -6 plugs
    -'Anyone with a Tough Mind... HELP!', 'All Your Base' song, birthday, computer problems, fathers in Tolkien, an event in Houston, baby names, mechs, NASA, religion, birthday,

    Posters (48): Air of Mystery, Airmid Star, Araeph, Arokka, Athena Arion, BeautyID, Berzerkerprime, Bjam, Boz4PM, Cygna-hime, Dragonlet, Elb, Elcalion, ElfEars, Ella Darcy, Enelya, Eumenides, Fire Sidoni, fondued jicama, gundamkiwi, Huinesoron, Jaster, Jess, Jury, Kaitlyn, Katharine Faith, Kerowyn, Latent Psychopath, Leto Haven, Little Baldwin, Luthien, Morgul, Mum's the Word, nscangal, Puredeadthingy, Randomelf, Rath, Rez, Salix, Sil, Sliven, SlivenFdF, Spoofmaster, Techno-Dann, The Greenough Hall MSTers Club, Tulkas, TZA, wrongdimension

    2004

    Length of Front Page: 20 threads.
    Total Posts on Front Page: 125

    Time Between First and Last Thread: Aug 11 11:09am to Aug 12 8:53pm, so 1 day 10 hours
    Average Threads per Day: 14.1
    Average Posts per Hour: 3.7

    Topics:
    -1 newbie, 1 returnbie
    -2 plugs, 2 badfic threads, 2 beta request
    -Boarder photo, birthday, 'Elrond married an empath', Celebrian, Sue and Stu names, message for Fondued Jicama, LotR Exhibition, Hurricane Charlie, new Department, error, 'What about the Czechs?', 'the truth about the One Ring'

    Posters (39): A Random Boo, Airmid Star, Andy, Annalas, Araeph, BeautyID, Bjam, Bridiliel, Cerberus Dis, Ealasaid, Ekwy, Evil Bob, fondued jicama, French Pony, Gen, hailthewarrior, Hawkelf, Hellga, Huinesoron, Jocelyn, Ké Sonraume, Laburnum, Laih, Little Baldwin, Luthien, Mercuria, Miiro, Narello, Newmoon, Niamh, Rath, Sliven, Tamaris, technetium, Techno-Dann, Teena, Twiggy, TZA, wingnut

    2003

    Length of Front Page: 20 threads.
    Total Posts on Front Page: 123

    Time Between First and Last Thread: Aug 10 7:54pm to Aug 11 5:20pm, so 21 hours
    Average Threads per Day: 22.9
    Average Posts per Hour: 5.9

    Topics:
    -1 newbie, 3 returnbies
    -3 plugs, 3 badfic threads, 1 beta request
    -plotbunny, website, Catchup project, CD recommendation, Suvians, error, song parodies, song parodies, song parodies

    Posters (48): AC, Aldarwen, Al's Waiter, Artemis, BeautyID, bjam, Blue Iris, Bodldops, Bookwyrm, Caraid, Chirleep, Drew, Elena, Ella Darcy, Em, EruNephew, French Pony, GreyLadyBast, He Who Hunts, HonorH, Inannle, Jay Sea, Jedipati, Jo, Kaltia, Katharine/Dour K, Leto Haven, Luhtarian, Majoranka, Mercuria, nilib, one of the lurking masses, oracle, Otik [aka Jay!], Raen, Rhysdux, Sarah, Simmí, Sparkling Diamond, Starbrat, Steel Lily, T.E.O.W., Teensy Whitman, Thalia Weaver, Tough Cookie, TZA, Vemi, Zahri

    2002

    Length of Front Page: 20 threads.
    Total Posts on Front Page: 63

    Time Between First and Last Thread: Dec 3 11:32pm to Dec 11 12:26am, so 8 days 1 hour
    Average Threads per Day: 2.5
    Average Posts per Hour: 0.3

    Topics:
    -3 plugs, 8 badfic threads
    -questions, something funny, 'Find me a LOGICAL description somewhere!', opinions on Manwe, Suedom, question, computer problems, The Two Towers, random stuff

    Posters (23): Acacia, Architeuthis, Canon Police, Cimmoren, Curious Kazra, Emily Posts ;-), Gaslight, Maureen Lycaon, Meg Thornton, Meir Brin, Miss Cam, Nath, Otik [aka Jay], P@L, Rose, Salad the Deceiver, Secret Identity, The Andy Half, The Critic, The Evil Old Woman, The Saphie Half, Tragic
    Beauty, Winterfox




    And the 'too many words' version: a graph of averages.



    hS

    • Wow by Elcalion on 2013-09-03 12:27:00 UTC Link to this

      So many names, such a blast from the past. Thanks for putting this together hS!

    • Dang... by Herr Wozzeck on 2013-09-02 04:11:00 UTC Link to this

      Wow, it's interesting how much this sort of thing is put into perspective by something like this. I mean, Jeez... it's almost difficult to believe that this place has been around for 10 years and it's doing all this stuff with that...

      Now I feel kinda honored...

    • Very Nice. by Pretzel on 2013-09-02 02:45:00 UTC Link to this

      That had to have taken a lot of effort to put together. Great job!

    • Oh, wow. by Gen on 2013-09-02 00:04:00 UTC Link to this

      Seeing the names of people from when I first joined brings back so many memories. :D

    • Wow. by Lenore Snow on 2013-09-01 23:37:00 UTC Link to this

      Again, I'm amazed by the work you put into the PPC. These are really intriguing, and I especially like the line graphs at the end. Seems like 2008 was the golden age of the PPC...

      • Better to say... by Phobos on 2013-09-02 00:08:00 UTC Link to this

        A golden age. I like to believe that the best is yet to come.

        -Phobos

        • Well said. by Lenore Snow on 2013-09-02 00:41:00 UTC Link to this

          The golden age... thus far.

    • Re: Where We Were by AdmiralSakai on 2013-09-01 17:59:00 UTC Link to this

      Most fascinating. I'm still amazed when I see that the PPC has been around since the early 2000s...

    • You, sir, by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-01 16:47:00 UTC Link to this

      are mad.

      Keep it up.

      Also what's going on with OFU-Squared.

      • OFU-Squared by Huinesoron on 2013-09-01 18:56:00 UTC Link to this

        OFU2 is essentially waiting for everyone to be happy that they've put in everything they want. Then I think we should clear out all the comments and go through on a general clean-up; we can comment anything we think needs major changes, and simply edit anything that looks minor.

        hS

        • Mkay by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-01 19:12:00 UTC Link to this

          I'll give it a look-see later-ish.

          • Good stuff. :) (nm) by Huinesoron on 2013-09-01 19:16:00 UTC Link to this
    • Very interesting by Phobos on 2013-09-01 15:23:00 UTC Link to this

      I could swear I was around in 2009. I remember the discussion on Fair Trade Chocolate. Maybe I just wasn't posting yet. It is a whole lot of fun to see how much I remembered of what was going on while I've been here.

      Also, the graphs at the end show me something interesting. It seems that we have fewer conversations than they did at the beginning of the group, but our conversations are longer , on average. I wonder why that is.

      Also...Neshomeh and Phobos' wedding made the list! Drinks for everyone!

      -Phobos

      • Longer conversations. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-01 19:09:00 UTC Link to this

        I think the primary reason for longer conversations is two reasons. ;) Okay:

        1/ The speed of new thread formation. In 2003 we got through the front page in 21 hours. That means there was no chance of a long thread forming. Nowadays we tend to keep threads active until they're about halfway down the front page - in 2003, those same threads would have been five pages back already! Note that the frequency of posts is down by a factor of 4 from 2003 - we said a lot more then, we just had less time to say it in!

        2/ We aggregate threads a lot more these days. 2002 shows this very clearly - they had 8 badfic threads, almost half the front page! Nowadays we clump those together.

        3/ Did I say two?

        4/ Newbies. The early years had one newbie per front page, more or less. This year, we had 5. Newbie threads often garner a lot of replies. This isn't, obviously, a bad thing - but it does skew the figures a bit.

        That said, it is an interesting phenomenon. I wonder to what extent it would drop out if we applied some sort of standardisation to the dataset - perhaps classing all badfic posts under one 'thread', and removing all newbie posts from consideration. I might take a look at that - purely for giggles.

        hS

        (Also - you probably were around in '09. Bear in mind, this is just the people who posted on one particular page - Kaitlyn doesn't appear in two of the three-ish years she was active, for example, because she simply didn't post at the right time)

        • That makes sense. by Phobos on 2013-09-01 19:52:00 UTC Link to this

          Wow. 21 hours for a thread to be gone from the front page. Not much time at all. I know that some of us check the Board pretty often, but there are people who might miss whole pages of threads if they couldn't get access on a weekend, or something. That's pretty amazing.

          Thread aggregation is not something I had considered. Makes sense, though. I know we make an effort for that sort of thing, now.

          You did say two. Perhaps you missed the superscript two above it?

          Ah, Newbies. They do draw in a lot of comments, don't they?

          Good luck on the statistical manipulations. I lack such skills, myself.

          -Phobos

          (Also, I had not considered that. I would have just moved out to Chicago, at the time. Maybe I did not yet have internet.)

  • Can We Stop Adapting Things? by Huinesoron on 2013-09-02 11:53:00 UTC Link to this

    ... or, actually: Can We Start Adapting Things?

    I'm sure it's escaped no-one's notice that the film world is obsessed with adaptations and sequels. I guess that's been true for a long time, but I think it's become much more prevalent lately. And, actually, that's great - seeing something you loved as a book turned into a film is brilliant, and if you watch the film first, then you have a book to look forward to. Okay, good.

    But... well, it's great in theory. In practice, filmmakers seem to have a fanatical aversion to just adapting books: they always want to change them.

    To use some Lord of the Rings examples: I'm not talking about cuts and changes made for the sake of time. I would dearly love to see a 100% faithful filming of the entire book, but I accept that wouldn't be something you could sell. So yes, Tom Bombadil goes, a lot of the complexity gets stripped out - it's painful, but some things have to happen.

    But then you have things they added. Things like Faramir trying to take Frodo and Sam to Minas Tirith, or Flaming Denethor, or Sam turning around outside Shelob's lair. Those aren't time-saving, or complexity-reduction - they're a simple case of the filmmaker saying 'I know better than the writer I'm adapting'.

    And it's not just Lord of the Rings. When they filmed The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, they inexplicably made it into a film about a quest to collect seven magical swords and destroy a... sentient dark cloud, or whatever was going on there at the end. And for me, that ruined the film. Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief got turned into a multi-part quest too for some reason (specifically 'find the three magical pearls!', because... what, them being a gift was too complicated?), and that ignores the multiple other issues with it. The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey acquired a whole new villain out of nowhere, despite the fact that pretty much every chapter already has an antagonist. And I'm sure there are other examples - these are just the ones on the tip of my brain.

    So this is my question, I guess: not 'Can we stop making adaptations?', but, 'Why can't people START adapting books, rather than changing them?'. Why can't they accept that, if they're filming a popular book, their job is (or should be) to come as close to the original as possible with the resources they have?

    hS

    • I dunno... by Data Junkie on 2013-09-03 09:33:00 UTC Link to this

      I mean, I liked the Harry Potter and LotR/Hobbit movies significantly more than the books. And these are book series I read multiple times as a child.

      On the other hand, World War Z was awful. It would have been cheaper, easier, and more accurate to make a mockumentary about life after the zombie apocalypse.

      One thing I think we can all agree on though is that 90% of videogame adaptations are awful,

      • Oh, the video games... by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-03 15:31:00 UTC Link to this

        Yeah, those tend to be not-so-great. But I am pleased to see someone else who likes the LotR/Hobbit movies more than the books. Don't get me wrong, Hobbit was my favorite book growing up, but I love the cinematic version.

    • On Adaptations and Mediums by Phobos on 2013-09-02 17:35:00 UTC Link to this

      First off, let me say that I agree with your major points. Cutting for time, Peter Jackson being bad at this, etc. All of your points are well made. We could argue about the merits of some of the changes, but that is not what I want to talk about.

      What I would like to point out is that there is an element missing in this discussion. And that is Medium. We see a fairly large number of Book to Movie adaptations, and those are usually the big names. However, we also have Graphic Novels, Television shows, and the occasional Musical Theatre adaptation. Each of these mediums have their strengths and their weaknesses.

      Books: You want information and detail? Books have that in spades. You want a story that you can experience in less than 4 hours? Not so much. A book can be as long as the author wants because you can put it down if you need to go to work or something.

      Movies: Want to experience an epic story in less than 4 hours? Done and done. Want to know what your characters are thinking? Not so good for that. Movies are great for a condensed story, and for being allowing you to see the action. However, they come with a time limit, so something is going to have to go.

      TV Show: Want a half-way point between movies at books? This is the medium for you. TV shows, whether full or mini series, can have greater length than movies, while still keeping many of the benefits. They also allow for more detail, though not as much as books.

      Graphic Novels: Allow for the length that books enjoy, though somewhat less detail, while still allowing you to see what is going on.

      Musicals: I don't even know.



      So, the big problem, I feel, is that people do not consider the medium when adapting a book. If you go from a book to a movie, you are going from the least compressed medium to the most compressed. The change is not likely to be smooth unless you really know what you are doing. Book to TV, however, is going from the least compressed to a moderately compressed medium. The transition is likely to be more forgiving.

      If they decide to go straight from book to video, then some big changes might be called for. For example, I have a friend who absolutely hated the recent adaptation of World War Z, because it was nothing like the book. When I read the book, I couldn't understand her hatred. It was unreasonable to expect that the movie would be a guy interviewing 30-ish people after the Zombie War. There wasn't the time, and there wasn't any good way to do it. An adaptation would have been terrible. So they didn't make one. They made a movie inspired by the book. In order to make a true adaptation, they would have had to make it into a mini-series style mockumentary.

      There is something to be said for just not making something, though. I have several books/series that I think would make terrible movies.

      -Phobos

    • Well, to be honest... by hermione of vulcan on 2013-09-02 15:34:00 UTC Link to this

      There are two sides to this, which I'm not sure you're acknowledging (if you are, sorry for assuming).

      The first side:

      I agree with everything you said about Percy Jackson. I was so mad about that movie. Sea of Monsters was marginally better, but still pretty bad. I really think in this case, they let money dictate creative decisions and now it's screwing them, because they alienated all the fans.

      And I have to say, the more I think about it, the more I don't like the Star Trek reboot. Too many lens flares, too sexist, too much action. Also, comparing it to DS9, which I'm about halfway through at the moment, is no contest. And DS9's the one with less fans. *shakes head*

      And sequels can be very bad, especially when the movie was meant as a stand alone. So I too am wary of them.

      However...

      The other side:

      I think a lot of these examples are actually really good adaptations. LOTR changed things and added things, yes, but those things were (for the most part) good. Arwen gets character development. The Ring tempts everyone. The long hobbit birthday party gets trimmed down. People actually talk like people talk. I was annoyed at some of the overly long fight scenes in ROTK, though, and would have liked to see more Faramir/Eowyn and the "hands of a king are the hands of a healer" scene. But overall, I think they're quite good.

      Voyage of the Dawn Treader was a very episodic book. It would have worked better as perhaps a miniseries. To adapt it to a movie, they had to give it an overarching plotline. It's been a while since I've seen it, but I remember it working.

      The Hobbit - well, three parts is a bit much, but the book is, on the whole, unimpressive cinematically. I was rereading it in preparation for the movie and was actually craving eggs and bacon because Bilbo mentioned them so much. That's not the tone you want for a movie that's set in the same 'verse as LOTR. So I understand why they did a lot of what they did. They went a bit far (like I said, three parts), but they had to do something.

      And also, some sequels are good. The Wrath of Khan is better that The Motion Picture. Everyone I've talked to loves Iron Man 3. TNG, DS9, and Voyager are excellent series.

      And we can all agree that the Harry Potter and Hunger Games adaptations are (at least so far with Hunger Games) really good? They have their flaws, but so do everything.


      I guess what I'm trying to say here is that I don't see a trend towards making bad adaptations and sequels. There are lots of bad sequels and adaptations, but there are also good ones, and I really can't say that there are more or less, or that the trend swings one way or another.

      • Well, I certainly tried to acknowledge it. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-04 08:04:00 UTC Link to this

        To sit solely in my favourite example, LotR, you... actually, I'm going to run through your examples one by one, because they hit some points I'd like to/tried to make.

        -Arwen gets character development. Well, her character certainly 'develops', but since that development is from 'fearless sword-girl' to 'does everything Daddy says even when it's stupid' to 'ODE MARRIAGE MAKES CHILDREN!?!?', I'm not sure that's a positive... ;) But yes, she gets screentime, and given that the romance is a significant (if not major) part of the plot, I have no problem with that. My problem with the treatment of Arwen is that it was wildly inconsistent - and pretty darn illogical in places. (As I've seen mentioned recently, the way she talks in her introduction, she knew Frodo was deathly ill - so why was it she decided to start out by playing 'Let's put a sword to the North's greatest fighter's throat and hope he doesn't kill me before he knows who I am'?)

        -The Ring tempts everyone. This seems to fall into two categories. On the one hand, we have scenes like Boromir picking it up on Caradhras, and various 'hey look it talks' scenes. These, I have no problem with. On the other hand, you have Faramir. Who, apparently, they did the whole 'let's show my quality by kidnapping!' thing to show that everyone is tempted by the Ring. Only... two things. No, three:

        1) That is a perfect example of 'I know better than that 'Tolkien' bloke'. JRRT specifically wrote Faramir as not giving in to temptation. It's not like it never came up - the character faced exactly the same dilemma, and the canonical version did the opposite to the film version. To me, that feels very much like the scriptwriter thinking they can write stories better than the person they're adapting - which was a major part of what I was complaining about.

        2) Faramir didn't give into temptation. We know what the Ring tempts people to do - take it, by force if necessary, and use it themselves. Not take it to their father.

        3) Even ignoring the way they got there, Frodo and Sam being in Osgiliath opened up a slew of plotholes which never got closed. First, they ended up walking further after, without Faramir ever giving them the extra food they needed - and given that the lembas got chucked away later, the films should have ended with two Hobbits starving to death. But secondly, a Nazgul saw the Ring was there. Sauron launched an all-out assault on Gondor, ahead of schedule, because he suspected Aragorn had the Ring. Why didn't he throw everything he had at Osgiliath as soon as the Nazgul detected Frodo? For that matter, why didn't he connect the dots once he captured a short person in Cirith Ungol? The side-trip to Osgiliath, triggered by 'I can write Faramir better than Tolkien', was not well-written, and its consequences were ignored.

        -The long hobbit birthday party gets trimmed down. And that's good! Or at least acceptable. Like I said, I understand that it's a different medium; things have to be cut, and tweaked around to make the cuts make sense. I'm not actually sure it was cut that much: mostly the book just tells us what has already happened, and we did end up with long sequences involving Merry and Pippin. But yes, things were cut, and when they're not significant to the plot, or can be worked around, that's okay.

        -People actually talk like people talk. And again, that's adaptation for you. What works on the page doesn't always work on the screen (and vice versa), so of course they had to tweak and change the lines. I don't object to that, or to other changes made to make the thing filmable! What I object to - strongly - is changes made for no good reason, which aren't well thought-out, and which serve only to promote the filmmaker's 'vision' as more important than the author's.

        (And to head off a potential point - yes, I'm sure there are screenwriters who are better writers than the authors they're adapting. That's not the point. If you're adapting something, you try to make something close to the source - or you should)

        hS

    • I guess,.. by KittyEden on 2013-09-02 13:22:00 UTC Link to this

      ...it's becausthey think it won't be exciting enough.
      I was unhappy with PJ too. Annabeth's supposed to be BLOND, for crying out loud!
      Don't get me started on Mr Popper's Penguins...

      • On character appearance. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-02 13:40:00 UTC Link to this

        I actually don't mind (too much) that they changed Annabeth's hair colour - it's entirely non-plot-relevant. Similarly, they cast the Norse god Heimdall as black in Thor - and he was really good.

        Yes, I suppose that appearance should be looked into, although a lot of it can be changed by makeup (Legolas was played by Orlando Bloom who has entirely different hair and eye colour); that said, it usually won't spoil a movie if it's the only problem.

        That also said, I have major problems with movie!Annabeth in general. We just saw Sea of Monsters, and, er... why did I come out of the cinema liking Clarisse-daughter-of-Ares about ten times more than Annabeth-the-other-main-character? Annabeth spent all her time glowering and not being wise (you know, which as a daughter of Athena is sort of her point), while Clarisse - who in that book is a vicious, ungrateful bully - was all smiles. I could see her as Annabeth, no problem.

        hS

        • Annabeth's appearance bothered me a lot... by hermione of vulcan on 2013-09-02 14:53:00 UTC Link to this

          ...because it showed how little they cared about being close to the book. As in, they couldn't even bother to get that right.

          • I can see your point. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-02 16:31:00 UTC Link to this

            And in this case, that almost certainly was the reason. They couldn't be bothered to get Annabeth's hair right, so why should we have expected them to use a Greek depiction of Hades? It's so much less hassle to just make it into a fiery Hell instead, right? I mean, honestly, do those fans think we're out to adapt the book or something? Pfft, who does that 'Rich Riddorian' person think he is, anyway?

            Er, sorry, got distracted there. My point was... did I have a point?

            Oh, yes. I think the 'couldn't even be bothered' thing was the point of my original post, really - as in, if you're not going to bother doing it properly, why bother at all? But in the specific case of appearance... I don't think we'd complain about Annabeth's hair if the rest of the film was good. It's one of those complaints, like Philosopher at Large writing an essay about how the Black Ships at Minas Tirith were Dromonds, Not Junks - it's a good point, and it is irritating, but if the movie had been good otherwise, we wouldn't be too bothered about it.

            hS

    • I've heard a phrase once ... by BlockMechanics on 2013-09-02 13:20:00 UTC Link to this

      ... That goes along the lines of "If you wanted to watch an accurate adaption of a book, go read the book!". Personally though, its a flimsy excuse, but somehow a passable one at that.

      As much as I want to expand on my argument, I can't seem to find a movie that had to make changes for the sake of making changes. I would've used Coraline as a point, but Wybie was made so that the movie doesn't turn into Monologue: The Movie.

  • Here's a scary thought... by KittyEden on 2013-09-02 13:29:00 UTC Link to this

    I just thought of this and had to share it.
    I was reading about Hitler and how he was exterminating anyone who wasn't part of the 'Aryan Race'. Basically, blonde hair, blue eyes, and fair skin.
    So wasn't he basically trying to make a world of Sues?
    Maybe Sues exsisted before FanFiction was born, but in different ways!
    Could make an interesting story...

    • Many many thoughts by Huinesoron on 2013-09-02 15:29:00 UTC Link to this

      (I'll try and cram these into some kind of structure, so be warned: Here Be Lists)

      1/ Mary-Sues are of course not defined by their appearance. There are almost certainly millions of blonde/blue characters who aren't 'Sues - and equally many 'Sues who don't have blonde hair! For that matter, what self-respecting 'Sue would have an eye colour as boring as 'blue'? Now, if 'Aryan' meant 'and I mean like with these really vivid purple orbs only when she gets angry they glow red'...

      2/ I know you weren't, but let's be careful not to compare 'Sues - or, especially, Suethors - to Nazis.

      3/ Hitler, of course, doesn't pre-date fanfiction. Fanfic is ancient. To pick a random (and if you can believe it, relatively modern) example, the Aeneid, by Virgil, is fanfiction of the Iliad - and is over two thousand years old! I'll leave it to someone who's read the thing to decide whether Aeneas is a Gary-Stu...

      4/ Coming round eventually to your original idea... what if Mary-Sues existed before they were a common feature in fanfic? What if, indeed, a society on Earth (or a canon world) dedicated itself to breeding them?

      A few thoughts:

      -The League of Mary-Sue Factories, along with a number of other groups in the Multiverse (there's a city somewhere named Sparklee...), are doing just that: producing 'Sues, one way or another, and sending them into fanfic. The League have used them to attack the PPC on occasion. Sparklee, actually, goes even further - it's set up as a city-state populated entirely by 'Sues and 'Stus, pretty much exactly like you're thinking of.

      -For that matter, the Mirror Multiverse Enforcers of the Plot Continuum (EPC) are doing much the same thing - building a society of 'Sues, and attempting to conquer everything else. They're a dictatorship with no regards for morality or ethics, so I'm sure Nazi parallels have been drawn...

      -What I'm not sure anyone has written is a society of normal people which - by choice or by external/dictatorial force - turns itself into a nation of 'Sues. It could be an interesting story, indeed - but I wonder how hard it would be? After all, Mary-Sues, by occasional definition, aren't exactly well-rounded characters - and aren't (usually!) intentional villains. Writing a story about 'Sues taking over, while ensuring the 'Sues can keep their own worldview (how they are the best thing ever to happen to everything) intact... it would be a big challenge.

      hS

    • Well... by Desdendelle on 2013-09-02 14:47:00 UTC Link to this

      While that might be true, a lot of people would find that demeaning or offending. Here there be dragons, methinks, and it's best not to tread there.

  • Anniversaries for the Potterverse and Tolkienverse... by Cassie on 2013-09-02 17:11:00 UTC Link to this

    Yesterday was the first day of the Hogwarts school year. Anybody else oversleep and miss the train again? :(

    Today is the 40th anniversary of the death of John Ronald Reuel Tolkien. Let us lay spiritual wreaths at his grave.

    *lays wreath of entwined elanor, niphredil and sweet galenas*

    • My owl got lost in the Appalachians. by Lenore Snow on 2013-09-05 23:51:00 UTC Link to this

      At least, that's what I like to tell myself. *lays wreath*

    • Ai, so long? by VixenMage on 2013-09-04 02:31:00 UTC Link to this

      A wreath at his grave indeed, and may he ever rest in peace.

    • Simbelmyne... by Elcalion on 2013-09-03 12:24:00 UTC Link to this

      Ever shall it lie on the grave where JRR and Edith lie asleep together. Beren and Luthien together at last...

      Thanks for creating such a wonderful world, Professor!

      Elcalion, pensive

    • Wow. It's been a long time. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-02 20:36:00 UTC Link to this



      Rest in peace, Professor - wherever Iluvatar's grace has taken you.

      hS

    • *lays wreath of seregon and mellyrn boughs* (nm) by Ailavyn Siniyash on 2013-09-02 19:28:00 UTC Link to this
  • Happy Labor Day! by son_of_heaven176 on 2013-09-02 18:28:00 UTC Link to this

    To those of you in the USA, I wish you all a happy Labor Day! I hope you all enjoy the unofficial end of summer!

    • The end of summer? by Huinesoron on 2013-09-04 10:16:00 UTC Link to this

      I blame you entirely for this:



      The day before yesterday we had brilliant sunshine. This is all your fault.

      hS

    • End of summer? by Phobos on 2013-09-03 02:48:00 UTC Link to this

      I will be glad to see the back of it. I don't do well in the heat, you see. Now, Fall I can work with.

      -Phobos

    • My summer ended long before this, LOL. by Herr Wozzeck on 2013-09-03 01:31:00 UTC Link to this

      And I am so glad to be back in the school year already. Man, I had a great summer, but I'll be damned if I wasn't ready to just sit there and lounge around doing nothing after playing opera pit for a month and a half...

    • Ooh, the end of summer's nice by TopHatOfDoom on 2013-09-03 00:38:00 UTC Link to this

      Seriously, it has gotten way, way too hot this year. Kind of glad for any end to the season, unofficial or otherwise.

    • Re: Happy Labor Day! by Duothimir on 2013-09-02 22:13:00 UTC Link to this

      Oh yes, I will enjoy the cooler weather. Thank you, sir, and a happy Labor Day to you too.

    • If it means I can open the windows again... by Endless Sea on 2013-09-02 21:35:00 UTC Link to this

      ...without fear of burning to death, that is, then I most certainly will enjoy it. ^^

    • Happy? End of summer? by hermione of vulcan on 2013-09-02 21:06:00 UTC Link to this

      Does...not...compute.

      Though, of course, I don't really see a problem with enjoying any day, so I will wish you the same.

    • I start school tomorrow. So quite the official end for me. (nm) by Ailavyn Siniyash on 2013-09-02 19:29:00 UTC Link to this
  • So I got older today. by DemonFiren on 2013-09-03 14:18:00 UTC Link to this

    28,in fact, and I don't feel different from being 27.

    Still, 's fun.


    Now, I'd have birthday-presents for all of you, but sadly I don't think I know you well to pick the proper ones (and certainly not the quietly humourous ones that, for instance, Mr Bilbo Baggins chose.)

    • Happy birthday! **confetti** (nm) by Lenore Snow on 2013-09-05 23:48:00 UTC Link to this
    • Happy even-more-slightly-belated birthday! by son_of_heaven176 on 2013-09-05 03:16:00 UTC Link to this

      And for my usual birthday gift:

      In honor of your birthday, I have a special present for you! Or to be more precise, a special something that has a special present for you!

      Now where did I put it?
      *rummages through bag of holding*
      *Pulls out Poké Ball*
      Here you go! Inside is a Delibird, the Delivery Pokemon. But you accept its deliveries at your own risk; its presents have a chance to either heal your wounds or explode! A very...interesting companion to have around!

      • I suppose... by DemonFiren on 2013-09-05 16:18:00 UTC Link to this

        ...using a universal analyser and determining the contents of the box and therefore the delivery destination is a viable option?

        • It's a random selection. Scanning the box wouldn't help. by Outhra on 2013-09-05 21:08:00 UTC Link to this

          Sort of a Shrödinger's cat situation, except instead of existing as anything between two options and solidifying if it's observed, it can only be solidified if the move is used, and the boxes themselves exist in a state of flux between existence and non-existence, at least until removed from Delibird's pouch.
          With the way it thumbs its nose at physics like that, I'd almost say Delibird might be the proxy of some sort of chaos-loving extradimensional entity. I might say that, but then I would open up to whether Blastoise would be subject to a similar entity that allows it to store a nigh-infinite amount of Hydro Cannon water within a finite amount of body space, or whether the Miltank, Pikachu or what have you that learned Present from a Delibird father is also tied to a similar otherworldly being. It's probably best to just roll with the Pokémon universe's unusual treatment of the nature of matter. You'll be saner that way.

          • Sanity is boring. by DemonFiren on 2013-09-06 04:04:00 UTC Link to this

            I'd rather make up my own madness to modify the one given to me.

    • Happy slightly-more-belated Birthday! (nm) by the Irish Samurai on 2013-09-04 12:04:00 UTC Link to this
    • Happy slightly-belated birthday! (nm) by Huinesoron on 2013-09-04 07:41:00 UTC Link to this
    • Happy birthday! by Duothimir on 2013-09-03 23:30:00 UTC Link to this

      I bestow upon you the gift of air from my lungs. I'm still working out how to transfer that over the internet.

      • Quite easy, really. by DemonFiren on 2013-09-04 12:33:00 UTC Link to this

        The Internet is a series of tubes. All you need is build a lot of pressure, and maybe I'll get it.

        Bonus points if you manage to air out my computer.

    • Happy Birthday! by Kittythekatty on 2013-09-03 22:18:00 UTC Link to this

      Happy Birthday! Here, have an Official Fanfiction University of Doctor Who sweatshirt (Sorry if it isn't one of your fandoms) and have a sonic pen. Useful for sonicy stuff.
      Hope you have and or are having a great day!

    • As is rapidly becoming my tradition... by TopHatOfDoom on 2013-09-03 18:25:00 UTC Link to this

      I have for you a top hat kitten, strange biological anomalies and all. As I recall, you have thought about how it fits together, so I need not give you the warning associate with using feline eldritch abominations as gifts.

      Happy Birthday!

      • I'll be certain... by DemonFiren on 2013-09-03 18:32:00 UTC Link to this

        ...to put it next to its big brother, the gay leopard jacket, as Michael Thorton called it.

        Together they're certain to be more protective than any suit of armour.

    • Happy Birthday! (nm) by Antigone68104 on 2013-09-03 17:04:00 UTC Link to this
    • Happy birthday! by Phobos on 2013-09-03 15:38:00 UTC Link to this

      Drinks for everyone!

      • Gin and tonic, hold the gin. by DemonFiren on 2013-09-03 18:46:00 UTC Link to this

        I love tonic water, and I don't drink alcohol.

        I wonder...does Bleepto-Dismal taste similar?

        • That's cool. by Phobos on 2013-09-03 19:58:00 UTC Link to this

          I don't know that I've ever had tonic water, actually. I might have to try that sometime.

          Anyway, you are not the only person who doesn't drink alcohol around here. Neshomeh is also a teetotaler, and that is perfectly fine. Just means there is more alcohol for me. :P

          So, enjoy your drink of choice, everyone!

          -Phobos

    • Happy Birthday! by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-03 15:27:00 UTC Link to this

      Have a baker's dozen of chocolate chip cookies. They're not a lie I swear.

      • This is so very much appreciated... by DemonFiren on 2013-09-03 15:31:00 UTC Link to this

        ...that I can't add much commentary to it. Nice, thanks!

        Mm...chocolate.

        • There's also Bleepolate, if you like. by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-03 16:48:00 UTC Link to this

          I, uh, may have gone overboard on the baking >.>

          • Oh, come on... by DemonFiren on 2013-09-03 18:30:00 UTC Link to this

            ...there's no such thing as going overboard with baking.

            Unless you happen to lose it and start going Sweeney Todd, in which case I'm fairly certain I've got a Suelent Green recipe somewhere.

            • ... by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-03 19:54:00 UTC Link to this

              ...I've got the oven if you've got the 'Sue.

              • I'm still digging. by DemonFiren on 2013-09-03 19:58:00 UTC Link to this

                I've put it at the bottom of a mineshaft along with the Deletium from my last Windows uninstall.

                • Yay! by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-04 22:12:00 UTC Link to this

                  I'll fire up the oven!

    • Happy birthday! by Ailavyn Siniyash on 2013-09-03 15:15:00 UTC Link to this

      *wraps Random Generic Gift in purple paper*

      *hands to DemonFiren*

      *runs away*

      -Aila

      • Ah, thanks for the gift... by DemonFiren on 2013-09-03 15:30:00 UTC Link to this

        ...and thanks for not using urple paper.

        And I see I've got a blaster with two settings: Quince jelly and raspberry ice cream.

    • Happy birthday! :D by Cassie on 2013-09-03 14:41:00 UTC Link to this

      Have a sack of pebbles and your very own sling to throw them with! Also cake!

      • Oh, slings, those are difficult to use... by DemonFiren on 2013-09-03 14:55:00 UTC Link to this

        ...give me a Sueliath and call me David, though, I promise I'll practice.

        As for the cake, which universe is it from? Do I get uj'alayi, or a lie?

        • Sure! by Cassie on 2013-09-04 00:51:00 UTC Link to this

          If you want uj cake, vode, you may have it. :D

  • Back from unplugging and MIA AGENT SPOTTED by Voyd on 2013-09-03 16:23:00 UTC Link to this

    ATTENTION! ATTENTION! MIA PPC AGENT "LABURNUM" SPOTTED ON TV TROPES! LAST KNOWN ACTIVITY: EDITING SCP FOUNDATION! YELLING!

    Now that that's out of the way, hey all, I'm back. I was disconnected from the Internet for a while because of various and sundry reasons, all personal.

    • DIA Internal Report: Missing Agent by Huinesoron on 2013-09-04 15:46:00 UTC Link to this

      Dear all,

      Following the recent disappearence of former DOGA Agent Selene [...] Windflower from her padded room in FicPsych, we have naturally been keeping an eye out for her across the multiverse. Recently, one of DOGA's other agents claimed to have encountered her on a mission:

      "I almost tripped over her in the woods. She didn't look happy to see me. I mean, really unhappy - glowing red eyes and everything."

      When questioned further as to how he was able to identify former agent Selene, the agent responded:

      "Well, I recognised her, you know? Like you do with people you... recognise?"

      This agent's lack of cooperation has been noted.

      To aid in identification of this potentially distressed, possibly dangerous escapee, we have compiled an artist's impression from our informant's description.



      ~Agent Irvine




      Irvine,

      You're just embarassing yourself further. Agent Huinesoron was drunk and spouting nonsense. Leave the report writing to me in future.

      -Black

      PS: And learn to draw.

      • Re: DIA Internal Report: Missing Agent by Outhra on 2013-09-05 22:27:00 UTC Link to this

        Oh no! Selene Windflower's insanity has advanced to such a state that her torso has been absorbed into her head! I didn't even know that was possible! I'm glad that the sketch artist used such a simplified style, since either her limbs have migrated to the top of her head or her hair has grown to enormous lengths and migrated around the front of her face to rearrange itself into a spiky fan-like structure, either of which would be horrible to look at, but to different extents and for different reasons.

        Fortunately, she can't have gotten far. Giant heads like that can normally only propel themselves by hopping around comically, which has an incredibly slow movement rate. Unless she's learned to levitate or she's somehow gotten a hold of one of M.O.D.O.K.'s spare pod-suit transport things, we should be perfectly safe. Perfectly safe from the psychopathic Pyro who may still have the ability to absorb living matter into her giant horrifying cranial mass.
        ...
        I'm going to check and make sure all of those spare pod-suits are still where they were a few days ago.

    • Another return! Yay! by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-03 16:48:00 UTC Link to this

      Isn't Internet a lovely thing to have?

  • Hello! I'm new. by QuietHiker on 2013-09-04 01:36:00 UTC Link to this

    Hello, PPC Boarders! I'm Wendy/QuietHiker/Quihi/whatever you want to call me that I'll know you're addressing me. After stalking the PPC for a week or two, joining the wiki, and reading quite a few stories, I decided to join you guys.

    I'm mainly into Lord of the Rings and that stuff and the Mysterious Benedict Society, and I also enjoy various other fantasy/science fiction books. I've been reading fanfiction for… 2-3 years. I don't really know what else to say about myself. So hello!

    • Welcome! by Lenore Snow on 2013-09-05 23:46:00 UTC Link to this

      I honestly have never seen the Mysterious Benedict Society listed as a fandom. I loved those books! Anyway, have a bottomless barrel of sushi as your housewarming gift, and I look forward to chattering with you. :D

      -- Len

      • Re: Welcome! by QuietHiker on 2013-09-06 02:20:00 UTC Link to this

        MBS is such a tiny fandom. It does make it possible to read every fanfic existing, most of it good, which is fun; it makes it easy to be noticed as well.

        Thank you for all of the gifts! That goes for everyone, by the way.

    • Hello! by son_of_heaven176 on 2013-09-05 21:36:00 UTC Link to this

      So, a LoTR fan, eh? You're in VERY good company here in the PPC! Now what should a Pokemon fan like myself give to a LoTR fan?

      *rummages through bag of holding*
      How'd I get ahold of this? Well...
      Here, have some lembas bread!

    • How about Avatar: The Last Airbender? by Legacy on 2013-09-05 16:17:00 UTC Link to this

      'Cause that one is awesome.

      Welcome to the PPC Board, have a fluffy velociraptor and all that. Have fun!

      • No, sorry by QuietHiker on 2013-09-05 18:45:00 UTC Link to this

        I didn't get Nickolodeon until the last couple years, so I never got into that. My friends tell me that it's awesome.

        Thank you!

    • Hello! by darklordaakmal on 2013-09-05 08:20:00 UTC Link to this

      Have some virtual fire crackers! Instead of an explosive device for celebrations, they are crackers that you may crack into two, and will catch fire. Useful for hunting trips, I say.

      You read Asimov? Quite interesting tales he had written.

    • Good to have you a-Board! by doctorlit on 2013-09-05 05:08:00 UTC Link to this

      Greetings, new friend! Have an egg!

      What kind of egg, you ask? Well, I don't know! We'll just have to wait and find out!







      (While I hide behind this steel door!)

    • Hello! by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-04 22:13:00 UTC Link to this

      Would you mind if I called you Wendy? It's easier to remember.

      What fantasy/sci-fi books do you enjoy? Any movies, TV series, games you like?

      • Re: Hello! by QuietHiker on 2013-09-05 01:49:00 UTC Link to this

        That works for me! And can I call you Karen?

        I think I'm just going to make a list of that stuff I like on my user page on the wiki- it would take me forever to copy it here.

        • Karen's fine, m'dear. by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-05 15:58:00 UTC Link to this

          Would you like a cookie? How long have you been writing?

    • Re: Hello! I'm new. by Antigone68104 on 2013-09-04 15:24:00 UTC Link to this

      Hi, have some fudge!

      • Re: Hello! I'm new. by QuietHiker on 2013-09-04 16:12:00 UTC Link to this

        Ooh, delicious! Thanks!

    • Thank you! by QuietHiker on 2013-09-04 15:14:00 UTC Link to this

      Thank you for all of the gifts! I shall find uses for them all, though I think I'll run away from the pokes. I've heard that lint makes an excellent fire starter, anyway.

      I used to have a lot more fandoms I was interested, but I then outgrew the books/they got worse when more books came out/I realized how bad they are. I also enjoy the Secret Series and… most children/young teen fantasy books!

    • Howdy. by KittyEden on 2013-09-04 11:53:00 UTC Link to this

      Hi Wendy, I'm Kitty. Welcome to the PPC! Here's a bled pen pack and notebook set!
      Join the irc channel, we always welcome new people. I'm one myself.

    • Well, HELLO there. :D by Cassie on 2013-09-04 11:06:00 UTC Link to this

      Welcome to the PPC, we like new people! Have a bag of pebbles and a Random Shiny Object.

      Hurray, fellow Tolkienite! It's good to meet more of my people. :P What other books are you into?

    • Wait, do I get to... ha! I do! First poke! by Huinesoron on 2013-09-04 10:50:00 UTC Link to this

      [Pokepokepoke]

      It is of course traditional to poke newbies. It's rather an old tradition, though - most people give presents these days instead. But what sort of welcome is that? I mean, really, what would you prefer - people throwing gifts at you, or a proper bewildered poking to try and figure out what you are?

      Don't answer that.

      Anyway, hello! Welcome a'Board! We hope you have fun, and please remember to leave your sanity at the door - it makes such a mess when it explodes.

      hS

    • Ahh. Another Tolkienite. Good. by AW on 2013-09-04 06:44:00 UTC Link to this

      Greetings! I'm one of the old farts from literally ten years ago that vanished off the board and then just recently came back myself, so I'm quite out of the loop as to what all has been going on in the past seven years or so.

      I'd give you a present, but I tend not to give out free things. MSTers, like myself, aren't paid very well, and we're very clingy about the things that we do have. I have some laundry lint I don't think I'm using if you feel so inclined. I... also have some mixed nuts... and a 2012 calender. Take your pick.

      I'm sure you'll like it here.

    • *waves* by Ailavyn Siniyash on 2013-09-04 06:06:00 UTC Link to this

      Hello and greetings!

      I hereby grant you a lined Infinite Notebook with urple covers and wilver binding for your very own. Just make sure you don't hurt your eyes looking at it. Please.

      -Aila

    • Welcome! by TopHatOfDoom on 2013-09-04 03:50:00 UTC Link to this

      I think I shall just call you something different something every time, Quihi. If that is okay.

      Welcome to the PPC, where shoes and sanity have no home. We're surprisingly friendly for a group that made its name on the internet by assassinating people's power fantasies.

      Here, have a top hat kitten! It is a wondrous beast, combining the best features of snazzy headwear and feline. Just don't look at it too much, or think about how it's supposed to work or fit together. That leads to headaches, nosebleeds, and an obsession with geometry that leads you to repainting every room you enter, muttering "the organs, the organs, the organs" until your voice wears out while you diagram the vivisection of worlds.

      So don't do that. Please?

    • Welcome aBoard. by AdmiralSakai on 2013-09-04 02:28:00 UTC Link to this

      Many greetings. I am AdmiralSakai, aspiring mad scientist and compulsive overthinker. Please feel free to take your shoes off, have a nice can of Purple Stuff (now available in World One!) and make yourself comfortable. Oh, and leave your sanity at the door- you won't be needing that here.


      You seem to have covered all of the main bases introductions-wise, although we would of course always be happy to hear more about you. I'm fairly new here myself, but I've had little trouble fitting in, so I'm sure you'll do fine. As an accountwarming gift, I present you with a Carafe of Continuous Caffeine- I promise no fundamental physical laws were harmed in its creation.

  • Questions about Elves by Huinesoron on 2013-09-04 11:54:00 UTC Link to this

    (I know - whoever thought you'd see a title like that from me? But bear with me)

    In case you missed it, The Official Fanfiction University of Discworld a) exists, and b) ended on July 4th this year. If you're worried about spoilers, I recommend you go and read it before continuing, because I'm about to discuss the sequel. Go ahead - I'll wait.







    Okay, here's the deal. Following their assault on OFUDisc, the Interdimensional Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Elves (Ispace) is on the rampage. They are well-trained and well-equipped, and they are out to prevent cruelty to elves.

    Any elves.

    Their current target is the Canon Protection Initiative - the PPC and the OFUs. They will fight to protect Mary-Sues (if they happen to be elves), OFU students (if they happen to be elves)... but also canons (ditto), OFU staff (ditto) and even agents (ditto, again). In one incident, they are known to have saved a 'Sue from the PPC (since she was an elf), but then kill her themselves (since she was causing harm to several canonical elves).

    There are rumours of this going round HQ, with the result that (at least some) agents are getting... let's say over-zealous about canon protection. They are, basically, getting a bit paranoid - anyone in the Word World who isn't in the Words is an object of extreme suspicion, because they might be an Ispace operative.

    All this is backstory and prologue for The Ispace Wars, the upcoming sequel to OFUDisc. This is not a PPC Emergency - it's actually remarkably small-scale, and HQ will never be under direct threat. But it's still something I need help with - quite a lot of help. So, as I said, I have some questions about Elves - and some requests.

    Question #1: Which OFUs have elves in them? That includes not only staff members, but also any students who might have signed up as 'elves'. The definition of 'elf' being used by Ispace is very generous - it includes everything actually called by the name (including, say, House Elves), and anything which is clearly based on the concept (such as the various types of Space Elf - Vulcans, for instance).

    Request #1: If you run an OFU with elves in it - can I invade you? Two chapters of The Ispace Wars will be an attack on an OFU, seen from the Ispace and OFU sides, and I'd really like to co-write or at least consult with the OFU's author. Dr Huinesoron will be on hand to help out with the repulsion, and unlike OFUDisc, I have no intention of closing down an OFU. But I would like it to be a co-write.

    Question #2: What fandoms are there that have both elves and a wiki or something I can steal information from? I need to write five (yes, 5) Mary-Sue badfics with elvish 'Sues, and I can't come up with the canons. Partly this is because of...

    Request #2: Who wants to write a mission into a specially-written Mary-Sue story? I need two of my five badfics to be written as missions, and while I'll write them myself if I have to, I'd much rather have other people do it. The way I see it working is for you to select a fandom and one of my five 'Sues, I write the story, and then you write a normal mission for it. One of these two missions will also involve a confrontation with Ispace, so that will turn into a true cowrite.

    Request #3: Do you have a Trans-Dimensional Organisation of your own, like Ispace, the PPC, the League of Mary-Sue Factories and so on? If so, would you like them to be involved in the Ispace Wars, and signitories to the Accords afterwards? If so, great! I'd love to discuss that with you and see if I can slot them in.

    Request #4: Who's willing to be publicly humiliated? ;) I have need for a pair of agents who a) don't know Dafydd Illian by sight, b) would be among those feeling paranoid and suspicious about the Ispace rumours, and c) are willing to be humiliated (but NOT harmed in any way) on a mission in Middle-earth. Oh, and they need to NOT be cyborgs or otherwise electronic. This one is less of a co-write, more of a 'put the names in the slots and tweak the scene to fit the characters' job, but it is still an important part of the story.

    Catchall Request #5: At some point I will be in need of large numbers of PPC agents and OFU staff (with no connection to elves necessary). These will mostly be cameos, unless something really good comes up, but I'd love as many as I can get. If you want to volunteer your characters, please do. No harm will come to them (unless you want it to?).

    I realise there's a lot to read up there, but I'm hoping you can get through it - I really need the help on this one. Thank you for reading, and if you can help - please reply!

    hS

    PS: I doubt it needs saying, but... any agents need Permission, of course. ~hS

    • Doc and Vania could be available for cameos . . . by doctorlit on 2013-09-06 05:39:00 UTC Link to this

      in the number five catch-all.

      (Darn, I waited too long for the missions bit! :( )

    • Exactly what is Ispace's definition of "elf"? by Outhra on 2013-09-06 00:06:00 UTC Link to this

      The species counted so far all seem to fit the more-or-less-a-human-with-pointy-ears model of elf, even if they, like the Vulcans or the Hylians, aren't elves by name, but there are other species referred to as elves that don't look the same as the standard elf does and don't behave in the standard elven manner.

      What about the not-so-human elves, like the ones in Discworld or Harry Potter? I know those were based on the folkloric fey and the brownie repectively, and not the Tolkien elves, but that might mean they're even closer to the root of elfdom, since the Tolkien elves were originally based on the Norse folkloric "light elves", or the "Ljósálfar", according to Wikipedia. I'm just going to trust its spelling there.

      As for the human-style elves, do they need to be follow the traditional fantasy elf body structure, or does Ispace cover any humanoid elf in their definition? Because if they do, there are still all of the elves in the Christmas specials of the world to be considered, some of which have been very, very abused and are in need of protection. I'm looking at you, vampire elves from The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy. Mrs. Claus had no right to turn you into her vampiric thralls.

      • They're a bit... well, it's rather a shotgun approach. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-06 16:43:00 UTC Link to this

        Basically, as explained by Liliac in OFUDisc:

        "[Without Elves] the whole of fiction would fall apart," she said. "We know – we've checked. There's a universe where the most popular subject for fanfic is, I kid you not, The Sound of Music – which has been remade six times. That's what happens without elves – and it still could. [...] Cruelty to elves is lessening people's respect for the fantastic. It doesn't matter if it's an original character torturing Legolas or the PPC killing a Mary-Sue – it turns the immortal into a joke. And if we let that happen, the human imagination will die."

        It seems that they aren't defending any particular type of elf - more the notion of 'elf' in the human consciousness. So they'll defend House Elves (because they're called elves), and Santa's Elfs (because they're called elves), and anything which is referred to as an elf. They're a bit fundamentalist about the whole thing.

        And yes, the places where this idea falls apart are part of the storyline of The Ispace Wars. I will probably address the issue of whether a character can be 'more elven' than another, too.

        hS

    • Sounds brilliant. by Lenore Snow on 2013-09-05 23:43:00 UTC Link to this

      I would definitely read that. I'd love to offer up my in-progress agents for humiliation, but unfortunately I lack Permission, and I'm still not ready to go about obtaining it.... It seems like you have plenty of volunteers anyway. Be sure to plug the finished product, because now you've got me intrigued!

      -- Len :)

    • I'm always up for cameos. {= ) by Neshomeh on 2013-09-05 18:29:00 UTC Link to this

      Feel free to borrow anyone from my stable. I've actually been looking for excuses to give Ilraen some battle-scars, so if you want to injure him a bit, that's fine with me. However, I reserve particularly symbolic areas such as the head and chest to damage for myself. {; ) I wouldn't mind Gall and Derik getting banged up a bit, either. Nume will avoid any situation likely to result in a physical confrontation unless there's no other choice.

      Do Andalites count as Space Elves, do you think? Also, Nume is Noldo-colored and occasionally compared to Vulcans and Hugo Weaving's Elrond (it's the Eyebrows o' Doom), so if you wanted to play with that, it might work...?

      I like the [wait] banners, by the way. {= )

      ~Neshomeh, finally starting to catch up with the week.

    • Re: Questions about Elves by Cyba Zero on 2013-09-05 18:29:00 UTC Link to this

      You can borrow my agents for a cameo if you wish.

      Oh, and there are elves in the Eragon continuum, of course...

      (Ducks behind desk.)

    • THIS SOUNDS SO AWESOME... by Legacy on 2013-09-05 16:14:00 UTC Link to this

      ...But I don't actually have an agent in the PPC yet, so I'm afraid I can't participate. Too bad.

      All I can say about the elves is that after LoTR, dozens of games and stories popped up sporting elves almost blatantly based off of the Eldar. Prominent examples would be Eragon and Dungeons and Dragons.

      I hope that at least helps. Boonzayah!

    • Elves (Might not be helpful) by Green Armada on 2013-09-05 11:46:00 UTC Link to this

      Nice spam block picture there.

      Other than LOTR, most fantasy genres have elves in them.
      But then again, some are pointy-eared, and some are pointy-eared and not considered elves (don't ask me why). Do those count?

    • Eek! So many volunteers! by Huinesoron on 2013-09-05 09:30:00 UTC Link to this

      Specifically for the missions... okay, let's see what we've got:

      -A 'maybe' from Desdendelle
      -A 'yes' from Irish Samurai (accepted)
      -The humiliation from Elcalion
      -A 'yes' from Phobos
      -A 'yes' from Cassie
      -A 'possibly' from Lily
      -And a 'possible' from hermione

      Well, that's definitely enough volunteers! And I guess that means I have to make a decision...

      ... decisions are boring. I'll wait to hear from Desdendelle. But at this point, I don't think I'll need any more volunteers for Requests 2 & 4. Cameos at the end are still wide open, of course!

      hS

      • Uck, my reply went unnoticed... by Desdendelle on 2013-09-09 07:04:00 UTC Link to this

        (We need a better Boa- *Brick'd*)
        Well, that was a definite yes to a cameo and a tentative yes to a mission, as long as you don't mind the mission running late (RL tends to kill my writing for extended periods of time).

        • What, your reply a day after I posted this comment? ;) (nm) by Huinesoron on 2013-09-09 09:16:00 UTC Link to this
      • Here, have another! by DawnFire on 2013-09-09 03:44:00 UTC Link to this

        And sorry I'm late. (And if you don't need any more at all by now, feel free to just tell me that and I shall...slink off into the distance or something. Sink into the murky waters of university and continue writing my Badfic Game entry, I suppose.)

        In answer to...question and request #1--SBEI has a co-coordinator who's a Tolkien Elf (specifically, she became one at OFUM and got to stay that way since she was going on to coordinate a different OFU). Karen and I want to have a couple more chapters written before we start posting it, though, so I don't know if that's an issue--but if it isn't, I'm fairly sure we're fine to be invaded. Why not? (I shall check with Karen, but if the 'currently unposted' thing isn't an issue, I, at least, am happy to have SBEI invaded). Apart from that--do you also need elven agents? I have a pair of Calaquendi who can be used.

        As for cameos at the end, feel free to use any (or all) of Agents Dawn McKenna, Edgar Sullivan, Agen____t, Brenda Loringham, Charlie Shoe, Kozar, T'Zar, Naergondir, and Gurnirel (the last two are the previously mentioned Calaquendi). If you need minis to cameo, I can volunteer some of those as well.

        Hopefully some of this helps...if it doesn't, well, a little more information never hurts! Unless it's about exactly how the flesh-eating spiders currently crawling all over you usually devour their prey...no, I don't know where my mind is either. Somewhere very odd, apparently.

        ~DF

    • Well, well, well. by World-Jumper on 2013-09-05 04:13:00 UTC Link to this

      This... Could be interesting.

      For cannons that have elves in them, let me suggest the Elder Scrolls seres. Oh lord above, do they have elves. You have Altmer, the high elves, who think themselves greater then all other races. The Bosmer, who live in the forests of Tamriel, and are masters of archery and sneaking through the undergrowth undetected. The Dunmer, dark elves who live in the volcanic wastelands of Morrowind. They worship the Daedra and are masters of summoning and have a special resistance to fire. Then the Osmer, the orcs, strong and stout, they stand among the strongest races in Tamriel. Then there's the Falmer, the Snow Elves, oh I could go on and on. Here, just look at these articles from the Elder Scrolls wiki, and you will see why it is important the Ispace visit this world:
      http://elderscrolls.wikia.com/wiki/Mer
      http://elderscrolls.wikia.com/wiki/Third_Aldmeri_Dominion - These guys are a group of elves that are trying to commit the genocide of all the races of man and beast, then later find a way to destroy the world so they can re-claim their supposed lost divinity. Yeah. Not good people.

      Next, if there is a multi-dimentional group I have created that would be involved with these guys. The answer is... Not really, but I do have Jumper, my namesake and character that can travel to fictional universes. His section of the multiverse acts differently from the PPC's multiverse, so he would be really invested in keeping them out of his sector. He will be/is a PPC agent, and may well run across the Ispase on his travels outside of the PPC. I would be honored if he gets to participate in this semi-event. If you want me to write out what he does or further discuss what his role may be in this, I would be happy to do so. Just be warned, I have a rather tight school schedule right now, so I may not be able to get his bits done for a while. Just a heads up.

      • Why didn't I think of that? by Cyba Zero on 2013-09-05 11:45:00 UTC Link to this

        Ah, the Elder Scrolls. I was planning to have my agents go there on a mission (and possible story arc) sometime.

        Oh, and you forgot the Dwemer, who are also classed as elves. They are also known as deep elves, or, more commonly, dwarves. In the present day as per the games, the Dwemer have been long vanished (where to and precisely how remain a mystery). However, many of their ruins remain, full of traps and steam-powered robots. (Seriously, the TCDA would love Dwemer technology.)

        Oh boy,now I get the terrifying image of ISPACE trying to prevent the Disappearance of the Dwarves (and thus completely rewriting the continuum, pretty much). Although... that would hinder any attempt to prevent the blinding of the Falmer at the hands of the Dwemer...

        Oh, and there is now a mini called Osmer wandering the Board. I think you meant Orsimer. (Last I heard, the type of mini was under debate - I personally would vote for mini-Daedra.)

        • Re: Why didn't I think of that? by World-Jumper on 2013-09-05 15:57:00 UTC Link to this

          Yeah, I was intending on sending Jumper there too, once I introduced him. Which I have to get this mission with Marvin and Printworthy done first, then introduce Jumper in the next mission of theirs. It's all planed out, don't worry about it. But yeah, Tamriel is such a beautiful world, with so much history and culture. It's almost as deep in culture as Middle Earth. In some places, dare I say, it has even more detail than Arda!

          I did not forget the Dwemer, merely left them for Huinesoron to see himself. If you look on the wiki page, they are right there. Way far down the page. Yes, I too agree, Dwemer technology is awesome! Perhaps I can snag myself a spider or something when I send Jumper one of these times...

          Pft, forget trying to stop the disappearance of the Dwemer, how about trying to keep the Ayleids in control? They would try to crush the rebellion and keep mankind enslaved, effectively destroying all potential for the preservation of canon. By the Nine, we have to stop them!

          Oh man, I did it again. I accidentally the letters. My bad. Now what, hypothetically, as we don't decide on mini species as a board but leave them to the first mission or OFU writers, should this mini be? (I have been scolded for this in the past, so I'm just covering my bases) I agree it should be a mini Daedra, but what Daedra? There are so many, which do we pick? I think all of the atronachs are out, as they look too much like regular elementals. Nothing that really says, "That's so Skyrim!" if you see what I mean. Perhaps a mini-Daedroth, or mini-Clannfear?

          • Re: Why didn't I think of that? by Cyba Zero on 2013-09-05 18:24:00 UTC Link to this

            The reason I thought mini-Daedra was because it would be cool if the type spawned depended on the kind of misspelling. That would leave room for a lot of fun minis... you might even get a mini of one of the princes if you misspelled something really important, like the continuum. Otherwise, whoever finds a mini gets to pick from all the varieties of Daedra, even rarer ones. There would be a whole range of choices, like the Winged Twilight or Spider Daedra, Clannfear, Ogrim, Xivilai, Dremora, Scamp, any of the Atronachs, Hunger, Dark Seducer, Golden Saint, etc. That way you can encompass a lot, which is nice in such a vast continuum.

            I can certainly see Sheogorath and the PPC being a right mixture, given all the crazy agents...

            • Ah, I see. by World-Jumper on 2013-09-05 20:57:00 UTC Link to this

              Yeah, that makes sense. So if I were to, say, misspell the Shivering Isles as Sivring Ises, I would get a mini-Dark Seducer or Golden Saint. But if I misspell Dovahkiin as Dovakin, I would get a mini-Scamp or Flame Atronach. I like that idea.

              Now I kinda want to make an agent who is from the Shivering Isles. Probably from Dementia, though a Manic may be interesting. Seeing how many demented agents we already have, one more aint gonna make any difference. Perhaps an Argonian, or a Dunmer. The possibilities...

              • Well, agents usually come in pairs... by Cyba Zero on 2013-09-06 10:01:00 UTC Link to this

                ... so you could have both, if you wanted. I daresay a Manic and a Demented would squabble like anything, and could be a hilarious pairing. (Alternatively, you could always visit the village of Split.)

                The problem about the Elder Scrolls with choosing any one type of Daedra for the mini is that some types do not appear in all the games - Skyrim seems to be especially lacking in Daedra, certainly all the more continuum-specific ones (except perhaps the Seekers in the Dragonborn expansion).

                The wiki currently states mini-Cliffracers as the Elder Scrolls mini, but it was under debate given that there does not seem to be a mission or an OFU for the continuum - and while Cliffracers are VERY annoying in Morrowind, they are extinct come the later games, so are not very representative of the continuum as a whole. I cannot see Daedra going extinct, somehow...

                Oh, and the Ayleids. How could I forget them? I agree, ISPACE trying to prevent the fall of the Ayleids would cause a right mess - preventing the rise of the Empire for one.

    • Not much help but... by Myrddin on 2013-09-05 02:29:00 UTC Link to this

      If you're looking for any canon that contains Elves, and especially since you've got a group there that is all for the protection of said Elves... you might look into using the Anime/Manga series "Those who hunt Elves" which is a thoroughly ridiculous series.

      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Those_Who_Hunt_Elves

    • /pops out of hidey-hole by Lily Winterwood on 2013-09-04 21:37:00 UTC Link to this

      I WILL TAKE IT! I WILL TAKE THE RING TO -- oops.

      Anyway, as of now I'm not entirely sure if there are Elves/Vulcans/pointy-eared little bastards at IAHF or MBSFA because I don't have the registration forms on hand at the moment, but I know that Agent Eledhwen, who is an Elf, happens to correspond with both institutions. Make of that what you will.

      I also volunteer the Consulting Sue Slayer verse (which can be found primarily through consultingsueslayer.tumblr.com and the Study in Rose RP that Dawn and I have on her and my Time Lord!Spock blog (long story)), which is known to have Vulcans in it somewhere, so there's some Elves for ya.

      I may not have time to write a mission, but if I do around the time you ask I will probably say a very enthusiastic yes because I'd major in Elvish studies here if I could.

      Finally I'd say yes to public humiliation for my Agents if they didn't already know who Dafydd was. So yeah.

      (also OH MY GOD KARL URBAN. /discreetly wipes drool off laptop)

    • Volunteering! by Cassie on 2013-09-04 21:31:00 UTC Link to this

      I'll go for writing a mission for you as per Request #2. If it's Tolkienverse that would be best, as I have a couple of Agents in mind who can take the job and really deserve an outing of their own.

      I also have vast swathes of Agents willing to take on Request #5 whenever required.

      • Hmm. Would you like to do something slightly different? by Huinesoron on 2013-09-05 15:02:00 UTC Link to this

        The Tolkienverse mission is the one I wasn't going to open up, because it's the one that drives the plot. Now you've got me thinking about it, though, I'm not sure anyone in PPC HQ knows where Ispace Mountain is... so... hrm.

        Can you drop me an email? I have something in mind you might be interested in.

        hS

        • *intrigued Cassie is intrigued* by Cassie on 2013-09-06 20:44:00 UTC Link to this

          Sent an email to one of your email addresses, I'm not sure if it's the right one though. :p

    • Re: Questions about Elves by Antigone68104 on 2013-09-04 15:24:00 UTC Link to this

      It looks like you've got volunteers already for Requests 2 and 4, but if anything falls through I'll toss Arthur Briggs and Lynn Gillies into the pot. Neither is particularly paranoid, but given Briggs' military background he would be interested in reports of organized opposition to PPC missions.

      And of course, they're both available for Request 5.

    • You have my axe by Phobos on 2013-09-04 15:01:00 UTC Link to this

      Warcraft has no fewer than 3 types of Elves (Night, High, and Blood Elves); more if you count the mutations (Naga, Harpies, Satyrs, Darkfallen). Some people believe Elves to be an offshoot of Trolls, so I wonder if the Ispace protections go all the way back to them.

      Anyway, here is a wiki.

      If you are willing to write a suefic for the Warcraft Universe, I have a pair of agents (Barid and Brightbeard) who are willing and able to take it down.

    • Sue Slayers is availible. by KittyEden on 2013-09-04 13:39:00 UTC Link to this

      My orginization, the Sue Slayers is a Multiversal concept that l''d let you use.

      • Do you know, I'd forgotten... by Huinesoron on 2013-09-04 14:19:00 UTC Link to this

        ... that you were the person who first showed up talking about the Sue Slayers.

        The role of the Sue Slayers would be fairly minor - a possible appearance forming an alliance with other organisations that share their worldview and interests, a few cameos in the ending, and (presumably) an appearance at the treaty table. If you're interested in working with me on that, can you drop me an email at the address linked behind my name?

        Also, do you have a logo? I like it when people have logos.

        hS

        • Okay, so... by KittyEden on 2013-09-05 12:03:00 UTC Link to this

          ...the link to your emailisn't working. But, yes, we do have an insignia that I can post on my blog, as well as some other little things, like a map of campus and portal locations in the multiverse.
          I can write some little paragraphs from The Sue Slayer's perspective. We don't have any elves, but have extensive research stations and avanced technology, which may be useful to the whole thing.
          Yeah, I really like the whole idea. Drop me a line at m blog, it has a contact form.

          • And where be your blog? (nm) by Huinesoron on 2013-09-05 12:16:00 UTC Link to this
            • Found a blog by the Irish Samurai on 2013-09-05 12:56:00 UTC Link to this

              http://www.misseden.blogspot.co.uk/

        • What are those things? by hermione of vulcan on 2013-09-05 00:47:00 UTC Link to this

          You've posted them once before, and I'm still baffled. Except for the Starfleet insignia with a heart. That's clearly something to do with Star Trek Sues.

          Oh, and in response to the main thingy, while OFAS has many Space Elves, I'm not really in a place in the story to be getting invaded. So...if nobody else volunteers...and I get another couple chapters up...maybe.

          And for a big group thing, I would volunteer Sebak and Tish. But I adopted Sebak from a mission written in 2009 and wrote three stories set directly after, so I'll need to write the next mission (which is...unusual, and will involve time displacement), before they'll actually be in 2013. And honestly, I'm not sure how much writing I can do, because Real Life is going to be piling stuff on me.

          So bottom line: I would love to, but that depends on whether I can write anything while Real Life is happening.

    • Volunteering by Elcalion on 2013-09-04 13:14:00 UTC Link to this

      Ill have a crack at writing one of the missions (ESAS being an elf-specialising division after all), and volunteering Logan and either Kern or Riboflavin for humiliation (because I'm evil to my agents) - depends whether you think having a Jedi or a HP wizard being humiliated would be funnier as to which of Kern/Riboflavin I'll use to partner Logan.

      Riboflavin joined after Dafydd retired. Logan and Kern probably haven't met/seen Dafydd but would certainly have heard of him.

      Elcalion

      • Thank you! by Huinesoron on 2013-09-04 14:10:00 UTC Link to this

        Since Desdendelle replied first, I'll hold off accepting your offer to write one of the missions until I know if he wants to do so, but for the humiliation - brilliant! I think the best way to decide who should be in it (or, indeed, if you want to back out) would be for me to simply email you the 'generic agents' version of that scene, and then discuss how well it works. I am of course willing to change virtually everything about it to make it fit the actual characters - this is supposed to be goodfic.

        I've thrown my email address in above, or if you prefer, leave yours and I'll get in touch with you. And again, thanks!

        hS

    • Answers about Elves by the Irish Samurai on 2013-09-04 12:44:00 UTC Link to this

      Q1) Other than the obvious (OFUM), I dunno, so I'm not much help on this one :)

      Q2) Well, Warhammer 40,000 has Space Elves (in Good and Evil flavours), and Warhammer Fantsay offers three different flavours. I've also seen the Navi be referred to as Elves in Space!, presumably because they have pointy ears and that whole 'living in harmony with nature' thing. I'm sure I read/watch plenty of other stuff with elves of some kind in, but I'm stuck at work at the minute, so can't check my bookshelves. I'll get back to you if I can think of any other particularly good ones.

      R2) Yeah, I'd be up for writing a mission in a specifically created badfic, if you think my agents will work for what you want to achieve.

      R3) Yes I do have my own Trans-Dimensional Organisation (or rather, I have ideas for them - one of these days I'll actually have to get around to writing about them), but then you knew that already. I can send you more details on them if you need it.

      R4) I don't think my agents quite fit the bill here - while they wouldn't recognise Dafydd, I can't see them getting too worked about the rumours. After all, there are rumours floating round about an HQ Pool, and that's clearly nonsense!

      R5) Sure, Skeet and Amy volunteer.

      • Mini Alert! by son_of_heaven176 on 2013-09-05 05:29:00 UTC Link to this

        Has anyone claimed an Avatar (the movie by James Cameron, not The Last Airbender) badfic? Because there's a mini here (Navi) whose species I cannot recognize!

        • Mini-toruks. by Outhra on 2013-09-05 18:44:00 UTC Link to this

          A.k.a. those giant orange lizard-bats Jake Sully learns to ride, or mind-control, or however that works.

          The mission where they are first found is here. I don't blame you for not recognizing the species; I had to consult Google because I couldn't remembered the name of the creature or the mission that it came from.
          I'm sure that the minis will enjoy the company of another of their kind after so long without new company. Unless toruks are territorial. It's been a while since I saw the movie.

      • Pointy ears is close enough for me! by Huinesoron on 2013-09-04 14:06:00 UTC Link to this

        After all the betaing work we've been throwing back and forth - not to mention Kayleigh's adoption of Aunt Sam, and your interpretation of the Sundering - I'd actually really like Skeet and Amy to make an appearance in The Ispace Wars. If you're up for it, I'd like them to take on the mission which leads to a (non-lethal!) confrontation with Ispace - which will end up being three chapters, one each from the perspective of the Sue (ie, the badfic), the PPCers, and the Ispace team. I have no plans in place for the outcome - the only requirement is that the PPCers get back to HQ and pass the word that Ispace is interfering with missions.

        (Actually, Skeet and Amy would work really well - because the person coordinating the slapdash information gathering effort is Kayleigh)

        If you're still interested, let me know and I'll throw you an email.

        hS

        • Yup, I'm still interested by the Irish Samurai on 2013-09-05 16:19:00 UTC Link to this

          Sounds fun - I look forward to your e-mail.

    • Answers, I guess. by Desdendelle on 2013-09-04 12:39:00 UTC Link to this

      Question #1) From the top of my head, I know that OFU of Azeroth has elves, OFUM has Elves (but of course), and the Hogwarts Fanfiction Academy has the House Elves (as you've mentioned).
      Request #1) I don't run an OFU.
      Question #2) I won't bother with the more common fandoms, but here are wikis for Forgotten Realms and Dragonlance. The Battle for Wesnoth has no (up-to-date) wiki per se, but its site and fora are more than enough.
      Request #2) Um... not sure. More details would be welcome. (Though if I'll accept it might force me to get off my lazy ass and actually write something longer than a post in a play-by-post RP...)
      Request #3) Nope, don't have one.
      Request #4) I'll pass on this one. Neither Agent!Des nor Anebrin are particularly paranoid.
      Request #5) They're more than up for a cameo, however.

      • Some of the more details. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-04 14:01:00 UTC Link to this

        I'm going to write five single-chapter elven Mary-Sue badfics. Since they'll be deliberately (but not parody) bad, I don't actually need to know the canon that well - just, for example, what I can pick up by skimming the Forgotten Realms wiki (maybe writer!me saw a picture of Drizzt and thinks he's hott ;)).

        But because, in the context of the story, these are real badfics which exist in the multiverse, there's a decent chance the PPC will come across them. So for two of them, the Department of Intelligence will write up a report and assign an agent team.

        On the practical side, because I'm writing the badfics to order, you (or whoever ends up doing it) gets to chose which of my four Sues they want to take down (they have named like Celia Bloodgage and Ravonia Darkmoor...), and also what canon you want to go into. Then I grit my teeth and write a bad story - one chapter long - and send it over for you to spork. Just like a normal mission, basically, with as little or as much writing as you choose.

        My plan is then to post the badfic and the mission both as chapters of The Ispace Wars. All copyright to the mission would of course remain with the writer, and I'd have no problem with you posting it with your own stuff as well - or with you not.

        Was that useful detail or just me rambling? And are you interested?

        hS

        • Hm... by Desdendelle on 2013-09-06 12:23:00 UTC Link to this

          Can't say I'm not tempted. But before I commit myself I'd like to know your timetable - whether the pieces are supposed to be due by some rough date, for example.

          • At the moment? There isn't one. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-09 09:14:00 UTC Link to this

            But me being me, I'm rather likely to create one at short notice at a later date.

            hS

            • A more useful answer: by Huinesoron on 2013-09-09 09:42:00 UTC Link to this

              While I don't at present have a deadline or timeline, I'm likely to get very twitchy if one chapter is taking vastly longer than the rest.

              hS

              • Well, throw it my way, then. by Desdendelle on 2013-09-09 19:51:00 UTC Link to this

                It might actually make me write in a pace which is faster than a snail's.

  • Mass Foundations: Redemption in the Stars by Nord Ronnoc on 2013-09-04 20:06:00 UTC Link to this

    Hello, everyone! Not too long ago, I have completed the Fallout/Mass Effect crossover, with the help of fellow co-author 4Ferelden, a frequent user on various Wiki sites, specifically Mass Effect and a few of the PPC users here. I would like to give my thanks to TopHatOfDoom, Caddy, and Leareth, among a few others.

    Set years after the events of Fallout: New Vegas, the Courier was transported to the Mass Effect universe when an attempt at improving the Transportalponder's efficiency has gone awry. Soon after, he met Dr. Liara T'Soni and Feron as he has gotten involved in the hunt for Commander Shepard's body before it falls to the hands of the Collectors. This is the second installment of a five-part saga.

    http://www.fanfiction.net/s/8803708/1/Mass-Foundations-Redemption-in-the-Stars

    If you have any questions for the fic or suggestions, constructive criticism, and ideas to improve this story and future installments, leave a reply. Feedback is appreciated!

  • The waters of Lake Waban stir, and out of it rises... by Lily Winterwood on 2013-09-04 21:42:00 UTC Link to this

    Me.

    Dropping in to say hi, I'm not actually dead, just trampling through the first days of college. Thought I'd drop by to say hi and ask hS when the next Badfic Game is happening (please tell me you haven't already played it).

    Greetings from Wellesley College, guys!

    • I sally forth with answers! by Huinesoron on 2013-09-05 09:17:00 UTC Link to this

      But no fanfare. No-one ever gives me a fanfare.

      Anyway, hi! Welcome back. The Badfic Game is planned for this month, but probably closer to the end than the beginning. I'd like to give fanficWorld a makeover before I start it, and get familiar with the coding again - but unfortunately, my work computer refuses to show the Javascript it runs on. That means I can only muck about with it from home, so it takes longer than I'd like (particularly since we're in the middle of moving - home is a busy place right now).

      But fear not - it is on its way. You haven't missed it.

      hS

    • Wait... Wellesley College? by Herr Wozzeck on 2013-09-05 04:40:00 UTC Link to this

      Holy Christ crackers, I think I was close to the area! It's the Wellesley near Boston, right?

      Anyways, welcome back! Does this mean we can look forward to more Multiverse Monitor Redux?

      • The very same! by Lily Winterwood on 2013-09-05 04:45:00 UTC Link to this

        If you ever find yourself in that neck of the woods again you should tell me and we can have a mini-Gathering or something. Because I've never met IRL PPCers and that makes me sad.

        I'm not entirely sure right now because god damn do I have homework, but if anything newsworthy happens in-universe I'll try to take note for a future issue or two. Chances are the New MM will just be a sporadic, whenever-there's-sh!t-going-down sort of thing to kinda commemorate and try to make sense of those events.

        • I'll be sure to let you know! by Herr Wozzeck on 2013-09-06 03:15:00 UTC Link to this

          I might not go back for a few years, but we'll see what happens with that, yeah?

    • Alrighty then. by Very jaunty object on 2013-09-04 22:38:00 UTC Link to this

      Good to have you back for however long you happen to be back for. Repetition aside, exactly are the badfic games.

      • You're a newbie, aren't you? by Lily Winterwood on 2013-09-05 02:34:00 UTC Link to this

        Have a... -rummages in pockets- bottle of lemming repellent for the wastes of the Circle of Lemmings!

        And the Badfic Game is a game where everyone writes PPC badfic (or, as I did last time around, PPC AUs with canon characters). It's so much fun watching your Agents get mutilated out of character. Heheh.

        • "It's so much fun watching your Agents get mutilated..." by Huinesoron on 2013-09-05 13:27:00 UTC Link to this

          You shouldn't have said that.

          You really shouldn't have said that.



          Using her powers of deduction learned from Sherlock Homes himself, Christianne threw up a wall of pure force to blunt Eledhwen's charge.

          "You cannot escape me!" Eledhwen snarled, her fangs growing longer by the second. "I am the Spider Queen of Mirkwood!"

          Oh yes I can!" Christianne exclaimed. "You forget, Eledhwen - I know your secret name!"




          (Will JayBird be expanding this into an epic tale of love and betrayal? If I get enough ideas, I'm sure she will)

          hS

          • I have learned new and important facts about Sherlock today. by Outhra on 2013-09-05 22:42:00 UTC Link to this

            I would never have suspected that an enhanced enough deductive capability would give someone psionic powers.

            That would explain how Sherlock survived his fall from that hospital roof! A person of such high deductive power would be able to deduce exactly what size and shape of force shield to create mid-descent to cushion his fall while still making it appear that the impact was fatal, and so, protected by his forcefield, Sherlock could have picked himself up from the ground once his acquaintances were safe without even scuffing his clothes.
            It's a subtle and unexpected plan, hinging entirely on mid-level psionic powers that were never exhibited before, for the simple reason that Sherlock had never needed them before. Just the sort of thing Sherlock would do.

            ((The Badfic Game is going to be fun.))

          • omg this is such a gud storie! by Lilith Wydenbrooke on 2013-09-05 14:04:00 UTC Link to this

            Rite moar soon I have to read moar!

            ((No, really, I'm laughing too hard. Oh you. ~Lily))

    • Hi Lily! by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-04 22:16:00 UTC Link to this

      Having fun with your first taste of college life?

      • Oh yes. by Lily Winterwood on 2013-09-05 02:33:00 UTC Link to this

        Everyone here is surprisingly welcoming and cheerful, or maybe that's just me with my first impression of college as the Official Fanfiction University of Middle-earth.

        Haha that being said, I'm enjoying Wellesley a lot! Everyone is so clever and have done great things. I'm still not sure how I even got in; this is Hilary Clinton's school after all.

        • Re: Oh yes. by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-05 16:03:00 UTC Link to this

          I took the time to look up your college, and I am not at all surprised you got in. It sounds like a perfect fit for you! What sort of classes are you taking your first semester?

          Heh, OFUM is probably a bad example of ordinary college life. People tend to be very happy about leaving the nest, and it shows. Just keep your fingers crossed you didn't get a roommate that'll steal from you - my cousin got one of those, and it was horrible. o.O

    • Welcome back! by Phobos on 2013-09-04 22:15:00 UTC Link to this

      College tends to make people drop off the face of the internet for a while. Glad to see you back, though.

      As for the Badfic Game, you haven't missed it, though I have no idea when it is going to be. I'm looking forward to it, as well. It's one of my favorites.

      -Phobos

      • 'College...make[s] people drop off the face of the internet' by DawnFire on 2013-09-09 03:33:00 UTC Link to this

        Well...I'm next. My first day's tomorrow.

        This should be interesting...

        ~DF

      • It's good to be back. by Lily Winterwood on 2013-09-05 02:36:00 UTC Link to this

        I do have to admit that had it not been for the PPC I don't think I'd be where I am today. So I have all of you to thank for that.

        Oh goody. I can't wait! I don't know whether to write a PPC AU ala Science of Suedom again or to just inflict terribleness on all of you. -maniacal cackling-

  • OT: Coursera by Huinesoron on 2013-09-05 12:59:00 UTC Link to this

    About a year ago, we ran across a fundamentally awesome website called Coursera. This is a site where you can take university-level courses, absolutely free! And by 'university level', I mean actual university professors from actual universities (as opposed to, say, the University of Power Cable, Nebraska) record audio-visual lecture courses running about 8-12 weeks, with (usually) weekly quizzes, and often some form of assignments or end-of-unit tests.

    The sign-ups for each course tend to run into the tens of thousands, and at least in my experience, they always have very active forums, with teaching assistants to act as moderators and answer questions. For most courses all you 'get' at the end is a certificate of completion, but I believe some offer a 'Signature Track' which means the university will verify that you actually took the course.

    Of course, what you actually get from the course is a heap of knowledge - in whatever subject you choose, for whatever reason you choose. The second course I did was Analytical Chemistry: Instrumental Analysis from Rice University. It was directly relevant to my job (I'm an analytical chemist), so that was actually helpful.

    My other two courses were purely for fun. I did Introduction to Astronomy with Duke University, and Archaeology's Dirty Little Secrets with Brown - which, I have to say, was incredibly good. Sue Alcock, the professor, put a heck of a lot of work into the course, and had a massive team. The course did a brilliant job of merging the theoretical and practical sides of archaeology, and if (when!) she runs it again, I highly recommend this course.

    But enough about me. ;) Has anyone else done anything on Coursera, or any similar site? How did you find it? I've had universally good experiences - how has it worked out for you?

    hS

    • Re: OT: Coursera by EileenAlphabet on 2013-09-10 09:07:00 UTC Link to this

      I did a Coursera course in fantastic litterature. It was a very good experience, although I ended up not completing it. The amount of text I had to read each week ended up being too much, what with me having a full time job and also wanting to sleep every now and then.
      But it did teach me a lot about looking for underlying themes in litterature. The 'thesis' that every work is putting forth and defending.

    • Coursera! by Techno-Dann on 2013-09-06 05:57:00 UTC Link to this

      I'm taking a programming languages class this fall - it starts next month, and it is going to be fun.

    • I've actually used YouTube by the Irish Samurai on 2013-09-05 22:18:00 UTC Link to this

      It's not interactive like what you've described, but there are a whole bunch of MIT lectures (and possibly stuff from other places too, I dunno, I didn't really look any further than the MIT stuff) that you can watch online.

      They've got videos of the full lecture courses for a range of topics available.

      I watched the courses on Vibrations and Waves and Electricity and Magnetism to help me understand electromagnetism well enough to do some electromagnetic simulation work for my previous company, despite my background being purely mechanical engineering.

      • That's pretty cool. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-09 16:03:00 UTC Link to this

        I guess one of the advantages of that approach is that you don't have to wait for the course to come around, and can do it in your own time. Additionally, I don't think the really big names like MIT are using Coursera much.

        The advantages of Coursera are that you get assignments which are graded, and also the chance to interact with both other students and the course staff. So it's sort of a swings and roundabouts thing.

        hS

        • It is pretty cool... by the Irish Samurai on 2013-09-09 21:36:00 UTC Link to this

          But in a way its biggest strength is its greatest weakness.

          The fact that they're all up there, ready to view at any time you choose, is really helpful. And unlike real lectures, if you don't quite get a bit you can just rewind and watch it again.

          But because it just passive viewing, with no kind incentive other than your own interest, it's very> easy to procrastinate and then just kind of forget about. Also, if rewinding and watching again doesn't help you understand, you can't ask any questions.

          Still, it worked for me, although this Coursera thing sounds interesting too. The graded assignments might actually give me more of an incentive to stick with it.

    • Hmm. by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-05 19:02:00 UTC Link to this

      This sounds pretty interesting. But I will admit to some skepticism, mostly on the basis that 1. The classes are free and 2. There is no such thing as a "free hug."

      What you've said sounds awesome, don't get me wrong, and I am tempted to look into these classes. But in my experience, there's always a catch...so what is it? The fact that you typically can't get recognition from the university that "hosted" the class is a drawback, but for someone who just wants to learn things, it isn't much of one.

      • Well, I haven't found a catch. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-06 16:38:00 UTC Link to this

        I guess what that question really means is 'What do the universities get out of it?', which is a decent question. I guess part of it is advertising, and possibly funding, but I honestly don't know.

        At the user's end, though, it's entirely free, other than the time commitment; the information is accurate, and conveyed by real professionals - AdmiralSakai mentions Andrew Ng of Stanford, who is apparently 'one of the world's leading experts in artificial intelligence'. So at least at the moment, there doesn't seem to be a catch.

        Oh, they do require ownership of your immortal soul. Is that important?

        hS

        • Wow. Really? by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-06 22:58:00 UTC Link to this

          I mean, my immortal soul's no big, it's currently on lease to my employers, but I suppose long-term ownership is up for grabs right now...

          But it does sound pretty sweet if there's no catch. Time is one thing I have enough of right now, so if it's really all you need to commit...

    • Hooray! by Kaitlyn on 2013-09-05 16:25:00 UTC Link to this

      I've finished two courses on Coursea -- one about contraception (very light and fluffy), one on human physiology (kicked my butt). I'm taking -- hold on, counting on my fingers -- three at the moment?

      Two are very quick to race through every week, one's a bit more time-consuming (global health). And actually the Vaccines course, which is supposed to be just a couple of hours a week, is taking a *lot* more time than that just to keep up with all the smallpox-eradication deniers in the discussion forums. People are crazy in the most unexpected directions these days.

      I'm also taking a course from edX, which is similar to Coursera. I find that Coursera is a lot easier to navigate, though.

      • Ooh, yours sound cool. by Neshomeh on 2013-09-05 17:26:00 UTC Link to this

        But, wait, what? Smallpox-eradication deniers? What exactly are they denying? I mean, I understand that there are some specimens locked up in the CDC and such, but...?

        ~Neshomeh

        • Well . . . by Kaitlyn on 2013-09-06 14:43:00 UTC Link to this

          Because viruses are very small, how could we ever know that we'd gotten rid of all of them? There might be a remote isolated case of latent/mutated smallpox virus in the Amazon rainforest somewhere.

          Also, the WHO are covering it up.

          . . . I'm not really sure what they're denying, and to be honest I don't think they know either. But they certainly don't understand how infectious diseases work. It's wildly entertaining.

    • I've head of it, too. by Neshomeh on 2013-09-05 15:04:00 UTC Link to this

      And it may well be something I'll look into if I'm ever not massively consumed with things. It used to be that I didn't think I could make myself do an online course, but I manage to do my online job, so maybe it's a possibility. How involved were the assignments in the courses you took? Homework has always been my big stumbling block.

      ~Neshomeh

      • On the level of involvement by Huinesoron on 2013-09-05 16:03:00 UTC Link to this

        It really does depend on the course. From what I've seen, every course has tests/quizzes, and a fair number have peer assessment assignments. To run through my three examples:

        -IntroAstro had no peer review stuff, but was a physics course. The weekly tests were stuffed with maths, and so took a lot of time - I think about two hours per week, and I'm good at maths.

        -Instrumental Analysis had two levels of quizzes - the simple 'were you watching the lecture' type, which took about ten minutes each (two per week), and the more in-depth ones. Again, it was a science course, but chemistry - particularly instrumental chemistry - is way less maths-heavy than astronomy. I'd say maybe an hour at most for those tests, but less on some weeks. It also had three 'peer assessed' assignments, spaced out over the length of the course. These were basically essay question quizzes (the standard quizzes are usually either numerical or multiple-choice); I don't think they took that long, maybe 3-4 hours. Then you're required to mark some (peer assessment, remember?), but there's usually a decent grading rubric. Say an hour, hour and a half total per assignment.

        -Archaeology had a weekly quiz which was entirely multiple-choice - basically just to check if you'd watched the videos and read the links. They never took me more than 10 minutes. It also had weekly peer-reviews, 'Archaeological Exercises'. We actually got to choose from three options each week, and the choices ranged from 'Find out about an archaeologist and write about the tools they had available' to 'Make a 3D model of something' to 'Write your name in Cuneiform'.

        In that case, the assignments were great fun, but occasionally time-consuming. On the one hand, Week 1's applying archaeological terminology to my office took maybe half an hour. On the other hand, my video for Week 7 took about five hours, maybe more, to put it all together. In general, though, the expected time per assignment was 1-3 hours, and you only had to do one a week.

        Then we were required to assess five other students' work. The grading was literally a score of 0, 1, 2 or 3, and a little bit of constructive criticism, but it still ate up time. Let's say an hour all told for each week's peer reviewing. Of course, the assignments offered enough scope that it didn't get boring...

        So, a summary:

        -IntroAstro: Maybe 4-5 hours a week watching videos and taking notes, and 2 hours answering tests.

        -Instrumental Analysis: Maybe 2-3 hours of videos/notes per week, an hour and a half of tests, and three times in the 8-week course, about 5-6 hours of assignment and peer review work.

        -Archaeology: Maybe 2 hours of (incredibly awesome) videos per week, plus half an hour of reading, ten minutes on a quiz, and a total of around 3-4 hours assessment/peer review per week.

        And it looks like the courses themselves back me up on this - they all seem to claim either 4-6 or 6-8 hours of work per week. That's only about an hour each night!

        hS

        PS: Hi there, Toey!

        • Hmm. by Neshomeh on 2013-09-05 17:32:00 UTC Link to this

          It sounds so reasonable in theory. ^_^;

          Though, since it's free, there's really no consequence (besides personal shame) for not following through, right? Or do they kick you out if you don't keep up with the work?

          ~Neshomeh

          • Nope, they don't kick you out. ;) by Huinesoron on 2013-09-06 17:01:00 UTC Link to this

            There's actually a whole bunch of people who watch the videos but don't do any of the assignments. You won't get a Certificate of Accomplishment at the end, but you still get all the knowledge.

            That being the case, though, I think it's better to at least try for the certificate - it's ever so much more rewarding, and doing something is usually the best way to learn about it.

            (ALSO ALSO WIK: personal shame is the worst consequence other than all the worse ones)

            hS

            • WIK? (nm) by son_of_heaven176 on 2013-09-06 21:57:00 UTC Link to this
              • No, also also wik. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-07 15:33:00 UTC Link to this

                You may want to watch this video.

                hS

      • *heard of it. Curse you, Toey! >. by Neshomeh on 2013-09-05 15:06:00 UTC Link to this
    • I think I've heard of this by Phobos on 2013-09-05 14:46:00 UTC Link to this

      Or at least something similar. It was on the Colbert Report not too long ago.

      This is really awesome. I am going to have to check out what they have to offer. I could always use some more knowledge.

      -Phobos

    • Re: OT: Coursera by AdmiralSakai on 2013-09-05 13:47:00 UTC Link to this

      Machine Learning with Stanford's wonderful Andrew Ng. I have literally studied with one of the world's leading experts in artificial intelligence... and it was AWESOME!

      • Psst is it okay if I giggle a little at your username? by Lily Winterwood on 2013-09-05 14:36:00 UTC Link to this

        Because Sakai is one of those teaching tools (kinda like Blackboard if you know what that is) that we use at my school.

        It was just extremely fitting, shhh.

        • Re: Psst is it okay if I giggle a little at your username? by AdmiralSakai on 2013-09-05 16:56:00 UTC Link to this

          I honestly don't remember where this username came FROM, so it's perfectly all right.

  • [Generic Newbie Introduction Title Here] by Artemis on 2013-09-05 22:01:00 UTC Link to this

    Um, hello! I'm Artemis, but I like to go by Arty, or pretty much anything anyone wants to call me. I found this place from the fantastic sporking of the MLP fanfic "Cupcakes" that was mentioned on TVtropes. I quickly fell in love, seeing as grammar, writing, and I are best friends. And, I mean, you literally KILL Sues! You dismember them and throw their bodies into pits of lava! Heck to the yes!!

    Contrary to what would be expected, I am not in the MLP fandom, though I've got a pretty good working knowledge of it due to a friend of mine. I am, however, a major Homestuck fan ((Homestuck High about did me in)), and Portal and Welcome to Nightvale reside among my rather large collection of "Things That Arty Enjoys". All three are not very big here, from what I can tell, but hopefully I can figure out something!

    I have some basic character drafts set up, but I don't plan on requesting permission for a while while I get my bearings. I've still got a lot of learning to do, and truth be told, I am extremely excited for it.

    Oh, and speaking of learning, please tell me if I mess something up. This should go without saying, since I'm here and all, but I am a big fan of logical criticism.

    A few quick questions before I end my first journey into the eldritch horror known as "The Board"...

    Roughly how many people are active here?
    What are the main fandoms?
    And, has anyone seen my pants?

    • [Generic Salutations Here] by darklordaakmal on 2013-09-14 19:19:00 UTC Link to this

      Roughly how many people are active here?

      I believe it's about 2 or 3 dozen people at a time. I'm not being active lately, just greetings newbies at most. Huinesoron did published a few charts a few threads down, you best refer to there.

      What are the main fandoms?

      Tolkienverse and MLP seems to be the mainstream here, but everyone have their own tastes. It seems that Tolkienverse is more important, as Jay and Acacia original missions are mostly centered there.

      And, has anyone seen my pants?

      Are you a nerdfighter?

    • Welcome a'Board! by Huinesoron on 2013-09-09 11:05:00 UTC Link to this

      Has anyone poked you yet? No? I can't see one. In that case, first poke! [Pokepokepoke]

      And here's an interesting fact for you: did you know you're the second Artemis we've had on the Board? The original left many years ago, and was the author of (I'm reasonably sure) Aerilyn and Zera, as well as the creator of the Department of Internal Affairs (specifically Agents Black and Irvine, though their stories are not lost :().

      hS

      • Re: Welcome a'Board! by Artemis on 2013-09-09 12:17:00 UTC Link to this

        I suppose it makes sense that there was at least one other Artemis on the board- it is, after all, a fantastic name, if I do say so myself. I'll get to reading those missions, thanks~

    • Hello, hello, hello! by Legacy on 2013-09-07 19:58:00 UTC Link to this

      How d'you feel about Avatar: The Last Airbender? Just asking.

      Anyways, welcome to the PPC, Arty! Try reading the Original Series and stuff like that. Have a fluffy velociraptor while you think on whether or not you like A:TLA!

      • Re: Hello, hello, hello! by Artemis on 2013-09-08 02:01:00 UTC Link to this

        I have minor knowledge of A:TLA. I haven't watched it in a while. Most of my recent stuff is based in LoK, as some people on my tumblr dash love it to pieces.

        I am in the middle of the original series- I like it a lot. Luxury is my favorite so far. Acy and Jay have a great banter set up. I also like the way they have neatly distinguished the rules of the PPC while not deviating from the story. After reading 100 pages of them, it was kind of nice to see them integrated well, hehe.

        I have to say, though, the person who did the Cupcakes sporking- and a few others- was fantastic. I loved how they approached it and how the story flowed. I definitely think they were a large part of me deciding to look the PPC up, as opposed to the idea of it alone.

    • Good to have you a-Board! by doctorlit on 2013-09-07 14:25:00 UTC Link to this

      Greetings, new friend! Have a potted Poison Joke!

    • Hello newbie! by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-06 23:03:00 UTC Link to this

      Welcome aBoard! So you listen to Cecil, eh? What do you think of the latest developments between him and Carlos?

      Then, to answer your questions:

      1. No idea
      2. We don't have any, we just all fool around. An argument could be made for LotR as our main fandom, since it was the founding fandom, but I think we can say with certainty we're all just putzing around the multiverse without focusing on any one fandom.
      3. Pants are forbidden on the Board unless you have special permission.

      • Re: Hello newbie! by Artemis on 2013-09-07 06:04:00 UTC Link to this

        I find the two to be a quite interesting pair, and I am eager to see what springs up- both in the canon, AND in badfic. It's a morbid excitement.

        • Oh, badfic. by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-09 23:06:00 UTC Link to this

          I've been too scared to look up any Night Vale fanfics...no telling what I might find.

    • Hello there! by son_of_heaven176 on 2013-09-06 22:14:00 UTC Link to this

      Hi there! Nice to see that you've started to get acquainted with the craziness that is the PPC. As has been said already, there are no "main fandoms" around here--though because the Original Series was based off of Lord of the Rings badfic, it's usually good to have a good LoTR background. (But, of course, it's by no means required--I, for one, am mainly a Pokemon fan, and I remember actually falling asleep when I last tried to read The Two Towers!)

      Speaking of the Original Series, have you read it? That is pretty much required reading around here, since all else is based off of it.

      Oh yeah, your newbie gift...
      *rummages through bag of holding*
      Aha!
      From the Jimmy Neutron continuum, have a self-folding pair of pants!

    • Re: [Generic Newbie Introduction Title Here] by Antigone68104 on 2013-09-06 16:07:00 UTC Link to this

      Hi, have some fudge!

    • Welcome to the Board! by Cassie on 2013-09-06 15:42:00 UTC Link to this

      It's good to meet you. Have a bag of pebbles and a Random Shiny Object; they are good for dealing with Sues. :D

    • Uhhh.... by Artemis on 2013-09-06 03:14:00 UTC Link to this

      Also I may have just requested permission by accident.
      ... Oops.

    • Greetings, friend, and well met! by Phobos on 2013-09-06 03:14:00 UTC Link to this

      Have this tiny plastic Marquise De Sod as a gift on your arrival.

      I am also a Homestuck and Portal fan. It doesn't matter if a fandom is not very big here, by the way. Many of the big ones now were not big historically. Things change over time. So bring your love of your chosen fandoms and they may become bigger as others catch on to what makes them great.

      As to your pants, I'm afraid I haven't seen them, which is odd. I am a notorious pants thief, in real life.

      -Phobos

      • Mini Alert? by son_of_heaven176 on 2013-09-06 22:08:00 UTC Link to this

        Uh...did the Marquis suddenly find a wife? Or did you just hand over a plastic figurine of a Mini-Flower as a newbie gift?

        • Oh...how did that 'e' get there? (nm) by Phobos on 2013-09-07 17:16:00 UTC Link to this
      • Why thank you! by Artemis on 2013-09-06 03:20:00 UTC Link to this

        Sounds good, thank you. I have been meaning to learn more about the Flowers, since it seems they might be classified as "important", heh. This should prove useful.
        ((Update: I have figured out that it is rather impossible to "accidentally" ask for permission through further reading. It appears I simply sent out the self-check. If someone actually reads those, then I'm so, so sorry.))

    • Oh hai there! by Herr Wozzeck on 2013-09-06 02:32:00 UTC Link to this

      Welcome to the PPC. Sit down, relax, and make yourself at home: we love newbies here! Just remember to leave your sanity at the door, and all will be amazing and awesome and hilarious.

      And main fandoms? Well, there are no main fandoms here. Mission authors can make their missions in whatever fandoms they want. So there's no rule.

      Anyway... Have some music by Helmut Lachenmann for the road: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pYKkZrPz13s

    • Hello! by QuietHiker on 2013-09-06 01:32:00 UTC Link to this

      Hi Artemis! I'm Wendy, fellow newbie to the boards. (I started actively lurking a couple days ago, so I don't know much, nor have I seen your pants.)

      Here's some pants I virtually made out of virtual duct tape; they might be a bit stiff, though.

    • *waves* by Ailavyn Siniyash on 2013-09-06 00:28:00 UTC Link to this

      Greetings and welcome!

      A Portal fan! I've been waiting for one so that I could pass on some of the extra combustible lemons my brother gave me. Here they are! *gives*

      Oh, and also take a lined Infinite Notebook with urple covers and wilver binding. Beware your eyes!

      -Aila

      • Re: *waves* by Anonymous on 2013-09-06 03:10:00 UTC Link to this

        Oh, thanks for the lemons as well. I have the whole rant memorized, but I figure I'll spare everyone looking at me as if I'm the sane one at a lunatic convention, heh.

    • Regarding the Pants by Lenore Snow on 2013-09-05 23:20:00 UTC Link to this

      Have you tried looking up? I often find shoes and other assorted garments dangling from rafters and power lines. In that spirit, have a giant hook fused to a ten-foot steel rod as your housewarming gift! Ya know, in case you ever need to retrieve some trousers from a telephone pole.

      I honestly have no clue how many people are active on the Board. I'd ask Huinesoron about that. He has all sorts of funky charts and nifty statistics in his arsenal.

      As for fandoms, the first replier named some pretty good ones. I have yet to meet anyone who doesn't like Harry Potter, and The Hunger Games and PJO are popular. There's a pretty wide variety, though. Anything goes fandom-wise.

      So, welcome to the PPC! I'd wish you good luck and intact sanity, but what fun would that be? My efforts would probably be futile, anyway. :D

      -- Len

      • Re: Regarding the Pants by Artemis on 2013-09-06 03:08:00 UTC Link to this

        Wow that got a bigger response than I was expecting, heh. Let's see...

        Thanks, but I only look up when the ceiling's on fire and there's blood dripping down on me. 0u0 I do appreciate the pole though. You might see me try to polejump over it at some point. That... should be interesting.

        Thank you for the duct tape pants, they make me feel quite at home! A website I mod at is big on duct tape ((it's a sim about invincible llamas and it's purrfect)) so it's rather nice to have something to remind me of it!

        Thank you for the potato cannon, I will be sure to use it quite, quite often. And two things I love include hoodies and Dr. Who ((though I'm only on the fifth season)) so it's like Christmas up in this hizz-ouse! Or hizose? I don't know. ANYWAYS.

        And finally, thank you for the grossly- I mean, wonderfully- colored notebook, it should come in handy. This way, I can charge for urple prose and actually have something to show them when their faces do that screwed-worse-n'-a-cork-screw thing! ((Which reminds me, how does one's face "screw"? I've never understood that expression.))

        • Re: Re: Regarding the Pants by Lenore Snow on 2013-09-06 03:18:00 UTC Link to this

          You are very much welcome, and I wish you the best of luck at your pole-vaulting exploits. Mind the hook! And ninjas. Dark and darkly-clad things come to those who don't look up now and then. :)

    • No, I haven't seen your pants, but... by Kittythekatty on 2013-09-05 22:41:00 UTC Link to this

      Hello there Artemis! Please accept my gift of a potato cannon and a sack of golden potatoes-great for dispatching Suvians. Okay, while not necessarily that lethal, it is tremendously satisfying to peg a Suvian with a bit of potato traveling at high speeds. Oh, and have an Official Fanfiction University of Doctor Who hoodie.

      As for the amount of fandoms...well there are a lot of them. I don't think there are any main ones, but I suppose examples of various fandoms would be Lord of the Rings, Star Trek, Doctor Who, Mass Effect, Sherlock...That's a sad list, but all I've got so far.

      As of the beginning of 2013 to about August 12th, there has been about 54 people active. Not including the people who join after that, of course.

      As for your pants, I don't know where they are. That's not my division. I could get you a pair of jeans though, there should be a plothole around here somewhere...

  • Triple Prime: SeaTurtle's Sundering by SeaTurtle on 2013-09-06 00:04:00 UTC Link to this

    Presenting a collaborative effort between me and the Irish Samurai:

    Prologue: Entanglement

    Where the wrong man in the right place can make all the difference in the world…

    I’d like to thank the Irish Samurai and Huinesoron for beta-reading this piece.

    Concrit is welcome, as always!

    • Hooray! by Huinesoron on 2013-09-09 10:56:00 UTC Link to this

      I liked this when I beta'd it, and I still like it now. I particularly like some of the lines which weren't there when I read it before - 'It was sort of like having a very nicely dressed falcon stare you down.' And in general, it was fun to read - and it's fun to see the timeline folding and refolding itself.

      The question is, if the PPC community still exists in the 2030s, will we be able to resolve these timelines? And how?

      And if we don't, do I get to write another History dealing with the Sundering That Didn't Sunder, and explaining exactly how everything ended up going on as usual? 2030... yeah, that should be enough time for me to want to go through that again.

      hS

    • Applying my foreign language skills again by Hieronymus Graubart on 2013-09-07 11:22:00 UTC Link to this

      Hundreds had died and so had most of Flowers - shouldn’t this be most of the Flowers?

      Is that grammatically and temporally correct enough, or I need to go on? - shouldn’t this be or do I need to go on?

      I’m quite confused now. I may need to re-read Huinesoron and Samurai’s stories.

      • Ooh, thanks for pointing those out. by SeaTurtle on 2013-09-07 21:00:00 UTC Link to this

        http://images.wikia.com/mspaintadventures/images/d/d0/Sweet_Catch.png

        I'll fix them right away.

        Thanks for reading!

    • Yay for timey-wimeyness! by the Irish Samurai on 2013-09-06 21:55:00 UTC Link to this

      Because there's just not enough of that around HQ :P

      I really like this piece, I think you've got a very interesting concept for the storyline (and I'm not just saying that because it's based on mine!). I look forward to seeing how things go for Gaspard with all his future knowledge.

      I've said it before, but I'll say it again - the interaction between Skeet and Amy was brilliant (particularly Skeet's line about the 'emergency flare').

      Nicely done.

    • And then there were three... by Phobos on 2013-09-06 02:06:00 UTC Link to this

      Time lines, that is. As I see it, you have the Paladin-line (which only occurs if the Paladins don't come back in time), the Tick-tock-line (started by the flowers vetoing the DoE) and now this new time line, which is new and different because of all the information that Gaspard has at his disposal.

      I can't wait to see how it gets more complicated down the line. How many branching time lines can one series of stories create? I don't know, but I want to find out.

      Well done, all around.

      -Phobos, lover of tangled time

      • Fun, isn't it? by SeaTurtle on 2013-09-06 08:57:00 UTC Link to this

        I'm eager to see if more people will write things set in the Sundering era. We've got the divergence and merging of timelines and all of that stuff... what's not to like?

        Anyhoo, thanks for reading!

        • As I mentioned to Irish Samurai... by Phobos on 2013-09-06 14:22:00 UTC Link to this

          I've got my own future story in the works (I posted a side story from it during a monthly writing challenge), though it has nothing to do with the Sundering. I should be coming out with it very soon.

          I do like divergent timelines. I'm just waiting for the inevitable Mobius Double Reach-around.

          -Phobos

          • Presenting the Inevitable Mobius Double Reach-around! by the Irish Samurai on 2013-09-12 19:53:00 UTC Link to this

            Actually, I'm not sure that I am - mostly because I have no idea what a Mobius Double Reach-around is, nor why it should be so inevitable.

            It sounds complicated though, and this piece does kind of complicated things to the timeline, so maybe it's close enough. In fact, it's possible that anything of sufficiently advanced complexity is indistinguishable from an Inevitable Mobius Double Reach-around.

            Anyway, this piece (probably/possibly) takes place prior to SeaTurtle's Triple Prime, and might even explain a little bit about just how my agents ended up in there:

            ~~~

            Skeet and Amy stepped out of the portal and into the SO's office, the handheld chrono-tracker showing that they had made it to the right point in the timestream.

            The SO wasn't there yet, which gave them time to hunt for the assassins. Suddenly, two (very familiar looking) human figures stood up from where they'd been hiding behind the room's large desk.

            “You?” Skeet said.

            “You!? I mean, me? I mean... oh hell, I don’t know.” The other Skeet said.

            The Skeet and Amy that had been hiding behind the desk looked identical to the other pair, except for the fact that these ones had obviously recently been in combat. Their clothing was torn and patched, their faces smudged with dirt – the other Skeet had a bandage on his upper arm, and his Amy had a cast on her wrist.

            “What are you doing here?” Skeet asked his doppelganger.

            “We're here to kill the SO, before he can trigger the Sundering and the End Times.”

            Skeet and Amy shared a look. "We're here to stop the SO from being killed, so that with his leadership the Board votes against the Department of Efficiency proposals, thereby avoiding the Sundering."

            “Huh, well this awkward.” Injured!Skeet said.

            “Yeah. Hey, wait a minute, why were you surprised to see me?”

            “Because I wasn’t expecting you, dumbass.”

            “Listen, smeghead, I wasn’t expecting you either. How does that work? We can’t have both got here before each other, can we? How would that work?”

            The two Skeets began trying to work it out, using their fingers to represent different points in time and seeing if they could be moved into order, but then quickly fell back to insulting each other. It was left to their partners to try and sort it out. As the girls began to work things through, their partners moved on from insults, to arguments, to actual fighting.

            “Er, guys?” Injured!Amy said. “We’re AUs of each other. This is our first meeting, from both sides.”

            The Skeets looked up at her. Injured!Skeet had Skeet in a headlock, and had been trying to convince him of his superior reasoning powers via a series of blows to the head, while Skeet was preparing to make a cunning counter-argument by elbowing his opponent in the stomach.

            “AUs? Radagast on a bunny sled, how much more complicated is this gonna get?”

            “Quite a lot actually,” said a third Skeet, as he appeared out of a portal. This Skeet had short hair, was clean-shaven, and dressed mostly in white. A chatter of voices could be heard from the other side of his portal. “That’s why we formed the Council.”

            “What Council?” asked Skeet.

            “The Council of Us: all the Skeets, and all the Amys. We’re gonna sort this mess out.” He turned and walked back to his portal, calling over his shoulder, “Come on, you don’t want to be late.”

            “Dude, we’re time-travellers-”

            “Exactly, so think how embarrassing it would be for you if you were late.” Councillor!Skeet said, as he walked through the portal.

            Four confused Assassins followed him.

            They emerged in a large chamber, possibly one of HQ’s auditoriums. The grey walls seemed pristine when viewed from some angles, but were clearly battle-scarred from others. There were at least twenty different versions of Skeet and Amy in the room, several dressed in the identical simple black of a PPC agent, but some of them looked more distinctive.

            As the last four arrived, a Skeet near the podium (this one wearing an eyepatch on his left eye) called for order.

            “OK, now as I'm sure some of you have noticed, our efforts to go back in time and prevent the Sundering haven’t exactly gone smoothly...”

            This brought a round of chuckles from his audience.

            “...which is why we’ve decided to try and bring some level of rationality to our efforts. Now, we’ve got some visitors from even further in the future,” he gestured to four hooded and cloaked figures behind him, “but their involvement is going to have to be strictly limited. They’re basically just here so we don’t waste our time, but they can’t just tell us what to do – we have to come up with the solution that they used ourselves.”

            He paused for breath, and was about to continue when he was pre-empted by a beeping from his pocket. Seconds later, another beeping started up from with the crowd, and an Amy rushed forward to the podium. The two held a hurried, whispered, conversation.

            “Shit, sorry about this.” Eyepatch!Skeet addressed the crowd. “I’ve got a thing.”

            With that ‘explanation’ given, the two of them disappeared through a portal, leaving confused mutterings in their wake.

            Another Skeet took to the stage and took off his fedora, revealing that he too wore an eyepatch. “Right, well, now that that’s been taken care of – and I can assure you, it was very important – we can get down to business.

            “First things first: it’s going to be difficult enough telling us apart as it is, so if you haven’t already adopted some ridiculous affection,” here he nodded at a pair of partners in full pirate regalia, “to make your appearance more unique, then I suggest you do so now.

            “Next up, let’s start by mapping out the distinct timelines we’ve identified so far, and look for points of commonality and divergence...”

            • Wow. That was... impressive. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-13 11:12:00 UTC Link to this

              (Is this canon? Tell me this is canon)

              I've played with a similar idea before - various incarnations of Agent Lou have run into each other, and I have two stories stored away involving a dozen different versions of me (from different stories) meeting up - but I don't think my versions have ever organised. I can definitely see it of Skeet and Amy, though.

              The story itself, I enjoyed - things like the two versions having opposite reasons for being there, and the 'We can’t have both got here before each other' discussion. And the 'how embarrasing it would be to be late' thing, and of course the 'ridiculous affectation' thing... yeah, basically it was a fun little read.

              I wonder what's going on with the cloaked group, though. I do hope they're not from really far in the future and engaged in a religious war...

              hS

              • Thank you. by the Irish Samurai on 2013-09-13 12:28:00 UTC Link to this

                Yeah, this story falls under the same category as 'Trousers' did - it's canon for my agents, and anyone else that wants it to be. If it messes up anyone else's plans for future timelines, then they're free to consider it non-canon. But yes, as far as I'm concerned, all of that was canon.

                As for the hooded figures, well, they could be anyone (or anything - surely they're not just wearing those hoods and cloaks to be fashionable. Hmm, a religious war hey... *starts scribbling notes furiously*)

                I'm glad you liked it, and I'm planning more in stories in this little mini-series.

                • At this point... by Huinesoron on 2013-09-13 12:55:00 UTC Link to this

                  ... I'm not sure we could mess up each other's future timelines any more if we tried. I'm just assuming that 4D being from Animorphs will show up at some point and fix everything - or maybe Superboy can show up and give the space-time continuum a punching.

                  hS

                  • Challenge accepted! by the Irish Samurai on 2013-09-13 18:40:00 UTC Link to this

                    That was a challenge, right? Where you said 'not sure we could mess up each other's future timelines any more if we tried'? Cos that sounds like a challenege to me :)

                    Actually, while I am planning on writing several more pieces featuring Future!Skeet and Amy (currently under the working title 'The Glass Clock Sequence' - for what I'm assuming will be obvious reasons to you), there probably won't be much more timeline mangling going on.

                    As it happens, the piece that I failed to finish writing for your Third Writing Challenge, and the piece that I am currently failing to finish for your Fourth, both feature my future agents. I really need to get round to finishing those off...

            • That... by Phobos on 2013-09-12 22:26:00 UTC Link to this

              ...was way more than a Mobius Double Reach-around. Well done. I'll have more specific comments when I have more time.

              -Phobos

              • Cool! by the Irish Samurai on 2013-09-13 12:20:00 UTC Link to this

                I'm glad to see that my experimental research into Mobius Triple Reach-arounds has paid off :)

    • Ah, so this is why the timelines were different. by Outhra on 2013-09-06 00:33:00 UTC Link to this

      My questions were answered in the sequel! Since the original Door From the Future RP/Trousers of Time world didn't have someone neuralyzing the agents, this timeline proceeded with less knowledge of the DoE.
      The Flowers found out through the agents that retained their knowledge, or possibly just because they're the Flowers, so seeing all and knowing all is part of their job, but the agents not retaining their memories set off a temporal domino effect, In Want Of A Nailing the entire timeline to a different course!
      Not only does this remove my previous "how is it an Alternate Universe story for all but a few people when the few people exist in the same universe as those who it is an Alternate Universe story for" by revealing that the timelines were in fact distinct all along, just imagine how Amy is going to react when she realizes that she was unintentionally responsible for the timeline containing the Tick-Tock Men and the DTOM to come into being! I mean, judging by Skeet's dialogue, the two would have known at least at some point that their arrival into the past was the cause of the timelines differentiating each other, so it's not going to be an "I did what?" sort of reaction, but it's probably still going to be a huge emotional hit.

      I wish you hadn't used the term "fixed point in time", though. It may have been unintentional, but it's giving me unpleasant flashbacks to when I tried to puzzle out how Steven Moffat's time travel rules work. Uuggghh. Logic and Moffat do not combine.

      By the way, before Skeet's watch beeps, there's a [SI3] in the text. What does that mean? Does it represent a sound?

      • Thanks for reading! by SeaTurtle on 2013-09-06 07:56:00 UTC Link to this

        ...though I don't quite exactly follow your temporal reasoning. The way I saw the timeline was:

        Present PPC ==> Huinesoron's Sundering ==> Door From the Future RP ==> [Board of Department Heads forewarned] ==> [Rise of the DTOM] ==> the Irish Samurai's Sundering ==> [Skeet and Amy's time travelling] ==> [Return to the Door From the Future, neuralysed all present except one] ==> [Prime Timeline reestablished] ==> Triple Prime

        ...so this is the third lap around the block for everyone involved.


        As for the use of "fixed point in time", I chose it because it was short and to the point. While I wasn't trying to make it into a Moffat-ism, I felt that it was a term a lot of people could recognize or understand quite easily.

        Erp, the [SI3] was a leftover from my betas. All gone now! Thanks for pointing it out.

        • Here's how I interpreted the events: by Outhra on 2013-09-07 04:58:00 UTC Link to this

          The Door From the Future RP occurs, in which people from Huinesoron's original Sundering time stream enter the "prime" or "main" PPC time stream.
          Differentiation occurs with the arrival of the Skeet and Amy from either The Wrong Trousers's time stream or the future of the SeaTurtle's Sundering time stream(this detail was unclear, but doesn't affect event progression, and actually opens up some interesting questions by remaining ambiguous), and Amy neuralyzes most of the agents who witnessed the arrival of the future-people.
          In addition, a separate differentiation occurs when Skeet leaves a psychic message from alternate-older-Gaspard. This doesn't create a new timeline, but simply further alters an existing one.

          In the main timeline, the Flowers found out about the bad future from the agents that witnessed the future-people and took steps to prevent it, resulting in a timeline that, while not free of conflict and potential future power struggles, lacks a Sundering.

          In the altered timeline, most of the "present" agents were neuralyzed, save Gaspard and a few others that weren't in the room when Amy and Skeet came in, such as Kayleigh Leonard. This caused future events to change, since there was less knowledge in the "present" about the DoE and Sundering than there was in the main time stream, setting off a chain of events that allowed the DTOM to form and rise to an level of power unseen since the Mysterious Somebody's day.
          I admit, this is a bit of a leap, since as I said, it is currently unclear whether the Skeet and Amy were bringing a message from STS Gaspard's future self, or simply the future self of a Gaspard. If it was just the future self of a Gaspard, the future of the STS time stream may not have a DoE or a DTOM, may being the operative word due to the potential(in time travel, this is a distinctly different word than "possible") synonymity of the STS timeline and The Wrong Trousers's timeline.

          Regardless, events would have proceeded similarly to the main timeline if Amy hadn't neuralyzed the Agents.

          Judging by General de Grasse's dialogue, if Gaspard were ever to reveal the information that he now knows about the future, events in STS Gaspard's native time stream would proceed similarly to those in The Wrong Trousers's time stream, or perhaps the two timelines would become synonymous, as I said before. I'm not sure how much hyperbole was used in alternate-older Gaspard's statement there, but going by main-current-Gaspard's demeanor, I'm guessing not much.

          I figured that, with the "Triple Prime" chapter title, you had been referring to the three time streams: one in the STS story, one in The Wrong Trousers, and one original timeline that the two latter time streams differentiated from.

          From what I can tell, my interpretation seems to at least be close to what you were trying to go for, save that bit at the end about some people having been on a "third lap around the block". Does that mean there have been major characters in three separate timelines, or that the reader has seen iterations of the main characters in three separate time streams, or what exactly?
          Perhaps my original reasoning being hard to follow was just due to me phrasing things poorly. It wouldn't be unlike me.

          I know you weren't trying to invoke Moffat with that line about fixed points in time, especially since your take on the term as "circumstantial simultaneity of events in several related but unconnected alternate universes" is different than his less-suitable definition. I just inwardly flinched when I saw the term, is all. It's nothing against the way your story handled time.
          In fact, I actually quite like your time travel model. Keeping details and possibilities in flux while still keeping a few elements of predestination would seem like trying to, to invoke a phrase, both having and eating one's cake, if it was handled in a less effective manner. As it is here, it opens some interesting mysteries and potential for dramatic tension, which is always a plus.

      • Oops. by Outhra on 2013-09-06 00:36:00 UTC Link to this

        I realized just after posting that one of my sentences is really confusingly structured. I think you'll probably be able to to figure out what it means, but it's got too many clauses, and one of them's in the wrong spot. Just... well, too late for a warning, so an apology, then. Sorry.

  • Fourth Monthlyish PPC Writing Challenge: 'Return' by Huinesoron on 2013-09-06 16:34:00 UTC Link to this

    (I meant to get this up a bit earlier in the day; on the other hand, I suppose it's not even noon in America yet, so it's okay)

    For the fourth time, I present the Monthlyish PPC Writing Challenge!

    Here at the PPC we're very big on writing. We write missions, we rant about the bad writing in badfics, we even play games like Fill The Plothole, which consist of, yep, writing. But at no point do we all sit down and try to improve our writing together.

    So. The objective of the Monthly PPC Writing Challenge is to write a short story to a set theme, and then give useful, constructive criticism to other participants.


    Here are The Rules:

    -Write a (reasonably short) story in response to the Theme below, and post it on this thread. You may use a beta if you wish, but it is not required.
    -Give constructive criticism (at least one positive point, at least one negative with suggestions for improvement) to at least one other submission.
    -You may rewrite your story based on concrit you receive and repost it, but this is not required.
    -Obvious fact, but no flaming! This isn't like the Badfic Contest - the goal here is to write a good story and get feedback from the community.
    -You do not require Permission to participate in the Challenge. Neither do your agents need to be approved for you to use them.
    -However, nothing written for the Challenge is considered part of the PPC Canon unless you do have Permission, and explicitly claim it as canon.

    I think that covers it. Remember that both the writing and the giving of concrit are part of the challenge. (And no, there's no time limit - but there's not usually much point posting on a thread that's left the front page)

    And this month's Theme:

    A character in the PPC returns something.

    Deliberately short-but-sweet. I hope you can find something interesting to do with it. And remember... have fun!

    hS

    • Workplace Hazards by VixenMage on 2013-09-10 09:08:00 UTC Link to this

      Er, I wrote the first part of this on a rock in the middle of a river, before reading Phobos' plug down-page. And now I'm looking at the whole thing twice, but anyway. If you haven't read it yet, you should.

      ---

      The sink gurgled as the drain swallowed the last of the suds. Mohan watched them disappear, ran the tap one more time to clear it, and glanced up quickly as the door closed. Lyn clicked the latch home and shook her head. He sighed and turned back to the counter, where several cubic metres of turnip stood.

      "I keep saying we should get some kind of a partition set up," Lyn said, behind him. He heard the clunk as she pulled the case down from the cabinet.

      "It wouldn't do any good," he told her, retrieving his own knife from the block.

      He hefted the long blade once, swing it straight across for the whistle, and brought it down hard on the massive root vegetable. The counter shook slightly with the noise. He grinned nastily at the slice, pulled the knife out, and reached back up to swing again. The knives they used for these were long, and kept sharp. They'd learned to be a bit more careful while chopping vegetables, these days.

      Behind him, the chainsaw revved to life, and there was no conversation for a while as Lyn worked on the other half of the recipe.

      "I know," she said, as she killed the engine. "But we've got to do something! He won't wear gloves, and I don't blame him - Cafeteria bylaws have a lot of words about that."

      "I still think somebody should have told them why gloves were such an important part of World One foodhandling tradition," Mohan said, bringing the knife down to take another two-inch slice of the turnip. "You never know, it might not be the worst idea."

      "No, the worst idea was importing ice wraiths for the walk-in freezers."

      Mohan shook his head. "What, and not that time someone decided what we really needed was a Durian Casserole?"

      "Okay, that was--"

      "--or when someone thought the best place to get carrots was in the middle of a Looney Tunes firefight?"

      "Whoa, but that--"

      "--or that time with the Wreck-it Ralph badfic--"

      "--Okay! I get it!" His partner glared at him from the other side of the kitchen. He did not bother to grant the glare the dignity of turning around; Lyn could glare holes in asbestos.

      "If we changed the bylaws specifically to allow gloves for hazards to workers, what would that do?"

      "Probably nothing," Lyn said, pushing the bowl of sawdust up on the counter. "He wouldn't wear them anyway, and he'd be upset if we tried to change the rules for him. Watch out, that's got to go here."

      He stepped out of the way as she slid the stack of sliced turnips into the mixing bowl, and carried it over to the sink to blend.

      "How many batches are we making, anyway?"

      She shrugged. "I figure we might as well use all of it. He should be back pretty soon. We've just got to talk to DoSAT, or maybe Medical, about a way to fix all this."

      Mohan nodded, and returned to cleaving the turnips. He'd nearly finished the row when there was a knock on the door; he and Lyn nearly knocked each other over opening it.

      Igor raised an eyebrow at them. "He ith yourth, yeth?"

      Behind him was the tall, slightly sheepish figure of an Enderman in Cafeteria uniform. He disappeared from view immediately, leaving only a trail of purple sparks past the Igor and into the kitchen. Lyn followed him; Mohan sighed.

      "Yes, he is. Thank you, Igor. Is he alright?"

      "He ith fine. The burnth will heal in a few dayth. He theemth quite eager to return, tho Doctor Fitthgerald athked me to ethcort him here."

      The short medic reached into his lab pocket and pulled out a small box. "He altho athked me to return thith to your Department."

      Mohan frowned. "Oh - thank you. He didn't say what it was...?"

      But the Igor had already disappeared. Mohan sighed, closed the door, and opened the box.

      "...Oh, damn it." He followed the trail of purple sparks through the kitchen, to where Lyn and Jof were lounging outside of the freezers, eating sandwiches. "Jof, Igor brought this back, too." He handed the little device to his partner, who frowned.

      "Ah," he said, after a moment. "That would explain it."

      Mohan and Lyn waited a few minutes. Mohan sighed.

      "That would explain...?"

      The Enderman looked up. "The hydrophobic device. I left it behind while visiting last week." He slid the thing into the front pocket of his uniform and took another bite out of his sandwich.

      Lyn shrugged, took another bite out of her own sandwich, and grinned happily. Mohan thought of saying something like "...and you didn't mention this?" or "...and you still decided to make chicken soup?" or "can we weld that to your neck?" sighed, thought better of it, and sat down, snagging the remains of sandwich-making-supplies for himself.

      It wasn't until that night at about two o'clock in the morning (the Ironic Overpower Approved time for sudden revelations) when the image of an Igor and a hydrophobic device clicked in his head. He sat bolt upright.

      "Lyn?"

      "nghwha?"

      "How toxic to an Enderman do you think the waters of the Ankh would be?"

      "I was asleep, you--" she stopped. "I don't know, let's find out."

      "Tomorrow."

      ---

      (I only realized partway that the whole "stretching mashed turnips by mixing in sawdust" thing might not be universal, in which case this probably looks random as hell. But yes, that is what they are doing, and no, I probably could not tell you exactly why, besides that my grandpa had some very interesting stories about his childhood.)

      (And yes, I think I'm going to say this is canon, and now I think there needs to be a story about what happens when the Cafeteria decides that they are now doing all their prep and cooking with either Ankh "water" or at least a mixture involving Ankh "water" in some ratio..)

      • Eugh. by VixenMage on 2013-09-11 04:46:00 UTC Link to this

        By the light of day, and less sleep deprivation, this thing is ghastly. Don't bother trying to find concrit; I'll rewrite it and hopefully find some way to make it less clunky before the thread falls off the page.

    • My contribution by hermione of vulcan on 2013-09-10 01:05:00 UTC Link to this

      Note: The opinions expressed here are the opinions of the characters, not necessarily of the author. Also, I have no idea if this is any good.

      Tish dropped the Lord of the Rings trilogy (plus The Hobbit) on Sebak's bunk. They bounced, and the top book skittered off the stack and bumped into Sebak's leg. "I'm done!" she said. "Finally."

      Sebak looked up and carefully restacked The Fellowship of the Ring. "Did you enjoy them?"

      Tish nodded. "Yeah. I liked The Hobbit the best because Bilbo's character development is cool. I think the riddles were a really creative way to deal with something scary. And I liked trying to guess the answers. It's so funny, too, Bilbo being all like 'I want my hobbit-hole'!"

      The Vulcan tilted his head. "I found that one the least enjoyable."

      Tish nodded. "You probably like The Silmarillion the best," she guessed.

      "Did you read it?" Sebak asked, looking almost hopeful.

      Tish snorted. "I tried. But you didn't say it was required, and it's really boring! I'd read it if it was told like a story, but ugh."

      "Tolkien's prose is considered quite beautiful," Sebak said.

      "Yeah, it is," Tish said. "And that's the problem. It's like 'hey look I'm a linguistics professor!' rather than 'hey I'm going to tell you a cool story'!"

      "I thought you said you liked the series."

      She sighed. "First of all, they’re not as bad as The Silmarillion. And there's still a cool story there. But I kept stopping and starting because I kept losing interest. If I hadn't promised you, I probably wouldn't have finished them."

      Sebak raised his eyebrows. "Why did you read them for me? When you worked in the Lord of the Rings division you would have likely had a partner that would have tried to make you read them."

      "Yeah, but she kept trying to convince me to like them and well, you won't. You're just like 'it's logical to read them because there is a lot of badfic for them'. I like things to make sense."

      "Really."

      "Yeah," Tish said.

      "Hm. Considering what I have learned about you, that is most - "

      "Fascinating, I know," Tish said, sighing. "Could you not be stereotypical? Anyhow, I read them for you. Happy? Right, stupid question," she added as Sebak arched an eyebrow.

      "I am disappointed that you did not enjoy them," he replied. "However, as you said, they are necessary."

      "Well, we can agree to disagree on that. Most fic is movieverse. And I didn't say I didn't like them!"

      "You explained your problems with them quite thoroughly," Sebak pointed out.

      She shrugged. "It's just kind of overrated, that's all."

      "That is your opinion."

      "Right," she said.

      Sebak nodded.

      Tish grinned. "So, will you read Percy Jackson?"

      • Perfect. XD by DawnFire on 2013-09-12 03:34:00 UTC Link to this

        I'm really growing to love your characters rather a lot with every bit of their lives that you share. I also think that you've written a very IC Vulcan, which, well...well done :) And Tish explained her reasons and was an illogically logical (or possibly logically illogical) human about it all. It was quite fun, and the end--Percy Jackson--had me giggling, probably both because of the request and because I could picture Sebak's expression (okay, fine, his inner expression). Also because I then went on to picture Sebak's reaction to the books themselves and also probably because I just finished reading The Mark of Athena (er, I think I finished it...it's so recent I can't remember if I have a couple more pages or not, but I think I finished it.) Anyway, it was very fun to read, and I enjoyed it a great deal, and I'm going to post this now before I really start repeating myself. Good night! :)

        ~DF

        • Thanks! by hermione of vulcan on 2013-09-15 02:37:00 UTC Link to this

          Honestly, it's not all that hard to write an IC Vulcan. At least for me. I basically learned how to write fanfiction writing Data, so I just add a bit more snark and use more contractions.

          And I think it will be fun to see Sebak's reaction. I think the two series make a nice contrast - Tolkien being intellectual high fantasy, Percy Jackson being fantasy but more fun and snarky (though no less intelligent). I'll definitely be rereading the series again in preparation for House of Hades, maybe I'll write Sebak's reaction then.

          Anyhow, I'm glad you enjoyed it!

          • Ooh, are you going to write his reac--oh, you just said that by DawnFire on 2013-09-15 05:21:00 UTC Link to this

            Should be awesome :D If you ever feel doubtful that anyone wants to read it, drop me a line, and I'll flood you with encouragement and excited jumping up and down.

            I think my praise of the IC-Vulcan-ness is partially because of a rather traumatic (certainly to the agents involved) Spock replacement, partially because of my own occasional difficulty in determining just how many emotion-based words my Vulcan character would use, and definitely out of admiration at seeing a well-written Vulcan character, one who really reads like a Vulcan. It's been a pleasure :)

            ~DF

            • Stop that, you're making me blush. :) by hermione of vulcan on 2013-09-16 02:26:00 UTC Link to this

              As to writing Vulcans, you write them like other characters, but do what I call "translation". Satisfied or pleased for happy, disappointed or displeased for unhappy, gratified for thankful, mildly irritated for pissed off. And skeptical and confused are good words to use. Use "mildly" and "vaguely" - mildly irritated, vaguely amused. Also, lots of eyebrow movements.

              Though, honestly, I'm sure you're doing fine. :) I look forward to reading said mission.

              Also, while I'm talking to you - how's the Avengers OFU going? It's just that I'm working my way through the movies right now - seen everything except Hulk and Iron Man 3, and I want to watch the Avengers again now that I know everyone's backstory - and I'd love to read it. And submit a fangirl. Because I've kind of got myself to base her on.

      • Wow, how many times have I had that conversation? {X D by Neshomeh on 2013-09-10 03:47:00 UTC Link to this

        This definitely sounds like a real conversation between a pro-Tolkien and "meh"-Tolkien person. I've heard just about all of these points from real people, and I think you've got a fair representation of both sides here—except that I'd personally be a whole lot more insistent than Sebak was about how freaking beautiful Tolkien's language is and nobody appreciates a well-turned sentence these days. >.>

        Ahem. Anyway. As a piece of dialogue, this works pretty well. You've set the scene well enough that I know what the conversation is about and why it's happening. It helps that I already know who these characters are, and I'm not sure if it would be as enjoyable to someone who hasn't met them yet, but for the purpose of illustrating how some people really like Tolkien while others are indifferent, I think it's not terribly important.

        There was one hitch for me:

        "Fascinating, I know," Tish said, sighing. "Could you not be stereotypical? Anyhow, I read them for you. Happy? Right, stupid question," she added as Sebak arched an eyebrow.

        At the end of this line, you've got events happening out of order: Tish responds to Sebak raising his eyebrow before he's shown to do it. Worse, the word "as" means that she reacts to his action at the same time he performs it.* When the reader inevitably realizes that the eyebrow must have happened first and Tish's reaction comes second, they have to pause and reset their mental image, which is a distraction. A small one, yes, but still something to be avoided. I'd rewrite the line like this:

        "Fascinating, I know," Tish said, sighing. "Could you not be stereotypical? Anyhow, I read them for you. Happy?"

        Sebak arched an eyebrow.

        "Right, stupid question," she added.


        This way, everyone is reacting to what came before in a linear progression of cause and effect. It is, you might say, logical. {= )

        ~Neshomeh

        * Full disclosure: I was scarred for life by this fic and learned to hate the word "as" with a fiery burning passion. I take a pretty firm stance on when it should and shouldn't be used. Looser stances may technically be acceptable. Now, if you'll please pardon me, I have to go wipe some bloody sputum off my chin...

        • Oh, good. by hermione of vulcan on 2013-09-11 03:12:00 UTC Link to this

          I'm glad it sounds real. I'm on Tish's side for the most part, but I do want to write Sebak as being much more of a Tolkien fan. For future reference, what other arguments could I possibly use on his side? I didn't really show much of his side here because I wasn't sure I'd get it right.

          And I'll fix that error if I ever rework this into an opening for a mission. Of course, that would require finding a LOTR badfic that would annoy both of them, and that might be kind of hard, seeing as Tish is indifferent and Sebak is a Vulcan.

          • Hm... by Neshomeh on 2013-09-12 19:57:00 UTC Link to this

            I don't know how much use my arguments would be for Sebak, since most of them have to do with feelings invoked by the work. There are a couple academic things I can point to, though.

            In a word, craftsmanship. Tolkien put a massive amount of work into Middle-earth, and it shows in the snippets of languages, poetry, and history that pop up throughout the tale. It's the kind of thing where you get out of it what you put into it. If you're only reading for the adventure story, that's all you'll get, and yeah, it's not your modern action-packed mile-a-minute romp. It's slow, it digresses, it rambles.

            But if you take the time to study it, though, to learn who those people in the songs are, and why there are ruins on Weathertop, and where the Dunedain came from, and the real-life inspiration behind the Rohirrim—and let me just take a moment to say alliterative verse. My mind was blown all over again when I got to college and learned what alliterative verse is, and how he chooses to use it is just perfect, and . . . .

            Ahem. Sorry.

            Speaking to characters for a moment. Again, I think the issue that people have is that everything about them isn't necessarily right there on the page, so if you're not interested in their motifs, archetypes, symbolism, etc., there's not much there. We don't delve into their psyches a whole lot, and few of them are the type to spill everything they're thinking through their dialogue.

            To appreciate Aragorn, for instance, you have to bear in mind that he's old, he's been living like an exile in the wild his entire adult life, and he's not even allowed to be with the woman he loves unless ultimate evil can be destroyed and he becomes king, redeeming the humongous screw-ups of his ancestors who could have prevented this whole mess in the first place if they'd just listened. This quest, while having the highest fate-of-the-world stakes you can possibly get, is also seriously, brutally personal for him. Just because we never hear him complain about it doesn't mean it doesn't weigh on his mind and influence every single decision he makes. So, when he chooses to follow Merry and Pippin instead of Frodo and Sam, or to look into the palantir, or to take the Paths of the Dead, the risk he's taking is enormous, not just for Middle-earth, but for him personally. Every decision is agonizingly risky, but he chooses to take the harder path anyway, because it's just that goddamn crucial. Meanwhile, he still manages to find the time to say a few kind words to poor Eowyn, heal the stricken, and generally act like a compassionate and caring guy. Aragorn is freaking awesome.

            What else...? Oh, I happen to love Tolkien's sense of humor. Yes, he has one. No, it does not involve dwarf-tossing and troll boogers. -_-; It mostly comes from the way joy and laughter can surprise you, I think, so naturally the hobbits are the chief source. You get moments like Gimli waxing poetic about the Glittering Caves in the aftermath of the Battle of Helm's Deep, or Merry and Pippin having a smoke atop the ruins of Isengard, or Sam going on about how their adventures would make a great story someday. It's like... wow, guys, this is what you choose to fixate on at a time like this? Really?

            And the answer is "Yeah, really," because otherwise life just wouldn't be worth the long, hard fight.

            I guess what I'm trying to say is, Tolkien is an academic's dream, but a casual reader's nightmare. Sebak, as an academic, can find all sorts of things to appreciate through study and contemplation of the background details, themes, mythology, inspirations, and broader contexts of the work, whereas Tish, who's looking for a fun, exciting ride, won't find it here. There's nothing wrong with either approach to reading in general, it's just that, when it comes to Tolkien, one will reward you forever and the other one won't.

            I know that probably sounds elitist even though I don't mean it that way... I'll just add that it's really, really okay if you don't love Tolkien. People don't have to love all the same things equally. That would be stupid.

            ~Neshomeh

        • Meanwhile, I completely agree with Tish. by World-Jumper on 2013-09-10 21:32:00 UTC Link to this

          Not to go on to much of a tangent, but I truly find LoTR to be really good, but not fantastic. The kea problem for me is that I am not a wordsmith, but a storyteller. When I read a story, I expect flow in narrative, and the actions motivating the story. I have read books that others have blasted as horribly written, but enjoyed them, as I found value in the story that was being told. One of my good friends, however, was a wordsmith. He could write the most beautiful prose, with description that could blow you away. However, I was a constant critic of his stories, because like Tolkien, he let the construction of the words and the description the the world take precedence over the characters and story. The number of arguments we have had over literature... So yeah, I'm with Tish here. Perhaps after I have finally finished the series I will write a paper on what, exactly, I find wrong with Mr. Tolkien's writing style.

          As for the story you wrote Hermione, I found nothing wrong with it that Nesh has not already pointed out. I have not read anything with these two before, but what I gleamed about them is very interesting. Fascinating, you might say. I am very interested in seeing more from these two. Well done.

          • Also agreeing. by hermione of vulcan on 2013-09-11 03:25:00 UTC Link to this

            I like books the way I like almost everything - pretty and functional. It seems to me that Tolkien goes a little over the top with "pretty".

            I do believe you were away when I posted the first stories with Sebak and Tish, so here are the links to their wiki pages:

            Tish

            Sebak

            Hope you enjoy!

    • Contribution - 'Returning' by Huinesoron on 2013-09-08 18:21:00 UTC Link to this

      (This may be a cursed thread... I meant to post this yesterday, but have been too busy/ill to do so until now...)




      Tango Dioxide (né Dioxide - her culture didn't go in for changing surnames when you got married) jumped into the elevator as soon as it arrived. The doors slammed shut in flagrant disregard of health and safety regs, not to mention the Laws of Narrative Comedy - no-one should ever be able to easily escape a rampaging mob just by getting in a lift. Someone at Legal's going to get in trouble for that one, Tango thought, making the sign of the Legal Chao with one hand.

      The ride up was accompanied by tinny music by a band that wouldn't have been allowed to exist if the Wrecked Music Department were anything more than a rumour, and then as the doors sprung apart Tango discovered exactly why Legal had been so lax:

      Mobius lifts.

      The one upside of her spatial loop of a journey was that the mob weren't expecting her to return. As they stared at her in confusion, Tango took the opportunity to bolt sideways - jumping over one particularly diminuative mobster... or mobette... or whatever the word was - and was off down a corridor. She hastily began to recite Treebeard's song in the original Entish, hoping that her 'unless you hadn't noticed' would trump the mob's 'catch the blasphemer'.

      It didn't really work out. Gasping for breath, Tango threw a glance back over her shoulder to find her pursuers closer than ever. I haven't kept in shape, she lamented. Eight years ago they wouldn't stand a cha-OOF!

      The 'oof' was the natural consequence of running headlong into a potted artificial plant, one of the hideous things Building Maintenance had decided to decorate the lobby with. Except this one wasn't in the lobby, it was in the middle of a corridor - and had a hand reaching out of it.

      "Come on," snapped a woman's voice. "Do you want to be dismembered?"

      "I'm sure they wouldn't-" Tango began, and then heard the distinctive snap-hiss of a dozen lightsabers igniting. "Uh, never mind." She grabbed the hand and let it drag her through the branches, into-

      -a sleek metallic room far larger than the pot plant, or even the corridor. She looked around in wonder, and then turned to the owner of the hand: a short woman with cropped black hair, waiting with her other hand on her hip.

      "A TARDIS," Tango breathed. "I've never actually been in one before."

      "That's always nice to hear," the woman replied. "Nowadays I usually get 'Oh, did you pick one up during the Macrovirus infection too?'. Amateurs." She sniffed, then leant back and tapped something on the console. "There, we're in flight. You're welcome, by the way."

      "Um, thank you," Tango said hurriedly. "But I don't understand. You're PPC - okay, DMS, I see the flashpatch, and it explains the shelf of potted cacti - but who are you? And, not that I'm complaining, why did you help me?"

      The woman frowned at her. "I'm returning the favour," she pointed out. "Remember? When my pack got stolen by goblins in that Labyrinth 'fic, you and Nyx came and rescued me. Well, I saw you were in trouble, and-"

      "Wait, wait." Tango held up a hand. "I've never even set foot in Labyrinth 'fic. I'm sure I'd remember."

      "Hmm." The woman turned and tapped a dial on her console, then shrugged. "Must be on the blink again. So I guess I'm returning the favour in advance. That would explain a few of the things you said..."

      Tango rubbed the bridge of her nose and leant on the nearest piece of furniture, which turned out to be a hatstand. "So you're from the future?"

      "Or you're from the past," the woman offered. "Morgan. Nice to meet you - again."

      "Uh, likewise." Tango shook her head slowly. "So what happens now?"

      Morgan grinned and pulled a lever. A familiar rising and falling whine started up - the sound of a TARDIS dematerialising, made famous by the Doctor Who TV series. "Now I drop you off at your RC, and you do your level best to avoid... what was it you did to get them after you, anyway?"

      "Nothing, really," Tango shrugged. "I just mentioned that I thought The Phantom Menace was the best Star Wars film... what?"

      Morgan's grin had morphed into a frozen rictus, and she leant back against the console and closed her eyes. "I wonder," she said to the room at large, "if it's too late to put her back...?"

      • Applying my foreign language skills once more by Hieronymus Graubart on 2013-09-08 19:33:00 UTC Link to this

        "I've never even set foot in Labyrinth 'fic. I'm sure I'd remember."

        Isn’t there an „a“ missing between „in“ and „Labyrinth”?

        (Yes, it’s a cursed thread. I don’t have time to think about any real concrit.)

        • I'm not really sure. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-09 15:11:00 UTC Link to this

          I agree that in normal English it would need to be there, but as far as I'm aware, this version is standard PPC usage. Another instance of the same kind of thing would be a sentence like:

          "I've got a lot of experience in Labyrinth fic."

          Or even,

          "I'll happily take on Labyrinth fic."

          In general (at least when written by me!) PPC agents tend to drop the 'a' or 'any' before, or the plural after, a '[canon] fic' mention. So '[a/any] Labyrinth fic[s]' just becomes 'Labyrinth fic'.

          Both of which words no longer look like words after this post...

          hS

    • Short story contribution. by Cassie on 2013-09-06 21:48:00 UTC Link to this

      There was a very hesitant knock at the door to RC #583. No sound came from within, but the door opened anyway, revealing a darkened room lit only by a projection lamp that was currently displaying a pattern of stars. The person who had been knocking entered; it was a small, young woman with a mass of curly red hair and a very anxious expression.

      "Kelvin?"

      "I'm busy, Lyra."

      She sighed, peering at the tall figure sprawled on his bed at the far side of the room. "No, you're not. I can see you, even with the light off."

      "I'm thinking, and not in the mood for an argument." The dark-haired elf's tone was brittle with anger and unhappiness.

      Lyra Mackenzie rolled her eyes and switched the light on, giving her partner a stern look. "At least try to be nice? I'm not looking for an argument either, you know."

      The only response was something that sounded like Sindarin, but the tone made it clear that the actual comment was rather vulgar; she knew bits of the language after four years of working with him, but she'd never heard that phrase before, and her translator had clearly decided it wasn't about to help.

      "Sod you too," she said mildly. She knew why he was upset, after all, so she was doing her best not to be offended, even if it did mean controlling her temper much more tightly than usual. "Look, I found -"

      He sat up and fixed her with a glare. "I really do not want to talk right now."

      "Well, tough, because I do." She pulled a little jewellery box out of her bag and offered it to him. "Like I was saying, I found this at one of the jewellery shops."

      "...What is it?" Now Kelvin was giving her a dubious look. It was wholly out of character for her to give him anything.

      The small girl couldn't help a rather self-satisfied grin. "Take a look and find out."

      Rather hesitantly, he did as bidden... and for once, she had the satisfaction of seeing him look truly stunned as he held up the box's contents. "Where did you find this? We thought it was lost for good!"

      "At one of the jewellery shops, like I said. Someone came in and sold it to them, I don't think they knew what it was really worth -"

      She was cut off as Kelvin unexpectedly hugged her tightly, laughing with relief. "Stars above, Lyra, thank you," he managed hoarsely after a moment. "I never thought we'd see it again, Cassie's going to be so glad..."

      She hugged back, a bit awkwardly, before escaping and smoothing down her trousers. It felt rather nice, she noted absently, to see him looking that happy. "Well, just tell her to keep a better eye on it in future," she said, nodding to the necklace - an oval-cut blue-tinged diamond pendant set in truesilver - and shrugging a little. "If she's going to keep a wedding present that valuable..."

      "I know." He smiled broadly, his former mood quite vanished. "I'll see if Mazarun has any ideas - a spell or something. But I'd best go and give this to her now."

      "...Okay." Lyra's smile dropped a little at the mention of the drow who'd become Kelvin's closest friend; Mazarun had always creeped her out. "See you later. Get cracking before the console goes off."

      He chuckled, tucked the box into his tunic, and slipped out with another murmured thanks.

      • Concrit! by Huinesoron on 2013-09-09 15:01:00 UTC Link to this

        I actually have a slight problem with your opening line. It switches between a POV inside and outside the RC. I'll try and clarify that by bolding the stuff that feels like we're inside, and italicising what feels like we're outside:

        There was a very hesitant knock at the door to RC #583. No sound came from within, but the door opened anyway, revealing a darkened room lit only by a projection lamp that was currently displaying a pattern of stars. The person who had been knocking entered...

        'We' don't know who's knocking, suggesting we're on the other side of the door to them. Then we're outside, listening to 'no sound'. Then the door opens, presumably by way of the unseen knocker. Then we, from outside, see the room for the first time. Then, inside, we see the knocker come in...

        But, that said, I can find nothing to complain about in the rest of the story (except the capital W in '... What is it?'). You do a good job of conveying the shifts in mood as the story progresses, and (in contrast to my last entry!) keep your characters physically present, rather than turning them into talking heads. And the pendant sounds quite pretty - is that truesilver as in mithril, or some other metal by the same name?

        Oh, actually, one more thing! Lyra is a 'young woman' when she comes in, but halfway down she's a 'small girl'. Yes, technically that second description is accurate - but it feels like 'child', not 'tiny'. In this context, either 'petite' or simply 'short' might work better. Or, if she is as young as it implies, turn her into a 'young' or 'teenaged' girl at her introduction.

        hS

        • Thanks! :) by Cassie on 2013-09-09 20:44:00 UTC Link to this

          I knew those first few sentences weren't quite right, but this is what happens when I don't get beta-readers in before I post something. :P

          And yes, it's kind of difficult deciding what descriptions to use with Lyra - she's twenty, but her maturity level isn't level, really, she's had to forcibly grow up a bit whilst in HQ, but she arrived as a spoilt brat and regresses on occasion. I'll work on that.

          I'm glad the rest of the piece is good, though! :D And yes, the necklace is mithril - the diamond came from Faerun, Kelvin's friend Mazarun gave it to him, and Kel decided to go to Middle-earth to get it made into the pendant, because he doesn't do half measures when it comes to special gifts. :p

  • The Importance of Being Earnest Punctuation by the Irish Samurai on 2013-09-06 19:21:00 UTC Link to this

    I remembered reading this in one of the 'how to write' books I own, and looked it up again because I want to try and do something similar in a forthcoming mission. It's amazing how much a bit of punctuation can change the meaning of a sentence (well, I say that - I guess in many ways, that's actually what punctuation is there for).

    Anyway, I thought this was brilliant, so figured I'd share it.

    Take the following examples. They both use identical wordings, but the sentiments expressed are... somewhat different.

    Version the first:

    Dear John,

    I want a man who knows what love is all about. You are kind, generous, and thoughtful. People who are not like you admit to being useless and inferior. You have ruined me for other men. I yearn for you. I have no feelings whatsoever when we’re apart. I can be forever happy.

    Will you let me be yours?

    Gloria



    Version the second:

    Dear John,

    I want a man who knows what love is. All about you are kind, generous and thoughtful people, who are not like you. Admit to being useless and inferior. You have ruined me. For other men, I yearn. For you, I have no feelings whatsoever. When we’re apart, I can be forever happy.

    Will you let me be?

    Yours,

    Gloria



    Anyone else got any examples of this kind of thing they want to share? I figure there must be plenty of times in badfic where the meaning of a sentence gets unintentionally changed.

    • There was one that I found funny... by Ailavyn Siniyash on 2013-09-10 03:19:00 UTC Link to this

      ...on the wall of my seventh grade humanities classroom --

      "Let's eat, Grandpa!"

      could become

      "Let's eat Grandpa!"

      if the comma is left out.

      -Aila

    • The Oxford comma (and why I'm a fan). by Neshomeh on 2013-09-09 18:36:00 UTC Link to this

      In case anyone's not aware, the Oxford comma (or serial comma) is the one that goes before the final "and" in a list, such as "Spam, eggs, sausage, and spam." It's preferred in most (though not all) American usage because it can prevent the kind of ambiguity under discussion in this thread. For instance, there's a huge difference in meaning between the following lines:

      * This book is dedicated to my roommates, Nicole Kidman, and God.

      * This book is dedicated to my roommates, Nicole Kidman and God.

      Without the Oxford comma, it seems this author had some very interesting roommates!


      Here's a MILDLY NSFW illustrated example I've seen floating around:


      [Save yourself if you're somewhere you could be embarrassed!]


      [Are you sure you want to scroll down?]


      [Really really sure?]


      [Okay, go on then.]


      http://cdn.thegloss.com/files/2011/09/jfk.jpg

      So basically, my feeling is this: if you're making a list, using the Oxford comma can't damage your meaning, but leaving it out can. The Oxford comma: better safe than sorry!

      ~Neshomeh

      • Argh, yes, this. by VixenMage on 2013-09-10 09:46:00 UTC Link to this

        I've never honestly understood why anyone argues against the Oxford comma. It's so useful! There's no reason I can see to get rid of it.

        But, unfortunately... Associated Press Style doesn't use it. Or at least, the copy-editing class I took last quarter took points off for using it, and cited the AP Stylebook. Which means that I am going to develop a nasty twitch while editing articles this quarter.

        • But we'll never get those pixels back! by Huinesoron on 2013-09-10 16:09:00 UTC Link to this

          No, all right, sorry, I'll be serious.

          ...

          ...

          ...

          ... no I won't.

          Erm, right. The Oxford Comma is useful in the event of a list where the latter items look like they could be a description of the former - so 'I went to work for two ducks, Roderick and Clement' is unclear as to whether those are the names of the ducks, whereas 'two ducks, Roderick, and Clement' indicates clearly that your place of employment has a very strange management system. Of course, in this case, you could simply restructure the sentence - 'Roderick, Clement, and two ducks' - which resolves the ambiguity just as well. It also works around the problem that if I discuss 'two ducks, Roderick and Clement', you don't know if I'm simply failing to use the Oxford Comma, or actually discussing the named waterfowl. Abandoning the OC in favour of restructuring removes that ambiguity.

          (Actually the best thing is to use either 'Roderick, Clement[,] and two ducks' or 'two ducks named Roderick and Clement' to remove all possible ambiguity)

          There are other cases where the OC does absolutely nothing, because the ambiguity never existed. 'My parents were a hamster, an elderberry bush, and a giant wooden rabbit' works either way, unless you assume that a hamster can be 'an elderberry bush and a giant wooden rabbit', in which case, head down to FicPsych immediately.

          Then, as Wikipedia is telling me, there are cases where the OC fails to resolve ambiguity. 'In the lands far to the north dwell Noggin the Nog, a cormorant and a knave'. Well, we know Noggin isn't a knave (he's a king), so let's put that Oxford Comma back! '...Noggin the Nog, a cormorant, and a knave'. Great! So, er, is Noggin a cormorant? (Answer: No, that's Graculus).

          Again, in this case restructuring is the answer. We can't say 'a cormorant, Noggin the Nog, and a knave', because that could still imply poor Noggin is a bird. 'a cormorant, Noggin the Nog and a knave' is actually clearer in this instance, because you'd never use that structure to discuss the knavish cormorant Noggin. But in the end, the best structure is probably 'a cormorant, a knave, and Noggin the Nog' - which works exactly the same with or without the OC.

          (And the final variant, with two names and one possible descriptor - 'I rode into Chippenham with Count Dracula, Marie Curie and the King of England'. Again, the OC is irrelevant - but put His Majesty anywhere else in that sentence, and you're making an... interesting political statement)

          (And England doesn't have a king right now. Honestly, what are you like?)

          hS

          "In the lands of the North, where the Black Rocks stand guard against the cold sea, in the dark night that is very long, the Men of the Northlands sit by their great log fires, and they tell a tale..."

    • Here's a good one. by KittyEden on 2013-09-07 08:19:00 UTC Link to this

      Sophie walked on her head a little higher than usual.
      Beware teachers when parking.

      • Those just seem like non sequiturs either way. by Outhra on 2013-09-07 16:54:00 UTC Link to this

        Also, this sort of thing doesn't really work if you don't provide the alternate punctuation yourself. There are exceptions if punctuation error is apparent, like in the example with the talking panda a little earlier, but those two fit neither case, and so are just confusing.
        Was there supposed to be a colon somewhere? Commas? A little more detail will be required for these to make sense.

        • Providing punctuation by Hieronymus Graubart on 2013-09-07 19:36:00 UTC Link to this

          Sophie walked on, her head a little higher than usual.
          This is what the author probably intended to say, although I’m not sure whether it is good grammar.

          Sophie walked on her head, a little higher than usual.
          I’m pretty sure that the agents would see this, but I cannot quite imagine how it looks like.

          I don’t know what to do with
          Beware
          teachers
          when
          parking

          Is it a sign on a schoolyard, telling me that I shouldn’t knock over teachers when I park my car? Do you use punctuation on traffic signs? Where should the punctuation go and what should it be?

          • Beware, teachers, when parking. (nm) by World-Jumper on 2013-09-07 20:30:00 UTC Link to this
            • What would the alternate punctuation be, then? by Outhra on 2013-09-07 21:07:00 UTC Link to this

              The only one I could figure out was "Beware: teachers when parking." but that makes no sense. People don't just become teachers as they park. How would that change them from what they were before they became teachers? Would the people parking suddenly start coming up with lesson plans, and then forget about them as they get out of the car? Or will the teacher-effects become permanent, and they would suddenly get a job teaching a tenth-grade geometry class, apropos of nothing? That sounds like the plot for an episode of a particularly desperate sitcom more than something that would be printed on a sign, or wherever that sentence would be showing up.

              I'm not very good with word puzzles, though, so the answer will probably be obvious in retrospect. Then again, most things are.

            • Another Way? by QuietHiker on 2013-09-07 20:58:00 UTC Link to this

              I was just thinking that perhaps there could be 3 ways to interpret "Beware teachers when parking," though I may have messed up the grammar…

              Beware, teachers, when parking. (Telling the teachers to be careful)
              Beware teachers when [you are] parking. (Telling the drivers not to hit teachers)
              Beware teachers when [they are] parking. (Perhaps the teachers are bad at parking and tend to crash into things.)

              I think that sentence just needs more detail or to be in context.


              Grammar is a wondrous thing.

              • So, it was supposed to have more words than it did? by Outhra on 2013-09-07 21:22:00 UTC Link to this

                Was that what was going on all this time? It makes a little more sense, but the way the sentences were presented in the original post seems to indicate that all that was needed was the provided text, and everything else was punctuation. Perhaps I'm thinking about this in the wrong direction.

                Well, at least that sentence was a good proponent of the "grammar is important" lesson the thread was created for, so points to that.

                • Not that I know ofÂ… by QuietHiker on 2013-09-07 21:54:00 UTC Link to this

                  I think you were supposed to just add punctuation. I was just looking at how it could sort of make sense with no punctuation and added the words in brackets to show what I meant. On the other hand, that did ignore the point of the thread.

                  That was a very confusing sentence, and I'm not sure if grammar was its only problem, or if it was aimed at the teachers and it should have simply had the commas.

                  I don't think there's such thing as wrong direction of thought.

      • ? (nm) by son_of_heaven176 on 2013-09-07 15:47:00 UTC Link to this
    • Re: The Importance of Being Earnest Punctuation by son_of_heaven176 on 2013-09-06 22:26:00 UTC Link to this

      I remember a story about punctuation that I saw when I was in Law Review:

      A teacher wrote these words on the board

      Woman without her man is nothing

      and asked her class to punctuate the sentence.

      All the males punctuated it thus: Woman, without her man, is nothing.

      All the females punctuated it thus: Woman: without her, man is nothing.

      Punctuation matters!

      • Well, there's surely more versions than that! by Huinesoron on 2013-09-09 15:51:00 UTC Link to this

        For one, I can think of:

        Woman without - her man is nothing

        Or in other words:

        A woman is outside - her boyfriend/husband is insignificant

        And, of course, using that version we can render the whole sentence algebraically in far fewer words, without making a statement about which of the two original versions is 'correct':

        ♀ [♀'s ♂] = 0

        hS, fun with fake maths!

    • Re: The Importance of Being Earnest Punctuation by Artemis on 2013-09-06 20:47:00 UTC Link to this

      I've heard of a rather amusing one where a panda walks into a restaurant, gets dinner, pulls out a gun and shoots the ceiling, then walks out. He returns the next day and the waitress asks him why he did it.
      He holds up a book about pandas and says: "Well, this book says we eat, shoots, and leaves."

  • Debate Time! *yay* by dramaticsoprano on 2013-09-06 23:21:00 UTC Link to this

    Who do you think would win in a fight to the death? Starscream from the G1 "Transformers" or Thor from "Thor: God of Thunder"?

    Rules For The Debate:
    1.Please give specific details to back up your argument. Do not say "Because he's more awesome" or other such things because they don't mean anything and are not convincing enough evidence. I want good and reasonable arguments here.

    2.Make note of their various weapons, abilities, and their temperaments.

    3.Please, no name-calling, curses, damnations, etc. I want this to be civil.

    • No contest by World-Jumper on 2013-09-07 08:36:00 UTC Link to this

      Thor, beyond a shadow of a doubt. However, I am getting way, way ahead of myself. Before we get too far into 'who would win in a death battle,' we have to know what each one brings to the table as far as combat goes.

      While I have seen Thor, I have not seen much of g1 Transformers (not even a full episode), so most of my Starscream knowledge has to come from somebody else. It just so happens that the information I am using comes from Death Battle, the episode where g1 Starscream fought against g4 Rainbow Dash, from My Little Pony, Friendship is Magic. and got crushed like a tin can He fought well, and provided the data I need for my argument. It also happens that Thor was also involved in a Death Battle, this time against Raiden from Mortal Combat. For the sake of being fair, I will use most of the points they raised in that battle for support, including his weaknesses, though most of my argument comes from the movies.

      Let's start with Starscream, and run down his armor, weapons, and skill.
      Starscream comes in two forms: F-15 Eagle fighter jet, and giant-frickin-robot. In his land based form, Starscream comes with an assortment of weapons, including:
      Cluster bombs
      Missiles
      Machine guns
      Some laser guns
      Null-Ray: The Null-Ray focuses energy into a contained blast to shut down anything that runs on electricity. (How he did not manage to take over the Decepticons with this thing alone baffles me, but that's unimportant)
      As a jet, his weaponry includes:
      AIM homing missiles
      -7F/M Sparrows
      -120 AMRAAM Slammers
      -9L/M Sidewinders
      M61A1 Vulcan gatling gun
      I have little idea of what these truly are, but from what I have gleamed, the three missiles are basically different ranges. In order as presented above: Mid-range, long-range, short-range. The gatling gun shoots really, really fast. It's rather good. Not much else to say on it.

      Starscream can fly, either over short distances in his robot form, or long-ranges in his jet form. As a jet, he can fly at top speeds of Mach 2.5+ or 1,650+ mph.

      Starscream likes to think of himself as a strategist, though several of his plans fail. Miserably. Despite this, he does have a way with words, and manages to be just competent enough to stay as one of the higher-ranking officials. He is fond of stabbing people in the back and utilizing the element of surprise. That said, he is also headstrong, so his idea of 'surprise' is often "charge in front of the enemy, fein damage and inhabitation, then shoot them when they least expect it." This makes his Null-Ray more effective, as it seems to work best at close distances. This may be because Starscream is a horrid shot. There is a reason his missiles are tracking.

      Now let's cover Thor.
      Thor is the Norse god of thunder, giving him mastery over storms and lightning. His weaponry includes:
      Lightning bolts
      Thunder blasts
      Vortexes
      Storms
      Mjolnir

      Mjolnir is Thor's signature weapon. This one handed hammer, forged by the dwarves as an ultimate gift, can perform a variety of attacks. When the dwarves gave the hammer to Thor, they described it as such: "Thor might smite as hard as he desired, whatsoever might be before him, and the hammer would not fail; and if he threw it at anything, it would never miss, and never fly so far as not to return to his hand; and if be desired, he might keep it in his sark, it was so small; but indeed it was a flaw in the hammer that the fore-haft was somewhat short." Beyond these powers, it seems to be a conduit for Thor's energy. He can send lightning bolts out of the head, call forth his armor, and even fly after spinning the hammer in his hand really fast. It has also been known in the comics to control electro-magnetic fields, though this ability has not been shown in the movies yet.

      Thor is a mountain of a man, as well as a god. His skin is neigh invulnerable, though he can be damaged if enough force is applied. Thor has had numerous fights with the Hulk, one of the strongest and hardest hitting things in the universe, and has escaped with only a few bruises. Even though his hammer carries most of his strength inside of it, Thor is no weakling himself. He among the strongest of the Asgardians, and as stated before, has traded blows with the Hulk, one of the few beings that can be stronger then him.

      So, now it comes down to this. Who would win? As I said in the beginning, Thor would not only win, but annihilate Starscream.

      Starscream's best weapon, the Null-Ray, is completely useless against organic beings, which Thor is. The rest of his arsenal, while it may be able to damage Thor if he concentrated almost all of his firepower onto the god at once, but even then it seems unlikely. Starscream's best chance is to grab Thor in a bear hug and transform into a jet as soon as he could, crushing Thor in the process. Of corse, that would probably only allow the god to rip him apart from the inside.

      Thor on the other hand has a much greater offensive capability. All electrical systems can be overpowered, and several bolts of lightning should overcharge any robot, no matter how advanced their technology is. Should Starscream attempt to fly away, Thor could easily catch up to him, using his hammer to fly up to the jet. Once close enough to Starscream to hit, Mjolnir would be more then strong enough to tear right through him. In fact, Thor does not even need to be close to hit, as he has shown remarkable throwing capabilities with his hammer. Finaly, should Starscream manage to fly far enough away that Thor could not catch him, the god of thunder could call in a vortex to rip Starscream's body apart with lightning and extraordinarily heavy wind.

      The winner is Thor.

      • I think you've missed a key point. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-09 15:25:00 UTC Link to this

        Ignore virtually everything about the two, and just consider the implications of Mjolnir. It's a hammer which cannot be lifted by anything other than Thor. That's been shown[Citation Needed] to include the Hulk.

        The battle goes something like this:

        -Thor, being smaller and thus more maneuverable, gets above Starscream.
        -Thor drops Mjolnir on Starscream, pinning or pushing Starscream to the ground.
        -Thor hits the grounded Starscream with lightning until he's dead.

        The key point is that, unlike the people-sized things Thor usually fights, Starscream has large flat areas. That means Mjolnir won't slide off or anything. And a stationary target is more correctly known as target practice.

        (Also, if this isn't how it works - like if Thor dropped Mjolnir while on the Helicarrier or something and didn't thereby tear a hole through it/smash it to the ground - that's stupid and Marvel haven't thought the physics through. I know, I know, crazy notion...)

        hS

        • Some peripheral physics wank. by AdmiralSakai on 2013-09-09 21:22:00 UTC Link to this

          I'm not terribly familiar with Thor lore (Norse or Marvel versions), but I sort of thought of "cannot be lifted by anyone other than Thor" as more a security "device" that prevents it from being picked up by people. Inanimate objects can support just fine, although it probably really is quite heavy. (Although what the hammer classifies as an inanimate object (like, I don't know, giant transforming robots) is an interesting discussion to have!).

          Another possibility is that the hammer really can only be LIFTED by Thor. That is, only Thor can increase its altitude (technically, only Thor can increase the magnitude of its vector in the direction opposite that of the gravitational field at that point). Other objects or people can move it laterally, or control or stop its descent just fine, but they just can't make it RISE. Although, once again, it is probably still quite heavy regardless.


          Both of these interpretations involve a lot of "exact words"ing, but given that the hammer's properties are pretty much magical in nature, this doesn't seem unreasonable. There has to be SOME limit on its liftability.... otherwise, if Thor ever dropped it, it would tunnel directly to the core of the planet!

          As for the hammer being made of neutronium, I'd say it's possible, but unlikely without magic. We don't really have very good models of what that kind of density would DO when brought into a terrestrial environment.

          • I think it is more akin to a security feature. by Outhra on 2013-09-10 16:50:00 UTC Link to this

            Thor's hammer has an incantation of some sort on it that prevents it from being picked up by anyone save those who are deemed worthy or honorable enough to wield it, suggesting that the hammer has some capacity to scan minds and judge people by its near-unattainably high standards. In the comics, there have been a few others that have been seen by Mjolnir as worthy to bear it, and then those individuals can carry it around with one hand the way Thor does.

            Mjolnir tends to blow a huge hole in the ground whenever Thor drops it while flying, though, so it is still crazy heavy, but someone with a Decepticon's level of strength should be able to move out from under it. Starscream couldn't grab the hammer and throw it off of him, since that would count as using the hammer, which might also preclude pushing it with his hands and feet, but he should be able to tilt himself so it slides off, or activate his jet thrusters and then flip over, causing the hammer to fall off of him and land on the ground below.

            As for whether it was made of a neutron star(warning: this is probably going to come across as a huge nitpick to some people), the stars in Norse mythology were actually fragments of a planet-sized primordial giant named Ymir, set on fire with unending flame in a world composed almost entirely of lava and other high-temperature substances, and then hung on the inside of the night sky, a.k.a. Ymir's skull, which had recently been set over the world by the Aesir as part of their celebration for killing the world-giant.
            A "dying star" in that context would still be very dense and strong, since it was made out of divine biomass, but it wouldn't be neutronium.

        • That is a really good point. by dramaticsoprano on 2013-09-09 20:37:00 UTC Link to this

          I don't know why I didn't think of that myself. I saw the Thor vs. Raiden "Death Battle" video yesterday, and I found out that according the Norse legends, Mjolnir was made from the remains of a dying star. That star would have been a neutron star, and that could weigh up to one million tons! No wonder the Hulk would not able to lift it!

      • The Game is Called "Mortal Kombat" (nm) by dramaticsoprano on 2013-09-07 22:10:00 UTC Link to this
        • Sorry, remembered the name, forgot the spelling. My bad. (nm) by World-Jumper on 2013-09-07 22:20:00 UTC Link to this
      • Technical note by Techno-Dann on 2013-09-07 18:28:00 UTC Link to this

        Airplanes don't much mind getting hit by lightning. It happens on a regular basis (about once a year in the US alone). The last serious accident caused by lightning strike was in 1967, and airplane lightning protection systems have been completely redesigned since then - including the ones that protect the F-15 Eagle.

        That said, I agree with your analysis completely.

        • Point about the lightning, here. by Legacy on 2013-09-07 19:50:00 UTC Link to this

          In the Avengers movie, Thor's lightning is show to be powerful enough to melt holes in Iron Man's armor. While the Iron Man suit is repeatedly torn to shreds in all it's appearances so far, it's made out of super-strong alloys and capable of withstanding a direct hit from a tank. Also, this is Tony Stark we're talking about here, who would likely include every defense against the elements he possibly could (including updated lightning protection).

          Thus, Thor's lightning is far hotter than the explosion of a tank shell, and would likely do at least some damage. There you go.

          Sorry for the run-on sentences.

          • I don't think it was that version of Thor, though. by Outhra on 2013-09-07 20:55:00 UTC Link to this

            The Avengers movieverse version of Thor is different from the comics version of Thor, and the two Thors may not have the exact same capabilities and levels of power for the capabilities that they share.
            I say it "may not" be the same Thor because a quick Google search told me that "Thor: God of Thunder", the Thor incarnation that the first post said the fight was dealing with, was a MARVEL NOW! comic series, which would make it the comics' Thor, or at least a comics' Thor. Yet, the same title is also given to the Thor movie licensed video game, which would presumably use the same Thor or at least one with the same combat potential as the Marvel Cinematic Universe Thor, which would mean that your point would unequivocally apply.
            Canon apocrypha can be difficult.

            Basically, you've got to have consistent universe framing for this sort of fight speculation. Starscream G1, Unicron Trilogy Starscream, and Transformers Animated Starscream have different abilities and levels of power, so treating them all as "Starscream" would keep the potentials from being objective, so it should be the same with "Thor".
            Transformers Animated Starscream might even be able to take certain versions of Thor on, since the Allspark fragment embedded in his head gives him enhanced powers (also, the head apparently becomes indestructible, but that's a minor detail) and blasts from his weapons are capable of ripping apart buildings, which makes him much more powerful than the G1 Starscream, who as World-Jumper said, really only had the Null-ray going for him aside from the traditional plane-caliber missiles that most Thors would probably just be knocked back a few meters by.

  • Artemis Fowl BADfic by KittyEden on 2013-09-08 13:35:00 UTC Link to this

    www.fanfiction.net/9666932/1/
    I honestly started crying when I read this. The chaptrs are only about 50 words each, there's barely any punctuation to be seen, and it's cliché.

    • Re: Artemis Fowl BADfic by Artemis on 2013-09-09 23:57:00 UTC Link to this

      BAM. 'A special thank you to arty97, thanks for the tips.' It looks a lot better. Not up to standards, but at least you can understand it now. Semi- success is better than nothing.

    • *SniffSniff* by AW on 2013-09-09 03:56:00 UTC Link to this

      Smells funny. You sure it's not a troll?

      • Re: *SniffSniff* by AdmiralSakai on 2013-09-09 20:43:00 UTC Link to this

        I'd guess no, but I'm not sure. The train-and-volcanoes plan has the sort of hyperbole common in trollfics, but the rest of it is just pure insanity that's very hard to replicate- even the legendary Squirrelking was more comprehensible than this. You'd think that if a troll came up with something as mindbendingly stupid as the drill plan, (s)he'd at least want to make sure the reader knew what it was.

        • Re: *SniffSniff* by AW on 2013-09-09 21:52:00 UTC Link to this

          Not necessarily.

          A troll's main goal is to get reactions out of people. That's it.

          It's to get flames. It's to get flack. To get praise. To attract other trolls.

          At least, that's my past experience of troll and troll activities.

    • ??!!?!!!?!!!?!?!?!? by AdmiralSakai on 2013-09-08 21:34:00 UTC Link to this

      Artemis Fowl pretty much singlehandedly set me on the path to mad science. I still have every book in readable condition save the first, which I have been pursuing for literally YEARS. I feel like this 'fic would have sent me into a blind rage if I could just figure out what any of it meant!

      I mean, I get the broad strokes, that there's this OC brother and Juliet is involved in some kind of angst and Geovanni Zito is somehow evil and trying to drill down into the core, but other than that...

      • Re: ??!!?!!!?!!!?!?!?!? by son_of_heaven176 on 2013-09-08 22:38:00 UTC Link to this

        Your subject hit it right on the money. Even skimming through the "chapters," I can see that this fic needs a LOT of help. Can someone with some amount of patience send some concrit his way? This fic was LITERALLY posted yesterday, and there are no reviews, so I am willing to bet at this point that it would do the author some good for someone took the time to slow him down and give him some pointers.

        • Re: ??!!?!!!?!!!?!?!?!? by Artemis on 2013-09-09 03:55:00 UTC Link to this

          Did so. It's my first time, so please tell me if I messed up on anything. Bluh. That story kind of hurts me inside. I got my name from Artemis Fowl. I grew up on it.

          • Sounds good to me by son_of_heaven176 on 2013-09-09 04:11:00 UTC Link to this

            but I'd like to see what other people think of your review as well.

        • Re: ??!!?!!!?!!!?!?!?!? by AdmiralSakai on 2013-09-08 22:49:00 UTC Link to this

          I would, but I'm not sure how to do it without sounding reeeeely condescending.

    • Summary by QuietHiker on 2013-09-08 20:18:00 UTC Link to this

      Wow, that story (the first one, I mean) is awful.
      However, does anyone else think that the summary is surprisingly good, at least compared to the story?

      • Considering that the story is incomprehensible... by Outhra on 2013-09-08 23:08:00 UTC Link to this

        You are right in that case. Despite the mess of a sentence that is "Plus Danso finds love, will he in to puberty or will he defeat it and the drill once and for all.", I can at least tell what the summary is trying to go for. Kind of.

        But, seriously, what is going on here? Apparently "Danso Fowl Juillet" is trying to stop a drill from going to the core of "thyne earth"(thine Earth?) because Julius Root doesn't like fairies any more for a reason that was never explained... and someone named Zito is involved and was somehow able to land a jet without being present, but only after filling it with his bodyguards, which would be pointless if he isn't going to be in the helicopter... but he was actually planning something the next floor down so the helicopter's entire presence is pointless... and his plan was that he wants to make the world's fastest train by cutting through the core of the planet with a laser, and also kill people with a volcano? And then all of a sudden, out of nowhere, Mulch Diggums and Holly Short are there, and do nothing of note before the story just stops.
        I give up. I have no idea why anything is anywhere, and why anything is happening to anyone.

        On another note, if I just drastically misread the plan-describing sentences, which is entirely possible, and Zito's actual end goal is to create trains that are powered by volcanic eruptions, and then run over all of his buisiness rivals with them, he may have created the most blindingly idiotic plan in the history of fanfiction.

        • Volcano trains by Very jaunty object on 2013-09-09 02:47:00 UTC Link to this

          Perhaps the trains are figurative. Geothermal powered widespread transportation will run OOC Zito's rivals out of business. That, or I'm just trying to rationalize things. Does anyone feel that this fic may have been written by an overeager young fangirl/boy who isn't remotely aware of the plot of Artemis Fowl?

        • Re: Considering that the story is incomprehensible... by AdmiralSakai on 2013-09-09 02:13:00 UTC Link to this

          I think that Giovanni Zito*'s plan is to drill into the core in order to spark volcanic eruptions that will destroy his enemies. The "train tunnel through the center of the Earth" thing is a cover story for that plan. How he plans to direct the volcanoes to his enemies, who his enemies are, and why he drills one big hole into the core instead of a bunch of little holes into the lithosphere are anyone's guess.

          *In case you don't know, Zito is a famous philanthropist/environmentalist who showed up in AF canon. He was involved in an antagonist's plan to drill a hole into the fairy outpost in the Earth's core and expose it to humans, but was under fairy mind control the entire time. Once his free will was restored, he kind of dropped off the map, but one line later on mentioned that he and Artemis Fowl are on speaking terms.

    • Since we're talking about AF badfics here... by Desdendelle on 2013-09-08 19:43:00 UTC Link to this

      Time is your Friend, Dont you believe me?[sic], by strikeIWSP, rated T. Artemis Fowl x Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha.
      what if Artemis knew more about the fairy's then he was supposed to, long before he actually had any plans to kidnap one. crossover,Nanoha-s. Some swearing so T just in case. on hold may continue sooner if their are comments.

      Well... first of all, it's script!fic. Second, bad SPaG. Third, OOC characters all over the place. Fourth, Artemis gets a stupid Device for no reason. Bah. Also, it's beiger than sepia.
      (PS: I've found this ages ago and it's already in the Unclaimed Badfic page, in case you're wondering.)

    • You may have to fix the link to that. (nm) by Very jaunty object on 2013-09-08 13:47:00 UTC Link to this
      • Fixed link by Ponystar17 on 2013-09-08 19:06:00 UTC Link to this

        http://www.fanfiction.net/s/9666932/1/ is the fixed link. Also, wow. That's bad.

  • A plug by Phobos on 2013-09-08 19:30:00 UTC Link to this

    As some of you know, I have been working on my own future story for the PPC. It made its first appearance two months ago during the Monthly Writing Challenge with the short story "Catastrophe Theory: Bound and Gagged". Well, I have been hard at work finishing up part one of the main story and it is finally time to unveil it.

    I give you: "Catastrophe Theory: The End Is Nigh!"

    The future ain't what it used to be.

    -Phobos

    • Ouchie. This quite of a bad future. by Sergio Turbo on 2013-09-16 21:54:00 UTC Link to this

      And you killed off Corolla.

      Now, both Sergio and Nikki aren't in the PPC anymore by then, but I guess they would discover what happened anyway (If Sues didn't attack where they are, that is) but ooh, boy. They're gonna to be pissed off.

      The fact is...

      SPOILERS

      Sergio is a Stu who more or less reformed on his own... and suffered the loss of several friends already. Suffering some more at the hands of Sues, especially after he retired... it's snapping time, especially if the Sues somehow manage to get Nikki too.

      And if he snaps, it will be something along the lines to wear a black cloak, a Crysis-verse nanosuit and a Just Cause-verse grappling hook, dual wield a lightsaber and a Patriot from Metal Gear-verse, and allow a Sueness relapse... in order to fight the Sues with their very own methods. 'Cause by then he would be enough insane to make such a thing work.

      "If only a Sue is strong enough to kill another Sue... Then I will become one to kill them all."

      • You are correct. by Phobos on 2013-09-17 03:58:00 UTC Link to this

        That is a bad future. It is, in fact, the worst that I thought I could get away with in the PPC.

        I like your idea about Sergio purposefully relapsing to get revenge. I think it fits in really well with the world I've laid out here. I honestly don't know where Sergio and Nikki are in this future. They may be dead, or Sued. Or, they may have gotten out before the initial invasion and subsequent occupation. If that is the case, they very probably can't get back in. They might fight the Sues in the Word Worlds looking for a way in, or just to do what damage they can.

        That is up to your imagination.

        -Phobos

    • All the obvious comments have already been made by Tomash on 2013-09-15 06:02:00 UTC Link to this

      , so I just wanted to say that this was great.

      • Thanks, Tomash (nm) by Phobos on 2013-09-15 16:34:00 UTC Link to this
        • You're welcome (nm) (nm) by Tomash on 2013-09-15 18:16:00 UTC Link to this
    • I just discovered your source! by Huinesoron on 2013-09-11 13:12:00 UTC Link to this

      Oh, you thought we wouldn't find out, didn't you? You thought your secret plagiarism was safe? But no! We see all! Behold!

      Time Compression

      Yes, you, Phobos, have been filthily plagiarising from the writing genius known as 'Patron PPC Demi-Goddess', one of the most famous writers of FanficLand! The ideas are all there for everyone to see: a character in the future of the PPC, HQ wrecked, the Sues taking over, someone being sent back in time... oh yes, your secret is will and truly out.

      hS

      (Yes, I'm joking. ;) It's an entry to the Badfic Game from back in 2006, I don't really think you've plagiarised it. Although if the, uh, 'Sunclover' shows up in your story... ~hS)

      • Interesting by Phobos on 2013-09-11 16:35:00 UTC Link to this

        Yep. You caught me. I stole it all from the Badfic Game. I never expected anyone to look there. But I've been caught. Whatever shall I do?

        Nah, I was actually unaware that 'Patron PPC Demi-Goddess' had written such a story. If I'd known, I definitely wouldn't have made mine so similar. Just look at these two sections:

        From CT: The halls of HQ had seen better days. Walls were crumbling and covered in Suvian graffiti. Doors lay broken on the floor, if they were there at all. Piles of debris littered the hallways. Sparks shot intermittently from breaches in the Generic Surface. There were occasional stains on the floors and walls, in a variety of colors and levels of sparkle, that were best not to speculate about.

        From TC: Things were looking bleak now. What once was had been reduced into a mockery of a head quarters. There wasn’t a place where you stepped that was not covered with something. Blood. Fertilizer. Debris and sliced wires, lost limbs and poured guts. Sparks were flying out every once in a while from the wires that were hanging loose from the ceiling. Broken glass and plaster crunched underfoot.


        Really similar stuff. Eerily similar, you might say. I mean, did you notice the abbreviations? CT and TC? I smell a conspiracy.

        Actually, I imagine they had some of the same inspirations that I did. There's nothing inherent in the setting that is new and different, after all. Pretty standard for a post-apocalyptic future. The big difference is, I think, in the fact that they (GreyLadyBast, I assume?) were attempting to write Badfic (should I worry that my story is so similar to intentional badfic? I'm not sure).

        Anyway, interesting find, hS.

        -Phobos

        • I actually don't know who it was. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-11 16:47:00 UTC Link to this

          That's the only chapter of the only story she ever wrote, and I don't seem to have noted down her username in the source code like I tried to do. I would have assumed Bast - it was 2006, so I guess she was still around - but it could also have been whoever was behind the Dark Canine God Kit (my memory's saying Teena?), or simply someone coming up with a suitably Badficcy name. It doesn't read like Bast, at any rate.

          But yeah, 'HQ is smashed and someone should go back in time to fix it' isn't a particularly unique concept. ;) I think the reason CT feels like TC - and Triple Prime and Trousers didn't - is that you and PPDG both described the broken HQ. Part of the 'bad' in this badfic is that it was written to be UltraDarkSerious, which we try to avoid in the PPC. Any section of an actual fic which takes a dark and serious approach to something is likely to spark off similarities with something on FfL.

          hS

          • Has to be Keily. by Neshomeh on 2013-09-11 18:02:00 UTC Link to this

            Her main agent was Keily Shinra, who was a notorious Clover-luster, and Boarder!Keily was a big Flower-shipper, IIRC. I don't think anyone else would have come up with the "Sunclover."

            ~Neshomeh

            • Main problem with that... by Huinesoron on 2013-09-11 21:32:00 UTC Link to this

              ... is that Keily was Flowergirl of the HQ in that same year. I'm moderately sure we didn't have people using multiple names way back then. Hrm.

              ...

              All right. It's two hours later and I'm drowning in websites - but we can do this.

              The following 'authors' participated in 2006 and can be identified (mostly by my naming them in the source code ;)):

              Zephyr's Fire - Starwind Rohana
              Huinesoron - Huinesoron
              Flowergirl of the HQ - Keily
              Kryska the Christian - Kaitlyn
              OuRlOvEcAnTrAnScEnDtImE - Err...
              gutsygemiwrya - Twiggy
              xxPPCpRiNcEsSgUrLxx - Gillespy
              kippur - kippur

              The following wrote about or named themselves after a specific non-NPC character, and so are probably their creator:

              ErinsEvilTwin - named for Erin Mirestone, so probably Laureril
              Spufie42 - wrote about Gammut and Debris, so probably Spoofmaster - and the names match
              Janetsgurl - named for Janet of Janet and Cygna, so probably Cygna Hime

              SorceressGurl and Purple Raine both wrote about Suicide, Diocletian and Ithalond; either of them could be TungstenMonk. I'd lean more towards the latter, since Suicide was a designated Hott Man, while Ithalond wasn't.

              The following are unidentified, but wrote stories:

              SparklyStarPrincess382
              Patron PPC Demi-Goddess
              Slashforever
              Haunted Sinner

              The following only left reviews:

              kiwigurl528 - possibly gundamkiwi
              brandywine_baby89 - Neshomeh
              MistressofTheSea002 - unknown
              veetvoojagig - unknown
              Ainu Laire - unknown

              There are a handful of Wayback Machine-copied front pages from 2006, with one in May, one in September... by going through those, can you make any guesses as to who the unknowns were?

              hS

              • Uhm, wasn't around back then, but.... by Sergio Turbo on 2013-09-12 11:32:00 UTC Link to this

                Any chance "Patron PPC Demi-Goddess" could be GreyLadyBast?

                I'm laso a bit curious about Cygna Hime and her Agents, though, being the only one who did card Captor Sakura missions before I joined. Information about her Agents is very scarce, considering they don't even have their own pages and the missions were recovered by Wayback Machine or something like that.

                • From what I can see... by Huinesoron on 2013-09-12 13:44:00 UTC Link to this

                  ... via the Wayback Machine (you have to give the old Board address - disc.server.com/Indices/199610.html), Bast had already left by that time. I can't find anyone in that year who springs out at me as a candidate, either...

                  As to Cygna-hime... well, from looking at old front pages I can tell you she was a fan of both Narnia and Lord of the Rings (she uses 'Ai!' as an exclamation); that she was writing Sakura PPC in late 2005; that she was also an MSTer; that she... had political opinions (she replied positively to a post titled 'I think much better of [US Democratic Presidential Candidate] Kerry for this...', but so did Rath, who was I believe a Republican-leaning Utahn - actually, an earlier thread has her seeming to be somewhat left-wing, but this is pure conjecture); and that she was around as far back as 2004.

                  As for her agents... well, they have about two missions, plus a four-chapter badfic. You can probably at least extract character descriptions (we have a lovely badfic-y description of Cygna: 'Cygna lifted her eyes to the mirror. She looked at her wavy crimson tresses and saw a carrot-colored, frizzy horror; looked at her emerald orbs and saw pale green eyes; looked at the delicate spattering of freckles on her nose and saw a horrible disfigurement.'), but obviously the plot is irrelevant.

                  hS

                • Dang it, it's also, not laso. by Sergio Turbo on 2013-09-12 11:34:00 UTC Link to this

                  And wanting to catch some other Boarder with a lasso would be kinda rude.

    • Brilliantly written! by Cyba Zero on 2013-09-10 10:22:00 UTC Link to this

      I thoroughly enjoyed that. All these future timelines at the moment are so fun!

      I think most of the best points have already been mentioned, but I think it is very interesting to see the PPC actually lose - it shows they are just as vulnerable as any other character (and hence are not 'Sues). I also find it interesting about the 'Sues being able to forcibly convert non-'Sues - always a nasty tactic. I am thoroughly looking forward to part 2.

      One little thing - Eagrus' full name is Eagrus Khan, so this Eagrus Kahn must be mini-Agent...

      • Thank you! by Phobos on 2013-09-10 15:53:00 UTC Link to this

        The future is always a fun canvas to work with because it isn't set in stone. Who knows what any of these characters are going to look like in 10 years? I don't. I just like to play with the possibilities.

        I knew this couldn't be perfect. So, thank you for pointing out the mistake in Eagrus' name. It has been fixed.

        -Phobos

    • Ye gods, Phobos. by VixenMage on 2013-09-10 08:11:00 UTC Link to this

      This was good. Really, really good. You set the tone very well - things just feel desperate, very nearly hopeless, in a realistic and not-overdone way. Even if the POV characters aren't quite at the end of their ropes, knowing how far down this is from the PPC 'present' sets the reader in a very dark place. It's hard to fully express - the imagery and thought of HQ being so utterly destroyed, unsafe on a permanent level/timeframe is very, very unsettling. Somehow this managed to be more deeply devastating than Emergencies, or even the Crashing Down stories (though it might be that I haven't read those in too long). It's like having a dream of your childhood home (or some comparable safe space) eating you alive, or something. Especially the thing where - I don't quite know if this was intentional, though I assume it was - the hallways aren't the whimsical "don't think about your destination" sort of way they usually are. It's... bleak. And it does that job very, very well.

      Less bleakly, I look forward to a continuation! If you're doing one? Which I assume you are. Hope you are, anyway.

      I'd also managed to completely forget that you were using Jof here, but I'm glad he worked with the story, and thank you for the use and characterization and such.

      • And little fishes? by Phobos on 2013-09-10 15:41:00 UTC Link to this

        Please tell me there are little fishes!

        Anyway, I am glad you liked it. You saying that it "managed to be more deeply devastating than Emergencies" is high praise. Thank you.

        And, yeah, the distinct lack of whimsy was intentional. Everything is broken in this future.

        Don't worry, the continuation is coming. This part was all the backstory that needed to be laid out in order to write the story that I originally wanted to tell. Stay tuned...just not soon. I haven't even started writing it, yet.

        -Phobos

    • Re: Story by doctorlit on 2013-09-10 00:13:00 UTC Link to this

      Super exciting! I love seeing a super dark and deadly What-If; I especially love seeing one that can be prevented. This will give Oopart some serious work to do back in the present timeline. (Back in the present? What?)

      The thing that really makes the Department of Resistance feel unified and cohesive is the huge amount of cameos you threw in. It really makes this story feel like a (possible future) culmination of the last few years' worth of PPC writing.

      Also, I need to take a moment to be disproportionately egotistical. When I saw Doc's name in the list of dead, I was like, "Yeah, he would get pwned pretty hard." Then, when you mentioned the Sueified characters, I felt like Vania would wind up in that group, and figured that would be the end of my cameos. AND THEN I got to the Council at the end and was like HOLY CRAP one of my dudes IS LIKE MAJOR and then I spent about two hours trying to imagine how Vania wound up there.

      . . . Uh, so yeah. Thank you for that! It really made my day. I think I'd like to explore what happened to my agents in this timeline eventually, once you have your main parts finalized. Lots to do in the present in the mean-time, though.

      • Glad I could make your day! by Phobos on 2013-09-10 03:22:00 UTC Link to this

        I agree with you on the cameos. I needed a quick and dirty way to show how many the PPC had lost, as well as how the survivors were doing, and cameos were the best way to make that happen. It also allowed the story to connect on an emotional level that just saying "we lost more than 3/4 of the PPC" never would have.

        I'm glad I had you speculating about where Vania was. That was the point of not telling anyone who's names were behind that curtain. I wanted to give people's imaginations enough freedom to fill in the details. So, this is exactly the kind of response I wanted this story to get.

        -Phobos

    • Interesting stuff! by Herr Wozzeck on 2013-09-09 23:02:00 UTC Link to this

      I especially liked the building up of the setting. That's some masterfully paced dread-stuffs there. I certainly wouldn't want to be caught there, and the fact that there's a sense of ever-present danger helped a lot. Yeah, masterfully done dread-stuffs is always awesome.

      I also like Oopard as a character: he's wracked by guilt, he's in a life of danger, and he's being selected for a mission that he doesn't really know even the half of. His lot is kind of sorry, and I do hope he succeeds in his mission since he seems like a nice enough guy. I'd especially love to see his reaction to meeting agents he knows from the future well before he ever met them, but... y'know.

      Sorry, I'm probably not saying anything particularly helpful about this writing, but I loved it! So... Yeah. It was great.

      (P.S. I'd be kind of interested to know how Eusabius got that scar, IMO.)

      • Glad you enjoyed it! by Phobos on 2013-09-09 23:39:00 UTC Link to this

        "Masterfully paced dread-stuffs"? I like it.

        As to Oopart, I'm glad the guilt came through. That was kind of an important thing, for me. Whether he succeeds or not is going to have to wait until Part 2, I'm afraid.

        Also, if you want to know how Eusabius got that scar, you might eventually get a chance to find out. Just not from me, probably. Once I have finished the story, I might open up the timeline to other interested people, with my permission and some additional information to keep things consistent. It would all have to be set between the start of the invasion and the end of The End Is Nigh!, of course. Some people will want to have a say in what happened to their agents, and this would be a chance to do that.

        -Phobos

        • Oh mai... by Herr Wozzeck on 2013-09-10 00:03:00 UTC Link to this

          I think I might know what it is Eusabius is humming while scratching that scar...

          http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=APeEUfUCDVk

          *twirls non-existent moustache*

    • Fantastic! (spoilers) by the Irish Samurai on 2013-09-09 21:22:00 UTC Link to this

      I've read this several times now, and I think it's brilliant.

      It was very interesting to read about a situation where the Sues actually won. The occupation of HQ would be a major triumph for them, even if they couldn't achieve total victory. I thought you did a very good job of protraying just what it would be like for the agents living through the occupation, there were a load of nice little touches like the food getting even worse, as well as the dangers that they faced - particularly that one section of the Lists.

      I'm looking forward to seeing what Oopart gets up to next (and of course, hoping to find out if the Potted Fern Official ever finds true love - although that does seem somewhat unlikely now...)

      Alas, poor Amy. I knew her well.

      (Oh yeah, and thanks for making Skeet such a badass - that was cool)

      The future sure ain't what it used to be.

      • Thank you by Phobos on 2013-09-09 21:51:00 UTC Link to this

        You and Nesh were such a huge help during this process. It would not be as good as it is without the work you two put into it. Thank you.

        And about Skeet being a badass, that was a direct result of your comments and suggestions. And it turned out better than I could have expected. Skeet makes a brilliant foil for Oopart, especially at the end.

        Now, the PFO's love life is not something I had planned on discussing, but since you asked...I'm not touching that with a twenty-nine-and-a-half-foot pole.

        -Phobos

        • Glad I could help :) by the Irish Samurai on 2013-09-11 12:39:00 UTC Link to this

          As for Skeet at the end, well, I think the scene you wrote is far better than the stuff I suggested.

    • I am deeply impressed (spoilers) by Huinesoron on 2013-09-09 12:23:00 UTC Link to this

      You are much better at writing a defeat/resistance scenario than I've ever been (which is why I've tried to avoid it in my own Histories on either side). You manage to evoke both fear and determination in Oopart's movements in the first part, and then follow it up with an extremely realistic (if I can use the term) portrayal of how the Department of Resistance might work. Jof's contribution is ingenious, and I was genuinely moved by the Tomb and the Lists.

      I noticed a whole heap of both explicit references ('Why we sing it we don't know/We can't make the words rhyme properly!') and what appear to be 'inspired by' sections. Two in particular caught my eye. First, Oopart's reading of the List was similar to Vimes' Disorganiser in Jingo, with its final list of 'death of [Name]... death of [Name]'. Actually I think you missed a trick here - the impact of that list would have been greater if you put Lux's name right at the end, as a sort of climax (if you'll pardon the pun). I think if it ran as it does, but ended with 'Zim. Otik Horak. Luxury.', it would drive home the emotional point (that no-one is safe just by being a long-term character) even better. (I'm not sure this actually was an 'inspired by', but it evokes the same feel)

      The other reference I picked up on particularly was the Hippie Sequoia's sacrifice/defence. Okay, he quotes Gandalf, but that's not what I mean. I'm thinking of the actions of Jedi Master Ood Bnar during the fall of Ossus, in the Star Wars Expanded Universe. He, too, turns himself into a rooted tree with the knowledge that it will kill him, in order to save something of greater value to him than his life.

      And... well, if you are referencing/inspired by that, it might be a good idea to note something of the sort in your disclaimer. We recently read the account of the Cassandra Claire Plagiarism Debacle, and not noting that she'd taken whole heaps of quotes from other sources was one of the catalysts for that. Kaitlyn says that she had a whole file of Cassie Claire quotes saved - with no knowledge at the time that most of them weren't hers.

      You're no Cassie Claire (thank the stars!), and the Sequoia's scene is very powerful in its own right, even without knowing the (possible) inspiration. But if you've done a similar thing in other places, it would be nice to know about it.

      Okay, enough twitchy!hS. I liked 'Don't like, don't eat'! I also thought you did very well with the attack, but also with the little things: lines like 'She was not one of the lucky ones.' are very powerful, because you're evoking the common idea that 'The ones who died were the lucky ones' without actually saying it - because it doesn't need saying, because your audience already knows that.

      And that ending... very well-paced, very suitably disastrous. Like I said - I'm impressed! And the little details (such as the perpetual watermill) keep on coming, even when the plot speeds up. So all in all - well done, and I can't wait to see the next part.

      hS

      (PS: Once The Trousers of Time, Triple Prime and Catastrophe Theory have more written about them, I think we definitely need a non-canonical collision of all the different time-travellers and their associates... ~hS)

      • Thank you very much (more spoilers) by Phobos on 2013-09-09 13:33:00 UTC Link to this

        Part of the reason I went the way I did with this story is because we'd never seen the PPC in defeat. It had splintered, yes. It had fought armies and itself. But when it came down to it, they still got the job done when it was over. So I felt there was an envelope worth pushing, there. I'm glad it worked as well as it did.

        As to the references, I wish I had remembered the Disorganizer. That's the reason Jingo is one of my favorite books in the series. And I see your point about the list. It is something I might fix later, since I need Nesh to actually do that.

        The Hippie Sequoia scene did reference a couple of things, but the Star Wars EU was not among them, because I have no knowledge beyond the movies. Before the Gandalf quote, the Sequoia actually combines two Star Trek quotes, which is fitting, given her job.

        I'm surprised, with your mention of Jingo, earlier, that you didn't mention the other oblique Discworld reference. "Operation Sweeper" was, of course, named for a little man with a broom who mucks about with time, when it is absolutely necessary.

        I am very glad that you enjoyed this. It was, at times, both a joy to write and very difficult to write. The dream sequence, in particular, still makes me choke up, and I wrote the thing.

        The next part will likely be a little while, due to other irons in other fires. But I might write a few more short stories to flesh out some details that were unimportant to the main story, but I think are pretty interesting.

        -Phobos, destroyer of worlds

  • Another plug, although not for my writing. by Endless Sea on 2013-09-08 20:16:00 UTC Link to this

    So, a fellow member of the WTF forums from that TVTropes ARG a year ago (WTF forums meaning http://forum.watchthefootage.com/index.php in case you were wondering) has gotten around to writing a piece of original fiction. Having somewhat recently joined the PPC community, I figured I might as well ask permission to link it on the Board, and, well, I got it! So, without further ado:

    http://www.fictionpress.com/s/3151469/1/Daybreak

    Haven't read it yet meself, admittedly, although I'll get around to it in time. :P We're interested in seeing what you guys think, though!

  • OT: I'd like to say a huge 'Well done' to Neshomeh. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-09 11:50:00 UTC Link to this

    Okay, that seems a little out of the blue... let me explain:

    In the course of saying hello to Artemis Mk. 2, I talked about the DIA, and specifically Black and Irvine, written by the original Artemis. Their missions used to be hosted on the Bad Roleplay Department website, which, alas, died with Geocities.

    Not that I was going to let that stop me! I prowled the web looking for the various sites which had archived bits of Geocities, sure that at least one of them must have something. And finally, I found that the Oocities site has a unified search engine (in the top right corner) - one which will pull up results from all the salvaged Geocities archives!

    Brilliant! I thought. I may not be able to find the BRD, but surely there'll be something of value in there!

    (Yes, I am getting to the point)

    Well... no. Or rather, yes, there is. Among the saved websites are Hellga's SIELU collection, the JAAKSONS, the missions of Dee and Milask, Suicide and Diocletian... whole heaps of pretty important stuff from the early days of the PPC!

    And it's all entirely useless, because Neshomeh has saved every single thing I can find (with the exception of a handful of 'I made this page but never posted any missions or anything' sites) to the Lost Tales. So there's nothing left for me to do!

    Seriously. I'm very impressed. Well done, Nesh - and thanks!

    hS

    • Awesome, Neshomeh! by VixenMage on 2013-09-10 09:41:00 UTC Link to this

      Between Archiving All The Things and Basically Running the Wiki, I'm pretty sure we should have some kind of PPC-Super-Librarian hat to bestow, or something. You do all kindsa really awesome stuff and keep things running, and just so you know, we really appreciate it. You rock.

      • ^This. by DawnFire on 2013-09-11 03:33:00 UTC Link to this

        ...I wanted to add a message, but I actually think that's everything I wanted to say. We really do appreciate everything you do, and you're amazing and awesome and a whole thesaurus' worth of adjectives meaning 'great'. Thank you *hugs*

        ...oh, right, that's the only thing I can add. Thank you! :D

        ~DF

    • *brings in the cookie pie* by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-09 23:10:00 UTC Link to this

      At first I thought I'd just offer up some cookies, but then I realized that - true to Dean Winchester's opinion - pie is indeed better. But I can't just cut out the cookies, so I made cookie pie. *offers* Enough for everyone. I made fifty.

      • (takes a slice of the Neshomeh-is-awesome pie) (nm) by Outhra on 2013-09-11 00:26:00 UTC Link to this
      • Ooh, cookie pie. by Neshomeh on 2013-09-10 18:31:00 UTC Link to this

        It sure is warm under this here spotlight, so I hope it's the kind of pie that's served cold. ^_^

        (Seriously, thanks, guys. Wow. I don't even. I'll just. Yeah.)

        ~Neshomeh

        • Served cold indeed. by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-10 22:57:00 UTC Link to this

          With whipped cream. And hey, if you don't want the whipped cream...

          • I'll take it! by DawnFire on 2013-09-11 03:35:00 UTC Link to this

            Always down for extra whipped cream...yum. May I?

            And if I mayn't, well...*runs off with all the extra whipped cream*

            ~DF

            PS: I have this vision of myself as Obelix, but with whipped cream instead of wild boar. It's...rather odd, and doesn't really hold up, but...

            • Hold up! by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-11 05:57:00 UTC Link to this

              Dawn, I have to ask. Do you...would you be perfectly okay with buying a new container of whipped cream, opening it up, and nomming it up?

              Because I mean...whipped cream is kinda sorta one of my addictions...sooo...

              • YES. by DawnFire on 2013-09-11 12:13:00 UTC Link to this

                I mean, being me, I'd probably put most of it in hot chocolate, which I did a number of times last year, but yessss.

                ~DF

                • *holds hand up for high five* (nm) by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-11 22:56:00 UTC Link to this
      • Yay! by Kittythekatty on 2013-09-10 01:53:00 UTC Link to this

        Pie is good. Cookies are good. But how would a cookie pie work? Is there a pie crust and the filling made out of cookies?
        Or is the crust cookie?

        • I don't know... by VixenMage on 2013-09-10 09:43:00 UTC Link to this

          ...but with a shot like this, I'm not going to ask questions, either.

          • Close. by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-10 16:16:00 UTC Link to this

            But not quite. Just enjoy the cookie pie and ask no questions.

            Blindfolds are mandatory to eat the pie. Can't have anyone figuring out my technique, can I? :3

    • *claps loudly* (nm) by Ailavyn Siniyash on 2013-09-09 19:13:00 UTC Link to this
    • Bwuh? O.o by Neshomeh on 2013-09-09 17:18:00 UTC Link to this

      Oh. That. Wow, okay. Thanks. That definitely came right out of nowhere, but thanks. ^_^;

      And, hey, let's not forget you've done some preservation work yourself, hS. Pretty much everything that used to be hosted on OddLots is on your site now, right? Sure made my job a lot easier, especially when I set about archiving the Original Series. If you hadn't saved the OddLots main page, I never would've figured out something was missing and found "The Dark Elf." {= )

      ... Also, visiting that page again, I can now pin a date on the founding of SIELU, which will be handy for the timeline of the Department of Floaters I've been working on in anticipation of sprucing up its wiki page. And there are several other dates recorded, too, which is awesome—we can know for certain when some of the last TOS missions were released, for instance. So, thanks for saving such valuable historical data!

      ~Neshomeh

      • Eh, not really. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-11 13:59:00 UTC Link to this

        My preservation efforts tend to be marred by my switching over to something else halfway through. So I think my version of the dear departed Oddlots page includes the Buffyverse missions - but all the other links are dead. I guess that means I should do something about that...

        hS

      • Yeah, well done! by the Irish Samurai on 2013-09-09 20:42:00 UTC Link to this

        And not just for the archiving of stories, but for all the work you do on the wiki as well.

    • *applause* by Cassie on 2013-09-09 12:41:00 UTC Link to this

      The PPC wouldn't be what it is today if we let ancient writings be forgotten, and Neshomeh's our star archivist. :D Hurrah for Neshomeh!

  • A brief return by Storme Hawk on 2013-09-09 12:30:00 UTC Link to this

    Hey guys, I'm back. Well when I say back I mean for a bit, I won't be properly back until the 21st, a mixture of being grounded and a new university have seen to that. To 'the Irish Samurai' and 'Desdendelle' I apologize for keeping you hanging with my writing sample for the permission request, but it's one of the first things on my to do list once I get back on my laptop.
    I've probably rambled on for long enough now. I'll get back on when I can.

    • No worries, by the Irish Samurai on 2013-09-09 21:10:00 UTC Link to this

      My offer to beta still stands - just send it through whenever you've got it ready.

      Good luck with your new uni, the first couple of weeks are always a little hectic.

      • Been through it once already by Storme Hawk on 2013-09-09 23:02:00 UTC Link to this

        Thanks, I can't currently access it but like I said before once I'm settled in I'll get it done.

        This is my second Uni, so I've been through Freshers and stuff before. Thankfully this one isn't on the other side of the country so I should do better.

    • Hey... by AW on 2013-09-09 17:45:00 UTC Link to this

      Did anyone get the licence plate of that drive-by Hi-ing?

      And I got you beat for leaving people hanging on writings; can you beat eight years? Heh.

    • Welcome ba- oh, you've gone again. ;) (nm) by Huinesoron on 2013-09-09 15:54:00 UTC Link to this
  • Cool things about colleges (& other schools) (& workplaces) by DawnFire on 2013-09-09 17:48:00 UTC Link to this

    In light of there being so many people, myself included, who have just started or are about to start college/university, I thought it might be a good time for a thread about it. In light of that...what's the coolest thing about your college or uni? And what's your favorite part so far? I feel like this could be an interesting discussion...

    My uni has a sort of pool...with a pair of geese in it. Or maybe they're ducks; I'm not completely sure. But seriously...geese? Wow. Yay Canada! :D

    I'm still working on my favorite part, though. What can I say, I haven't even finished my first day yet.

    People in middle-school (do we have any?), high school, and so on (work, grad school, etc, I expect) are also welcome to share answers to these questions!

    And feel free to have some fun...I myself am working on writing a sort of OFUM-based first-day-of-school horror story which may never be posted as my classes are so far interesting enough for me not to tune out. Bother.

    Anyone else? Share your experiences! Make us envy you for where you study! Write chilling tales of terror that will terrify us terrifically...okay, I think academia has started to affect me. But like I said, feel free to have some fun; I'm sure it'll be interesting!

    ~DF

    PS: Two people so far have asked me for directions. Do I look approachable? Comfortable? Like the second-year student I'm not? Hm...
    Ooh. That could go in the horror story...
    ~DF

    • Here's a good one: by BeautyID on 2013-09-11 04:15:00 UTC Link to this

      The air conditioning system was broken at my university today. There was a heat wave. It got up to about 95 degrees and with the humidex it felt like 115. The workers who would fix the AC system... are on strike.

      • This puts me in mind of... by Huinesoron on 2013-09-12 16:12:00 UTC Link to this

        ... well, somewhere. I can't actually place the memory - it may be as far back as school (which, good grief, makes it over ten years ago). Wherever it was, we had air conditioning, which was great! Except that there was a six month lag in when they turned the thing on. So it was entirely non-functional in summer, and on full-blast in winter. Yeah, I don't think we were very impressed.

        Fortunately, nowadays I have access to the aircon remote... ;)

        hS

        • Re: This puts me in mind of... by BeautyID on 2013-09-13 18:30:00 UTC Link to this

          My university made an enthusiastic post on Facebook yesterday declaring that the AC would be fixed by noon today! Which is great because today it is 60 degrees and no one needs air conditioning.

    • College was the best. by Neshomeh on 2013-09-10 22:27:00 UTC Link to this

      And also the worst, at times. But mostly the best.

      Phobos and I both went to a really small college in the middle of Michigan, so it wasn't exactly the most exciting territory, but the people more than made up for it. The entire campus is no more than a fifteen-minute walk from one end to the other, and that's only if you stretch to the really out of the way student housing, so your friends and any cool activities going on are right there when you want them.

      That's the thing I miss most. Chicago is great and there's plenty of stuff going on at any given time, but it's rarely on my doorstep, and my friends are scattered thirty minutes apart or more. Plus, I can't just turn up to something new and trust that most of the people present are friendly or have anything in common with me outside X thing, which makes it really nerve-wracking to make the effort to find the ones that are and do.

      One particularly cool thing about my college, though, is that our gaming and anime club hosts an annual con in February, and this year Doug Walker (the Nostalgia Critic) is one of our guests. Check it out if you think you might like to go. Phobos and I will be there, and we'd love to see you. {= )

      As for my job, I work from home, so not much to add there. I have a cat, though. He sleeps next to me on the couch while I work, and that's nice.

      ~Neshomeh

      • Also... by DawnFire on 2013-09-11 03:23:00 UTC Link to this

        I'm liking my university so far, but the fifteen-minute walk across campus sounds nice right about now--my campus is so huge I can safely say I haven't ever even gone around it, and they don't even stop with residences--they have a village. It's kind of insane. It's a gorgeous campus, though, and they've set up the insides of the buildings fairly well too, so I can't complain about that...

        ~DF

      • Doug Walker? *flailing* by DawnFire on 2013-09-11 03:21:00 UTC Link to this

        No way I can get there, though, so there's that. Oh well. You guys will just have to have twice the amount of fun in my stead! :D

        (So happy I started this thread...look at all the cool things people are bringing up!)

        What's Michigan like? I've never been there and I have no actual preconceptions besides a vague impression of trees. Also, what's your cat's name? Did you have him from kittenhood or after?

        ~DF

        • Michigan by Neshomeh on 2013-09-12 18:24:00 UTC Link to this

          It is indeed full of trees. Trees and fields in the lower peninsula, trees and more trees in the upper peninsula. There are also some really nice rivers, and of course the shoreline. There are some great beaches and some really awful ones. The further north you go, the more rocks there are, which is great if you're into rock-hunting. Michigan also boasts some pretty cool landforms such as the Sleeping Bear Dunes and the Pictured Rocks. Overall, it's very pretty.

          Alas, the weather can be pretty terrible. It's... well, kind of a swamp, what with being low-lying and full of water, so it's humid a lot, and "allergy season" is basically all year. And then there's the economy, which was tanking even before the recession hit, not to mention the current government, which seems to be trying its damnedest to kill democracy, but I won't say any more about that. >.>

          In conclusion, Michigan's a nice place to visit, but you wouldn't want to actually live there—not right now, anyway.

          As for my cat, his name is Merlin, and I have a picture!

          http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v155/Neshomeh/merlin11-18.jpg

          Also featuring my right knee and the edge of my lap desk. It's not a great picture. >.>

          Anyway! He's a Tonkinese, and we got him when he was a kitten. He's about 13 now, still causing as much trouble as ever. {= )

          ~Neshomeh

    • I'm long out of Uni... by Huinesoron on 2013-09-10 09:31:00 UTC Link to this

      ... but you did add a parenthetical (& workplaces), so maybe I can throw out some horror stories from my job at an industrial chemical company?

      Like the part where we have a brand new plant for making bleach from chlorine gas, and people keep doing clever things like cutting into active pipes 'because it's quicker'?

      Or the part where, for no reason whatsoever, one of our storage tanks decided to snap in half, fall over, knock over a second tank full of hydrochloric acid, and blow HCl fumes all over the nearby main road?

      Ooh! Or the time we thought a test reaction would only heat the tank up to 60C (er, 140F, apparently), only we hadn't taken into account the fact that all the chemicals were going in through one small pipe, and accidentally set a 25 tonne tank rocking and rolling as the water boiled inside?

      ^_^ Chemistry is fun!

      hS

      • Good Lord. by DawnFire on 2013-09-10 17:39:00 UTC Link to this

        You do lead a rather exciting life, don't you? May I ask how many injuries you've sustained at work?

        Chemistry is pretty fun, though (says the girl who took a class in it in Grade 11 and then completely failed at sitting in on the Grade 12 class).

        I'm so glad this thread seems to be taking off...and the responses have been great! Keep them coming, people! :D

        ~DF

      • Heh. by VixenMage on 2013-09-10 09:38:00 UTC Link to this

        Every new anecdote about your workplace increases my belief that PPC members are living in a reality several magnitudes weirder than the "normal" reality that's supposed to exist around us.

        (Also those are all very horrifying stories. Please don't accidentally turn into a supervillain.)

        • ...I'd buy that belief. by DawnFire on 2013-09-10 17:42:00 UTC Link to this

          That is, I think you may have a point, and am drowning in idioms and possibly not using them correctly. What's uni doing to me?

          (Also, supervillain!hS kind of scares me. And...pretty much everything you've written in this post is inspiring me to write, mostly for the Badfic game. I don't think I want you to stop, though, it's pretty interesting...)

          ~DF

          • Yep. by VixenMage on 2013-09-11 05:07:00 UTC Link to this

            There was a PPCer who had to shoo a moose out of her backyard, and while she was at school a bat once flew off with the tissue box she'd had in the window.

            I forget what it was about this university that prompted someone to decide that it's located in Nightvale. Possibly the fact that the top floor lounges of my dorm glows in the dark - running through the entire color spectrum over and over. Or the top of the Science building glowing in the dark, that might've done it. Add that to the fact that we're a little valley in the middle of the desert...

            So yes. PPCers seem to attract very odd realities. I'm not sure why, and it probably calls for SCIENCE!.

          • Well, if he does go evil... by Outhra on 2013-09-11 01:17:00 UTC Link to this

            At least there's already a pre-defined aesthetic. The mad scientist supervillain outfit just needs a few tweaks to make it truly one's own, but if he decided to stick to the classic model, it's hard to go wrong with lab coats and giant robots. Just imagine it: a Tolkien elf in a billowing lab coat and thick goggles, standing atop a three-story machine and laughing manaically while it launches acid into a nearby city. I admit it's a little expected, but if someone tries to call you out on it, giant robots excel at looming menacingly and swatting people across city blocks.

            Wait, he'd be chemistry-themed. You don't make robots with chemistry. You power them with chemistry, though. That might be enough of a stretch. Even if there isn't a robot, he'd probably need some kind of device, because a science-themed villain often has very weak or indirect supernatural abilities and he's going to need something to fight off the helicopters they'll send after him once he robs the Science Symposium to get the last ingredients to build his superweapon or cloning ray or giant acid monster or what have you.
            Hold on... would a cloning ray be biology, or would the necessary biochemical functions to maintain clones allow it to fall under chemistry? Planning for this sort of thing is more difficult than I thought it would be.

            • Thank you for feeding the plotbunnies. by DawnFire on 2013-09-11 03:29:00 UTC Link to this

              Mind if I repossess some of that for the badfic, if I end up writing it? Supervillain!hS gets more terrifying by the second...and I'm pretty sure the badfic game is the place for this story.

              ...it's a little hard to picture a Tolkien Elf laughing maniacally, though, at least in the crazed sense. Laughing merrily, maybe...

              We seem to be overthinking this. It is rather fun, though. Also, he could just team up with an engineer--a sort of minion or sidekick or something...

              ~DF

              • It saddens me to point out... by Huinesoron on 2013-09-11 09:26:00 UTC Link to this

                ... that the Badfic Game is usually about agents in the PPC, not Boarders.

                That said, there is an Agent Huinesoron, who shares much of my backstory... not sure if he's a chemist, but hey, it's the Badfic Game - who cares?

                hS

                PS: Pretty sure I have a picture of myself as a mad scientist somewhere...

                • Hm. (thanks for clarifying) by DawnFire on 2013-09-11 12:20:00 UTC Link to this

                  Alright, I can write this about Agent hS instead. And rampantly make things up, because badfic :)

                  Can Boarders make a brief appearance, though? In the sense of 'just when you thought Agent hS was the most terrifying supervillain you've ever seen...along comes Boarder hS to team up with him and the story ends with them making plans to take over the multiverse'? Because that could be pretty awesome.

                  (I'm quite tempted now to, in the tradition of the Jaycacia stories, have a scene of the real Agent hS reacting to the badfic. Not sure if it will go in, but, out of curiosity, would you be willing to write that scene? You obviously know him a good deal better than I do*...)

                  Also, a picture? Why? I mean, awesome, but who drew it? Why did they draw it? How mad of a mad scientist?

                  ~DF

                  *Said lack of knowledge will probably result in even more badficcy badfic, so I'll do my best to just make a series of assumptions in order to write this...

                  • For science! by Huinesoron on 2013-09-11 21:34:00 UTC Link to this



                    hS

                  • Weeeeeell, probably. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-11 13:07:00 UTC Link to this

                    I know we've had agents appearing in the Shipficfest before, though I can't actually recall Boarders wandering into the Badfic Game... still, I'm sure you could get away with it.

                    I'm willing to write a 'hS reacts' scenelet, sure. They're always fun.

                    Oops, did I say picture? I meant as in photograph. I'll see if I can track it down tonight.

                    hS

              • Oh no, there are plenty of Tolkien Elves who'd do that. (nm) by VixenMage on 2013-09-11 05:03:00 UTC Link to this
                • ...fair point. I'd forgotten. (nm) by DawnFire on 2013-09-11 12:21:00 UTC Link to this
    • Basically awesome! by VixenMage on 2013-09-10 05:15:00 UTC Link to this

      I actually started at this university in the Spring quarter, so I've been cooling my heels here since the Summer quarter ended... and Fall quarter's at the end of the month. But my favorite thing about campus is the crows. They're everywhere and wicked smart and becoming quite friendly to me.

      Really there are cool things all over though, and since I moved here from about 2800 miles East-Southeast, everything about the valley and town is new. Mostly the most awesome thing so far is the church, actually, which also hits "workplace" in a roundabout way - I started tentatively attending, then got informally adopted en masse by about 1/3 of the congregation, and then because I was having trouble finding a job and had nothing to do, I started working on the grounds.

      And then, despite repeated warning to not work too hard/take it easy, I proceeded to get really intense about working the grounds, and started spending pretty much all day pulling weeds and wrestling bushes and fallen limbs. An awesome way to spend the summer... and also sort of an awesome way of eating all my time. Which is why I've not been around here as often. Still reading! Just a lot less energy to respond.

      My favorite part of the university, though, is the newspaper. It's awesome and the folks are awesome and even though I'd rather be a reporter I'm gonna be assistant news editor starting Fall. It's all very exciting!

    • I'm feeling so old. XD by Gen on 2013-09-10 02:20:00 UTC Link to this

      I've started my first year of grad school a few weeks ago. My school is in a very large city that attracts a lot of famous people, so there's always a lot going on. I think there's an X Factor audition today because I heard some people talking about it.

      Peter S Beagle stopped by my school during the tour for The Last Unicorn movie. I've met him before and he is just the nicest person. If you like his work, definitely try to meet him if you can. He makes a lot of time for his fans and has some great stories!

      Hmm. What else is interesting about my school?

      There are a couple of bars on campus. I went to a small institution for my undergrad, so it's still amazing that this campus has so many food places. I spend most of my time in one building, so I don't really experience everything.

      Does anyone else's school bookstores sell Hello Kitty plushes with your school's logo on a little shirt? I think they're adorable and I've bought them from my undergrad and grad schools. XD

    • Conservatory environment... by Herr Wozzeck on 2013-09-09 23:57:00 UTC Link to this

      It's a really crazy place, I'll just say that. It's not surrounded by much except a bigger university, but that just makes the area pretty nice and healthy by comparison, so I'll just leave that be.

      As for my favorite part... I have two. The one is my current composition teacher (who's frickin' amazing at what he does), and the other is the electronic music room (which has a bunch of synthesizers plus a computer, keyboard, and hard drive full of all these awesome virtual instruments). So yeah...

    • Well, my college... by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-09 23:36:00 UTC Link to this

      ...is really kinda boring. Except for the group of people that get together for medieval dancing and heavy fighting and what. They're pretty fun. :3

    • Uni by Storme Hawk on 2013-09-09 23:14:00 UTC Link to this

      My last Uni was in the home of Rugby League (you can guess which sport we specialized in), and we had the Sir Patrick Stewart (AKA Jean Luc Picard, Charles Xavier etc etc.) as our chancellor, even better? I got to speak to him once (I then joked with my friends "Right that's it, that's all I came here for I'm leaving" and lo and behold I'm not there anymore.) We also had our own Games Studio that released games onto the Xbox Arcade and have a Canal running right through our campus (complete with a lock and the occasional barge).

      That's just about it for my University besides the notorious bad weather, but that's England for you.

      • Also, further incoherent sputtering. by VixenMage on 2013-09-10 07:32:00 UTC Link to this

        Sir Patrick Stewart is basically the most amazing dude! (WHAT DID YOU TALK ABOUT.)

      • *incoherent sputtering* by hermione of vulcan on 2013-09-10 00:04:00 UTC Link to this

        YOU GOT TO MEET SIR PATRICK STEWART?!

        WORDS CANNOT DESCRIBE HOW JEALOUS I AM.

        Seriouslyohmygodswhatdidyoutalkabout?

        Excuse my blatant fangirling, I just…Picard is my role model, that's all.

        • Re: *incoherent sputtering* by Storme Hawk on 2013-09-10 14:35:00 UTC Link to this

          I'm going to be honest it wasn't planned or anything. It was after our last exam of term me and a couple of mates had finished early and were allowed out and we were waiting for the exam to end, so we're chatting outside the hall and suddenly we look up the steps to the main block and there he was walking down with some assistants or something like that. Spotting us hanging around he stopped said "Hello" to us, asked why we were hanging around there and then wished us good luck in our exam before moving on.

          Best bit is that if you do Drama at the Uni in final year he can even comes in and teach a couple of the classes.

    • Wow... by Kittythekatty on 2013-09-09 22:43:00 UTC Link to this

      I feel really childlike compared to y'all. I'm in High School.

      Anything cool? Well, We celebrated our school's 50 year anniversary. Oh, and it's located in a forest. No joke, for track, we used to go running on the trails in the forest...that our school is located in. It's also next to a power station. And there's a graveyard nearby...I feel a bit scared because GRAVEYARD.
      Oh and one year during our recess, we swung on vines. Like Tarzan. I'm not kidding. We also got to explore the forest and trails for P.E and recess and fun. And we see deer a lot.
      But I think the best part about my school is the teachers.I've known them for a while due to going to a small private school and the fact that some of them taught me in middle school. They are really dedicated to their jobs and a lot of them have talents/hobbies/occupations/etc. we wouldn't expect; my former Math teacher was a ballet dancer and choreographs the school's musicals, my Biology teacher was a Nurse and a Cheer leading coach. I had two teachers that loved Star Trek and many fandoms in general.
      I guess that's all I've got. Kinda plain, but I like it.

      • Re: Wow... by Ball Python on 2013-09-10 09:58:00 UTC Link to this

        You feel young? I'm in middle school. I feel even younger.
        My favorite thing about my school is the community. And I mean community. Not just humans. The Greenfield Lizard and that weird quail who keeps crashing into the window too.
        I love our school celebrations, too. Especially Pesta Rakyat, the Independence Day celebration. Last Pesta Rakyat, they had the great idea of making the security guards do tug-of-war against the English teacher, Math teacher, science teacher and principal.

    • Re: Cool things about colleges (& other schools) (& workplaces) by Ailavyn Siniyash on 2013-09-09 19:20:00 UTC Link to this

      I'm currently on my second week of my first year of high school, and so far, it's actually quite good!

      For one, there is free (well, included in tuition) lunches that are good for you and very, very delicious, and also tea and bagels in the morning if you want. (It's a small school; about 400 including the teachers.)

      Also the location's really pretty; it's in the Presidio, a forest-park-thing right near the Bay (I live in San Francisco) and everyone's very nice, including the teachers.

      Lastly, it seems like half the school, at least, knows what fandom is, so that made me happy.

      I rather like it.

      -Aila

    • You're making me feel old... by AW on 2013-09-09 19:19:00 UTC Link to this

      Damn kids! Get off my lawn!

      • Re: You're making me feel old... by AW on 2013-09-10 21:02:00 UTC Link to this

        To expand on this: I have been out of college for four years (Aie-yai) and before that I was in college before I joined the PPC (though technically I never actually joined the PPC, more like adopted really) back in the fall of 2000.

        You kids seriously make me feel old, but when I say that I've been online (actively) for sixteen years, that says something in itself.

        With that said, I loved College. It was there that I learned to drink cold coffee on a regular basis since we couldn't bring the drinks into the classroom due to all the pricey computers, and with hour long lectures at the beginning with the break after, coffee was then cold.

        Though my program was a bit on the crazy side (three - five projects a week - due every two), it was fun and I probably would do it again in a heart beat. The friends definitely made it worth while. Even though it was four years ago, a group of us still get together regularly every few months to have coffee at Tim Horton's and catch up or just talk about stupid stuff like new movies and the like.

        I also don't think I'm entirely finished with college either. Darn technology; you think you're on top of it, and then they release something new.

        ~AW~

        • Welcome to the club. {= ) by Neshomeh on 2013-09-10 21:36:00 UTC Link to this

          Phobos and I graduated from college in 2008 and 2009, respectively, though if you were already in college in 2000, you were at it longer than we were. I didn't get started until 2004. I had a gap between high school (class of `03) and my first two years, then another gap between my first two and my second two and a half, wherein I transferred from community college to four-year college.

          Still, there's a few of us "real adults" kicking around, though I think we tend to stretch the definition a little in our circles. I figure being a grown-up means you get to pursue whatever silly hobbies you like and no one can make you stop, so I say live it up! Y'know, just as long as the bills get paid and no one is starving or naked. {; )

          ~Neshomeh

          • Edjamacation and Hobbies by AW on 2013-09-10 22:05:00 UTC Link to this

            And even if they *are* nekkid, so long as they're fed, right?

            I graduated from HS in 2000, and got accepted right off the bat for Television Animation. I found out a year and a half later that I was not cut out for animation and then took a four year break to figure out what I wanted/need/could do. In 2006 I got accepted into the Graphic Design program and did very well. Which is one of the main reasons why I fell off the website updating schedule. That and MMORPGing.

            Now I'm just looking for work, while doing odd jobs here and there, making sure I have money for hobbies as well as presents and personal crack.

            I was mid-range in age back when I was active in the PPC Boards before. Now I'm supposedly an adult. HA! Say what?! Says who?

    • Re: Cool things about colleges (& other schools) (& workplaces) by AdmiralSakai on 2013-09-09 19:05:00 UTC Link to this

      Back in the 1880s, my university ran an experiment that became one of the foundations of relativity theory. They literally will not shut up about it- there's I think six or seven different plaques around campus, two named buildings, a small museum of the thing in the department of physics, and a fountain.

      We also have one of the largest LARP games of "Humans versus zombies" in the word.

      I still insist that the two are connected.

      • Human vs. zombie LARP? by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-09 23:13:00 UTC Link to this

        Your school sounds interesting.

        • I've heard of that. by Cassie on 2013-09-10 01:09:00 UTC Link to this

          It runs at at least one school I know of - Geneseo State University of New York. One of our old lurker Boarders goes there.

  • Open Letter to the Future by Huinesoron on 2013-09-10 12:41:00 UTC Link to this

    Dear Future PPC Community Members,

    Hi! Am I still around? If so, HI, FUTURE ME! I hope you're as awesome as you should be and haven't turned (even more) crotchety! And if you're not the one reading this, I hope whoever is passes on my greeting. Wow, that would be kind of cool, wouldn't it? A personalised greeting from your past self?

    ... is the thought process that led to this message. Because recently I've been looking over the Board's archives, and I thought it would be nice to leave something for our future.

    So, hi! It's 2013. The PPC has been in existence for about eleven years, and the Board has been here for most of that. As I write, we're on our second (third?) PPC chat - this one is usually referred to as 'the IRC'. We have our own Wiki, with about two and a half thousand articles. And our plans for world domination have reached Phase Nine-Point-Five.

    ... no, all right, I'm kidding about that last one. We're only on Phase Six.

    We have the usual population profile - lots of newbies, a whole bunch of Middlebies, and a small collection of Very Oldbies (like, say, me). A lot of our newbies these days come from a website called TVTropes, which has changed the demographics somewhat from the days when we were all refugees from Fanfiction.net. But hey, I assume your current source of influx is, like, a dating website or something. Times change, the Board remains.

    Or does it?!?!?andotherpunctuation Certainly at the moment there seems to be no chance of the PPC giving up on the concept of a Board, but maybe things are different in the future. Hey, if you have time travel, could you... no, scratch that. I don't think I want to know what things are like. It might be depressingly bad - or depressingly good.

    So where was I? We have a solid bunch of writers, working on missions, AUs, interludes - I've just finally written Origins. We have an active community in the IRC (or so I'm told - I don't visit). One thing we haven't had in a while is a UK Gathering, but we're hoping to pin one down sometime next year.

    Anyway, I don't want to bore you, so I'll hang up now (that's a reference to telephones - the non-mobile kind - look, ask your parents, okay? Or, if you're a LONG way in the future, your grandparents). But I have a strong feeling (hint, hint!) that others in the community would like to leave you a message, too! So go for it, guys - I hope you can be funnier than me. ;)

    Thank you for reading, Future!PPCers. I hope your world is as awesome as ours.

    hS

    • Hi Past. by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-10 16:25:00 UTC Link to this

      So I feel I should warn you-in-the-past about a few upcoming major disasters, including a terrible earthquake in Haiti that'll show up sometime in 2009, a tsunami and subsequent nuclear meltdown in Japan on some Friday (I think?) of March 2011, the election of Tony Abbott as Australia's Prime Minister in fall 2013...

      • Ah! You must have read... by Huinesoron on 2013-09-10 16:39:00 UTC Link to this

        ... this comic.

        (And if not - why not?)

        hS

        • hS... by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-10 17:06:00 UTC Link to this

          ...hug. Now.

          And you got the reference yes.

  • A Thought by KittyEden on 2013-09-10 12:58:00 UTC Link to this

    Has anyone read the BeanWorld graphic novel series by Larry Marder? If not, then I strongly reccommend it. You'l be hooked, I guarantee it.
    The thing is, Larry Marder describes the whole place he has made an ongoing stoory "a process, not a place." This got me thinking.
    When the PPC was setup first, it was just an idea. A great idea, but nonetheless just an idea.
    Then, Jay and Acacia started a series.
    A year or two later, Bleeprin was added.
    The more departments came into play.
    My point here is that 5 years from now, the PPC will have new ideas and terms that we didn't even begin to think of thinking of.
    So, in a way, the PPC isn't just a place. It's a process.
    And t-that's all, folks.

    • Oh, yes; wildly so. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-10 14:21:00 UTC Link to this

      (Although I will point out that 'Jay and Acacia started a series' is where it all began; the stories begat the community, not the other way round!)

      The PPC has always been a shared universe where things changed. New agents come in and out, and put their own spin on things. New concepts show up - like the recent advent of four separate 'fall of the future PPC' timelines - and either work or get forgotten. New chunks of the community appear - I was here before the Wiki - and disappear - I remember the Livejournal agent journals. And occasionally something pops up like the city in New Caledonia that changes the whole shape of things.

      But for all that, actually, a lot of things are static. Agents are still using the same technology that was established in the first few years of writing - the last major innovation was TARDISes back in 2008. The list of departments is largely static, having come to a stable state with (roughly) the Departments of Temporal Offenses, Angst, and WhatThe. The proceedure for carrying out a mission has been standardised (back in the day, Bad Slash didn't have charge lists!). While people keep coming up with new bleeproducts and Suvian colours, they don't actually get used all that much - the defaults are still bleeprin, bleepka, urple and wilver.

      In fact, the PPC is basically the same now as it was five years ago. But five years before that, practically none of it existed (and Despatch was a major department!). So what'll happen in another five years?

      No answers from me! But Tia Hyrax will be 14 years old and in training to join the Department of Bad Slash - back when I joined in 2003, she was still a year away from being born! Now that's what I call an achievement.

      hS

  • I, formerly known as AelinTheAmazing, have returned. by Impossible on 2013-09-10 17:25:00 UTC Link to this

    First of all, welcome and a toaster to any newbies that I may have missed during my absence. Be careful of the toaster, though. It's liable to shoot anything you put into it right back into your face.

    I've just started a new school year, so I haven't had much time to post, but I'll be back more now that things have settled down. I also haven't been posting for various other reasons, which include the reason why I changed my username.

    One of those reasons is that I've been trying to catch up on the old seasons of Doctor Who, and it's been taking up a lot of my free time. Therefore, I pose the Whovians of the Board a question:

    If you were a Time Lord, what do you think your title would be? (The Doctor, the Master, the Monk, etc., etc.)

    • Further Time Lord stories/bios by Huinesoron on 2013-09-16 12:59:00 UTC Link to this

      Bios

      Stories

      And specifically, there is a new story starring the Pathologist (Kaitlyn, who has so far refused to post), the Archivist (Neshomeh), the Supporter (Storme Hawk) and the Samurai (the Irish Samurai). I'll paste it in for those having trouble with the docs:




      Degenerate Regenerate

      “He’s dead, Jim - but not as we know it.”

      The Supporter exchanged a blank look with the Archivist. “Um… who’s Jim?”

      The Pathologist stared at the pair for a moment. “Er. Okay. It doesn’t matter.” She lowered her voice for a moment into a barely-audible mutter: “Primitives. What matters is that he’s dead… only not.”

      “You’re going to have to explain that a bit better,” the Archivist suggested. “Because that wasn’t an explanation.”

      “Right, right.” The Pathologist ran a hand through her hair. “Okay. You know Christmas?”

      “With the eggs and things?” The Archivist frowned. “No, that’s the other one…”

      “Trees,” the Supporter supplied. “And presents, and jolly red aliens coming down the chimney.”

      “You wouldn’t be ‘jolly’ if you were that morbidly obese,” the Pathologist observed, “but I digress. It’s the trees I’m thinking about. They’re dead, yes?”

      “They don’t have to be,” the Archivist pointed out. “That last planet we stopped over at, they grow all their plants in underground pots so they can be moved - I’ve got one back in my rooms-”

      “They also killed one of our friends,” the Supporter reminded her, gesturing at the corpse under discussion.

      “Oh, yes. And that’s bad. But he’ll get better, right?”

      “That’s what I’m trying to discuss,” the Pathologist replied snippily. “A tree can be… no, look, forget the analogy. You remember his plan for getting past the Judoon and their genetic scanner?”

      “I remember the Mechanic’s reaction,” the Archivist said with a slight smile. “‘You want to do what to my Chameleon Arch?’ Not that I don’t sympathise…”

      “Right,” the Pathologist agreed. “So he partially altered his DNA to match the local inhabitants and fool the scanner.”

      “It’s a shame it didn’t work,” the Supporter said, glancing at the body. “It was a really good plan.”

      “Yes, except that DNA doesn’t work that way.” The Pathologist frowned. “Or it shouldn’t. But… okay, this next bit is going to sound painfully stupid.”

      “Cool!” exclaimed the Archivist. “What? No, sorry, I mean - go ahead.”

      The Pathologist took a deep breath. “When the Judoon shot him, the Time Lord part of him died as normal. But the Judoon had safeties on their guns to prevent them killing the locals even accidentally. The gun refused to kill the Arch-implanted part of his DNA - so he’s only half dead. And since regeneration relies on a Time Lord being actually dead, he’s stuck like this.”

      “That’s awful!” The Supporter had to take a deep breath after her outburst before continuing. “How can we help him?”

      “It should be fairly simple,” the Pathologist shrugged. “Once his Arch transformation is undone, he should be able to regenerate as normal. Only this partial transform didn’t take his memories, and didn’t create a capsule - so we need an intact Chameleon Arch to do it.”

      “But the Mechanic took ours apart,” the Archivist pointed out. “Do we have enough time for him to reconstruct it?”

      “We don’t need to!” the Supporter realised. “Archivist, you’ve got an Arch in your display room - I remember it!”

      The Archivist twitched. “That’s not just a Chameleon Arch,” she pointed out. “That’s the original Arch - the one built by Rassilon himself to-”

      “And it can save our friend,” the Pathologist cut her off. “Isn’t that more important?”

      “No!” the Archivist wailed, but then sighed. “I suppose. Maybe.”

      “Good.” The Pathologist looked at the Supporter. “Do you know where it is?”

      “Absolutely,” the Supporter agreed, and dashed off. The small room was left in uncomfortable silence, the two Time Ladies not meeting each other’s gaze, until she returned.

      The Archivist winced visibly as the Supporter ran back in, bouncing the Arch off the doorframe. “All right, but I’m setting it up,” she said, taking the device from the other woman. “It’s not that I don’t trust you, but…”

      Soon enough, the Chameleon Arch was in place. The Pathologist took her place next to the machine and looked at her colleagues. “Ready?”

      “Happy birthday,” the Archivist replied absently, still looking twitchy. The Pathologist shrugged and flicked the switch.

      Nothing happened.

      “Um…” the Supporter began.

      “It’s fine,” the Pathologist assured her. “He’s just dying.”

      “Oh, is that all?”

      There was a sound from the body on the table - a sort of long sigh. Then, as the trio watched, his skin began to glow with rainbow light, growing more and more intense until they had to shield their eyes. There was a sudden, blinding pulse of light, and then it was over.

      The Pathologist was the first to recover. Blinking away the afterimage of the light, she squinted at the newly-regenerated figure on the table. “Human,” she reported. “Apparently perfectly normal. Not sure about the hair, but at least he’s got all his teeth…” She leant forward. “Samurai? Can you hear me?”

      “I say,” the Samurai replied, without opening his eyes or moving a muscle, “do you have to be so dashed loud? Some of us are trying to rest, you know.”

      “He’s fine,” the Supporter surmised with a sigh of relief.

      “I wouldn’t say so,” the Samurai retorted. “I’ve got the most terrible thirst.” He opened one eye, looking around furtively, and then sat jerkily upright. “Would there happen to be such a thing as a cup of tea around here?”




      As far as I can track, then, the only Time Lords without stories are the Acoustician, the Analyzer, and the Weirdo. And counting both Librarians, we have a TARDIS crew of fifteen...

      hS

      • And one last story - 'The Crowded TARDIS' by Huinesoron on 2013-09-17 10:51:00 UTC Link to this

        Featuring, I think, everyone who's offered a name. I'm not sure everyone has spoken lines, but we're all in there...




        "Can we get some quiet in here?"

        The answer, apparently, was no. The multiple conversations went on, getting louder all the time. The Strategist scowled and looked at the Speaker, who shrugged.

        "I can't convince them if they can't hear me," he called over the racket. "The Acoustician might be able to rig something up."

        "He's too busy arguing with the Mechanic over whose responsibility the viewscreens are," the Strategist pointed out.

        "The Bluejay could probably shut them up - but again, only if they can hear her."

        "Precisely." The Strategist frowned around the console room. "The Supporter... well, she'd mean well, I'm sure. Oh, now, I wonder..."

        The two Time Lords put their heads together. About a minute later, a new head dropped down from the gantry, fortunately attached to a body.

        "Hi!" exclaimed the Weirdo. "Anything good?"

        The Strategist did his best to hide a smile. "Actually, yes. We wanted to talk to everyone, but they can't hear us..."

        "Oh, that's simple," the Weirdo beamed, and then yelled at the top of her lungs: "Oy! You lot! Daleks!"

        The hubbub stopped instantly as the Time Lords looked around frantically. The Strategist nodded his gratitude to the Weirdo and hopped up onto one of the seats.

        "Get off that!" the Mechanic yelled. "Do you know how long it takes to build a safe TARDIS ejector seat?"

        "I don't plan to break it," the Strategist assured him. "But I need to get your attention, however many of you there are-"

        "Fifteen," four voices chorused from around the room, and the two Librarians, the Archivist, and the Analyzer exchanged satisfied looks.

        "Or fourteen," the Analyzer went on, "if you subscribe to the belief that the Librarians are the same person."

        "Fourteen or fifteen, a TARDIS has a crew of six," the Strategist pointed out. "We have a severe excess of Time Lords."

        "Well, some of us aren't exactly permanent crew," the Pathologist pointed out. "If you want me to take my TARDIS and go..."

        "You can't!" exclaimed the Alchemist. "Who's going to patch up my burns if you go?"

        "And that's a very significant point," the Analyzer put in. "We need everyone in the crew."

        "Rubbish!" the Weirdo shouted. "The Artisan? The Acoustician? Four nearly-identical bookworms? The Weirdo?" She blinked. "Wait, that's me. Who needs me? What good am I?" And she burst into tears.

        "Oh, don't cry!" the Supporter exclaimed, running over to her. "It's all right, we do need you, you're an invaluable part of the team..."

        "Really? Brill!" The Weirdo beamed at her.

        Meanwhile, the First Librarian was tapping away at his tablet computer. He beckoned his possible later form over and pointed at something.

        "And I resent the implication that I'm unnecessary," the Acoustician put in. "I mean, if you want to go back to the days of never knowing what the away team is up to..."

        Now the Second Librarian, nodding in agreement with her counterpart, beckoned the Archivist over. Together they peered at the screen, and then the Archivist scurried off into the depths of the TARDIS.

        "Am I allowed to object too?" the Artisan asked. "I mean, yes, in a literal view of our mission statement, I'm not 'necessary'. But what good is helping people if you turn the universe into featureless cold metal along the way? We must be artists, not just soldiers. I might even say, more artists than soldiers."

        "Yes, you probably would," the Samurai agreed amiably. "But I must say, that would be jolly bad form. The fact that some of us are skilled with weapons rather than crafts hardly means you should belittle us."

        The Archivist returned, carrying a thick book, and passed it to the Second Librarian. The latter flicked through the pages, hunting.

        "Personally I'm amazed no-one's mentioned me yet," the Bluejay said, swinging her legs where she sat on the railing. "Aren't I pretty much the definition of a tagalong?"

        "Don't lay it on too thick," the Pathologist said dryly. "Besides, even if you were, history - well, fiction - shows that quirky girls 'just along for the ride' solve a significant number of major catastrophes."

        The Second Librarian, having found her page, hurried over to the Analyzer and pointed at something. The latter woman frowned, then raised her eyebrow. The Librarian whispered something in her ear.

        "I think the real issue isn't 'useless in isolation'," said the Mechanic. "It's redundancy. We have - sorry, Acoustician - two engineers, four information junkies, two diplomats, three fighters... how many of each do we actually need?"

        "As many as we can get," the Supporter said firmly. "What's the alternative - telling people to pack their bags and get lost?"

        "If necessary," the Mechanic shrugged. "If a part is unnecessary, discard it."

        The Analyzer, still frowning at the book, crossed the room to the Speaker. She ran her finger down the page, demonstrating something to him, then entered into a whispered conversation.

        "You can't talk about people as parts, though," the Bluejay said, uncharacteristically serious. "They're - we're - people, with our own hopes and dreams, our own feelings and desires, our own-"

        "I don't know," the First Librarian cut in. "I think we can all be defined pretty quickly. As someone said, I'm a bookworm, the Mechanic is an engineer, and you're a-"

        "Manic Pixie Dream Girl?" the Pathologist suggested. "But she's right - even if you can define us in one word, that doesn't say everything about us."

        "That's a bit metaphysical for you, isn't it?" the Artisan asked. "I thought you were pretty down on all that 'messy emotional business'."

        "Emotional?" the Pathologist asked, bemused. "I was talking about genetics."

        "Enough of this," the Strategist cut in, silencing the hubbub. "The key point here is that- yes, what is it?"

        The Speaker had tapped his shoulder, and the Strategist leant down to listen. After a few moments he stood again, and shrugged.

        "Apparently," he said, "a study by the United Universities of Raxacoricofallapatorius has conclusively demonstrated that, when it comes to starship crews, a larger, more varied team is always preferable. I'm quite surprised, I will admit, but the Analyzer says the proof is undeniable."

        "Well, that settles it, then," the Alchemist said, grinning. "You have to let me start up my trans-temporal replication experiments again."

        "I said 'crew'," the Strategist pointed out wearily, "not 'hideous abominations that should be time-locked and forgotten'."

        "True enough," the Alchemist mused, "but on the other hand..."

        "Don't even," the Pathologist cut in. "Remember I know where the sedatives are..."

        • Well done by World-Jumper on 2013-09-18 00:52:00 UTC Link to this

          An excellent addition to the Time Lord chronicles. I know I am invested in these characters, at least somewhat, and an interested in seeing more from them. I think this weekend, if I have time, I will write out some of the Speaker's backstory, probably up to recruitment into the team in his second generation. No promises mind you...

          As cool as this story was, I personally subscribe to the belief that all 15 are not present on the TARDIS at one time. The crew is more of a small community of Time Lords that will follow the Strategist whenever he needs something done, and act as resources when needed, but otherwise are left to their own devices. I see the Speaker mostly staying on the main TARDIS, as he has nothing else better to do, and the Strategist always needs a diplomat (or a charmer). As for the others, I cannot speak for them, but I would think the seven from the first story are pretty much the group that stays on the ship most of the time. However, fifteen Time Lords stuck together in a giant box is great potential for humor, as well as constantly having a ready expedition team... Whatever, it can be however anybody thinks it should be.

        • Brilliant. ^.^ by Neshomeh on 2013-09-17 16:57:00 UTC Link to this

          This can only go amazing and hilarious places.

          BTW, the characterization of the Archivist in "Degenerate Regenerate" is eerily spot-on for me. I spent a good minute giggling at "Cool! ... What? No, sorry, I mean - go ahead." As Phobos will attest, I have a bad habit of making verbal responses even when I'm not fully paying attention (lost in thought, trying to read something at the same time, etc.), which results in not-infrequent moments pretty much exactly like that one. Phobos has gotten me to accidentally agree to all sorts of things. ^_^;

          Also, I think she would be all over delineating and possibly diagramming each person's exact role in the crew. Duty rosters and job descriptions and mission statements and otherwise making clear who is supposed to be doing what (and how, and why) at any given time is essential to the orderly and efficient operation of any sufficiently complex enterprise, and fifteen Time Lords and Ladies in a box together is about as complicated as it gets. Also, people might want to know that sort of thing in the future, so keeping records of it is good for posterity!

          ~Neshomeh

          • I feel like the Archivist and the Analyzer... by hermione of vulcan on 2013-09-18 21:55:00 UTC Link to this

            ...should be friends. They seem to have a similar way of looking at things - if I understand correctly, it's looking at all the small details to see how they make up the big picture. And having lots of random trivia in their minds. And reading. And sometimes mixing up common responses. I swear I've done "Happy Birthday!" "You too!" before. Though the Archivist seems much more about recording things, while the Analyzer likes studying the universe just because it's all so very interesting.

            Oh, and as to the hair - it's the progression of hair throughout my life, the current incarnation being the closest to my current self. Make of that what you will.

    • Not a Whovian, but... by hermione of vulcan on 2013-09-15 02:07:00 UTC Link to this

      I think I'll be the Analyzer. And doing regenerations sounds fun.

      General Traits:
      The thing that always stays the same about the Analyzer is her ability to think deeply about things. She tries to come at problems from new angles and enjoys exploring the complexities of the universe.

      The First Analyzer:
      some_text
      This incarnation is very happy. She likes bright colors and smiles a lot (when not thinking). However, she's only happy as long as no one questions her thinking. She's convinced she's right about everything, and tends to disrespect authority. This alienates people, so she values the friends she makes and clings to them, not trying to make more. She died in an accident that claimed the lives of her only friends.

      The Second Analyzer
      some_text
      This incarnation reaps the consequences from her last self's arrogance, and has difficulty making friends, retreating into her thoughts and reading most of the time. She's shy and reclusive, but still resents being ordered to do anything. She died in an accident involving an earthquake and poorly-constructed bookshelves.

      The Third Analyzer (current regeneration)
      some_text
      This incarnation is much more friendly than her last two, though she dislikes small talk and formalities and can come off a bit brusque at times. She's decided to apply her way of thinking to solving the problems of the universe, getting involved in multiple causes for equality. On multiple planets. She can get overwhelmed easily, but at the same time sees the universe in a very rich, detailed way.

      • I like the progression of the hair. by Neshomeh on 2013-09-17 16:59:00 UTC Link to this

        It seems to transition from straight to curly. Was that deliberate?

        ~Neshomeh

    • Me? A Time Lord? by Legacy on 2013-09-14 19:16:00 UTC Link to this

      I'd be the most irresponsible, destructive Time Lord ever.

      'Cause of that, I'd probably be known as the Weirdo.

    • Hmmm.... by Elcalion on 2013-09-14 00:12:00 UTC Link to this

      Welcome back! *dodges toast*

      I'd say if I were a Time Lord I would be either the Engineer (which makes it sound waaaaay too much like Miss Saigon) or perhaps The Scholar. (The Acoustician, while technically accurate for my day job, perhaps doesn't have quite the ring to it).

      Elcalion, having to think up of regenerations now

      • Re: Hmmm.... by Desdendelle on 2013-09-14 20:07:00 UTC Link to this

        'The Acoustician' is the awesomest Time Lord name ever. You should use that.

    • Time Lord me. by Storme Hawk on 2013-09-13 00:37:00 UTC Link to this

      Scary thought, very scary thought.

      The best title for me would probably be something like The Supporter. It's what I do, generally I'll support an idea one of my friends has, if we're playing games I'm generally the support for the team, and so on and so on.


    • Had to do this - a short Time Lord sketch. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-11 16:40:00 UTC Link to this

      The Mechanic stuck his head out from behind a hatch and pushed his goggles up onto his forehead. "All fixed," he said. "Well, moderately fixed."

      "You're making me twitchy," the Librarian muttered, not glancing up from his book. "Would it hurt you to at least look at the manual?"

      "Where's the fun in that?" the Mechanic sniffed. "I mean, really - doing things by the book? That's so dull."

      "That's right!" the Artisan piped up, scrambling down a ladder from the upper gallery. "Running a TARDIS is an art, not some complicated science! You have to feel your way through it. If you don't love your TARDIS, you-"

      "Oh, spare me." The Alchemist walked into the console room, white coat billowing behind him. "All this 'art and science are totally separate' business - the trick is to synthesise them. Logic and emotion aren't antithetical, no matter what Doctor Spock says."

      "That's Mister Spock," the Librarian pointed out, "or if you want to get technical, Science Officer Spock. At least until he became Ambassador Spock, and-"

      "Yes, yes." The Alchemist tapped a button on the console and peered at the screen. "The stabilisers are still reading as down..."

      "Really? Let me see." The Mechanic frowned at the data printout, then pulled a large rubber mallet from his toolbelt and tapped the screen sharply. "That should do it."

      "Great!" exclaimed the Bluejay from where she perched on the railing. "So are we ready to go?"

      "Not until the Betrayer gets here," the Librarian pointed out.

      "You really shouldn't call him that," the Speaker chided him, standing up at last from his position by the main doors. "It's exceptionally rude to refuse to use the name someone has chosen in favour of an insulting epithet."

      "Well, if he didn't betray people all the time..." the Artisan put in, but trailed off in the face of the Speaker's gaze.

      "I ask you," the Speaker went on, "each of you - how would you feel if you were known by invented nicknames? If people kept calling you 'the Flighty'," he nodded at the Bluejay, "or 'the Erratic'," to the Mechanic, "or 'the Explosive'," to the Alchemist.

      "Well, speaking for myself, I wouldn't mind-" the Alchemist began. Then one of the doors swung open, and the Strategist strode in. He was, as usual, dressed all in black, and already scowling.

      "Well?" he asked in the sudden silence. "What are we waiting for?"

      "A TARDIS requires a crew of six," the Librarian pointed out. "You were absent."

      "I was planning," the Strategist corrected, "and you already have six crew members here."

      "Oh, I'm just along for the ride," the Bluejay called chirpily. "Don't mind me."

      "Hm." The Strategist crossed to the console and took his place in front of one of the six segments, standing next to the Alchemist and the Mechanic. "But I am here now," he pointed out. "So, I ask again - what are we waiting for?"




      I've tried to give everyone personalities suggested by their names. Actual accuracy to real life not guaranteed.

      (Also, these characters are really fun to work with. If you don't believe me, try it yourself!)

      hS

      • Yes. by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-13 16:42:00 UTC Link to this

        I am totally just along for the ride. I'll also be singing badly and mimicking everyone's voices first chance I get.

        "Flighty," pfft, yes. All the yes. There is so much yes in this whole thing.

      • The Alchemist(s) - A Short Biography(/ies) by Huinesoron on 2013-09-13 09:03:00 UTC Link to this

        The First Alchemist



        This incarnation still used his given name. He spent his entire life on Gallifrey as a theoretical exotic chemist, basically achieving nothing of significance, before finally dying at the hands of Something Bad out of Gallifrey's past.

        The Second Alchemist



        This is the 'darkest' Alchemist. He devoted himself to studying the deep, dark history of Gallifrey and the universe, and adopted the use-name 'Alchemist', cutting off all ties with his former life. His studies led him into conflict with Time Lord society, and he eventually fled off-world to continue his investigations. He died in the heart of a cloud of toxic gas, which he had released in attempting to unlock an ancient sealed tomb.

        The Third Alchemist (The Chemist)



        This incarnation completely abandoned his former interests, even amending his name slightly to become 'the Chemist'. He was a firm believer in rigorous experimentation and logic as the only ways to solve a problem. He spent his time travelling the universe, having adventures and righting wrongs, possibly - although he never admitted it - in an effort to atone for his prior self's darker deeds. This is the version who took Lise Meitner as a Companion. He eventually died at the hands of a mob on a wildly xenophobic world.

        The Fourth Alchemist



        This incarnation is one of the shortest-lived Time Lord incarnations on record, and the only non-'human' regeneration of the Alchemist. He lived for about forty-eight hours, constantly on the run, before the authorities of the same world as his prior self died on caught him and had him put down.

        The Fifth Alchemist



        This incarnation began her (yes, her) life in mortal danger from the same mob as Alchemists III and IV had been killed by. She re-adopted the Alchemist name almost instantly, and used her twelve hour 'invulnerability' grace period after regenerating to build herself a working matter transmuter, then created a large quantity of explosives and blasted her way free. She was the 'mad scientist' incarnation, frequently throwing caution to the wind in favour of improvising wildly with high technology and complex (and highly explosive) chemistry. She continued the 'righting wrongs' theme of the Third Alchemist, but rarely took long-term Companions. Ultimately she died on an alternate, Steampunk Earth while attempting to thwart an army of clockwork men.

        The Sixth Alchemist



        This is the current incarnation, and adopted the steampunk aesthetic of his 'birth' world. Through coincidence or design, his appearence is very similar to his third self, though his methods rely more on intuition than careful analysis. He still invents things on the fly, like his Fifth incarnation, but they tend towards chemical concoctions rather than machines and explosives.




        I would actually love to do this for all our Time Lords, but the appearances might be a bit tricky... ;)

        hS

        • I consent. by Kittythekatty on 2013-09-13 23:44:00 UTC Link to this

          I give you full permission to use the Artisan. I have created some different incarnations, but I'm a bit unsure how to share/post them. I'm still a newbie and figuring out how to work the board.

          If it's alright with you, I'd like to design the Artisan. As for the biography, do whatever you like. I'm still a bit unsure about how many incarnations the Artisan has. I guess four is alright. Now, if you excuse me, I need to design.

          Oh, and could you please tell me how to post/share the avatars? Sorry, newbie problems...

          • Syntax by Desdendelle on 2013-09-14 20:09:00 UTC Link to this

            This Board uses HTML code. Here's the info you're looking for.

        • Do you require aid? by Desdendelle on 2013-09-13 11:27:00 UTC Link to this

          The First Librarian
          One sharp-dressed Librarian, at y'service.

          • That is fantastic. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-13 12:00:00 UTC Link to this

            The First Librarian



            This incarnation began life on Gallifrey. He passed through the Time Lord Academy, and seemed content to live out his lives as a researcher into the Matrix - until, out of the blue, he went rogue, fleeing from Gallifrey and taking the name 'the Librarian'. He is highly skilled with most computer systems, and capable of drawing out the most tenuous details with relative ease. Ultimately, it is suspected that he will die under the influence of a powerful anasthetic, leaving his second incarnation with no memory of him (although this, obviously, cannot be confirmed).

            The Second Librarian

            This incarnation - or, possibly, distinct individual - shares much of the First Librarian's skills. She tends to use books rather than computers, and has an almost eidetic memory - if it's in one of her books, she can find it for you. Her skills at synthesis are not as good, but working together, the two Librarians can tell you essentially anything you want to know.

            (Desdendelle - thanks! That is a fantastic image; much better than some of mine, and fits the theme nicely too)

            (Impossible - if you want to either create a 'you' on TekTek or provide a description [at least hair-eye-skin, and as many details of clothing as you like], I can add her to the file)

            (And anyone else - the same applies! I'm having too much fun to stop now. ;) I've already come up with prior regenerations for several of you...)

            hS

            • I bestow upon you full permission and a TekTek. by Impossible on 2013-09-14 22:24:00 UTC Link to this

              As long as I can use the Librarian for myself as well, of course.

              Now have a Second Librarian and some more biographical details, aside from the biography she's already got.



              (Yes, she is overly fond of cats, and yes, that is a quill she's holding - more specifically a quantum quill, her equivalent of a sonic.)

              The number of books she has read have led to her gaining a superb vocabulary and a vast repertoire of mostly useless facts, making her extremely annoying to play trivia games with. She can also be dreadfully sarcastic and is easily distracted by a favorite book or interesting object. This has led to any spaces empty of books being filled with piles of knickknacks ranging from a cheap kaleidoscope to a Raxacoricofallapatorian claw. Most of her time is spent bouncing around time and space, chronicling everything she experiences in a futile attempt to finish her magnum opus, The Narrative of Existence.

            • Make it! by World-Jumper on 2013-09-13 17:43:00 UTC Link to this

              I give you full permission to make and use the Speaker. Assuming that I can keep him to use as well.

            • I leave you full freedom. by Sergio Turbo on 2013-09-13 17:37:00 UTC Link to this

              Also because I still don't quite understand TekTek.... as shown by the fact that I use Go Fetch instead.

            • Since we're playing with TekTek... by Neshomeh on 2013-09-13 17:23:00 UTC Link to this

              I love TekTek. ^_^

              My Time Lord name would (of course) be the Archivist. She may have more than one regeneration, but you'd be hard-pressed to tell what any of them really look like, considering...

              http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v155/Neshomeh/archivist-1.png

              ~Neshomeh

              • Regenerations. by Neshomeh on 2013-09-13 22:04:00 UTC Link to this

                The First Archivist

                http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v155/Neshomeh/archivist1-1.png

                The First Archivist was the requisite fashion-impaired one. She was more of a collector than anything else, and would pick up anything that happened to strike her fancy—books, pretty rocks, shells, cool words (such as "archivist," for instance), hats, silver spoons, etc. Her focus changed frequently, and old collections, though neatly organized, would be abandoned to gather dust on their shelves. Still, throwing anything out would be unthinkable. You never know when you might want it! She met her end in an unfortunate accident involving ten thousand spoons, when all she needed to save herself was a knife.

                The Second Archivist

                http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v155/Neshomeh/archivist2.png

                The Second Archivist was completely different from the first. Controlling, strict, and impatient, she had no use for anything that didn't directly contribute to the greater whole of her designs, including people, which she regarded purely as resources for the getting of more information. She would play the social game as long as she needed to keep herself in their good graces, but once she got what she wanted, it was over; they'd never hear from her again. She died friendless and with a knife in her back, when she'd finally spurned and offended the wrong people.

                The Third Archivist

                http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v155/Neshomeh/archivist1.png

                The Third Archivist is the current one, and by far the most balanced. She's a dotty but harmless hermit who rarely emerges from her lair, which is filled with books, papers, various digital media storage, and tea. When she does appear, it's often to exclaim over a "new" discovery or an "exciting" system of organization she's come up with. Systems are what she does best, and unlike her previous regenerations, it's the intricate order and interconnectedness of things that interests her more than the actual nodes of information in any given system (though understanding the nodes is crucial to understanding the system as a whole). She's friendly enough, but often gets her social conventions and associated stock responses mixed up.

                "Happy Christmas, Archivist!" - "Oh, yes! Gesundheit!"

                (Feel free to change the backstories, hS. You can probably come up with something more fitting and Whovian than I can. ^_^ )

                ~Neshomeh

                • Hmm... by Phobos on 2013-09-13 22:11:00 UTC Link to this

                  Not so sure about the first one. A little too ironic? Yeah, I really do think.

                  -Phobos, :P

            • I'm working on The Strategist by Phobos on 2013-09-13 17:06:00 UTC Link to this

              He'll have 7 regenerations, and I currently only have the last 3 made, if you have any for him.

              -Phobos

              • What I have so far by Phobos on 2013-09-13 18:59:00 UTC Link to this

                The Strategist V

                The Strategist V

                This incarnation of The Strategist is not one for planning ahead of time. He prefers to make all of his plans on the fly, and he is very good at it. He is an energetic people person and a pacifist. He met his end when his opponent forced him to choose between his companion and himself. He sacrificed himself and regenerated.

                The Strategist VI - The Betrayer

                The Betrayer

                Gone are the bright colors and the warmth of the Fifth Strategist. The Time Lord, who would go on to earn the name The Betrayer, favors stark black and white clothing and masquerade masks. Unlike his his predecessor, he carries a weapon: a single-shot pistol. He says, "If I need more than one shot, I've done something very wrong." One thing he has in common with his previous incarnation is that he has charm in spades. However, what he has in charm, he lacks in empathy. He is not afraid to use those around him as pawns in his plans. He was, possibly, the most ingenious of the regenerations. His death was the result of his last, great betrayal. He betrayed himself to his death and, like so many before him, he never saw it coming.

                The Strategist VII

                The Strategist VII photo TheStrategist.png

                The demise of The Betrayer resulted in his regeneration into a more sober individual, who is less personable and more prone to scowling. He shares his previous self's penchant for black clothing, though he tends to look a bit like a vaudevillian magician. He takes the long view of events, and his plans reflect those long sighted calculations. He still carries the stigma of The Betrayer with him, but he no longer carries a weapon.

                • What I have so far (for everyone). by Huinesoron on 2013-09-13 19:07:00 UTC Link to this

                  Is behind this handy link.

                  Obviously my version of the Strategist (who has four incarnations) will need some editing to fit with yours. Actually, in theory he could just slot in as versions 1-4... we'll see.

                  Anyway, the list is under vague expansion, and will have pictures added as and when. Comments, criticisms and corrections are more than welcome!

                  hS

                  • Oh, BTW by Desdendelle on 2013-09-15 14:51:00 UTC Link to this

                    I am planning to use First Librarian as an Agent at some point in the future, but you can use him for your sketches. I've a feeling they'll be awesome.

                  • Your link doesn't show me anything by Hieronymus Graubart on 2013-09-14 12:44:00 UTC Link to this

                    Do I need a Google Docs account?

                    • Um, you shouldn't do. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-16 10:50:00 UTC Link to this

                      If you're still having trouble, this should definitely work. It does seem to throw the images around a bit, though.

                      hS

                      • Oh, it works now (both links), and it's amazing. (nm) by Hieronymus Graubart on 2013-09-17 13:37:00 UTC Link to this
                  • Re: What I have so far (for everyone). by World-Jumper on 2013-09-13 21:14:00 UTC Link to this

                    Interesting. I like the idea that the Speaker was a bit of a con artist in his first incarnation, especially in contrast to his second incarnation. I imagine his theme song would be "With a Flair" from Bedknobs and Broomsticks.

                    Later, I think I will write a story in his first incarnation, detailing some of his personal life and why the Master killed him. I mean, other then the Master was bored and the Speaker was the closest one to zap. Perhaps he tried to scam the Master and it just about worked, but when the Master caught on...

                    One question I have, and this is for everyone: When and why did they all come together in a team? I personally think the Speaker joined in his second incarnation, the Strategist recruiting him for some plan of his. The Speaker knew he was part of some plan, but the cause was important enough to him. What that cause was, I have no idea, I'll leave that for the others to decide.

                    • First Librarian... by Desdendelle on 2013-09-13 21:25:00 UTC Link to this

                      That's easy, really. He's after the Riddle of the Osirians, and The Strategist has a hint as to where The Librarian can find an ancient terminal containing info pertaining to the Riddle.

                  • Re: What I have so far (for everyone). by Outhra on 2013-09-13 21:10:00 UTC Link to this

                    I wish I could take part in the fun here, but whenever I try and come up with a Time Lord name, it comes up as something ridiculous and not really connected with my personality at all. I tried for a while, but I knew it wasn't going to work after I just went off into tangential aspects of my personality and started trying to match them with words that were fun to say out loud.

                    By the way, the First Speaker is described as an "illisionist". You're probably going to want to fix that.

                  • Interesting by Phobos on 2013-09-13 19:22:00 UTC Link to this

                    The first and second incarnations should work fine. I especially like the games aspect of the second one. Your third and fourth seem to actually be my sixth and seventh, just told from a slightly different angle. There are definitely pieces of your fourth that I would incorporate into my seventh. In fact, I think it would read like this:

                    The demise of The Betrayer resulted in his regeneration into a more sober individual, who is less personable and more prone to scowling. He shares his previous self's penchant for black clothing, though he tends to look a bit like a vaudevillian magician. He is a gifted forward planner. Given enough time and information, he is capable of coming up with a plan to accomplish any goal you care to name. He works closely with the Speaker and the two Librarians to direct the team's actions. He is still willing to sacrifice his allies at need, and will mislead and manipulate them in order to accomplish this, but his detailed plans always include ways to rescue them or otherwise repair the damage.

                    • That's roughly what I was thinking. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-13 19:35:00 UTC Link to this

                      We both went for 'he did more betraying in his previous incarnation, but he's a bit better now'. ;) I've taken your 'Seven' combined description, and I'm cobbling together Six and Three into one now. It's coming out longer than a lot of the others, but that's mostly because you've described the clothes, which I don't tend to do.

                      'Gone are the bright colors and the warmth of the Fifth Strategist. The Time Lord, the only incarnation to embrace the nickname of ‘the Betrayer’, favors stark black and white clothing and masquerade masks. Unlike his his predecessor, he carries a weapon: a single-shot pistol. He says, "If I need more than one shot, I've done something very wrong." One thing he has in common with his previous incarnation is that he has charm in spades. However, what he has in charm, he lacks in empathy. This incarnation was a ruthless schemer, and possibly the most ingenious of the regenerations. He created loose plans, but was capable of altering and updating them on the fly. His goal in every situation was utter dominance - whatever group or individual he faced, he would not rest until they were either completely powerless or dead. He was willing to sacrifice everything to his goals, including friends, allies, and the space-time continuum - and, ultimately, his own life, in his last, great betrayal.'

                      Like I say - long, but the first half is stuff I didn't cover in my versions.

                      Of course, this leaves Three and Four as mysteries...

                      hS

                      hS

                      • I like it by Phobos on 2013-09-13 19:52:00 UTC Link to this

                        I think you've done an excellent job integrating our two interpretations of the character. Also, I believe (and I think you agree) it is important that he not be as bad as before. Otherwise, no one in the crew would trust him (not that they all trust him now, his past being what it is).

                        -Phobos

      • An edited version & 'The Two Librarians' by Huinesoron on 2013-09-12 10:21:00 UTC Link to this

        The Mechanic stuck his head out from behind a hatch and pushed his goggles up onto his forehead. "All fixed," he said. "Well, moderately fixed."

        "You're making me twitchy," the Librarian muttered, not glancing up from his tablet computer. "Would it hurt you to at least look at the manual?"

        "I had to construct a whole new temporal transfer junction and bypass the entire neutron flow system to get her working again," the Mechanic pointed out. "I'm writing the manual. This isn't a repair job – by the time I'm through, this TARDIS will be a whole new ship."

        "And where's the fun in reading the manual, anyway?" the Artisan piped up, scrambling down a ladder from the upper gallery. "Running a TARDIS is an art, not some complicated science! You have to feel your way through it. If you don't love your TARDIS, you-"

        "Oh, spare me." The Alchemist walked into the console room, white coat billowing behind him. "All this 'art and science are totally separate' business - the trick is to synthesise them. Logic and emotion aren't antithetical, no matter what Doctor Spock says."

        "That's Mister Spock," the Librarian corrected, "or if you want to get technical, Science Officer Spock. At least until he became Ambassador Spock, and-"

        "Yes, yes." The Alchemist tapped a button on the console and peered at the screen. "The stabilisers are still reading as down..."

        "Really? Let me see." The Mechanic frowned at the data printout, then pulled a large rubber mallet from his toolbelt and tapped the screen sharply. "That should do it."

        "Great!" exclaimed the Bluejay from where she perched on the railing. "So are we ready to go?"

        "Not until the Betrayer gets here," the Librarian informed her.

        "You really shouldn't call him that," the Speaker chided him, standing up at last from his position by the main doors. "It's exceptionally rude to refuse to use the name someone has chosen in favour of an insulting epithet."

        "Oh, not more preaching!" the Bluejay protested. "I thought you got over this when you regenerated!"

        "This is important," the Speaker told her. "I know what it's like to be forcibly given a nickname-"

        "Well, they're accurate," the Artisan put in. "You like to give presentations, he betrays people all the time…" She trailed off in the face of the Speaker's glare.

        "I ask you," the Speaker said, looking around the console room, "each of you - how would you feel if no-one would use your chosen name? If people kept calling you 'the Flighty'," he nodded at the Bluejay, "or 'the Oil-stained'," to the Mechanic, "or 'the Explosive'," to the Alchemist.

        "Well, speaking for myself, I wouldn't mind-" the Alchemist began. Then one of the doors swung open, and the Strategist strode in. He was, as usual, dressed all in black, and already scowling.

        "Well?" he asked in the sudden silence. "What are we waiting for?"

        "A TARDIS requires a crew of six," the Librarian pointed out. "You were absent."

        "I was planning," the Strategist corrected, "and you already have six crew members here."

        "Oh, I'm just along for the ride," the Bluejay called chirpily. "Don't mind me."

        "Hm." The Strategist crossed to the console and took his place in front of one of the six segments, standing next to the Alchemist and the Mechanic. "But I am here now," he pointed out. "So, I ask again - what are we waiting for?"




        And later on…

        The Librarian walked the corridors of the TARDIS, scowling at his computer, trying yet again to pin down the solution to the Riddle of the Osirians. So absorbed was he that he failed to notice the other person in the corridor until he walked into her. Books went flying everywhere, and the Time Lord was barely able to catch himself in time.

        "My books!" exclaimed the women he had run into, scrambling to collect them all. She straightened up and glared at the Librarian. "Why don't you look where you're going?"

        "Why don't you?" the Librarian retorted. "I'm hardly the only one who can be held responsible here."

        "No, but you had the most choice," the woman said, flicking a hand at his computer (and nearly losing her stack of books again). "I can barely see round this lot at all – you just had to stop working for half a minute until you got where you were headed!"

        "… fair enough," the Librarian agreed. "I apologise. The Librarian, by the way."

        The woman looked puzzled. "Yes? What of it?"

        "That's me," the Librarian clarified.

        The woman snorted. "Don't be ridiculous," she said. "I'm the Librarian. Now who are you really?"

        "But I'm the Librarian," the (male) Librarian protested. "You can't steal my name!"

        "I'm stealing your name?" the (female) Librarian exclaimed. "More like the other way round! Look at you – you're still on your first body!"

        "Due to careful preservation of myself against danger, yes," the male said. Then he frowned, as a horrible thought began to dawn on him. "You don't think…?"

        "No." The female shook her head. "No, that's ridiculous. Unthinkable."

        "Absurd," the male supplied. "Inconceivable."

        "Nonsensical," the female agreed. "To think that I could regenerate from-"

        "That I could regenerate into-"

        "Someone like you!" they finished together.

        The male glared at the female, who returned the expression with equal distaste. "But no," he said at last. "Surely you'd remember if you'd ever been… well, me."

        "Surely," she replied, but looked uncertain. "Except… well, there was a bit of trouble with my regeneration, actually. I was dead for a bit too long, and my memories… aren't what they used to be."

        "That's awful!" the male Librarian exclaimed. "Losing your memories - that's like… like…"

        "Like the burning of the Library of Alexandria," the female supplied. "I know. I've been trying to get them back, but nothing seems to work."

        The First Librarian frowned and peered at his tablet. "You know," he said slowly, "I've been working on this riddle… the Riddle of the Osirians. And it seems to have something to do with memory…"

        The Second Librarian's eyebrows rose. "The Osirians?" she repeated. "I have a book on them here somewhere – maybe it will help. Is there a table nearby…?"




        Two notes:

        -I'm not making a statement that the two Librarians are the same person - but I'm also not ruling it out. These characters are presumably not the same as any hypothetical PPC agents by the same names.

        -I hope I've got everyone's gender right! This applies across both stories, naturally.

        hS

        • Nicely done, that was really fun to read! by the Irish Samurai on 2013-09-13 18:59:00 UTC Link to this

          You managed to give all the characters a decent amount of screentime, and I think you did a really good job of characterising them. They all have clearly distinct personalities, which is most impressive considering how few lines they get each.

          I particularly like the Mechanic's reply of 'I'm writing the manual.' - I've worked on jobs before where it's felt like I'm doing just that.

          As for what my Timelord name would be... I have no idea, so may not be joining in. 'The Engineer' would probably step on the Mechanic's toes as far as characterisation goes, and I currently can't think of anything else ('The Samurai' sounds far to pretentious for me to even consider).


        • So perfect. by Impossible on 2013-09-12 17:02:00 UTC Link to this

          In terms of accuracy, this is me all over.

          And I find it quite amusing that you had the female Librarian mention the burning of the Library of Alexandria, because the last monologue that I did for my Theatre class focused mostly on that (it was from the play Arcadia, for anyone who's curious).

      • Heh, that's great! by World-Jumper on 2013-09-12 00:49:00 UTC Link to this

        As for the accuracy, yeah, I am often the diplomat amongst my friends. While the Speaker seems to be a little more...how do I put this...professional (?) then I am usually, I could definitely see myself saying something along those lines. I say that because it seems like he is constantly in the middle of a speech whenever he opens his mouth. Nice for characterization, but not my own personality, per-se. However, hanging in the shadows by the door, rather then standing with the group, is definitely something I have/would do.

        You know, I kinda want to see more from these guys. It seems like an interesting group, and following their adventures through the universe would be cool. I'm not sure if I would write the next installment, but it would be nice. Perhaps the people who these Time Lords are based off of could be the beta readers for their next story, and insert little personality quirks that the other authors would not know about? Just a thought.

        • A few responses. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-12 09:43:00 UTC Link to this

          There's a couple of reasons the Speaker might not match you exactly in this scene:

          -This could be one of his hangups. Perhaps people occasionally call him 'the Presenter', which he thinks sounds like some sort of tawdry entertainer, not an accomplished giver-of-presentations like him. So he's not always ready with a speech - just in this instance.

          -Alternately, it could be a feature of this particular regeneration. Perhaps this version is rather preachy, while the previous iteration simply liked to lay things out in a clear spoken format before making a plan.

          Actually, I think that version of the Speaker would get on well with the Strategist, since they both centre around careful planning. Maybe this version should regenerate soon...




          The problem with getting the people they're based on to beta is that, well, there's seven - no, eight, if we include Impossible - people involved so far, and could be more coming. I've always been exceptionally lucky with betas, but that's pushing it a bit far.

          On the other hand... I'm quite capable of rewriting based on comments here for now. Actually, I've just figured a way to tweak the Speaker to fit your comments... updated version coming soon.

          hS

      • Actual Accuracy... by Kittythekatty on 2013-09-12 00:11:00 UTC Link to this

        You were pretty accurate. I'm not always "by the book" so to speak. This is somewhat with my crocheting. I read the pattern to get an idea of the shape and then I do whatever I like. The results are usually nice, though there are some times where the end product looks terrible.

        I like the way how you wrote the Artisan. The little "Art" verses "Science" spat was a lovely touch. I might try to write a short sketch. Good job.

      • "Actual accuracy to real life not guaranteed." by Desdendelle on 2013-09-11 21:34:00 UTC Link to this

        (Yes, I stole Sergio's title. So what?)
        Actually, pretty accurate, just replace 'book' with 'computer' half of the time. That said, I'm really tempted to pair this Librarian guy with Agent!Des - I'm planning on retiring Anebrin, since it feels I haven't had reasons enough to make him an Elf rather than just another guy, and he feels... flat. That said, I am planning on having the pair's next mission go wrong...

        • This is an incredibly funny coincidence. by Impossible on 2013-09-11 22:02:00 UTC Link to this

          Since I've been plotting my Permission request, I've been thinking about a pair of Time Lord agents, and one of them was going to be named (yes, you guessed it) the Librarian.

          On the same note, I wonder what the protocol is around Time Lord names - is it possible for two of them to have the same title?

          • Something to consider... by Phobos on 2013-09-11 22:23:00 UTC Link to this

            There are, currently, 7 Time Lords (thought only 4 are naturally Time Lords and not all of them are active) in the organization. This is not to say that you shouldn't go ahead with your plan. I am just putting the information out there about the state of affairs in HQ, where it deals with time-locked races that have very famous "last of their kind" figures.

            If you decide to go ahead with these agents, you will want to carefully consider how they managed to escape the fate of the rest of their people.

            -Phobos

            • Well... by Desdendelle on 2013-09-12 21:39:00 UTC Link to this

              I'm not if the cider I drank is making me think that's a good idea... but what if the Weeping Angels got the (male) Librarian before the Time War?

      • Pretty accurate for me, actually. by Phobos on 2013-09-11 18:56:00 UTC Link to this

        I like the balance that the characters have here. There are natural alliances and rivalries between the various characters, which you've used very well. The Art vs Science alignments being the most clearly identifiable.

        In the modified DnD Alignment system that I use (just replace 'Good vs Evil' with 'Selfless vs Selfish' and you're there), I see the characters breaking down like this:

        Lawful Selfless: The Speaker
        Lawful Neutral: The Librarian
        Lawful Selfish: N/A
        Neutral Selfless: The Bluejay
        True Neutral: The Alchemist
        Neutral Selfish: The Strategist
        Chaotic Selfless: The Mechanic
        Chaotic Neutral: The Artisan
        Chaotic Selfish: N/A

        So, the group skews toward the Selfless, overall, and is fairly balanced on the 'Law vs Chaos' scale. Not a bad group, in my opinion. Plenty of room for differing points of view, and interpersonal conflict. There is also room for both a Lawful Selfish villain as well as a Chaotic Selfish one.

        -Phobos, over-analyzing things since 1986

      • "Actual accuracy to real life not guaranteed"? by Sergio Turbo on 2013-09-11 18:34:00 UTC Link to this

        Considering that The Mechanic doesn't use manuals while real life me not only likes to double-check, but it is pretty much REQUIRED by aviation legislation...

        Besides, as I said I am qualified to build aircraft while The Mechanic repairs stuff. Building and repairing are completely different things in aviation

        But enough nitpicking. This piece was great!

        • Oh, I don't know... by Huinesoron on 2013-09-11 19:51:00 UTC Link to this

          (Okay, that's the third time that subject line's appeared in this thread...)

          Have you ever tried repairing a TARDIS? Judging by Nine through Eleven's console rooms, 'repair' is a synonym for 'make something new to compensate for the breakdown'.

          And there is a TARDIS manual... but I don't think it bears much resemblance to reality any more.

          hS

          "It's not supposed to make that noise - you leave the brakes on."

    • Re: I, formerly known as AelinTheAmazing, have returned. by Phobos on 2013-09-11 15:59:00 UTC Link to this

      Well, my Time Lord name could be the title that my friends gave me several years back. However, The Betraying Betrayer Who Betrays just doesn't roll off the tongue.

      Maybe something to better represent my many and varied artistic endeavors? How about The Bard? That's a good one, right?

      Huh?

      What do you mean it's already taken?

      Well you tell that Shakespeare guy to give someone else a turn!

      Ugh, fine.

      In that case, I have to go with The Strategist. Plans and plots are my thing. I make simple plans, complicated plans, cartoonishly over-complicated plans, whatever. I like strategy games (Diplomacy being a personal favorite). I like plotting the destruction of civilization as we know it (according to my 7th grade history teacher [not joking]). So, yeah, The Strategist sounds good to me.

      -Phobos, who earned the title "The Betraying Betrayer Who Betrays" in a game of Diplomacy

      • Oh, I don't know. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-11 16:18:00 UTC Link to this

        I kind of like the idea of a Time Lord who chooses to go by 'The Betrayer'. Of course, the way to make that into a good story is for him to be a good guy. Yes, the Betrayer will make promises he has no intention of keeping, sell out people who think they're his friends, and invite alien species down onto helpless planets - but his lies are to manipulate people into doing what needs doing, he abandons his friends to protect them (even if that means they get captured - a prison cell is a pretty safe place!), and the aliens would have come anyway - this way, he can control the situation.

        hS

    • Ooh, a good question. by Huinesoron on 2013-09-11 13:19:00 UTC Link to this

      I think, going by the conversation further down the Board, I would have to be 'The Chemist'. Or, no, even better - 'The Alchemist'.

      Of course, if you delve into the annals of PPC Board History, I was occasionally known as Elf Boy or Monk Boy... but let's go with the modern version.

      And for my 'requisit famous companion', a la Morgan's friends Amelia and Fred, I choose Lise Meitner. Yes, she's a physicist rather than a chemist, but as long as I don't have to deal with any biologists, I'm equal-opportunity. ;)

      hS

      • Re: Ooh, a good question. by Gen on 2013-09-12 08:09:00 UTC Link to this

        I am always insanely happy when I hear of other people who think Lise Meitner is awesome. :D

    • Ooh... by Kittythekatty on 2013-09-11 00:44:00 UTC Link to this

      Hello there! Nice to meet you? Another Whovian? I'm starting an OFU for Doctor Who, if you like to join or contribute any agents, please contact me a kittythekatty@gmail.com

      Anywho, Time Lord name...Hm, I guess the Artisan? I draw, paint, crochet, craft, write, etc...
      What would your title be?

      • Oh, I don't know. by Impossible on 2013-09-11 17:14:00 UTC Link to this

        Since I started watching Who I've been thinking about this, and for most of it I've been considering the Librarian (same as Desdendelle - I was wondering if anyone else would say that) who may end up being one of my future agents.

        The Clever One might also do, because if anyone wanted to summon me, they would have to say, "Call the Clever One!" or "Where is the Clever One?" and I would be like "I'm here, and thank you, I think I am rather intelligent."

        On a similar note, what if a Time Lord, theoretically, was named the Dalek?
        "Dalek? WHERE? RUN AWAY!"
        "No, not a Dalek, THE Dalek."
        "Not HER again!"

    • Welcome back! by Sergio Turbo on 2013-09-10 22:01:00 UTC Link to this

      My name as a Time Lord... Uhm, it might be a bit cheap but it would probably be "The Turbo", 'cause I'm quite of a car and aircraft enthusiast. Or maybe "The Mechanic"? After all, I just got my helicopter building degree.

    • Welcome Back! by Desdendelle on 2013-09-10 21:01:00 UTC Link to this

      As a welcome-back gift I give you a cup of Elysian Tea - this one won't try to eat you!
      That said, to answer your question: if I were a Time Lord, my title would be, probably, 'The Librarian', due to the focus on books and knowledge my life seems to have.

    • Hello! by World-Jumper on 2013-09-10 20:58:00 UTC Link to this

      First, welcome back. I think I remember you, but it has been a while.

      Now, for your question. I think I would be The Speaker or The Presenter. I am very well known for my voice and presenting abilities among my friends, and I know that my future carrier will involve this to an extent. The ironic part is that one-on-one conversation is much harder for me then speaking to a crowd. Strange, but there you have it.

    • Welcome back! by Karen DuLay on 2013-09-10 18:21:00 UTC Link to this

      The Doctor Who was worth it.

      In response to your question, I think that if I was a Time Lord, my title (if I had one) would be The Bluejay. My reasoning for this is a bit long-winded and includes a friend's story featuring me and some other real-life friends, so I won't get into it.

This software is licensed under the GNU Affero GPL version 3 or later. Source code is located at Github